In the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) regime, quantum devices contain hardware-specific noise sources which restrict device-invariant error mitigation strategies. We explore transfer learning approaches to apply noise models learned on one quantum device to a different device with the help of a small amount of data. We create a real-hardware dataset from two IBM quantum devices, ibm_fez (source) and ibm_marrakesh (target), comprising 170 noisy and ideal circuit output distributions, with device calibration features added. We train a residual neural network on the source device to map noisy to ideal outcomes. The zero-shot transfer test shows a KL divergence of 1.6706 (up from 0.3014), establishing device specificity. With K = 20 fine-tuning samples, KL drops to 1.1924 (28.6% improvement over zero-shot), recovering 34.9% of the gap between zero-shot and in-domain KL. Ablation studies reveal that the major cause of mismatches across devices is CX gate error, followed by readout error. The results show quantum noise can be learned and fine-tuned with minimal samples, and provide a plausible approach to cross-device quantum error mitigation.
Comments
9 pages, 8 figures, 8 tables. Submitted to IEEE Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE) 2026
In the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) regime, quantum devices contain hardware-specific noise sources which restrict device-invariant error mitigation strategies. We explore transfer learning approaches to apply noise models learned on one quantum device to a different device with the help of a small amount of data. We create a real-hardware dataset from two IBM quantum devices, ibm_fez (source) and ibm_marrakesh (target), comprising 170 noisy and ideal circuit output distributions, with device calibration features added. We train a residual neural network on the source device to map noisy to ideal outcomes. The zero-shot transfer test shows a KL divergence of 1.6706 (up from 0.3014), establishing device specificity. With K = 20 fine-tuning samples, KL drops to 1.1924 (28.6% improvement over zero-shot), recovering 34.9% of the gap between zero-shot and in-domain KL. Ablation studies reveal that the major cause of mismatches across devices is CX gate error, followed by readout error. The results show quantum noise can be learned and fine-tuned with minimal samples, and provide a plausible approach to cross-device quantum error mitigation.
Quantum computers, while offering exponential computational advantages, are highly vulnerable to noise-induced errors, particularly during the measurement process. This paper investigates machine learning-based error mitigation strategies with a focus on transfer learning. By initially training a base model on a specific quantum device, we leverage transfer learning to adapt the model for use on different quantum computers. This approach not only achieves superior performance with reduced dataset size and training time but also maintains hardware agnosticism, as demonstrated through tests on various IBM quantum backends. Our method provides a practical solution for enhancing the accuracy and efficiency of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) algorithms by improving machine learning-based error mitigation.
We present a systematic investigation of deep learning methods applied to quantum error mitigation of noisy output probability distributions from measured quantum circuits. We compare different architectures, from fully connected neural networks to transformers, and we test different design/training modalities, identifying sequence-to-sequence, attention-based models as the most effective on our datasets. These models consistently produce mitigated distributions that are closer to the ideal outputs when tested on both simulated and real device data obtained from IBM superconducting quantum processing units (QPU) up to five qubits. Across several different circuit depths, our approach outperforms other baseline error mitigation techniques. We perform a series of ablation studies to examine: how different input features (circuit, device properties, noisy output statistics) affect performance; cross-dataset generalization across circuit families; and transfer learning to a different IBM QPU. We observe that generalization performance across similar devices with the same architecture works effectively, without needing to fully retrain models.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) is an exciting frontier applying the philosophy of quantum computation to classical machine learning for improved learning performance of complicated tasks. However, QML is greatly challenged by realistic issues like noisy quantum measurements and limited labeled quantum data caused by the high cost and technological limitations. This paper explores the novel transfer-learning mechanisms to tackle these issues, which allow the reuse of the knowledge from related quantum tasks for improving model performance and generalization in resource-limited scenarios. Transfer learning, one of the great and successful concepts of classical machine learning, is to transfer the learned parameters or features from the source domain (or task) to the target domain (or task). We further develop and investigate, in quantum, a methodology where parameterized quantum circuits (PQCs) learnt on a source quantum data set have certain parts partially re-used or fine-tuned for a target task, given limited amount of target data. This strategy also avoids large quantum training runs that are not scalable on state-of-the-art noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) processors. The suggested methods are layerwise quantum adaptation, quantum kernel reuse and hybrid quantum-classical feature transfer. We investigate the robustness of these mechanisms in presence of noise by simulating quantum circuits using depolarizing and readout noise models. Moreover, we show that pretraining of quantum models on synthetic (or simulated) data sets (which are generated using larger, less noisy systems) can be instrumental in learning on real, small-sized quantum devices. Experiment results in quantum classification tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of transfer learning in boosting the accuracy, accelerating the convergence, and lowering the quantum circuit depth of successfully trained model. It is interesting to mention that transfer using layer-wise models became very resistant to quantum noise, as its performance did not degrade significantly for noisy inputs. These results demonstrate that transfer learning can overcome the scarce quantum data and suppress the harmful impact of measurement noise. This work presents a potential venue for enhancing the applicability of QML in the NISQ era. By transferring knowledge from theoretical quantum learning models to actual quantum hardware constraints, transfer learning allows quantum algorithms to learn faster and generalize better across tasks.
Learning-based Quantum Error Mitigation (QEM) has emerged as a promising approach for reducing noise-induced bias on near-term Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware. While simulated noise models enable scalable training of learning-based mitigators, real hardware data more accurately reflect device-specific error mechanisms, but are expensive and sparse. Understanding how these two data regimes interact is therefore critical for the practical deployment of learning-based QEM. In this paper, we present a systematic and empirical analysis on the nature of the data (simulated versus hardware noise) for learning-based QEM. Using a recently developed attention-based graph transformer for small- and large-scale quantum error mitigation, we compare various training regimes, starting from exclusively simulated noise and progressively integrating more measurements from real quantum hardware. Our study spans two distinct circuit families: 1) randomly generated circuits with relatively homogeneous structure; and 2) targeted quantum circuits derived from a specific problem, in this case the one-dimensional Burgers’ equation. Across five-fold cross validation, we analyze how hardware data affects generalization performance as measured by mean absolute error (MAE). Our results demonstrate that the impact of hardware data strongly depends on circuit structure and diversity. For random circuits, simulated data already guarantees lower absolute error, while hardware data yields consistent, but moderate improvements. In contrast, for targeted circuits, like the structured Burgers’ circuits, simulated noise can be less representative of the actual (testing) quantum error, and incorporating hardware data produces substantially larger relative reductions in MAE – despite the intrinsically higher MAE. These findings indicate the value of the nature of the training data in learning-based QEM, which is governed not only by the data’s ability to approximate reality – as expected – but also by how difficult it may be to capture circuit-induced error mechanisms in quantum simulations. In general, this work highlights the urgency of quantum circuit coverage in designing scalable and cost-effective learning-based QEM pipelines for devices in this new NISQ-era.
Quantum machine learning (QML) models hold promise for leveraging quantum computers in data-driven tasks but their performance on today's noisy quantum hardware remains an open question. In this work, we investigate the impact of shot noise, the statistical noise due to finite sampling in quantum measurements, on the training and performance of quantum neural network (QNN) models. Using a dataset of dielectron collision events from CERN, we train QNNs under varying levels of simulated noise. Three ansatz circuit architectures are explored namely BasicEntanglerLayers (Ansatz-1), SimplifiedTwoDesign (Ansatz-2) and StronglyEntanglingLayers (Ansatz-3). Each model is repeatedly trained for multiple runs at noise levels ranging from zero up to significant noise fractions (0.5), with each training run consisting of 20 epochs of parameter optimization. We evaluate the convergence behavior, final error rates and variability across runs for each noise setting. Our results show a clear degradation of QNN performance as shot noise increases with training loss converging more slowly and to higher values and the model's prediction accuracy deteriorates with larger noise. Notably, the ansatz with fewer parametric gates demonstrates relatively better robustness to noise compared to deeper, more strongly entangling circuits which suffer sharper performance drops under noise. We provide detailed comparisons of the three circuit designs, including training loss curves and statistical summaries of performance at each noise level. These findings shed light on the practical limits of QML models in the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era and highlight the trade-offs between circuit expressiveness and noise resilience. Finally, we discuss implications for designing noise-aware quantum models and possible strategies to mitigate shot noise effects in quantum learning.
Abstract Accurately characterizing and mitigating the impact of noise is essential for improving the fidelity of quantum simulations on Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices. In this work, we introduce a circuit-structure-preserving error-mitigation framework designed for parameterized quantum circuits. Unlike conventional approaches that alter circuit topology or require heavy post-processing, our method preserves the native architecture while systematically diagnosing gate noise. This structure-preserving feature enables robust, high-fidelity simulations even in the presence of significant hardware noise, making the approach particularly effective for small-scale circuits executed at high sampling rates, such as those used in variational algorithms and quantum neural networks. To benchmark its performance, we apply the method to variational quantum simulations of a non-Hermitian ferromagnetic transverse-field Ising chain implemented on IBM Quantum processors. The mitigated results exhibit excellent agreement with exact theoretical predictions across a wide range of noise conditions. Thus, our framework provides a scalable and hardware-efficient strategy for the current hardware.