Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.24680 · Physical Review Letters

Optical depth dictates universal bounds on many-body decay in atomic ensembles

Cosimo C. Rusconi, Eric Sierra, Wai-Keong Mok, Avishi Poddar, Simon B. Jäger, Ana Asenjo-Garcia

quant-phSubmitted Apr 27, 2026• Announced Apr 28, 2026• 2 citations• Revised Oct 1, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Apr 27, 2026v2 · Oct 1, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Cooperative emission is well understood for idealized symmetric systems, but its fundamental limits in spatially extended, free-space ensembles remain an open question. Here, we derive a universal law for the scaling of the maximum photon emission rate with system size that unifies both ordered arrays and disordered atomic clouds in arbitrary dimensions at fixed density. We demonstrate that, for a fixed atomic density, the maximum emission rate scales universally as the product of the atom number and the system's geometric optical depth. The geometric optical depth differs from the result of the Beer-Lambert law at high density and encodes the dimensional scaling across all regimes from independent emission to the Dicke limit. Furthermore, we establish a scaling law for directional detection, revealing that the observed rate depends on the detector's numerical aperture: small apertures yield Dicke-like quadratic scaling, whereas large apertures recover our integrated universal bound. Our results establish optical depth as the parameter governing many-body cooperative emission in both ordered and disordered ensembles, and reveal that directional and total-emission scalings must be carefully distinguished in experimental settings.

Journal reference
Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 143603 (2026)
DOI
10.1103/xvt4-1vg7
Comments
Main text: 9 pages + 3 figures. Supplemental Material: 18 pages + 6 figures. v2: Published version

Related papers

Cooperative photon emission rates in random atomic clouds

Viviana Viggiano, Romain Bachelard, Fabio Deelan Cunden +4 more

We investigate the properties of the cooperative decay modes of a cold atomic cloud, characterized by a Gaussian distribution in three dimensions, initially excited by a laser in the linear regime. We study the properties of the decay rate matrix $S$, whose dimension coincides with the number of atoms in the cloud, in order to get a deeper insight into properties of cooperative photon emission. Since the atomic positions are random, $S$ is a Euclidean random matrix whose entries are a function of the atom distances. We show that in the limit of a large number of atoms in the cloud, the eigenvalue distribution of $S$ depends on a single parameter ${b}_{0}$, called the cooperativeness parameter, which can be viewed as a quantifier of the number of atoms that are coherently involved in an emission process. For very small values of ${b}_{0}$, we find that the limit eigenvalue density is approximately triangular. We also study the nearest-neighbor spacing distribution and the eigenvector statistics, finding that although the decay rate matrices are Euclidean, the bulk of their spectra mostly behaves according to the expectations of classical random matrix theory. In particular, in the bulk, there is level repulsion and the eigenvectors are delocalized, therefore exhibiting the universal behavior of chaotic quantum systems.

arXiv:2306.06055•Physical Review A•Dec 1, 2023•5 citations

Many-Body Super- and Subradiance in Ordered Atomic Arrays

Alec Douglas, Lin Su, Michal Szurek +7 more

When quantum emitters couple indistinguishably to light, they can synchronize into a collective light matter system with radiative properties profoundly different from those of independent particles. To date, the resulting collective effects have largely been confined to point like or homogeneous ensembles. Here, we open access to a qualitatively new collective regime by realizing geometrically ordered, spatially extended atom arrays with subwavelength spacing. This establishes a fundamentally new platform in which collective emission is no longer confined to a single Dicke mode but instead emerges from an ordered network of photon mediated interactions. We find that 2D atom arrays undergo strong super and subradiant emission. Despite subwavelength spacing, we achieve site resolved imaging and directly observe the buildup of spatial correlations, demonstrating the transformation of cooperative decay into a strongly correlated many-body process. We observe extensive scaling of superradiance, uncover superradiant revivals, and reveal the ferromagnetic nature of superradiance and the antiferromagnetic nature of subradiance. Our results realize a novel programmable platform for exploring and utilizing dissipative many-body quantum physics, opening new possibilities for photon capture, storage, and atom photon entanglement.

quant-pharXiv:2604.11795•Apr 14, 2026•18 citations

Optimization of photon storage fidelity in ordered atomic arrays

Marco T. Manzoni, Maria Moreno-Cardoner, Ana Asenjo-García +3 more

A major application for atomic ensembles consists of a quantum memory for light, in which an optical state can be reversibly converted to a collective atomic excitation on demand. There exists a well-known fundamental bound on the storage error, when the ensemble is describable by a continuous medium governed by the Maxwell–Bloch equations. However, these equations are semi-phenomenological, as they treat emission of the atoms into other directions other than the mode of interest as being independent. On the other hand, in systems such as dense, ordered atomic arrays, atoms interact with each other strongly and spatial interference of the emitted light might be exploited to suppress emission into unwanted directions, thereby enabling improved error bounds. Here, we develop a general formalism that fully accounts for spatial interference, and which finds the maximum storage efficiency for a single photon with known spatial input mode into a collection of atoms with discrete, known positions. As an example, we apply this technique to study a finite two-dimensional square array of atoms. We show that such a system enables a storage error that scales with atom number N a like , and that, remarkably, an array of just 4 × 4 atoms in principle allows for an error of less than 1%, which is comparable to a disordered ensemble with an optical depth of around 600.

arXiv:1710.06312•New Journal of Physics•Aug 20, 2018•106 citations

From superradiance to collective EIT in three-level ensembles

Hugo Sanchez, Luis F. A. da Silva, Mickel A. Ponte +2 more

We investigate the collective dynamics of a three-level ensemble under the Dicke limit, revealing a unified connection between superradiant emission and electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT). Our results show that the transient superradiant burst exhibits the expected peak intensity scaling $I_{\max}\!\sim\! N^2$, with a universal finite-size correction $|ξ(N)-2|\!\sim\! 1/\ln N$ that governs the apparent scaling exponent in realistic ensembles. In the stationary regime, collective broadening modifies the EIT response: although it typically enhances absorption, it counterintuitively increases the group velocity, leading to a relative scaling $v_g\!\propto\! N^2$, even while $v_g\!\ll\! c$. This effect suggests that cooperative interactions fundamentally limit the achievable slow-light delay in dense media. To achieve these results, we derive a representative-atom master equation that quantitatively reproduces both the superradiant and EIT regimes, in excellent agreement with the exact symmetric-subspace dynamics and correctly incorporating collective feedback and $N$-dependent broadening. This unified framework bridges transient superradiant emission and steady-state quantum interference, with direct implications for slow light, quantum memories, and precision metrology.

quant-pharXiv:2602.16892•Physical Review Applied•Feb 20, 2026•1 citation

Modifying cooperative decay via disorder in atom arrays

Nik O. Gjonbalaj, Stefan Ostermann, Susanne F. Yelin

Atomic arrays can exhibit collective light emission when the transition wavelength exceeds their lattice spacing. Subradiant states take advantage of this phenomenon to drastically reduce their overall decay rate, allowing for long-lived states in dissipative open systems. We build on previous work to investigate whether or not disorder can further decrease the decay rate of a singly excited atomic array. More specifically, we consider spatial disorder of varying strengths in a one-dimensional (1D) half waveguide and in 1D, two-dimensional (2D), and three-dimensional (3D) atomic arrays in free space and analyze the effect on the most subradiant modes. While we confirm that the dilute half waveguide exhibits an analog of Anderson localization, the dense half waveguide and free-space systems can be understood through the creation of close-packed, few-body subradiant states similar to those found in the Dicke limit. In general, we find that disorder provides little advantage in generating darker subradiant states in free space on average and will often accelerate decay. However, one could potentially change interatomic spacing within the array to engineer specific subradiant states.

arXiv:2309.04384•Physical Review A•Jan 25, 2024•8 citations

Band Structure and Dynamics of Single Photons in Atomic Lattices

Wenxuan Xie, John C. Schotland

We present a framework to investigate the collective properties of atomic lattices in one, two, and three dimensions. We analyze the single-photon band structure and associated atomic decay rates, revealing a fundamental dependence on dimensionality. One- and two-dimensional arrays are shown to be inherently radiative, exhibiting band gaps and decay rates that oscillate between superradiant and subradiant regimes, as a function of lattice spacing. In contrast, three-dimensional lattices are found to be fundamentally non-radiative due to the inhibition of spontaneous emission, with decay only at discrete Bragg resonances. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this structural difference dictates the system dynamics, which crosses over from dissipative decay in lower dimensions to coherent transport in three dimensions. Our results provide insight into cooperative effects in atomic arrays at the single-photon level.

quant-pharXiv:2512.24596•Physical Review A•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
Cooperative emission is well understood for idealized symmetric systems, but its fundamental limits in spatially extended, free-space ensembles remain an open question. Here, we derive a universal law for the scaling of the maximum photon emission rate with system size that unifies both ordered arrays and disordered atomic clouds in arbitrary dimensions at fixed density. We demonstrate that, for a fixed atomic density, the maximum emission rate scales universally as the product of the atom number and the system's geometric optical depth. The geometric optical depth differs from the result of the Beer-Lambert law at high density and encodes the dimensional scaling across all regimes from independent emission to the Dicke limit. Furthermore, we establish a scaling law for directional detection, revealing that the observed rate depends on the detector's numerical aperture: small apertures yield Dicke-like quadratic scaling, whereas large apertures recover our integrated universal bound. Our results establish optical depth as the parameter governing many-body cooperative emission in both ordered and disordered ensembles, and reveal that directional and total-emission scalings must be carefully distinguished in experimental settings.
We investigate the properties of the cooperative decay modes of a cold atomic cloud, characterized by a Gaussian distribution in three dimensions, initially excited by a laser in the linear regime. We study the properties of the decay rate matrix SSS, whose dimension coincides with the number of atoms in the cloud, in order to get a deeper insight into properties of cooperative photon emission. Since the atomic positions are random, SSS is a Euclidean random matrix whose entries are a function of the atom distances. We show that in the limit of a large number of atoms in the cloud, the eigenvalue distribution of SSS depends on a single parameter b0{b}_{0}b0​, called the cooperativeness parameter, which can be viewed as a quantifier of the number of atoms that are coherently involved in an emission process. For very small values of b0{b}_{0}b0​, we find that the limit eigenvalue density is approximately triangular. We also study the nearest-neighbor spacing distribution and the eigenvector statistics, finding that although the decay rate matrices are Euclidean, the bulk of their spectra mostly behaves according to the expectations of classical random matrix theory. In particular, in the bulk, there is level repulsion and the eigenvectors are delocalized, therefore exhibiting the universal behavior of chaotic quantum systems.
When quantum emitters couple indistinguishably to light, they can synchronize into a collective light matter system with radiative properties profoundly different from those of independent particles. To date, the resulting collective effects have largely been confined to point like or homogeneous ensembles. Here, we open access to a qualitatively new collective regime by realizing geometrically ordered, spatially extended atom arrays with subwavelength spacing. This establishes a fundamentally new platform in which collective emission is no longer confined to a single Dicke mode but instead emerges from an ordered network of photon mediated interactions. We find that 2D atom arrays undergo strong super and subradiant emission. Despite subwavelength spacing, we achieve site resolved imaging and directly observe the buildup of spatial correlations, demonstrating the transformation of cooperative decay into a strongly correlated many-body process. We observe extensive scaling of superradiance, uncover superradiant revivals, and reveal the ferromagnetic nature of superradiance and the antiferromagnetic nature of subradiance. Our results realize a novel programmable platform for exploring and utilizing dissipative many-body quantum physics, opening new possibilities for photon capture, storage, and atom photon entanglement.
A major application for atomic ensembles consists of a quantum memory for light, in which an optical state can be reversibly converted to a collective atomic excitation on demand. There exists a well-known fundamental bound on the storage error, when the ensemble is describable by a continuous medium governed by the Maxwell–Bloch equations. However, these equations are semi-phenomenological, as they treat emission of the atoms into other directions other than the mode of interest as being independent. On the other hand, in systems such as dense, ordered atomic arrays, atoms interact with each other strongly and spatial interference of the emitted light might be exploited to suppress emission into unwanted directions, thereby enabling improved error bounds. Here, we develop a general formalism that fully accounts for spatial interference, and which finds the maximum storage efficiency for a single photon with known spatial input mode into a collection of atoms with discrete, known positions. As an example, we apply this technique to study a finite two-dimensional square array of atoms. We show that such a system enables a storage error that scales with atom number N a like , and that, remarkably, an array of just 4 × 4 atoms in principle allows for an error of less than 1%, which is comparable to a disordered ensemble with an optical depth of around 600.
We investigate the collective dynamics of a three-level ensemble under the Dicke limit, revealing a unified connection between superradiant emission and electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT). Our results show that the transient superradiant burst exhibits the expected peak intensity scaling Imax⁡ ⁣∼ ⁣N2I_{\max}\!\sim\! N^2Imax​∼N2, with a universal finite-size correction ∣ξ(N)−2∣ ⁣∼ ⁣1/ln⁡N|ξ(N)-2|\!\sim\! 1/\ln N∣ξ(N)−2∣∼1/lnN that governs the apparent scaling exponent in realistic ensembles. In the stationary regime, collective broadening modifies the EIT response: although it typically enhances absorption, it counterintuitively increases the group velocity, leading to a relative scaling vg ⁣∝ ⁣N2v_g\!\propto\! N^2vg​∝N2, even while vg ⁣≪ ⁣cv_g\!\ll\! cvg​≪c. This effect suggests that cooperative interactions fundamentally limit the achievable slow-light delay in dense media. To achieve these results, we derive a representative-atom master equation that quantitatively reproduces both the superradiant and EIT regimes, in excellent agreement with the exact symmetric-subspace dynamics and correctly incorporating collective feedback and NNN-dependent broadening. This unified framework bridges transient superradiant emission and steady-state quantum interference, with direct implications for slow light, quantum memories, and precision metrology.
Atomic arrays can exhibit collective light emission when the transition wavelength exceeds their lattice spacing. Subradiant states take advantage of this phenomenon to drastically reduce their overall decay rate, allowing for long-lived states in dissipative open systems. We build on previous work to investigate whether or not disorder can further decrease the decay rate of a singly excited atomic array. More specifically, we consider spatial disorder of varying strengths in a one-dimensional (1D) half waveguide and in 1D, two-dimensional (2D), and three-dimensional (3D) atomic arrays in free space and analyze the effect on the most subradiant modes. While we confirm that the dilute half waveguide exhibits an analog of Anderson localization, the dense half waveguide and free-space systems can be understood through the creation of close-packed, few-body subradiant states similar to those found in the Dicke limit. In general, we find that disorder provides little advantage in generating darker subradiant states in free space on average and will often accelerate decay. However, one could potentially change interatomic spacing within the array to engineer specific subradiant states.
We present a framework to investigate the collective properties of atomic lattices in one, two, and three dimensions. We analyze the single-photon band structure and associated atomic decay rates, revealing a fundamental dependence on dimensionality. One- and two-dimensional arrays are shown to be inherently radiative, exhibiting band gaps and decay rates that oscillate between superradiant and subradiant regimes, as a function of lattice spacing. In contrast, three-dimensional lattices are found to be fundamentally non-radiative due to the inhibition of spontaneous emission, with decay only at discrete Bragg resonances. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this structural difference dictates the system dynamics, which crosses over from dissipative decay in lower dimensions to coherent transport in three dimensions. Our results provide insight into cooperative effects in atomic arrays at the single-photon level.