Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.10638

Quantifying the Hadamard Resilience Law: Discovery of the Coherence Gap in NISQ-Era Classifiers

Wladimir Silva

quant-phSubmitted May 11, 2026• Announced May 12, 2026• 0 citations• Revised May 13, 2026 (v2)
v1 · May 11, 2026v2 · May 13, 2026v3 · Sep 8, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We report on a fundamental disparity between stochastic noise models and algorithmic performance in NISQ-era classifiers. Utilizing the ibm_kingston processor, we characterize the "Kingston Constant" ($κ\approx 0.07$), representing a 93% signal magnitude collapse. Despite this decay, we demonstrate that the Hadamard Test Perceptron maintains a 93.9% MNIST accuracy, validating our proposed Hadamard Resilience Law. However, a systemic divergence -- the "Coherence Gap" ($Δρ\approx 0.91$) -- emerges at high feature depths ($N=256$), where physical hardware collapses while stochastic simulations remain resilient. This gap identifies coherent phase errors, rather than depolarizing noise, as the primary barrier to scaling quantum linear layers. Furthermore, experimental results on the ibm_kingston processor reveal a "Coherence Wall" at $N=256$, where circuit depth ($D \approx 10k$) exceeds the hardware's resilient depth limit ($D_{max} \approx 3.5k$). We provide a refined hardware-aware model that accounts for this coherence-induced signal decay, establishing a predictive boundary for robust quantum linear layers on current NISQ devices.

Comments
8 pages, 6 figures, 3 tables

Related papers

Variational Quantum Machine Learning for Binary Classification on NISQ Hardware: Expressibility, Trainability, and Noise Robustness

Priya S. Mehta, Aleksandr V. Korolev

This study investigates classification performance and trainability of variational quantum classifiers on near-term noisy quantum hardware across circuit depth and qubit count regimes within the context of quantum computing and machine learning, an area of growing scientific importance given its implications for hybrid quantum-classical algorithm design and practical NISQ hardware benchmarking for near-term quantum advantage assessment. Using gradient-based parameter optimization of parameterized quantum circuits with hardware noise modeling via density matrix simulation and physical execution on IBM Eagle processors, we examine expressibility of parameterized circuits enabling nonlinear decision boundaries in feature Hilbert space, with trainability constrained by barren plateau gradients at large qubit counts in 96 circuit architectures (4 qubit counts x 4 depths x 6 ansatz families) evaluated across 5 classification datasets with 20 random initialization seeds each drawn from IBM Quantum Eagle (127-qubit) and Falcon (27-qubit) processors with noise mitigation via zero-noise extrapolation. Results indicate that 10-qubit, 4-layer VQC achieves 84.2% classification accuracy on the best benchmark, within 3.8 percentage points of classical SVM, but gradient variance decays exponentially with qubit count (variance halving per 2 added qubits), confirming barren plateau scaling (p < 0.001), with 84.2% accuracy, 3.8 pp gap to classical SVM baseline as the primary quantitative benchmark. Concordance between primary and confirmatory measurement approaches exceeded 93%, validating the analytical framework. These findings contribute empirically to quantum computing and machine learning and carry actionable implications for the design of programs and policies targeting hybrid quantum-classical algorithm design and practical NISQ hardware benchmarking for near-term quantum advantage assessment.

Princeton Journal of Pre-Collegiate Research•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Emergent Effective Depth in Quantum Machine Learning: Empirical Gradient Attenuation Scaling in Noisy Variational Quantum Algorithms

Carlos Mario Braga, Manuel A. Serrano, Eduardo Fernández‐Medina

Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices impose structural constraints on the training of Variational Quantum Algorithms (VQAs). In the absence of full error correction, each quantum gate introduces a non-zero probability of error that accumulates with circuit depth, while gradient estimation through finite sampling adds additional statistical variability. As a result, convergence depends on a delicate balance between physical coherence and estimation variance. In this setting, the depth of the variational ansatz not only determines model expressivity, but also its operational feasibility under noise. Without an explicit characterization of the interaction between error accumulation, number of measurements (shots), and control strategies, increasing experimental resources may fail to improve performance and can even become counterproductive. In this work, we empirically analyze how circuit depth affects the practical signal of the gradient under depolarizing noise. Across multiple configurations ($q=4-7$qubits), we observe a pattern consistent with an effective exponential attenuation of the coherent gradient contribution, characterized by a per-layer rate$\epsilon_{\text{eff}}$. The estimated magnitude of$\epsilon_{\text{eff}}$depends on circuit complexity and remains largely independent of the measurement budget, indicating that it primarily reflects architectural and physical factors rather than sampling effects. The analysis of adaptive control strategies further suggests that accuracy gains are constrained by gradient attenuation, rather than scaling significantly with circuit depth. However, a crossmode comparison across three distinct training strategies reveals that, while accuracy improvements remain modest, adaptive perturbations substantially improve the statistical detectability of the attenuation signal, acting as diagnostic probes rather than mere optimization heuristics. Taken together, these results suggest that the usable depth of a variational ansatz can be interpreted as an emergent property of the effective signal-to-noise regime, governed by a measurable structural parameter whose ranking across circuit configurations is preserved independently of the training mode. This framework enables principled comparison of circuit architectures in terms of their effective trainability under noise, providing guidance for architectural and control design in Quantum Machine Learning under NISQ conditions.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Software (QSW)•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

Noise Resilience of Quantum Support Vector Machine with Selected Feature Maps

Muhammad Ahsan Shakeel, Saad Muzammil, Danyal Tayyub +1 more

Gate-level noise degrades the classification accuracy of Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVMs) on Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware, and the degree of degradation depends on how classical data is encoded into quantum states. We tested Z, ZZ, a Pauli, and an amplitude-inspired feature maps under depolarizing, bit-flip, and phase-flip noise channels in $52$ controlled experiments with error probabilities $p =0.01, 0.05, 0.10$, and $0.50$. The amplitude-inspired feature map had $100$\% test accuracy up to $p = 0.10$ across all three noise channels, while other feature maps fell to $65$-$90$\% under the same noise level and type. The Z feature map was found to be immune to phase-flip noise to a significantly high error rate, a consequence of the commutation relation $[R_Z, Z] = 0$. Entangled circuit variants produced generalization gaps in train-test sets of up to $17.5$\% under noise, whereas the amplitude variants maintained zero gap throughout. These results give practitioners data-driven criteria for a feature map on near-term quantum hardware.

quant-pharXiv:2608.17495•Aug 19, 2026•0 citations

Noise Resilience and the Quantum-Classical Boundary for NISQ Devices

Yalla Jnan Devi Satya Prasad

As quantum processors move into the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era, the central question is no longer whether a quantum algorithm is asymptotically faster than its classical counterpart, but whether it can retain a meaningful speedup under realistic noise, compilation, and measurement constraints. This work develops a quantitative framework for characterizing the noise resilience of quantum advantage. We introduce the advantage robustness function RA(ε), which measures how the asymptotic and concrete performance of an algorithm A degrades with physical error rate ε, and we compute it analytically or numerically for twelve representative algorithm families, including Grover search, amplitude estimation, phase estimation, HHL, VQE/QAOA, Hamiltonian simulation, and sampling algorithms. For each class, we derive critical noise thresholds and depth limits beyond which classical algorithms regain supremacy, explicitly incorporating realistic connectivity and compilation overheads. We show that algorithms based on coherent amplitude amplification are more fragile to coherent errors than depolarizing noise, while variational algorithms display a tradeoff between expressivity and robustness. By combining these algorithm-specific robustness curves with current and projected hardware error rates for superconducting, trapped-ion, neutralatom, and photonic platforms, we map out a phase diagram of practical quantum advantage that links problem size, noise rate, and algorithm type. Our analysis identifies promising near-term application windows in risk analytics, small-molecule chemistry, and structured optimization, and also delineates regions where no advantage is realistic, providing valuable guidance for both algorithm designers and hardware architects.

•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

NISQ in practice: navigating noise, scale, and hardware constraints of near-term devices in quantum machine learning workflows

Chisomo Daka, Somnath Bhattacharyya

Abstract The arrival of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices defines an era in which quantum utility is fundamentally constrained by finite coherence times, limited qubit counts, gate infidelities, restricted connectivity, and measurement noise. Within this regime, hybrid quantum-classical frameworks have emerged as the dominant operational paradigm, particularly for quantum machine learning (QML). This review identifies a fundamental trade-off between expressivity, trainability, and noise resilience that governs the performance and scalability of NISQ-era QML systems. To contextualize these challenges, we introduce the resource-constrained iterative routing framework, a hardware-aware conceptual architecture that integrates topology-aware classical compression and distributed quantum orchestration to maintain circuit depths within device-dependent limits while routing representations toward symmetry-constrained Hilbert subspaces to mitigate noise-induced barren plateaus. Furthermore, we shift the discussion of quantum advantage away from asymptotic fault-tolerant complexity toward the notion of operational NISQ advantage based on finite-resource scaling, trainability preservation, and sampling complexity. We evaluate the practical resource efficiency of variational quantum algorithms, quantum kernel methods, and quantum neural networks across superconducting, trapped-ion, neutral-atom, and photonic platforms. The review also examines reproducibility challenges, emphasizing benchmarking against optimized classical baselines, and discusses strategies for managing the sampling overhead of error mitigation alongside distributed execution and quantum circuit compilation. Ultimately, NISQ in Practice positions hybrid QML as a physically constrained computational paradigm while outlining a pathway from contemporary noisy workflows toward early fault-tolerant quantum architectures.

New Journal of Physics•Jun 22, 2026•1 citation

Noise or Signal? A Causal Mediation Analysis of Quantum Circuit Learning Under Real Hardware Noise

Cyrille YetuYetu Kesiku, Begonya García-Zapirain

We deploy a Quantum Counterfactual Mediation Analysis (QCMA) framework on IBM Quantum processors to ask a precise, hardware-grounded question: are causal regimes identified in noiseless simulation preserved under real quantum noise? Integrating partial quantum state tomography with a linear structural equation model, we decompose inter-architectural performance contrasts into direct effects and indirect quantum-mediated effects across twelve experiments spanning three circuit topologies and two benchmark datasets. Five of six topology-dataset pairs (83%) retain their causal regime when migrating from noiseless simulation to physical hardware. Decoherence inflates quantum-mediated contributions by up to one order of magnitude a noise artefact, not quantum advantage while the Neutral regime dominates both backend. These findings indicate that hardware noise may substantially limit the effective utilization of quantum resources in current NISQ circuits, and motivate further investigation into coherence-preserving circuit design strategies.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Software (QSW)•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations
We report on a fundamental disparity between stochastic noise models and algorithmic performance in NISQ-era classifiers. Utilizing the ibm_kingston processor, we characterize the "Kingston Constant" (κ≈0.07κ\approx 0.07κ≈0.07), representing a 93% signal magnitude collapse. Despite this decay, we demonstrate that the Hadamard Test Perceptron maintains a 93.9% MNIST accuracy, validating our proposed Hadamard Resilience Law. However, a systemic divergence -- the "Coherence Gap" (Δρ≈0.91Δρ\approx 0.91Δρ≈0.91) -- emerges at high feature depths (N=256N=256N=256), where physical hardware collapses while stochastic simulations remain resilient. This gap identifies coherent phase errors, rather than depolarizing noise, as the primary barrier to scaling quantum linear layers. Furthermore, experimental results on the ibm_kingston processor reveal a "Coherence Wall" at N=256N=256N=256, where circuit depth (D≈10kD \approx 10kD≈10k) exceeds the hardware's resilient depth limit (Dmax≈3.5kD_{max} \approx 3.5kDmax​≈3.5k). We provide a refined hardware-aware model that accounts for this coherence-induced signal decay, establishing a predictive boundary for robust quantum linear layers on current NISQ devices.
This study investigates classification performance and trainability of variational quantum classifiers on near-term noisy quantum hardware across circuit depth and qubit count regimes within the context of quantum computing and machine learning, an area of growing scientific importance given its implications for hybrid quantum-classical algorithm design and practical NISQ hardware benchmarking for near-term quantum advantage assessment. Using gradient-based parameter optimization of parameterized quantum circuits with hardware noise modeling via density matrix simulation and physical execution on IBM Eagle processors, we examine expressibility of parameterized circuits enabling nonlinear decision boundaries in feature Hilbert space, with trainability constrained by barren plateau gradients at large qubit counts in 96 circuit architectures (4 qubit counts x 4 depths x 6 ansatz families) evaluated across 5 classification datasets with 20 random initialization seeds each drawn from IBM Quantum Eagle (127-qubit) and Falcon (27-qubit) processors with noise mitigation via zero-noise extrapolation. Results indicate that 10-qubit, 4-layer VQC achieves 84.2% classification accuracy on the best benchmark, within 3.8 percentage points of classical SVM, but gradient variance decays exponentially with qubit count (variance halving per 2 added qubits), confirming barren plateau scaling (p < 0.001), with 84.2% accuracy, 3.8 pp gap to classical SVM baseline as the primary quantitative benchmark. Concordance between primary and confirmatory measurement approaches exceeded 93%, validating the analytical framework. These findings contribute empirically to quantum computing and machine learning and carry actionable implications for the design of programs and policies targeting hybrid quantum-classical algorithm design and practical NISQ hardware benchmarking for near-term quantum advantage assessment.
Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices impose structural constraints on the training of Variational Quantum Algorithms (VQAs). In the absence of full error correction, each quantum gate introduces a non-zero probability of error that accumulates with circuit depth, while gradient estimation through finite sampling adds additional statistical variability. As a result, convergence depends on a delicate balance between physical coherence and estimation variance. In this setting, the depth of the variational ansatz not only determines model expressivity, but also its operational feasibility under noise. Without an explicit characterization of the interaction between error accumulation, number of measurements (shots), and control strategies, increasing experimental resources may fail to improve performance and can even become counterproductive. In this work, we empirically analyze how circuit depth affects the practical signal of the gradient under depolarizing noise. Across multiple configurations (q=4−7q=4-7q=4−7qubits), we observe a pattern consistent with an effective exponential attenuation of the coherent gradient contribution, characterized by a per-layer rateϵeff\epsilon_{\text{eff}}ϵeff​. The estimated magnitude ofϵeff\epsilon_{\text{eff}}ϵeff​depends on circuit complexity and remains largely independent of the measurement budget, indicating that it primarily reflects architectural and physical factors rather than sampling effects. The analysis of adaptive control strategies further suggests that accuracy gains are constrained by gradient attenuation, rather than scaling significantly with circuit depth. However, a crossmode comparison across three distinct training strategies reveals that, while accuracy improvements remain modest, adaptive perturbations substantially improve the statistical detectability of the attenuation signal, acting as diagnostic probes rather than mere optimization heuristics. Taken together, these results suggest that the usable depth of a variational ansatz can be interpreted as an emergent property of the effective signal-to-noise regime, governed by a measurable structural parameter whose ranking across circuit configurations is preserved independently of the training mode. This framework enables principled comparison of circuit architectures in terms of their effective trainability under noise, providing guidance for architectural and control design in Quantum Machine Learning under NISQ conditions.
Gate-level noise degrades the classification accuracy of Quantum Support Vector Machines (QSVMs) on Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware, and the degree of degradation depends on how classical data is encoded into quantum states. We tested Z, ZZ, a Pauli, and an amplitude-inspired feature maps under depolarizing, bit-flip, and phase-flip noise channels in 525252 controlled experiments with error probabilities p=0.01,0.05,0.10p =0.01, 0.05, 0.10p=0.01,0.05,0.10, and 0.500.500.50. The amplitude-inspired feature map had 100100100\% test accuracy up to p=0.10p = 0.10p=0.10 across all three noise channels, while other feature maps fell to 656565-909090\% under the same noise level and type. The Z feature map was found to be immune to phase-flip noise to a significantly high error rate, a consequence of the commutation relation [RZ,Z]=0[R_Z, Z] = 0[RZ​,Z]=0. Entangled circuit variants produced generalization gaps in train-test sets of up to 17.517.517.5\% under noise, whereas the amplitude variants maintained zero gap throughout. These results give practitioners data-driven criteria for a feature map on near-term quantum hardware.
As quantum processors move into the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era, the central question is no longer whether a quantum algorithm is asymptotically faster than its classical counterpart, but whether it can retain a meaningful speedup under realistic noise, compilation, and measurement constraints. This work develops a quantitative framework for characterizing the noise resilience of quantum advantage. We introduce the advantage robustness function RA(ε), which measures how the asymptotic and concrete performance of an algorithm A degrades with physical error rate ε, and we compute it analytically or numerically for twelve representative algorithm families, including Grover search, amplitude estimation, phase estimation, HHL, VQE/QAOA, Hamiltonian simulation, and sampling algorithms. For each class, we derive critical noise thresholds and depth limits beyond which classical algorithms regain supremacy, explicitly incorporating realistic connectivity and compilation overheads. We show that algorithms based on coherent amplitude amplification are more fragile to coherent errors than depolarizing noise, while variational algorithms display a tradeoff between expressivity and robustness. By combining these algorithm-specific robustness curves with current and projected hardware error rates for superconducting, trapped-ion, neutralatom, and photonic platforms, we map out a phase diagram of practical quantum advantage that links problem size, noise rate, and algorithm type. Our analysis identifies promising near-term application windows in risk analytics, small-molecule chemistry, and structured optimization, and also delineates regions where no advantage is realistic, providing valuable guidance for both algorithm designers and hardware architects.
Abstract The arrival of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices defines an era in which quantum utility is fundamentally constrained by finite coherence times, limited qubit counts, gate infidelities, restricted connectivity, and measurement noise. Within this regime, hybrid quantum-classical frameworks have emerged as the dominant operational paradigm, particularly for quantum machine learning (QML). This review identifies a fundamental trade-off between expressivity, trainability, and noise resilience that governs the performance and scalability of NISQ-era QML systems. To contextualize these challenges, we introduce the resource-constrained iterative routing framework, a hardware-aware conceptual architecture that integrates topology-aware classical compression and distributed quantum orchestration to maintain circuit depths within device-dependent limits while routing representations toward symmetry-constrained Hilbert subspaces to mitigate noise-induced barren plateaus. Furthermore, we shift the discussion of quantum advantage away from asymptotic fault-tolerant complexity toward the notion of operational NISQ advantage based on finite-resource scaling, trainability preservation, and sampling complexity. We evaluate the practical resource efficiency of variational quantum algorithms, quantum kernel methods, and quantum neural networks across superconducting, trapped-ion, neutral-atom, and photonic platforms. The review also examines reproducibility challenges, emphasizing benchmarking against optimized classical baselines, and discusses strategies for managing the sampling overhead of error mitigation alongside distributed execution and quantum circuit compilation. Ultimately, NISQ in Practice positions hybrid QML as a physically constrained computational paradigm while outlining a pathway from contemporary noisy workflows toward early fault-tolerant quantum architectures.
We deploy a Quantum Counterfactual Mediation Analysis (QCMA) framework on IBM Quantum processors to ask a precise, hardware-grounded question: are causal regimes identified in noiseless simulation preserved under real quantum noise? Integrating partial quantum state tomography with a linear structural equation model, we decompose inter-architectural performance contrasts into direct effects and indirect quantum-mediated effects across twelve experiments spanning three circuit topologies and two benchmark datasets. Five of six topology-dataset pairs (83%) retain their causal regime when migrating from noiseless simulation to physical hardware. Decoherence inflates quantum-mediated contributions by up to one order of magnitude a noise artefact, not quantum advantage while the Neutral regime dominates both backend. These findings indicate that hardware noise may substantially limit the effective utilization of quantum resources in current NISQ circuits, and motivate further investigation into coherence-preserving circuit design strategies.