Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.24896 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Tightening energy-based boson truncation bound using Monte Carlo-assisted methods

Jinghong Yang, Christopher F. Kane, Shabnam Jabeen

hep-latquant-phSubmitted Apr 27, 2026• Announced Apr 29, 2026• 2 citations• Revised May 14, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Apr 27, 2026v2 · May 14, 2026v3 · May 19, 2026v4 · Aug 28, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum simulation offers a promising framework for quantum field theory calculations. Obtaining reliable results, however, requires careful characterization of systematic uncertainties. One important source is the boson truncation error, which arises from representing infinite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces with finite-dimensional ones. Previous studies have examined this problem from several perspectives. In particular, Jordan, Lee, and Preskill (arXiv:1111.3633) derived an energy-based bound applicable to generic low-energy states across a broad class of field theories. However, this approach often yields overly conservative bounds, especially at large volumes. In this work, we introduce a new methodology that significantly tightens the energy-based boson truncation bound through two complementary advances: an improved analytic derivation and a Monte Carlo-based numerical procedure. We demonstrate the method in (1+1)-dimensional scalar field theory and (2+1)-dimensional U(1) gauge theory in the dual formalism. Our approach substantially mitigates the volume dependence of the required truncation cutoff, achieving reductions nearly proportional to the volume in some cases and to the square root of the volume in others.

Journal reference
Phys. Rev. D 114, 034517 (2026)
DOI
10.1103/9yly-8dy7
Comments
20 pages + 8 page Appendices, 13 figures. Updated references and funding

Related papers

Provably accurate simulation of gauge theories and bosonic systems

Yu Tong, Victor V. Albert, Jarrod R. McClean +2 more

Quantum many-body systems involving bosonic modes or gauge fields have infinite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces which must be truncated to perform simulations of real-time dynamics on classical or quantum computers. To analyze the truncation error, we develop methods for bounding the rate of growth of local quantum numbers such as the occupation number of a mode at a lattice site, or the electric field at a lattice link. Our approach applies to various models of bosons interacting with spins or fermions, and also to both abelian and non-abelian gauge theories. We show that if states in these models are truncated by imposing an upper limit Λ on each local quantum number, and if the initial state has low local quantum numbers, then an error at most ϵ can be achieved by choosing Λ to scale polylogarithmically with ϵ−1 , an exponential improvement over previous bounds based on energy conservation. For the Hubbard-Holstein model, we numerically compute a bound on Λ that achieves accuracy ϵ , obtaining significantly improved estimates in various parameter regimes. We also establish a criterion for truncating the Hamiltonian with a provable guarantee on the accuracy of time evolution. Building on that result, we formulate quantum algorithms for dynamical simulation of lattice gauge theories and of models with bosonic modes; the gate complexity depends almost linearly on spacetime volume in the former case, and almost quadratically on time in the latter case. We establish a lower bound showing that there are systems involving bosons for which this quadratic scaling with time cannot be improved. By applying our result on the truncation error in time evolution, we also prove that spectrally isolated energy eigenstates can be approximated with accuracy ϵ by truncating local quantum numbers at Λ=polylog(ϵ−1) .

arXiv:2110.06942•Quantum•Sep 22, 2022•106 citations

Estimating truncation effects of quantum bosonic systems using sampling algorithms

Masanori Hanada, Junyu Liu, Enrico Rinaldi +1 more

Abstract To simulate bosons on a qubit- or qudit-based quantum computer, one has to regularize the theory by truncating infinite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces to finite dimensions. In the search for practical quantum applications, it is important to know how big the truncation errors can be. In general, it is not easy to estimate errors unless we have a good quantum computer. In this paper, we show that traditional sampling methods on classical devices, specifically Markov Chain Monte Carlo, can address this issue for a rather generic class of bosonic systems with a reasonable amount of computational resources available today. As a demonstration, we apply this idea to the scalar field theory on a two-dimensional lattice, with a size that goes beyond what is achievable using exact diagonalization methods. This method can be used to estimate the resources needed for realistic quantum simulations of bosonic theories, and also, to check the validity of the results of the corresponding quantum simulations.

arXiv:2212.08546•Machine Learning Science and Technology•Oct 13, 2023•15 citations

Nonperturbative Methods in Quantum Field Theory

Kara Farnsworth

<!--HTML-->Hamiltonian truncation is a non-perturbative numerical method for calculating observables of a quantum field theory by truncating the Hilbert space to states with energy below a maximum energy cutoff. In this talk I will present an effective field theory approach to Hamiltonian truncation, which provides a systematic way of improving the calculations without increasing the energy cutoff. I will demonstrate this with numerical results for the two dimensional phi^4 theory, and talk about future applications of this method to more complicated theories.

•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

A resource efficient approach for quantum and classical simulations of gauge theories in particle physics

Jan F. Haase, Luca Dellantonio, Alessio Celi +4 more

Gauge theories establish the standard model of particle physics, and lattice gauge theory (LGT) calculations employing Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods have been pivotal in our understanding of fundamental interactions. The present limitations of MCMC techniques may be overcome by Hamiltonian-based simulations on classical or quantum devices, which further provide the potential to address questions that lay beyond the capabilities of the current approaches. However, for continuous gauge groups, Hamiltonian-based formulations involve infinite-dimensional gauge degrees of freedom that can solely be handled by truncation. Current truncation schemes require dramatically increasing computational resources at small values of the bare couplings, where magnetic field effects become important. Such limitation precludes one from `taking the continuous limit' while working with finite resources. To overcome this limitation, we provide a resource-efficient protocol to simulate LGTs with continuous gauge groups in the Hamiltonian formulation. Our new method allows for calculations at arbitrary values of the bare coupling and lattice spacing. The approach consists of the combination of a Hilbert space truncation with a regularization of the gauge group, which permits an efficient description of the magnetically-dominated regime. We focus here on Abelian gauge theories and use 2 + 1 dimensional quantum electrodynamics as a benchmark example to demonstrate this efficient framework to achieve the continuum limit in LGTs. This possibility is a key requirement to make quantitative predictions at the field theory level and offers the long-term perspective to utilise quantum simulations to compute physically meaningful quantities in regimes that are precluded to quantum Monte Carlo.

arXiv:2006.14160•Quantum•Feb 4, 2021•186 citations

Truncation uncertainties for accurate quantum simulations of lattice gauge theories

Anthony N. Ciavarella, Siddharth Hariprakash, Jad C. Halimeh +1 more

The encoding of lattice gauge theories onto quantum computers requires a discretization of the gauge field's Hilbert space on each link, which presents errors with respect to the Kogut–Susskind limit. In the electric basis, Hilbert space fragmentation has recently been shown to limit the excitation of large electric fields. Here, we leverage this to develop a formalism for estimating the size of truncation errors in the electric basis. Generically, the truncation error falls off as a factorial of the field truncation. Examples of this formalism are applied to the Schwinger model and a pure U(1) lattice gauge theory. For reasonable choices of parameters, we improve on previous error estimates by a factor of 10 306 .

arXiv:2508.00061•Quantum•Sep 24, 2026•26 citations

Towards Precision Quantum Simulation of Lattice Gauge Theories

Siddharth Hariprakash

Quantum simulation of lattice gauge theories offers a path to first-principles calculations of real-time dynamics and finite-density phenomena that are inaccessible to classical Euclidean Monte Carlo methods. Realizing this potential requires a pipeline of controlled approximations---lattice discretization, truncation, digitization, state preparation, time evolution, measurement, and continuum extrapolation---each contributing errors and computational costs. General algorithmic asymptotic complexity arguments capture only part of the cost picture: the practical resources required for end-to-end simulation depend on numerical pre-factors, the cost of the subroutines that various algorithms call, and structural features of the lattice theory, all of which the asymptotic scaling leaves unspecified. This thesis develops contributions that aim to make such dependencies explicit and quantitative. We begin with a rigorous analysis of the asymptotic gate complexity of product formulas and Quantum Signal Processing (QSP) for the time evolution of general classes of lattice Hamiltonians, identifying the parameter regimes in which each method is favorable and estimating the associated pre-factors numerically. Since the cost of QSP-based simulation is dominated (in regimes of practical interest) by the block-encoding subroutine it calls, we also develop several novel block-encoding constructions tailored to bosonic lattice field theories and show that signal-processing techniques can be repurposed as highly efficient block-encoding subroutines. We then turn to the problem of truncating the Kogut--Susskind electric-field Hilbert space. Existing error bounds rely on energy-conservation arguments and require the truncation to grow with simulation time. By exploiting Hilbert space fragmentation we derive the tightest error bounds known to date: they decay factorially in the truncation parameter and are independent of simulation time. We validate them numerically for U(1) pure gauge theory and the Schwinger model. Finally, we address the continuum limit in the presence of approximate time evolution. For product formulas, we show that Trotter errors correspond to irrelevant operators that vanish in the continuum limit, which yields a renormalization trajectory independent of the Trotter step size. More generally, we introduce the Statistically-Bounded Time Evolution (SBTE) protocol, an algorithm-independent framework that treats approximation errors as a systematic uncertainty to be driven below the working statistical precision. This decouples the continuum-limit prescription from the choice of time-evolution algorithm and provides a basis for end-to-end cost comparisons across simulation methods.

•May 1, 2026•0 citations
Quantum simulation offers a promising framework for quantum field theory calculations. Obtaining reliable results, however, requires careful characterization of systematic uncertainties. One important source is the boson truncation error, which arises from representing infinite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces with finite-dimensional ones. Previous studies have examined this problem from several perspectives. In particular, Jordan, Lee, and Preskill (arXiv:1111.3633) derived an energy-based bound applicable to generic low-energy states across a broad class of field theories. However, this approach often yields overly conservative bounds, especially at large volumes. In this work, we introduce a new methodology that significantly tightens the energy-based boson truncation bound through two complementary advances: an improved analytic derivation and a Monte Carlo-based numerical procedure. We demonstrate the method in (1+1)-dimensional scalar field theory and (2+1)-dimensional U(1) gauge theory in the dual formalism. Our approach substantially mitigates the volume dependence of the required truncation cutoff, achieving reductions nearly proportional to the volume in some cases and to the square root of the volume in others.
Quantum many-body systems involving bosonic modes or gauge fields have infinite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces which must be truncated to perform simulations of real-time dynamics on classical or quantum computers. To analyze the truncation error, we develop methods for bounding the rate of growth of local quantum numbers such as the occupation number of a mode at a lattice site, or the electric field at a lattice link. Our approach applies to various models of bosons interacting with spins or fermions, and also to both abelian and non-abelian gauge theories. We show that if states in these models are truncated by imposing an upper limit Λ on each local quantum number, and if the initial state has low local quantum numbers, then an error at most ϵ can be achieved by choosing Λ to scale polylogarithmically with ϵ−1 , an exponential improvement over previous bounds based on energy conservation. For the Hubbard-Holstein model, we numerically compute a bound on Λ that achieves accuracy ϵ , obtaining significantly improved estimates in various parameter regimes. We also establish a criterion for truncating the Hamiltonian with a provable guarantee on the accuracy of time evolution. Building on that result, we formulate quantum algorithms for dynamical simulation of lattice gauge theories and of models with bosonic modes; the gate complexity depends almost linearly on spacetime volume in the former case, and almost quadratically on time in the latter case. We establish a lower bound showing that there are systems involving bosons for which this quadratic scaling with time cannot be improved. By applying our result on the truncation error in time evolution, we also prove that spectrally isolated energy eigenstates can be approximated with accuracy ϵ by truncating local quantum numbers at Λ=polylog(ϵ−1) .
Abstract To simulate bosons on a qubit- or qudit-based quantum computer, one has to regularize the theory by truncating infinite-dimensional local Hilbert spaces to finite dimensions. In the search for practical quantum applications, it is important to know how big the truncation errors can be. In general, it is not easy to estimate errors unless we have a good quantum computer. In this paper, we show that traditional sampling methods on classical devices, specifically Markov Chain Monte Carlo, can address this issue for a rather generic class of bosonic systems with a reasonable amount of computational resources available today. As a demonstration, we apply this idea to the scalar field theory on a two-dimensional lattice, with a size that goes beyond what is achievable using exact diagonalization methods. This method can be used to estimate the resources needed for realistic quantum simulations of bosonic theories, and also, to check the validity of the results of the corresponding quantum simulations.
<!--HTML-->Hamiltonian truncation is a non-perturbative numerical method for calculating observables of a quantum field theory by truncating the Hilbert space to states with energy below a maximum energy cutoff. In this talk I will present an effective field theory approach to Hamiltonian truncation, which provides a systematic way of improving the calculations without increasing the energy cutoff. I will demonstrate this with numerical results for the two dimensional phi^4 theory, and talk about future applications of this method to more complicated theories.
Gauge theories establish the standard model of particle physics, and lattice gauge theory (LGT) calculations employing Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods have been pivotal in our understanding of fundamental interactions. The present limitations of MCMC techniques may be overcome by Hamiltonian-based simulations on classical or quantum devices, which further provide the potential to address questions that lay beyond the capabilities of the current approaches. However, for continuous gauge groups, Hamiltonian-based formulations involve infinite-dimensional gauge degrees of freedom that can solely be handled by truncation. Current truncation schemes require dramatically increasing computational resources at small values of the bare couplings, where magnetic field effects become important. Such limitation precludes one from `taking the continuous limit' while working with finite resources. To overcome this limitation, we provide a resource-efficient protocol to simulate LGTs with continuous gauge groups in the Hamiltonian formulation. Our new method allows for calculations at arbitrary values of the bare coupling and lattice spacing. The approach consists of the combination of a Hilbert space truncation with a regularization of the gauge group, which permits an efficient description of the magnetically-dominated regime. We focus here on Abelian gauge theories and use 2 + 1 dimensional quantum electrodynamics as a benchmark example to demonstrate this efficient framework to achieve the continuum limit in LGTs. This possibility is a key requirement to make quantitative predictions at the field theory level and offers the long-term perspective to utilise quantum simulations to compute physically meaningful quantities in regimes that are precluded to quantum Monte Carlo.
The encoding of lattice gauge theories onto quantum computers requires a discretization of the gauge field's Hilbert space on each link, which presents errors with respect to the Kogut–Susskind limit. In the electric basis, Hilbert space fragmentation has recently been shown to limit the excitation of large electric fields. Here, we leverage this to develop a formalism for estimating the size of truncation errors in the electric basis. Generically, the truncation error falls off as a factorial of the field truncation. Examples of this formalism are applied to the Schwinger model and a pure U(1) lattice gauge theory. For reasonable choices of parameters, we improve on previous error estimates by a factor of 10 306 .
Quantum simulation of lattice gauge theories offers a path to first-principles calculations of real-time dynamics and finite-density phenomena that are inaccessible to classical Euclidean Monte Carlo methods. Realizing this potential requires a pipeline of controlled approximations---lattice discretization, truncation, digitization, state preparation, time evolution, measurement, and continuum extrapolation---each contributing errors and computational costs. General algorithmic asymptotic complexity arguments capture only part of the cost picture: the practical resources required for end-to-end simulation depend on numerical pre-factors, the cost of the subroutines that various algorithms call, and structural features of the lattice theory, all of which the asymptotic scaling leaves unspecified. This thesis develops contributions that aim to make such dependencies explicit and quantitative. We begin with a rigorous analysis of the asymptotic gate complexity of product formulas and Quantum Signal Processing (QSP) for the time evolution of general classes of lattice Hamiltonians, identifying the parameter regimes in which each method is favorable and estimating the associated pre-factors numerically. Since the cost of QSP-based simulation is dominated (in regimes of practical interest) by the block-encoding subroutine it calls, we also develop several novel block-encoding constructions tailored to bosonic lattice field theories and show that signal-processing techniques can be repurposed as highly efficient block-encoding subroutines. We then turn to the problem of truncating the Kogut--Susskind electric-field Hilbert space. Existing error bounds rely on energy-conservation arguments and require the truncation to grow with simulation time. By exploiting Hilbert space fragmentation we derive the tightest error bounds known to date: they decay factorially in the truncation parameter and are independent of simulation time. We validate them numerically for U(1) pure gauge theory and the Schwinger model. Finally, we address the continuum limit in the presence of approximate time evolution. For product formulas, we show that Trotter errors correspond to irrelevant operators that vanish in the continuum limit, which yields a renormalization trajectory independent of the Trotter step size. More generally, we introduce the Statistically-Bounded Time Evolution (SBTE) protocol, an algorithm-independent framework that treats approximation errors as a systematic uncertainty to be driven below the working statistical precision. This decouples the continuum-limit prescription from the choice of time-evolution algorithm and provides a basis for end-to-end cost comparisons across simulation methods.