Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.16439 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Comment on "Extension of the adiabatic theorem"

Jie Gu

cond-mat.stat-mechquant-phSubmitted Apr 7, 2026• Announced Apr 8, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Apr 21, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Apr 7, 2026v2 · Apr 21, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Phys. Rev. B 113, 165102 (2026) proposed the conjecture that, for quantum quenches within the same phase, the overlap between the initial ground state and postquench eigenstates is maximal for the postquench ground state. We show that this conjecture is not valid in general. An explicit local, translationally invariant, gapped free-fermion counterexample exists even though the pre- and postquench Hamiltonians are connected by a symmetry-preserving gapped path and the thermodynamic-limit spectrum is continuous.

Journal reference
Phys. Rev. B 114, 177101 (2026)
DOI
10.1103/8dmf-hrs2
Comments
Comment on arXiv:2505.06029

Related papers

Exact criteria for ground-state overlap dominance and dynamical quantum phase transitions

Taisanul Haque

It was recently conjectured and verified for the transverse-field Ising model [Phys. Rev. B 113, 165102 (2026)] that, after a sudden quench within the same equilibrium phase, the initial ground state has its largest overlap with the final ground state. We show that this phase-based criterion is generally false, even in translationally invariant free-fermion systems. For Hamiltonians that factorize into independent $2\times 2$ momentum sectors, we derive the exact necessary-and-sufficient condition for ground-state overlap dominance: the initial and final sector Bloch vectors must have positive dot product for every momentum. This result proves the conjecture in classes where same-phase quenches enforce this geometric condition, but gives explicit same-phase counterexamples in Kitaev chains, where excited final eigenstates can dominate the overlap distribution. We further show that the same obstruction controls real-time Fisher-zero crossings, allowing dynamical quantum phase transitions without crossing an equilibrium phase boundary.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2604.11420•Physical review. E•Apr 14, 2026•1 citation

1 AUTOMORPHIC EQUIVALENCE WITHIN GAPPED PHASES OF QUANTUM LATTICE SYSTEMS

Sven Bachmann, Spyridon Michalakis, Bruno Nachtergaele +1 more

Gapped ground states of quantum spin systems have been referred to in the physics\n literature as being `in the same phase' if there exists a family of Hamiltonians H(s), with\n finite range interactions depending continuously on $s \\in [0,1]$, such that for each $s$,\n H(s) has a non-vanishing gap above its ground state and with the two initial states being\n the ground states of H(0) and H(1), respectively. In this work, we give precise conditions\n under which any two gapped ground states of a given quantum spin system that 'belong to the\n same phase' are automorphically equivalent and show that this equivalence can be\n implemented as a flow generated by an $s$-dependent interaction which decays faster than\n any power law (in fact, almost exponentially). The flow is constructed using Hastings'\n 'quasi-adiabatic evolution' technique, of which we give a proof extended to\n infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. In addition, we derive a general result about the\n locality properties of the effect of perturbations of the dynamics for quantum systems with\n a quasi-local structure and prove that the flow, which we call the {\\em spectral flow},\n connecting the gapped ground states in the same phase, satisfies a Lieb-Robinson bound. As\n a result, we obtain that, in the thermodynamic limit, the spectral flow converges to a\n co-cycle of automorphisms of the algebra of quasi-local observables of the infinite spin\n system. This proves that the ground state phase structure is preserved along the curve of\n models $H(s), 0\\leq s\\leq 1$.

•Feb 4, 2011•155 citations

Adiabatic theorem in the thermodynamic limit: Systems with a uniform gap

Joscha Henheik, Stefan Teufel

We show that recent results on adiabatic theory for interacting gapped many-body systems on finite lattices remain valid in the thermodynamic limit. More precisely, we prove a generalized super-adiabatic theorem for the automorphism group describing the infinite volume dynamics on the quasi-local algebra of observables. The key assumption is the existence of a sequence of gapped finite volume Hamiltonians, which generates the same infinite volume dynamics in the thermodynamic limit. Our adiabatic theorem also holds for certain perturbations of gapped ground states that close the spectral gap (so it is also an adiabatic theorem for resonances and, in this sense, “generalized”), and it provides an adiabatic approximation to all orders in the adiabatic parameter (a property often called “super-adiabatic”). In addition to the existing results for finite lattices, we also perform a resummation of the adiabatic expansion and allow for observables that are not strictly local. Finally, as an application, we prove the validity of linear and higher order response theory for our class of perturbations for infinite systems. While we consider the result and its proof as new and interesting in itself, we also lay the foundation for the proof of an adiabatic theorem for systems with a gap only in the bulk, which will be presented in a follow-up article.

arXiv:2012.15238•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2022•13 citations

Stability of entanglement-spectrum crossing in quench dynamics of one-dimensional gapped free-fermion systems

Shuangyuan Lu, Jinlong Yu

In a recent work by Gong and Ueda [Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 250601 (2018)], the classification of (1+1)-dimensional quench dynamics for the ten Altland-Zirnbauer classes is achieved, and entanglement-spectrum crossings of the time-dependent states for the topological classes (AIII, DIII, CII, BDI, and D) are discovered as a consequence of the bulk-edge correspondence. We note that their classification scheme for the (1+1)-dimensional bulk topology as well as the adoption of entanglement-spectrum crossings as a diagnosis of topological edge states focus on the limit that the spectrum of the postquench Hamiltonian is flat. When band dispersion of the postquench Hamiltonian is considered, even though the bulk topology is still stable, the entanglement-spectrum crossing at the edge might be unstable due to the fact that the band dispersion can be regarded as a ``symmetry-breaking disorder'' in the frequency domain. Such a symmetry-breaking disorder lowers the symmetry for the edge side, and the conventional bulk-edge correspondence could not be applied directly for the quench dynamics. We show that because of the reduction of symmetry by finite energy dispersion the gapless entanglement-spectrum crossing in the flatband limit in classes AIII, DIII, and CII is unstable and could be gapped without closing the bulk gap. The entanglement-spectrum crossing in classes BDI and D is still stable against energy dispersion. We show that the quench process for classes BDI and D can be understood as a ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ fermion parity pump, and the entanglement-spectrum crossing for this case is protected by the conservation of fermion parity.

arXiv:1810.03534•Physical Review A•Mar 25, 2019•12 citations

Perturbative post-quench overlaps in quantum field theory

Kristóf Hódsági, Márton Kormos, G. Takács

Abstract In analytic descriptions of quantum quenches, the overlaps between the initial pre-quench state and the eigenstates of the time evolving Hamiltonian are crucial ingredients. We construct perturbative expansions of these overlaps in quantum field theories where either the pre-quench or the post-quench Hamiltonian is integrable. Using the E 8 Ising field theory for concrete computations, we give explicit expressions for the overlaps up to second order in the quench size, and verify our results against numerical results obtained using the Truncated Conformal Space Approach. We demonstrate that the expansion using the post-quench basis is very effective, but find some serious limitations for the alternative approach using the pre-quench basis.

arXiv:1905.05623•Journal of High Energy Physics•Aug 1, 2019•32 citations

The Adiabatic Theorem of Quantum Mechanics

J. E. Avron, Alexander Elgart

We prove the adiabatic theorem for quantum evolution without the traditional gap condition. We show that the theorem holds essentially in all cases where it can be formulated. In particular, our result implies that the adiabatic theorem holds also for eigenvalues embedded in the continuous spectrum. If there is information on the Hölder continuity of the spectral measure, then one can also estimate the rate at which the adiabatic limit is approached. The adiabatic theorem of Quantum Mechanics describes the long time behavior of the solutions of an initial value problem where the Hamiltonian generating the evolution depends slowly in time. Traditionally, the theorem is stated for Hamiltonians that have an eigenvalue which is separated by a gap from the rest of the spectrum. Folk wisdom is that a gap condition is a sine qua non for the adiabatic theorem to hold. In particular, according to this folk wisdom, one does not expect a general adiabatic theorem for Hamiltonians that have an eigenvalue embedded in, say, the continuous spectrum. Our purpose is to show that this folk wisdom is wrong, and there is a general adiabatic theorem without a gap condition. All one really needs for the adiabatic theorem is a spectral projection for the Hamiltonian that depends smoothly on time.

•May 25, 1998•66 citations
Phys. Rev. B 113, 165102 (2026) proposed the conjecture that, for quantum quenches within the same phase, the overlap between the initial ground state and postquench eigenstates is maximal for the postquench ground state. We show that this conjecture is not valid in general. An explicit local, translationally invariant, gapped free-fermion counterexample exists even though the pre- and postquench Hamiltonians are connected by a symmetry-preserving gapped path and the thermodynamic-limit spectrum is continuous.
It was recently conjectured and verified for the transverse-field Ising model [Phys. Rev. B 113, 165102 (2026)] that, after a sudden quench within the same equilibrium phase, the initial ground state has its largest overlap with the final ground state. We show that this phase-based criterion is generally false, even in translationally invariant free-fermion systems. For Hamiltonians that factorize into independent 2×22\times 22×2 momentum sectors, we derive the exact necessary-and-sufficient condition for ground-state overlap dominance: the initial and final sector Bloch vectors must have positive dot product for every momentum. This result proves the conjecture in classes where same-phase quenches enforce this geometric condition, but gives explicit same-phase counterexamples in Kitaev chains, where excited final eigenstates can dominate the overlap distribution. We further show that the same obstruction controls real-time Fisher-zero crossings, allowing dynamical quantum phase transitions without crossing an equilibrium phase boundary.
Gapped ground states of quantum spin systems have been referred to in the physics\n literature as being `in the same phase' if there exists a family of Hamiltonians H(s), with\n finite range interactions depending continuously on sin[0,1]s \\in [0,1]sin[0,1], such that for each sss,\n H(s) has a non-vanishing gap above its ground state and with the two initial states being\n the ground states of H(0) and H(1), respectively. In this work, we give precise conditions\n under which any two gapped ground states of a given quantum spin system that 'belong to the\n same phase' are automorphically equivalent and show that this equivalence can be\n implemented as a flow generated by an sss-dependent interaction which decays faster than\n any power law (in fact, almost exponentially). The flow is constructed using Hastings'\n 'quasi-adiabatic evolution' technique, of which we give a proof extended to\n infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. In addition, we derive a general result about the\n locality properties of the effect of perturbations of the dynamics for quantum systems with\n a quasi-local structure and prove that the flow, which we call the {\\em spectral flow},\n connecting the gapped ground states in the same phase, satisfies a Lieb-Robinson bound. As\n a result, we obtain that, in the thermodynamic limit, the spectral flow converges to a\n co-cycle of automorphisms of the algebra of quasi-local observables of the infinite spin\n system. This proves that the ground state phase structure is preserved along the curve of\n models H(s),0leqsleq1H(s), 0\\leq s\\leq 1H(s),0leqsleq1.
We show that recent results on adiabatic theory for interacting gapped many-body systems on finite lattices remain valid in the thermodynamic limit. More precisely, we prove a generalized super-adiabatic theorem for the automorphism group describing the infinite volume dynamics on the quasi-local algebra of observables. The key assumption is the existence of a sequence of gapped finite volume Hamiltonians, which generates the same infinite volume dynamics in the thermodynamic limit. Our adiabatic theorem also holds for certain perturbations of gapped ground states that close the spectral gap (so it is also an adiabatic theorem for resonances and, in this sense, “generalized”), and it provides an adiabatic approximation to all orders in the adiabatic parameter (a property often called “super-adiabatic”). In addition to the existing results for finite lattices, we also perform a resummation of the adiabatic expansion and allow for observables that are not strictly local. Finally, as an application, we prove the validity of linear and higher order response theory for our class of perturbations for infinite systems. While we consider the result and its proof as new and interesting in itself, we also lay the foundation for the proof of an adiabatic theorem for systems with a gap only in the bulk, which will be presented in a follow-up article.
In a recent work by Gong and Ueda [Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 250601 (2018)], the classification of (1+1)-dimensional quench dynamics for the ten Altland-Zirnbauer classes is achieved, and entanglement-spectrum crossings of the time-dependent states for the topological classes (AIII, DIII, CII, BDI, and D) are discovered as a consequence of the bulk-edge correspondence. We note that their classification scheme for the (1+1)-dimensional bulk topology as well as the adoption of entanglement-spectrum crossings as a diagnosis of topological edge states focus on the limit that the spectrum of the postquench Hamiltonian is flat. When band dispersion of the postquench Hamiltonian is considered, even though the bulk topology is still stable, the entanglement-spectrum crossing at the edge might be unstable due to the fact that the band dispersion can be regarded as a ``symmetry-breaking disorder'' in the frequency domain. Such a symmetry-breaking disorder lowers the symmetry for the edge side, and the conventional bulk-edge correspondence could not be applied directly for the quench dynamics. We show that because of the reduction of symmetry by finite energy dispersion the gapless entanglement-spectrum crossing in the flatband limit in classes AIII, DIII, and CII is unstable and could be gapped without closing the bulk gap. The entanglement-spectrum crossing in classes BDI and D is still stable against energy dispersion. We show that the quench process for classes BDI and D can be understood as a Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ fermion parity pump, and the entanglement-spectrum crossing for this case is protected by the conservation of fermion parity.
Abstract In analytic descriptions of quantum quenches, the overlaps between the initial pre-quench state and the eigenstates of the time evolving Hamiltonian are crucial ingredients. We construct perturbative expansions of these overlaps in quantum field theories where either the pre-quench or the post-quench Hamiltonian is integrable. Using the E 8 Ising field theory for concrete computations, we give explicit expressions for the overlaps up to second order in the quench size, and verify our results against numerical results obtained using the Truncated Conformal Space Approach. We demonstrate that the expansion using the post-quench basis is very effective, but find some serious limitations for the alternative approach using the pre-quench basis.
We prove the adiabatic theorem for quantum evolution without the traditional gap condition. We show that the theorem holds essentially in all cases where it can be formulated. In particular, our result implies that the adiabatic theorem holds also for eigenvalues embedded in the continuous spectrum. If there is information on the Hölder continuity of the spectral measure, then one can also estimate the rate at which the adiabatic limit is approached. The adiabatic theorem of Quantum Mechanics describes the long time behavior of the solutions of an initial value problem where the Hamiltonian generating the evolution depends slowly in time. Traditionally, the theorem is stated for Hamiltonians that have an eigenvalue which is separated by a gap from the rest of the spectrum. Folk wisdom is that a gap condition is a sine qua non for the adiabatic theorem to hold. In particular, according to this folk wisdom, one does not expect a general adiabatic theorem for Hamiltonians that have an eigenvalue embedded in, say, the continuous spectrum. Our purpose is to show that this folk wisdom is wrong, and there is a general adiabatic theorem without a gap condition. All one really needs for the adiabatic theorem is a spectral projection for the Hamiltonian that depends smoothly on time.