Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.16585

On the potential for high-accuracy spectroscopy of $\mathrm{H}_2^+$ and $\overline{\mathrm{H}}_2^-$ in Penning traps for a test of CPT invariance

Stephan Schiller, Juan M. Cornejo, Nikita Poljakov, Christian Ospelkaus, Stefan Ulmer, Dimitar Bakalov

quant-phSubmitted May 15, 2026• Announced May 19, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The comparison of vibrational transition frequencies of $\mathrm{H}_2^+$ and $\overline{\mathrm{H}}_2^-$ offers a new opportunity to test CPT invariance. Myers [Phys. Rev. A 98, 010101(R) (2018)] proposed performing laser spectroscopy in a Penning trap (PT) with non-destructive read-out. Here, we provide an extensive analysis of this proposal, introduce novel aspects, and discuss its implementation in PTs that incorporate either the continuous Stern-Gerlach effect or quantum-logic spectroscopy. We derive estimates for the achievable accuracy of the test. We find that a comparison of the vibrational frequencies at a fractional level of $1\times10^{-17}$ is a realistic prospect, using technology that is mostly already available. We also analyze complementary CPT invariance tests, namely those of the g-factor of the bound electron/positron via electron-spin-resonance spectroscopy and of the magnetic moment of the proton/antiproton via radiofrequency spectroscopy.

Related papers

Characterisation of an experiment for sympathetic cooling and coupling of ions in a cryogenic Penning trap

Teresa Meiners

The comparison of the g-factors of the proton and the antiproton is a stringent test of CPT invariance. The state-of-the-art method for the determination of the (anti-)proton's g-factor is the application of the continuous Stern-Gerlach effect. With this method, precisions in the low parts per billion regime could be achieved. However, preparation times for cold enough particles are on the order of minutes to hours. The implementation of sympathetic cooling using a co-trapped atomic ion could lead to preparation times in the milliseconds regime. Furthermore, the applicability of sympathetic cooling would enable an alternative readout scheme using quantum logic methods. This thesis presents a Penning trap system that is designed for ground state cooling, adiabatic transport, and motional coupling of single 9Be+ ions. It has been built in a modular manner, giving the option of adapting it for motional coupling and sympathetic cooling of single (anti-)protons. In the course of this work, the prerequisites for motional coupling of 9Be+ ions have been fulfilled: A cloud of 9Be+ ions was cooled to a temperature of 1.7~mK applying Doppler cooling. The achieved temperature is about three times the Doppler limit which is 0.5~mK for beryllium ions. Furthermore, a scheme for reproducible loading of the trap and reducing the particle number was developed. Finally, first transport in our apparatus was demonstrated with clouds of beryllium ions. The method used for that is directly applicable to single ions. The results of this work pave the way towards adiabatic transport of single 9Be+ ions, which is crucial for sympathetic cooling of (anti-)protons in a double-well potential as well as for implementing quantum logic spectroscopy with single (anti-)protons.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Thermometry of 9Be+ ions in a cryogenic Penning trap

J. Mielke

High precision comparisons of the proton and antiproton g-factor enable stringent tests of CPT symmetry in the baryonic sector. However, current measurement routines suffer from long preparation times and high particle temperatures, which complicate the increase of the precision beyond the parts per billion regime. As a solution, new sympathetic cooling schemes based on co-trapped laser-cooled ions may be used to cool (anti-)protons to the ground state of motion and to significantly decrease particle preparation times. In addition, motional coupling to an auxiliary ion in a double-well potential can be used for the implementation of new readout schemes based on quantum logic spectroscopy for the spin-state of the (anti-)protons. This thesis describes a cryogenic Penning trap system for ground state cooling of single 9Be+ ions, which represents the latest development of the BASE experiment in Hannover towards the implementation of sympathetic cooling schemes and quantum logic spectroscopy of single (anti-)protons. Furthermore, the setup and implementation of lasers systems at 313nm for Doppler cooling, repumping and Raman interactions are described. To this end, an optical platform for laser beam delivery to the vacuum system and an optical phase-locked loop for the stabilization of the relative phase of two lasers at 313 nm are presented. In this work, the laser systems are used for measurements of the optical resonance frequencies for cooling, probing and repumping of 9Be+ ions. In addition, stimulated Raman transitions are demonstrated using two phase-locked lasers at 313nm. In the following, this technique is used for high-precision measurements of the qubit frequency and the magnetic field, as well as themometry measurements with 9Be+ ions. The temperature of the ions after Doppler cooling is measured as a function of the cooling laser parameters and a minimal axial mode temperature of 1.77(10) mK is obtained. The results of this thesis pave the way for sideband spectroscopy and ground state cooling of single 9Be+ ions in Penning traps, which is an essential prerequisite for sympathetic ground state cooling of single (anti-)protons and the application of quantum logic spectroscopy to (anti-)proton g-factor measurements in the future.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Two-symmetry Penning-Ioffe trap for antihydrogen cooling and spectroscopy

E. R. Tardiff, Xing Fan, G. Gabrielse +12 more

High-accuracy spectroscopic comparisons of trapped antihydrogen atoms (H¯) and hydrogen atoms (H) promise to stringently test the fundamental CPT symmetry invariance of the standard model of particle physics. ATRAP’s nested Penning-Ioffe trap was developed for such studies. The first of its unique features is that its magnetic Ioffe trap for H¯atoms can be switched between quadrupole and octupole symmetries. The second is that it allows laser and microwave access perpendicular to the central axis of the traps.

arXiv:2003.05032•Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A Accelerators Spectrometers Detectors and Associated Equipment•Jun 24, 2020•6 citations

Quantum-logic spectroscopy of an electron or positron for precise tests of the standard model

Xing Fan, Atsushi Noguchi, Kento Taniguchi

We propose a scheme for quantum-logic spectroscopy of an electron or positron in a Penning trap. An electron or positron in a spectroscopy trap is coupled to a remote logic electron or positron via a wire to achieve motional entanglement. By separating the two traps, one can significantly improve magnetic field homogeneity, microwave characteristics, and detection sensitivity. The proposed scheme will improve the measurement precision of the electron's and positron's magnetic moments and charge-to-mass ratios, enabling precise tests of the standard model of particle physics.

arXiv:2502.14157•Physical Review A•Apr 7, 2025•4 citations

Development of a Pulse-Tube-Cooled, Cryogenic, Permanent Magnet Trap for Laser Cooling at μTEx

P. Justus

A direct, high-precision measurement of the 3He2+ nuclear magnetic moment in a Penning trap will provide the most accurate calibration of 3He probes for nuclear magnetic resonance. The magnetic moment measurement at μTEx is carried out using the so-called continuous Stern-Gerlach effect, in which the spin state of the trapped ion is determined via axial frequency shifts in an inhomogeneous magnetic field. However, its mass and small magnetic moment lead to difficulties in determining the spin state, as the axial frequency shifts are on the order of background frequency fluctuations. These fluctuations can be reduced by lowering the energy of the trapped ion. Since traditional resistive cooling is not sufficient, and a bare helium nucleus cannot be laser cooled directly to reduce its energy, sympathetic cooling of 3He2+ is a well-suited technique. It is achieved by coupling the nucleus to a cloud of Doppler-cooled 9Be+ ions - produced by laser ablation from a solid target - in a coupling trap. To characterise laser cooling of 9Be+ at its 2S1/2 →2 P3/2 transition and to test the available coupling trap, a new cryogenic Penning-trap experiment at μTEx is currently being developed. The experiment uses a pair of Penning traps coupled together over their endcaps forming the coupling trap for sympathetic laser cooling of 3He2+ with 9Be+. The setup, developed and characterized within this thesis, utilises a pulse-tube cooler to reach cryogenic temperatures of 4 K and a permanent magnet capable of generating a magnetic field of 240 mT, with the B2 parameter between ±2 T/m2 over a distance of 5 mm, and 0.75 T/m2 at the trap centre. The choice of a pulse tube cooler and permanent magnet makes the experiment capable of supporting frequent cooling cycles and quick changes. Initially, the experiment is supposed to test the coupling traps and to characterise laser cooling of 9Be+ ions, and in future, offer an adjustable platform for further testing of new components related to high-precision experiments in Penning traps.

•Aug 1, 2025•0 citations

Direct observation of a single proton in a Penning trap. Towards a direct measurement of the proton g-factor

S. Kreim

This PhD thesis presents experiments performed on a single proton stored in a Penning trap. The eigenmotion of an isolated, free proton could be detected electronically via a coupling to a resonance circuit. This represents a non-destructive measurement, i. e. the particle is not lost during the measurement. The free cyclotron frequency emerging from the measured eigenfrequencies is one of the two frequencies required for the determination of the magnetic moment. This enables a direct determination of the g-factor contrary to already existing works. Design, developing, and commissioning of the experimental setup have been accomplished within the scope of this work leading to a measuring accuracy of 10−7. The technical challenges for the determination of the second frequency (the Larmor frequency) arising from the smallness of the magnetic moment were mastered. Since the spin state required for this measurement is an internal degree of freedom, it can only be accessed through a coupling of the magnetic moment to the eigenmotion. A novel, hybrid penning trap is presented in this work, which imprints the spin information onto the eigenmotion, thus, realizing a quantum jump spectrometer. Therewith, the frequency shift of the two spin states resulting from the magnetic coupling reaches for the first time an electronically detectable range.

•Jun 29, 2009•0 citations
On the potential for high-accuracy spectroscopy of H2+\mathrm{H}_2^+H2+​ and H‾2−\overline{\mathrm{H}}_2^-H2−​ in Penning traps for a test of CPT invariance
The comparison of vibrational transition frequencies of H2+\mathrm{H}_2^+H2+​ and H‾2−\overline{\mathrm{H}}_2^-H2−​ offers a new opportunity to test CPT invariance. Myers [Phys. Rev. A 98, 010101(R) (2018)] proposed performing laser spectroscopy in a Penning trap (PT) with non-destructive read-out. Here, we provide an extensive analysis of this proposal, introduce novel aspects, and discuss its implementation in PTs that incorporate either the continuous Stern-Gerlach effect or quantum-logic spectroscopy. We derive estimates for the achievable accuracy of the test. We find that a comparison of the vibrational frequencies at a fractional level of 1×10−171\times10^{-17}1×10−17 is a realistic prospect, using technology that is mostly already available. We also analyze complementary CPT invariance tests, namely those of the g-factor of the bound electron/positron via electron-spin-resonance spectroscopy and of the magnetic moment of the proton/antiproton via radiofrequency spectroscopy.
The comparison of the g-factors of the proton and the antiproton is a stringent test of CPT invariance. The state-of-the-art method for the determination of the (anti-)proton's g-factor is the application of the continuous Stern-Gerlach effect. With this method, precisions in the low parts per billion regime could be achieved. However, preparation times for cold enough particles are on the order of minutes to hours. The implementation of sympathetic cooling using a co-trapped atomic ion could lead to preparation times in the milliseconds regime. Furthermore, the applicability of sympathetic cooling would enable an alternative readout scheme using quantum logic methods. This thesis presents a Penning trap system that is designed for ground state cooling, adiabatic transport, and motional coupling of single 9Be+ ions. It has been built in a modular manner, giving the option of adapting it for motional coupling and sympathetic cooling of single (anti-)protons. In the course of this work, the prerequisites for motional coupling of 9Be+ ions have been fulfilled: A cloud of 9Be+ ions was cooled to a temperature of 1.7~mK applying Doppler cooling. The achieved temperature is about three times the Doppler limit which is 0.5~mK for beryllium ions. Furthermore, a scheme for reproducible loading of the trap and reducing the particle number was developed. Finally, first transport in our apparatus was demonstrated with clouds of beryllium ions. The method used for that is directly applicable to single ions. The results of this work pave the way towards adiabatic transport of single 9Be+ ions, which is crucial for sympathetic cooling of (anti-)protons in a double-well potential as well as for implementing quantum logic spectroscopy with single (anti-)protons.
High precision comparisons of the proton and antiproton g-factor enable stringent tests of CPT symmetry in the baryonic sector. However, current measurement routines suffer from long preparation times and high particle temperatures, which complicate the increase of the precision beyond the parts per billion regime. As a solution, new sympathetic cooling schemes based on co-trapped laser-cooled ions may be used to cool (anti-)protons to the ground state of motion and to significantly decrease particle preparation times. In addition, motional coupling to an auxiliary ion in a double-well potential can be used for the implementation of new readout schemes based on quantum logic spectroscopy for the spin-state of the (anti-)protons. This thesis describes a cryogenic Penning trap system for ground state cooling of single 9Be+ ions, which represents the latest development of the BASE experiment in Hannover towards the implementation of sympathetic cooling schemes and quantum logic spectroscopy of single (anti-)protons. Furthermore, the setup and implementation of lasers systems at 313nm for Doppler cooling, repumping and Raman interactions are described. To this end, an optical platform for laser beam delivery to the vacuum system and an optical phase-locked loop for the stabilization of the relative phase of two lasers at 313 nm are presented. In this work, the laser systems are used for measurements of the optical resonance frequencies for cooling, probing and repumping of 9Be+ ions. In addition, stimulated Raman transitions are demonstrated using two phase-locked lasers at 313nm. In the following, this technique is used for high-precision measurements of the qubit frequency and the magnetic field, as well as themometry measurements with 9Be+ ions. The temperature of the ions after Doppler cooling is measured as a function of the cooling laser parameters and a minimal axial mode temperature of 1.77(10) mK is obtained. The results of this thesis pave the way for sideband spectroscopy and ground state cooling of single 9Be+ ions in Penning traps, which is an essential prerequisite for sympathetic ground state cooling of single (anti-)protons and the application of quantum logic spectroscopy to (anti-)proton g-factor measurements in the future.
High-accuracy spectroscopic comparisons of trapped antihydrogen atoms (H¯) and hydrogen atoms (H) promise to stringently test the fundamental CPT symmetry invariance of the standard model of particle physics. ATRAP’s nested Penning-Ioffe trap was developed for such studies. The first of its unique features is that its magnetic Ioffe trap for H¯atoms can be switched between quadrupole and octupole symmetries. The second is that it allows laser and microwave access perpendicular to the central axis of the traps.
We propose a scheme for quantum-logic spectroscopy of an electron or positron in a Penning trap. An electron or positron in a spectroscopy trap is coupled to a remote logic electron or positron via a wire to achieve motional entanglement. By separating the two traps, one can significantly improve magnetic field homogeneity, microwave characteristics, and detection sensitivity. The proposed scheme will improve the measurement precision of the electron's and positron's magnetic moments and charge-to-mass ratios, enabling precise tests of the standard model of particle physics.
A direct, high-precision measurement of the 3He2+ nuclear magnetic moment in a Penning trap will provide the most accurate calibration of 3He probes for nuclear magnetic resonance. The magnetic moment measurement at μTEx is carried out using the so-called continuous Stern-Gerlach effect, in which the spin state of the trapped ion is determined via axial frequency shifts in an inhomogeneous magnetic field. However, its mass and small magnetic moment lead to difficulties in determining the spin state, as the axial frequency shifts are on the order of background frequency fluctuations. These fluctuations can be reduced by lowering the energy of the trapped ion. Since traditional resistive cooling is not sufficient, and a bare helium nucleus cannot be laser cooled directly to reduce its energy, sympathetic cooling of 3He2+ is a well-suited technique. It is achieved by coupling the nucleus to a cloud of Doppler-cooled 9Be+ ions - produced by laser ablation from a solid target - in a coupling trap. To characterise laser cooling of 9Be+ at its 2S1/2 →2 P3/2 transition and to test the available coupling trap, a new cryogenic Penning-trap experiment at μTEx is currently being developed. The experiment uses a pair of Penning traps coupled together over their endcaps forming the coupling trap for sympathetic laser cooling of 3He2+ with 9Be+. The setup, developed and characterized within this thesis, utilises a pulse-tube cooler to reach cryogenic temperatures of 4 K and a permanent magnet capable of generating a magnetic field of 240 mT, with the B2 parameter between ±2 T/m2 over a distance of 5 mm, and 0.75 T/m2 at the trap centre. The choice of a pulse tube cooler and permanent magnet makes the experiment capable of supporting frequent cooling cycles and quick changes. Initially, the experiment is supposed to test the coupling traps and to characterise laser cooling of 9Be+ ions, and in future, offer an adjustable platform for further testing of new components related to high-precision experiments in Penning traps.
This PhD thesis presents experiments performed on a single proton stored in a Penning trap. The eigenmotion of an isolated, free proton could be detected electronically via a coupling to a resonance circuit. This represents a non-destructive measurement, i. e. the particle is not lost during the measurement. The free cyclotron frequency emerging from the measured eigenfrequencies is one of the two frequencies required for the determination of the magnetic moment. This enables a direct determination of the g-factor contrary to already existing works. Design, developing, and commissioning of the experimental setup have been accomplished within the scope of this work leading to a measuring accuracy of 10−7. The technical challenges for the determination of the second frequency (the Larmor frequency) arising from the smallness of the magnetic moment were mastered. Since the spin state required for this measurement is an internal degree of freedom, it can only be accessed through a coupling of the magnetic moment to the eigenmotion. A novel, hybrid penning trap is presented in this work, which imprints the spin information onto the eigenmotion, thus, realizing a quantum jump spectrometer. Therewith, the frequency shift of the two spin states resulting from the magnetic coupling reaches for the first time an electronically detectable range.