Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.16148

A reason why we do not observe Schrödinger's cats

Fabio Siringo

quant-phcond-mat.stat-mechhep-thSubmitted May 15, 2026• Announced May 18, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Jun 6, 2026 (v2)
v1 · May 15, 2026v2 · Jun 6, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A reason is discussed (may be not the only one) for why we do not see any superposition of macroscopic states in the real world. Under the general assumption that quantum macrostates are statistical ensembles of microstates, it is shown that any superposition of macrostates is reduced in a very short time by the unitary dynamics of the ordinary Schrödinger equation, deducing the Born rule without having to postulate it. In more detail, the macroscopic and microscopic degrees of freedom are decoupled in the Schrödinger equation, yielding an effective stochastic equation for the macroscopic variables, with the ensemble average of the microscopic amplitudes that acts as a self-generated internal white noise. The stochastic equation is shown to be a reducing Itô equation if some general causality conditions are met, predicting a very quick collapse of any macroscopic superposition upon formation, with probabilities which satisfy the Born rule. In the context of the von Neumann measurement scheme, the relevance of the result is discussed as a simple dynamical solution of the measurement problem.

Related papers

Without the Born Rule

Richard A. Mould

The auxiliary rules of quantum mechanics have always included the Born rule that connects probability with square modulus. This need not be the case, for it is possible to introduce probability into the theory through probability current alone. When this is done, other rules can provide for stochastically triggered measurements within a system of any size, microscopic or macroscopic; and solutions to the Schrodinger equation can be consistently applied to individual trials, not just to ensembles of trials. Other advantages appear. The rules can then resolve the paradox associated with the Schrodinger cat experiment, and remove the possibility of the many world thesis of Everett. As a result, the system can accommodate any conscious observer, including the principal investigator who cannot otherwise be included in a quantum mechanical system.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507170•Jul 18, 2005•6 citations

Is the Born rule a result of measurement noise?

Torres, Frank

The Born rule asserts the probability distribution of eigenstates observed in unbiased quantum measurements, but the reason it holds remains elusive. This manuscript discusses how the Born rule might be explained by Schrodinger equation dynamics, if a measurement comprises a system responding to random fluctuations until it is within an arbitrarily small tolerance of a measurement eigenstate. We describe the random walk dynamics that produce this behavior in terms of a class of time-dependent, stochastic unitary matrices U(t). We also discuss the class of stochastic potential energies in the Schrodinger equation that is equivalent to this class of unitary matrices. This analysis raises some questions worth considering, including how to determine if any measurements actually follow the predicted random walk mechanism and whether a reliable measurement apparatus could be designed that deviates from Born rule probabilities. Interestingly, if any measurements do follow this random walk mechanism, then exposing a quantum system to stochastic 'noise' is an intrinsic part of such a measurement, not merely an unwanted side effect. This characteristic would have implications for reducing noise in quantum sensing and quantum computing. This is a draft of a work in progress. Questions and suggestions are welcome.

arXiv:2407.03139•Jul 3, 2024•0 citations

Decay of quantum coherence using quantum trajectories

H. J. Carmichael, L. Tian, P. Kochan

In the quantum trajectory approach an open quantum system is represented by a stochastic pure-state wave function. The mixed-state density operator that satisfies the usual master equation is recovered from the quantum trajectories by performing either an ensemble average or, for stationary systems, an average over time. This unraveling of the master equation dynamics into pure-state trajectories provides new insight into the decay of quantum coherence in systems that are open to the environment. Under some conditions macroscopic superposition states are preserved as macroscopic superposition states along individual trajectories, but are reduced to mixtures by the trajectory average. Under other conditions one of the states in a macroscopic superposition becomes dominant (in amplitude) over the other along each quantum trajectory. We discuss the mechanisms that produce these dynamics and assess the implications for the observation of Schrodinger cat states in optics experiments. We present results for some specific examples of macroscopic superposition states generated by a cavity QED system. The system involves a small collection of atoms in an optical cavity driven by a coherent laser field. Under strong-coupling conditions this system produces a variety of Schrodinger cat states whose precise form depends on the number of atoms, the method of excitation (through a cavity mirror or from the side), the initial state of the atoms, and the position of the atoms in the cavity.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations

Scheme of a Derivation of Collapse from Quantum Dynamics

Roland L. Omnes

Two categories of results regarding quantum measurements are derived in this work and applied to the problem of collapse. The first category is concerned with local and transient features of the entanglement between a macroscopic measuring system and a measured one. These properties result directly from the Schrödinger equation. They cannot be formulated in terms of observables, do not affect the wave functions themselves but express their history in an irreversible way. They carry a specific new kind of local probabilities, which evolve with a finite velocity under nonlinear wave equations. The second category of results extends these local properties to the case of a macroscopic system and its environment. Fluctuations in their interaction are predicted then and generate a specific incoherence in the quantum state of the system. These two kinds of effects act together when a macroscopic measuring system interacts with a measured system and with an environment. Their combination yields then an explicit and effective mechanism of collapse, with a random behavior resulting from random incoherence. Born's basic probability rule for the results of measurements turns out then simply a consequence of quantum dynamics. Some conjectures still enter into the derivation of these effects, which one may recognize to look hardly credible at first sight. They fit however so well together that one proposes a more thorough investigation of their approach as a promising strategy for a self-contained explanation of collapse.

arXiv:1601.01214•Jan 6, 2016•1 citation

Schrödinger’s cat problem: Measurement, decoherence, macroscopic superposition, and definite outcomes

Sachin .

Schrödinger’s cat condenses the quantum measurement problem into an amplification chain: a microscopic alternative becomes correlated with distinguishable records, while linear quantum dynamics retains the records in an entangled state. The problem is not a puzzle about an animal with incompatible predicates. It concerns the relation between unitary dynamics, reduced-state classicality, and observing a outcome. This article develops the cat problem from the density-operator description of measurement, deriving the role of partial tracing and environmental decoherence, and distinguishing a decohered improper mixture from a proper classical ensemble. It examines pointer-state selection, Lindblad dynamics, quantum Darwinism, and responses to the outcome problem: Everettian branching, consistent histories, Bohmian mechanics, and objective-collapse models. Experimental realizations in trapped ions, cavity quantum electrodynamics, and mechanical resonators demonstrate superpositions of distinguishable alternatives. Bosonic cat codes show that macroscopic-superposition structure can be engineered as an information resource. The article identifies four weaknesses: conflating diagonal reduced states with collapse; treating non-equivalent “cat-size” measures as interchangeable; insufficient treatment of environmental noise in collapse tests; and an underdeveloped connection between measurement theory and error-corrected bosonic architectures.

International Journal of Physics and Mathematics•Jul 1, 2025•0 citations

A model for the solution of the quantum measurement problem

Biswaranjan Dikshit

The basic idea of quantum mechanics is that the property of any system can be in a state of superposition of various possibilities (or eigen states).This state of superposition is also known as wave function and it evolves linearly with time in a deterministic way in accordance with the Schrodinger equation.However, when a measurement is carried out on the system to determine the value of that property (say position), the system instantaneously transforms to one of the eigen states and thus we get only a single value as an outcome of the measurement.Quantum measurement problem seeks to find the cause and exact mechanism governing this transformation.In an attempt to solve the above problem, in this paper, we will first define what the wave function represents in real-world and will identify the root cause behind the stochastic nature of events.Then, we will develop a model to explain the mechanism of collapse of the quantum mechanical wave function in response to a measurement.In the process of development of model, we will explain Schrodinger cat paradox and will show how Born's rule for probability becomes a natural consequence of the measurement process.

Science & philosophy•Dec 30, 2019•0 citations
A reason is discussed (may be not the only one) for why we do not see any superposition of macroscopic states in the real world. Under the general assumption that quantum macrostates are statistical ensembles of microstates, it is shown that any superposition of macrostates is reduced in a very short time by the unitary dynamics of the ordinary Schrödinger equation, deducing the Born rule without having to postulate it. In more detail, the macroscopic and microscopic degrees of freedom are decoupled in the Schrödinger equation, yielding an effective stochastic equation for the macroscopic variables, with the ensemble average of the microscopic amplitudes that acts as a self-generated internal white noise. The stochastic equation is shown to be a reducing Itô equation if some general causality conditions are met, predicting a very quick collapse of any macroscopic superposition upon formation, with probabilities which satisfy the Born rule. In the context of the von Neumann measurement scheme, the relevance of the result is discussed as a simple dynamical solution of the measurement problem.
The auxiliary rules of quantum mechanics have always included the Born rule that connects probability with square modulus. This need not be the case, for it is possible to introduce probability into the theory through probability current alone. When this is done, other rules can provide for stochastically triggered measurements within a system of any size, microscopic or macroscopic; and solutions to the Schrodinger equation can be consistently applied to individual trials, not just to ensembles of trials. Other advantages appear. The rules can then resolve the paradox associated with the Schrodinger cat experiment, and remove the possibility of the many world thesis of Everett. As a result, the system can accommodate any conscious observer, including the principal investigator who cannot otherwise be included in a quantum mechanical system.
The Born rule asserts the probability distribution of eigenstates observed in unbiased quantum measurements, but the reason it holds remains elusive. This manuscript discusses how the Born rule might be explained by Schrodinger equation dynamics, if a measurement comprises a system responding to random fluctuations until it is within an arbitrarily small tolerance of a measurement eigenstate. We describe the random walk dynamics that produce this behavior in terms of a class of time-dependent, stochastic unitary matrices U(t). We also discuss the class of stochastic potential energies in the Schrodinger equation that is equivalent to this class of unitary matrices. This analysis raises some questions worth considering, including how to determine if any measurements actually follow the predicted random walk mechanism and whether a reliable measurement apparatus could be designed that deviates from Born rule probabilities. Interestingly, if any measurements do follow this random walk mechanism, then exposing a quantum system to stochastic 'noise' is an intrinsic part of such a measurement, not merely an unwanted side effect. This characteristic would have implications for reducing noise in quantum sensing and quantum computing. This is a draft of a work in progress. Questions and suggestions are welcome.
In the quantum trajectory approach an open quantum system is represented by a stochastic pure-state wave function. The mixed-state density operator that satisfies the usual master equation is recovered from the quantum trajectories by performing either an ensemble average or, for stationary systems, an average over time. This unraveling of the master equation dynamics into pure-state trajectories provides new insight into the decay of quantum coherence in systems that are open to the environment. Under some conditions macroscopic superposition states are preserved as macroscopic superposition states along individual trajectories, but are reduced to mixtures by the trajectory average. Under other conditions one of the states in a macroscopic superposition becomes dominant (in amplitude) over the other along each quantum trajectory. We discuss the mechanisms that produce these dynamics and assess the implications for the observation of Schrodinger cat states in optics experiments. We present results for some specific examples of macroscopic superposition states generated by a cavity QED system. The system involves a small collection of atoms in an optical cavity driven by a coherent laser field. Under strong-coupling conditions this system produces a variety of Schrodinger cat states whose precise form depends on the number of atoms, the method of excitation (through a cavity mirror or from the side), the initial state of the atoms, and the position of the atoms in the cavity.
Two categories of results regarding quantum measurements are derived in this work and applied to the problem of collapse. The first category is concerned with local and transient features of the entanglement between a macroscopic measuring system and a measured one. These properties result directly from the Schrödinger equation. They cannot be formulated in terms of observables, do not affect the wave functions themselves but express their history in an irreversible way. They carry a specific new kind of local probabilities, which evolve with a finite velocity under nonlinear wave equations. The second category of results extends these local properties to the case of a macroscopic system and its environment. Fluctuations in their interaction are predicted then and generate a specific incoherence in the quantum state of the system. These two kinds of effects act together when a macroscopic measuring system interacts with a measured system and with an environment. Their combination yields then an explicit and effective mechanism of collapse, with a random behavior resulting from random incoherence. Born's basic probability rule for the results of measurements turns out then simply a consequence of quantum dynamics. Some conjectures still enter into the derivation of these effects, which one may recognize to look hardly credible at first sight. They fit however so well together that one proposes a more thorough investigation of their approach as a promising strategy for a self-contained explanation of collapse.
Schrödinger’s cat condenses the quantum measurement problem into an amplification chain: a microscopic alternative becomes correlated with distinguishable records, while linear quantum dynamics retains the records in an entangled state. The problem is not a puzzle about an animal with incompatible predicates. It concerns the relation between unitary dynamics, reduced-state classicality, and observing a outcome. This article develops the cat problem from the density-operator description of measurement, deriving the role of partial tracing and environmental decoherence, and distinguishing a decohered improper mixture from a proper classical ensemble. It examines pointer-state selection, Lindblad dynamics, quantum Darwinism, and responses to the outcome problem: Everettian branching, consistent histories, Bohmian mechanics, and objective-collapse models. Experimental realizations in trapped ions, cavity quantum electrodynamics, and mechanical resonators demonstrate superpositions of distinguishable alternatives. Bosonic cat codes show that macroscopic-superposition structure can be engineered as an information resource. The article identifies four weaknesses: conflating diagonal reduced states with collapse; treating non-equivalent “cat-size” measures as interchangeable; insufficient treatment of environmental noise in collapse tests; and an underdeveloped connection between measurement theory and error-corrected bosonic architectures.
The basic idea of quantum mechanics is that the property of any system can be in a state of superposition of various possibilities (or eigen states).This state of superposition is also known as wave function and it evolves linearly with time in a deterministic way in accordance with the Schrodinger equation.However, when a measurement is carried out on the system to determine the value of that property (say position), the system instantaneously transforms to one of the eigen states and thus we get only a single value as an outcome of the measurement.Quantum measurement problem seeks to find the cause and exact mechanism governing this transformation.In an attempt to solve the above problem, in this paper, we will first define what the wave function represents in real-world and will identify the root cause behind the stochastic nature of events.Then, we will develop a model to explain the mechanism of collapse of the quantum mechanical wave function in response to a measurement.In the process of development of model, we will explain Schrodinger cat paradox and will show how Born's rule for probability becomes a natural consequence of the measurement process.