Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2605.00104 · Physical Review Letters

Criticality on Rényi Defects at (2+1)$D$ O(3) Quantum Critical Points

Yanzhang Zhu, Zhe Wang, Meng Cheng, Zheng Yan

cond-mat.str-elcond-mat.stat-mechhep-thquant-phSubmitted Apr 30, 2026• Announced May 4, 2026• 5 citations• Revised Oct 8, 2026 (v3)
v1 · Apr 30, 2026v2 · Jul 16, 2026v3 · Oct 8, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

At a quantum critical point, the universal scaling behavior of Rényi entanglement entropy is controlled by the universality class of the codimension-two Rényi (or conical) defects in the infrared theory. In this work we perform a systematic study of critical correlations along Rényi defect lines in (2+1)$D$ quantum spin models realizing quantum phase transitions described by the O(3) Wilson-Fisher universality class, using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We present numerical evidence that, for a fixed Rényi index $n$, there exist multiple Rényi defect universality classes, with distinct critical exponents for the O(3) order parameter on the defect. These universality classes are realized by choosing microscopically different entanglement cuts in lattice models, which we classify as ordinary, special and extraordinary according to their relation to surface criticality. For the extraordinary entanglement cut, we further find evidence for a phase transition on the defect as a function of the Rényi index. Our results highlight the key role of defect universality classes in determining the universal scaling of Rényi entropy, and provide a framework for understanding the previously observed dependence of Rényi entropy scaling on microscopic lattice details.

Journal reference
Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 156501 (2026)
DOI
10.1103/7zzj-78fv
Comments
7+4 pages; 4+6 figures

Related papers

Entanglement at a two-dimensional quantum critical point: aT= 0 projector quantum Monte Carlo study

Stephen Inglis, Roger G. Melko

Although the leading-order scaling of entanglement entropy is non-universal at a quantum critical point (QCP), sub-leading scaling can contain universal behaviour. Such universal quantities are commonly studied in non-interacting field theories, however it typically requires numerical calculation to access them in interacting theories. In this paper, we use large-scale T = 0 quantum Monte Carlo simulations to examine in detail the second Rényi entropy of entangled regions at the QCP in the transverse-field Ising model in 2 + 1 space–time dimensions—a fixed point for which there is no exact result for the scaling of entanglement entropy. We calculate a universal coefficient of a vertex-induced logarithmic scaling for a polygonal entangled subregion, and compare the result to interacting and non-interacting theories. We also examine the shape-dependence of the Rényi entropy for finite-size toroidal lattices divided into two entangled cylinders by smooth boundaries. Remarkably, we find that the dependence on cylinder length follows a shape-dependent function calculated previously by Stephan et al (2013 New J. Phys. 15 015004) at the QCP corresponding to the 2 + 1 dimensional quantum Lifshitz free scalar field theory. The quality of the fit of our data to this scaling function, as well as the apparent cutoff-independent coefficient that results, presents tantalizing evidence that this function may reflect universal behaviour across these and other very disparate QCPs in 2 + 1 dimensional systems.

arXiv:1305.1069•New Journal of Physics•Jul 26, 2013•48 citations

Entanglement entropy in the O(N) model

Max A. Metlitski, Carlos A Fuertes, Subir Sachdev A

It is generally believed that in spatial dimension $d>1$, the leading contribution to the entanglement entropy $S=\ensuremath{-}\text{tr}\text{ }{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}\text{ }\text{log}\text{ }{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}$ scales as the area of the boundary of subsystem $A$. The coefficient of this ``area law'' is nonuniversal. However, in the neighborhood of a quantum critical point $S$ is believed to possess subleading universal corrections. In the present work, we study the entanglement entropy in the quantum $O(N)$ model in $1<d<3$. We use an expansion in $ϵ=3\ensuremath{-}d$ to evaluate (i) the universal geometric correction to $S$ for an infinite cylinder divided along a circular boundary; (ii) the universal correction to $S$ due to a finite correlation length. Both corrections are different at the Wilson-Fisher and Gaussian fixed points, and the $ϵ\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ limit of the Wilson-Fisher fixed point is distinct from the Gaussian fixed point. In addition, we compute the correlation length correction to the Renyi entropy ${S}_{n}=\frac{1}{1\ensuremath{-}n}\text{log}\text{ }\text{tr}\text{ }{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}^{n}$ in $ϵ$ and large-$N$ expansions. For $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$, this correction generally scales as ${N}^{2}$ rather than the naively expected $N$. Moreover, the Renyi entropy has a phase transition as a function of $n$ for $d$ close to 3.

arXiv:0904.4477•Physical Review B•Sep 23, 2009•187 citations

Unusual corrections to scaling and convergence of universal Renyi properties at quantum critical points

Sharmistha Sahoo, Edwin Miles Stoudenmire, Jean-Marie Stéphan +3 more

At a quantum critical point, bipartite entanglement entropies have universal quantities which are subleading to the ubiquitous area law. For Renyi entropies, these terms are known to be similar to the von Neumann entropy, while being much more amenable to numerical and even experimental measurement. We show here that when calculating universal properties of Renyi entropies, it is important to account for unusual corrections to scaling that arise from relevant local operators present at the conical singularity in the multisheeted Riemann surface. These corrections grow in importance with increasing Renyi index. We present studies of Renyi correlation functions in the $1+1$ transverse-field Ising model (TFIM) using conformal field theory, mapping to free fermions, and series expansions, and the logarithmic entropy singularity at a corner in $2+1$ for both free bosonic field theory and the TFIM, using numerical linked cluster expansions. In all numerical studies, accurate results are only obtained when unusual corrections to scaling are taken into account. In the worst case, an analysis ignoring these corrections can get qualitatively incorrect answers, such as predicting a decrease in critical exponents with the Renyi index, when they are actually increasing. We discuss a two-step extrapolation procedure that can be used to account for the unusual corrections to scaling.

arXiv:1509.00468•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 12, 2016•25 citations

Boundary renormalization group flow of entanglement entropy at a ( 2 + 1 )-dimensional quantum critical point

Zhiyan Wang, Zhe Wang, Yi-Ming Ding +3 more

We investigate the second-order Rényi entanglement entropy at the quantum critical point of a spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model on a columnar dimerized square lattice. The universal constant $γ$ in the area-law scaling $S_{2}(\ell) = α\ell - γ$ is found to be sensitive to the entangling surface configurations, with $γ_{\text{sp}} > 0$ for strong-bond-cut (special) surfaces and $γ_{\text{ord}} < 0$ for weak-bond-cut (ordinary) surfaces, which is attributed to the distinct conformal boundary conditions. Introducing boundary dimerization drives a renormalization group (RG) flow from the special to the ordinary boundary criticality, and the constant $γ$ decreases monotonically with increasing dimerization strength, demonstrating irreversible evolution under the boundary RG flow. These results provide numerical evidence for a higher-dimensional analog of the $g$ theorem, and suggest $γ$ as a possible characteristic function for boundary RG flow in $(2+1)$-dimensional conformal field theory.

arXiv:2509.02044•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 12, 2026•2 citations

Precise computation of universal corner entanglement entropy at 2+1 dimension: From Ising to Gaussian quantum critical points

Ben Lee-Yeung Ngai, Justin Tim-Lok Chau, Junchen Rong +3 more

Computing the subleading logarithmic term in the entanglement entropy (EE) of (2+1)d quantum many-body systems remains a significant challenge, despite its central role in revealing universal information about quantum states and quantum critical points (QCPs). Building on recent algorithmic advances that enable the stable calculation of EE as an exponential observable~\cite{zhouIncremental2024,zhangIntegral2024,liaoExtracting2024}, we develop a {\it bubble basis} projector quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) algorithm to precisely and efficiently compute the universal corner of EE at QCPs in a (2+1)d square-lattice transverse-field Ising model augmented with a four-body interaction. Turning on this interaction allows us to trace an Ising critical line, reaching the tricritical point, and then a line of first-order phase transition. In (2+1)d, the tricritical point is described by the Gaussian theory, where a theoretical calculation of the corner logarithmic term in the 2nd Rényi entropy term is available~\cite{UniversalCasini2007}. Our QMC results are in quantitative agreement with this theoretical value, providing a highly nontrivial benchmark of the algorithm. Furthermore, we also study the Rényi EE at the Ising critical line and on the first-order transition line, obtaining results consistent with theoretical expectations. These findings establish the long-sought connection between the universal values of an exactly solvable limit and those of a strongly correlated regime at (2+1)d.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2512.00382•Reports on Progress in Physics•Dec 2, 2025•0 citations

Corner contribution to the entanglement entropy of strongly interacting O(2) quantum critical systems in 2+1 dimensions

Edwin Miles Stoudenmire, Peter Gustainis, Ravi Johal +2 more

In a $D=2+1$ quantum critical system, the entanglement entropy across a boundary with a corner contains a subleading logarithmic scaling term with a universal coefficient. It has been conjectured that this coefficient is, to leading order, proportional to the number of field components $N$ in the associated $\text{O}(N)$ continuum ${\ensuremath{\phi}}^{4}$ field theory. Using density matrix renormalization group calculations combined with the powerful numerical linked cluster expansion technique, we confirm this scenario for the $\text{O}(2)$ Wilson-Fisher fixed point in a striking way, through direct calculation at the quantum critical points of two very different microscopic models. The value of this corner coefficient is, to within our numerical precision, twice the coefficient of the Ising fixed point. Our results add to the growing body of evidence that this universal term in the R\'enyi entanglement entropy reflects the number of low-energy degrees of freedom in a system, even for strongly interacting theories.

arXiv:1409.6327•Physical Review B•Dec 2, 2014•70 citations
Criticality on Rényi Defects at (2+1)DDD O(3) Quantum Critical Points
At a quantum critical point, the universal scaling behavior of Rényi entanglement entropy is controlled by the universality class of the codimension-two Rényi (or conical) defects in the infrared theory. In this work we perform a systematic study of critical correlations along Rényi defect lines in (2+1)DDD quantum spin models realizing quantum phase transitions described by the O(3) Wilson-Fisher universality class, using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We present numerical evidence that, for a fixed Rényi index nnn, there exist multiple Rényi defect universality classes, with distinct critical exponents for the O(3) order parameter on the defect. These universality classes are realized by choosing microscopically different entanglement cuts in lattice models, which we classify as ordinary, special and extraordinary according to their relation to surface criticality. For the extraordinary entanglement cut, we further find evidence for a phase transition on the defect as a function of the Rényi index. Our results highlight the key role of defect universality classes in determining the universal scaling of Rényi entropy, and provide a framework for understanding the previously observed dependence of Rényi entropy scaling on microscopic lattice details.
Although the leading-order scaling of entanglement entropy is non-universal at a quantum critical point (QCP), sub-leading scaling can contain universal behaviour. Such universal quantities are commonly studied in non-interacting field theories, however it typically requires numerical calculation to access them in interacting theories. In this paper, we use large-scale T = 0 quantum Monte Carlo simulations to examine in detail the second Rényi entropy of entangled regions at the QCP in the transverse-field Ising model in 2 + 1 space–time dimensions—a fixed point for which there is no exact result for the scaling of entanglement entropy. We calculate a universal coefficient of a vertex-induced logarithmic scaling for a polygonal entangled subregion, and compare the result to interacting and non-interacting theories. We also examine the shape-dependence of the Rényi entropy for finite-size toroidal lattices divided into two entangled cylinders by smooth boundaries. Remarkably, we find that the dependence on cylinder length follows a shape-dependent function calculated previously by Stephan et al (2013 New J. Phys. 15 015004) at the QCP corresponding to the 2 + 1 dimensional quantum Lifshitz free scalar field theory. The quality of the fit of our data to this scaling function, as well as the apparent cutoff-independent coefficient that results, presents tantalizing evidence that this function may reflect universal behaviour across these and other very disparate QCPs in 2 + 1 dimensional systems.
It is generally believed that in spatial dimension d>1d>1d>1, the leading contribution to the entanglement entropy $S=\ensuremath{-}\text{tr}\text{ }{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}\text{ }\text{log}\text{ }{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}$ scales as the area of the boundary of subsystem AAA. The coefficient of this ``area law'' is nonuniversal. However, in the neighborhood of a quantum critical point SSS is believed to possess subleading universal corrections. In the present work, we study the entanglement entropy in the quantum O(N)O(N)O(N) model in 1<d<31<d<31<d<3. We use an expansion in $ϵ=3\ensuremath{-}d$ to evaluate (i) the universal geometric correction to SSS for an infinite cylinder divided along a circular boundary; (ii) the universal correction to SSS due to a finite correlation length. Both corrections are different at the Wilson-Fisher and Gaussian fixed points, and the $ϵ\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ limit of the Wilson-Fisher fixed point is distinct from the Gaussian fixed point. In addition, we compute the correlation length correction to the Renyi entropy ${S}_{n}=\frac{1}{1\ensuremath{-}n}\text{log}\text{ }\text{tr}\text{ }{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}^{n}$ in ϵϵϵ and large-NNN expansions. For $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$, this correction generally scales as N2{N}^{2}N2 rather than the naively expected NNN. Moreover, the Renyi entropy has a phase transition as a function of nnn for ddd close to 3.
At a quantum critical point, bipartite entanglement entropies have universal quantities which are subleading to the ubiquitous area law. For Renyi entropies, these terms are known to be similar to the von Neumann entropy, while being much more amenable to numerical and even experimental measurement. We show here that when calculating universal properties of Renyi entropies, it is important to account for unusual corrections to scaling that arise from relevant local operators present at the conical singularity in the multisheeted Riemann surface. These corrections grow in importance with increasing Renyi index. We present studies of Renyi correlation functions in the 1+11+11+1 transverse-field Ising model (TFIM) using conformal field theory, mapping to free fermions, and series expansions, and the logarithmic entropy singularity at a corner in 2+12+12+1 for both free bosonic field theory and the TFIM, using numerical linked cluster expansions. In all numerical studies, accurate results are only obtained when unusual corrections to scaling are taken into account. In the worst case, an analysis ignoring these corrections can get qualitatively incorrect answers, such as predicting a decrease in critical exponents with the Renyi index, when they are actually increasing. We discuss a two-step extrapolation procedure that can be used to account for the unusual corrections to scaling.
We investigate the second-order Rényi entanglement entropy at the quantum critical point of a spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model on a columnar dimerized square lattice. The universal constant γγγ in the area-law scaling S2(ℓ)=αℓ−γS_{2}(\ell) = α\ell - γS2​(ℓ)=αℓ−γ is found to be sensitive to the entangling surface configurations, with γsp>0γ_{\text{sp}} > 0γsp​>0 for strong-bond-cut (special) surfaces and γord<0γ_{\text{ord}} < 0γord​<0 for weak-bond-cut (ordinary) surfaces, which is attributed to the distinct conformal boundary conditions. Introducing boundary dimerization drives a renormalization group (RG) flow from the special to the ordinary boundary criticality, and the constant γγγ decreases monotonically with increasing dimerization strength, demonstrating irreversible evolution under the boundary RG flow. These results provide numerical evidence for a higher-dimensional analog of the ggg theorem, and suggest γγγ as a possible characteristic function for boundary RG flow in (2+1)(2+1)(2+1)-dimensional conformal field theory.
Computing the subleading logarithmic term in the entanglement entropy (EE) of (2+1)d quantum many-body systems remains a significant challenge, despite its central role in revealing universal information about quantum states and quantum critical points (QCPs). Building on recent algorithmic advances that enable the stable calculation of EE as an exponential observable~\cite{zhouIncremental2024,zhangIntegral2024,liaoExtracting2024}, we develop a {\it bubble basis} projector quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) algorithm to precisely and efficiently compute the universal corner of EE at QCPs in a (2+1)d square-lattice transverse-field Ising model augmented with a four-body interaction. Turning on this interaction allows us to trace an Ising critical line, reaching the tricritical point, and then a line of first-order phase transition. In (2+1)d, the tricritical point is described by the Gaussian theory, where a theoretical calculation of the corner logarithmic term in the 2nd Rényi entropy term is available~\cite{UniversalCasini2007}. Our QMC results are in quantitative agreement with this theoretical value, providing a highly nontrivial benchmark of the algorithm. Furthermore, we also study the Rényi EE at the Ising critical line and on the first-order transition line, obtaining results consistent with theoretical expectations. These findings establish the long-sought connection between the universal values of an exactly solvable limit and those of a strongly correlated regime at (2+1)d.
In a D=2+1D=2+1D=2+1 quantum critical system, the entanglement entropy across a boundary with a corner contains a subleading logarithmic scaling term with a universal coefficient. It has been conjectured that this coefficient is, to leading order, proportional to the number of field components NNN in the associated O(N)\text{O}(N)O(N) continuum ${\ensuremath{\phi}}^{4}$ field theory. Using density matrix renormalization group calculations combined with the powerful numerical linked cluster expansion technique, we confirm this scenario for the O(2)\text{O}(2)O(2) Wilson-Fisher fixed point in a striking way, through direct calculation at the quantum critical points of two very different microscopic models. The value of this corner coefficient is, to within our numerical precision, twice the coefficient of the Ising fixed point. Our results add to the growing body of evidence that this universal term in the R\'enyi entanglement entropy reflects the number of low-energy degrees of freedom in a system, even for strongly interacting theories.