Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.25665

Non-linear Sigma Model for the Surface Code with Coherent Errors

Stephen W. Yan, Yimu Bao, Sagar Vijay

cond-mat.stat-mechcond-mat.dis-nncond-mat.str-elquant-phSubmitted Mar 26, 2026• Announced Mar 27, 2026• 12 citations• Revised May 3, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Mar 26, 2026v2 · May 3, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The surface code is a promising platform for a quantum memory, but its threshold under coherent errors remains incompletely understood. We study maximum-likelihood decoding of the square-lattice surface code in the presence of single-qubit unitary rotations that create electric anyon excitations. We microscopically derive a non-linear sigma model with target space $\mathrm{SO}(2n)/\mathrm{U}(n)$ as the effective long-distance theory of this decoding problem, with distinct replica limits: $n\to1$ for optimal decoding, which assumes knowledge of the coherent rotation angle, and $n\to0$ for suboptimal decoding with imperfect angle information. This exposes a sharp distinction between the two decoders. The suboptimal decoder supports a "thermal-metal" phase, a non-decodable regime that is qualitatively distinct from the conventional non-decodable phase of the surface code under incoherent Pauli errors. By contrast, the metal phase cannot arise in optimal decoding, since the metallic fixed-point becomes unstable in the $n\to 1$ replica limit. We argue that optimal decoding may be possible up to the maximally-coherent rotation angle. Within the sigma model description, we show that the decoding fidelity is related to twist defects of the order-parameter field, yielding quantitative predictions for its system-size dependence near the metallic fixed point for both decoders. We examine our analytic predictions for the decoding fidelity as well as other physical observables with extensive numerical simulations. We discuss how the symmetries and the target space for the sigma model rely on the lattice of the surface code, and how a stable thermal metal phase can arise in optimal decoding when the syndromes reside on a non-bipartite lattice.

Comments
26+23 pages, 18 figures; typos corrected, improved figures in section VI, results unchanged

Related papers

Algebraic strong-to-weak symmetry breaking and partial decodability in the surface code

Stephen W. Yan, Yimu Bao, Sagar Vijay

Coherent noise can give rise to unconventional regimes of quantum information recovery and mixed-state order. We study these phenomena in two settings related by Wegner duality: the triangular-lattice surface code subject to single-qubit Pauli-$Z$ rotations followed by syndrome measurements, and a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ paramagnet subject to strongly symmetric decoherence. Increasing the rotation angle drives a transition from a decodable phase to a \emph{partially decodable} critical phase in the code, and from a strongly symmetric phase to a phase with \emph{algebraic} $\mathbb{Z}_2$ strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (SWSSB) in the dual paramagnet. We develop a common description of these phenomena in terms of a weakly coupled $\mathrm{SO}(n)$ nonlinear sigma model in the replica limit $n\to1$. Taking this replica limit analytically, we derive universal signatures of the critical phase: an optimal Pauli decoding fidelity that approaches a universal function of the system's aspect ratio in the thermodynamic limit, and a dual fidelity correlator that decays as a universal power law. These observables relate to correlations of twist operators in the sigma model description. Large-scale numerical simulations confirm these analytical predictions. We also argue that the algebraic SWSSB phase cannot be realized by any Pauli dephasing channel acting on the $\mathbb{Z}_{2}$ paramagnet. We probe this "non-classical" character through the output state's sensitivity to well-separated $\mathbb{Z}_{2}$ fluxes inserted in the initial state, which reveals persistent coherence between distinct $\mathbb{Z}_{2}$ charge trajectories at long distances.

quant-pharXiv:2610.40567•Oct 30, 2026•3 citations

Surface codes with coherent errors: optimal decoding and finite-size crossovers

Xu-Dong Dai, Zhou‐Quan Wan, Xi Dai +1 more

We study the surface code under uniform coherent $Z$ rotations $\exp{(iθZ)}$ followed by perfect syndrome measurements, a setting known to exhibit strong finite-size effects that complicate the extraction of the asymptotic decoding threshold. We identify finite-size behavior of both Pauli decoding measures and the coherent information with two characteristic lengths: an algebraic ballistic-crossover scale $d_{\mathrm{ba}}\sim 1/β_R^α$ ($α=1$ for odd $d$ and $α=2$ for even $d$) and a much larger renormalization-group scale $d_\mathrm{RG}\sim \exp{(C/β^{4}_R)}$, where $β_R=-\tfrac{1}{2}\ln\tanθ$ and $d$ is the system size. As $θ$ approaches the ballistic SWAP point $π/4$, the two length scales diverge at very different rates, leaving a broad intermediate regime $d_{\mathrm{ba}}\ll d\ll d_\mathrm{RG}$ in which these quantities show substantial finite-size drift and approximate plateaus. To establish the microscopic basis of this crossover picture, we derive a leading inter-flavor quartic interaction of order $β_R^2$ in the replicated Majorana theory, which provides a route to the class-D nonlinear sigma model. The resulting marginal RG flow motivates the scaling variable $X_4=β_R^4\ln d$, in which free-fermion simulations show approximate collapse of decoding measures. These results are consistent with a Pauli-decoding threshold at $θ_c=π/4$ in the thermodynamic limit. For any even $d$, we prove that maximum-likelihood Pauli decoding maximizes entanglement fidelity over all deterministic syndrome-conditioned quantum recoveries, and that its decoding threshold attains the quantum-optimal limit, coinciding with the one defined by coherent information.

arXiv:2611.13098•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

Decoding coherent errors in toric codes on honeycomb and square lattices: duality to Majorana monitored dynamics and symmetry classes

Zhou Yang, Andreas W. W. Ludwig, Chao-Ming Jian

Topological stabilizer codes, such as the toric and surface codes, are leading candidates for fault-tolerant quantum computation. While their decodability under stochastic noise has been extensively studied, the effects of coherent errors, which involve quantum interference, remain less explored. In this work, we study the decodability of toric codes on honeycomb and square lattices subject to $X$- and $Z$-type coherent errors generated by the $X$- and $Z$-rotations on each qubit. We establish a duality between these decoding problems and 1+1D monitored dynamics of non-interacting Majorana fermions. This duality shows that the Altland-Zirnbauer symmetry class of the dual Majorana dynamics governs the universal structure of the decodability phase diagram. We show that the honeycomb-lattice toric code (hTC) with $X$-type error is dual to class-DIII dynamics, while the hTC with $Z$-type error and the square-lattice toric code (sTC) with both error types are dual to class-D dynamics. The key distinction arises from time-reversal symmetry. In class DIII, the generic transition out of the decodable phase is dual to a measurement-induced transition between dynamical phases with area-law and logarithmic entanglement scaling. In contrast, in class D, the generic decodability transition corresponds to a transition between two topologically distinct area-law phases. To explore these transitions in microscopic models, we consider hTC and sTC with $X$-type errors as representatives and introduce a minimal two-parameter coherent error model with spatially varying rotation angles. Using analytical and numerical methods, we map out the decodability phase diagrams and characterize the universal behavior of the transitions. We find that the decodability of sTC is more vulnerable to spatially varying coherent errors than uniform ones.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2604.08650•Apr 13, 2026•9 citations

Proof of a positive coherent-error threshold for topological quantum codes

Shiro Tamiya, Masato Koashi

Threshold analyses of quantum error-correcting codes are well established for stochastic error models, in which errors occur randomly with given probabilities. However, errors in actual devices can also be coherent, such as unwanted $Z$ rotations due to imperfect control, which are not captured by stochastic error models. For the surface code, numerical studies have indicated threshold behavior even under coherent errors, but a rigorous proof of threshold existence is lacking. Here we prove that a positive threshold for coherent $Z$-rotation errors exists for quantum low-density parity-check codes with a bounded number of logical qubits, including the surface code and other topological codes. Specifically, we show that the maximum-likelihood Pauli recovery suppresses the entanglement infidelity exponentially in the code distance up to a prefactor linear in the number of physical qubits whenever the rotation angles lie below a constant that is independent of the code size. The proof combines Fourier analysis to retain the interference among the amplitudes of coherent errors with the cluster expansion of abstract polymer models. Our results expand the theoretical foundation of quantum error correction and offer a statistical-mechanical description of quantum error correction beyond stochastic errors.

quant-pharXiv:2609.20708•Sep 18, 2026•1 citation

Statistical Mechanical Mapping and Maximum-Likelihood Thresholds for the Surface Code under Generic Single-Qubit Coherent Errors

Jan Behrends, Benjámin Béri

The surface code, one of the leading candidates for quantum error correction, is known to protect encoded quantum information against stochastic, i.e., incoherent errors. The protection against coherent errors, such as from unwanted gate rotations, is however understood only for special cases, such as rotations about the X or Z axes. Here we consider generic single-qubit coherent errors in the surface code, i.e., rotations by angle α about an axis that can be chosen arbitrarily. We develop a statistical mechanical mapping for such errors and perform entanglement analysis in transfer matrix space to numerically establish the existence of an error-correcting phase, which we chart in a subspace of rotation axes to estimate the corresponding maximum-likelihood thresholds α th . The classical statistical mechanics model we derive is a random-bond Ising model with complex couplings and four-spin interactions (i.e., a complex-coupled Ashkin-Teller model). The error-correcting phase, α < α th , where the logical error rate decreases exponentially with code distance, is shown to correspond in transfer matrix space to a gapped one-dimensional quantum Hamiltonian exhibiting spontaneous breaking of a Z 2 symmetry. Our numerical results rest on two key ingredients: (i) we show that the state evolution under the transfer matrix, a nonunitary ( 1 + 1 ) -dimensional quantum circuit, can be efficiently numerically simulated using matrix product states; and (ii) based on this approach, we also develop an algorithm to (approximately) sample syndromes based on their Born probability. The α th values we find show that the maximum-likelihood thresholds for coherent errors are larger than those for the corresponding incoherent errors (from the Pauli twirl), and significantly exceed the values found using minimum weight perfect matching.

arXiv:2410.22436•PRX Quantum•Jul 28, 2025•21 citations

Phases of decodability in the surface code with unitary errors

Yimu Bao, Sajant Anand

The maximum likelihood (ML) decoder in the two-dimensional surface code with generic unitary errors is governed by a statistical mechanics model with complex weights, which can be simulated via (1+1)D transfer matrix contraction. Information loss with an increasing error rate manifests as a ferromagnetic-to-paramagnetic transition in the contraction dynamics. In this work, we establish entanglement as a separate obstruction to decoding; it can undergo a transition from area- to volume-law scaling in the transfer matrix contraction with increasing unitary error rate. In particular, the volume-law entanglement can coexist with ferromagnetic order, giving rise to a phase in which the encoded information is retained yet is effectively undecodable. We numerically simulate the ML decoding in the surface code subject to both single- and two-qubit Pauli-X rotations and obtain a phase diagram that contains a ferromagnetic area-law, a paramagnetic volume-law, and a potential ferromagnetic volume-law phase. We further show that, starting from the paramagnetic volume-law phase, tilting the single-qubit rotation away from the X-axis couples the stat-mech models for X and Z errors and can lead to a ferromagnetic volume-law phase in which, although Z errors remain in principle correctable, the encoded classical information is hard to recover. To perform numerical simulations, we develop an algorithm for syndrome sampling based on an isometric tensor network representation of the surface code.

arXiv:2411.05785•Nov 8, 2024•17 citations
The surface code is a promising platform for a quantum memory, but its threshold under coherent errors remains incompletely understood. We study maximum-likelihood decoding of the square-lattice surface code in the presence of single-qubit unitary rotations that create electric anyon excitations. We microscopically derive a non-linear sigma model with target space SO(2n)/U(n)\mathrm{SO}(2n)/\mathrm{U}(n)SO(2n)/U(n) as the effective long-distance theory of this decoding problem, with distinct replica limits: n→1n\to1n→1 for optimal decoding, which assumes knowledge of the coherent rotation angle, and n→0n\to0n→0 for suboptimal decoding with imperfect angle information. This exposes a sharp distinction between the two decoders. The suboptimal decoder supports a "thermal-metal" phase, a non-decodable regime that is qualitatively distinct from the conventional non-decodable phase of the surface code under incoherent Pauli errors. By contrast, the metal phase cannot arise in optimal decoding, since the metallic fixed-point becomes unstable in the n→1n\to 1n→1 replica limit. We argue that optimal decoding may be possible up to the maximally-coherent rotation angle. Within the sigma model description, we show that the decoding fidelity is related to twist defects of the order-parameter field, yielding quantitative predictions for its system-size dependence near the metallic fixed point for both decoders. We examine our analytic predictions for the decoding fidelity as well as other physical observables with extensive numerical simulations. We discuss how the symmetries and the target space for the sigma model rely on the lattice of the surface code, and how a stable thermal metal phase can arise in optimal decoding when the syndromes reside on a non-bipartite lattice.
Coherent noise can give rise to unconventional regimes of quantum information recovery and mixed-state order. We study these phenomena in two settings related by Wegner duality: the triangular-lattice surface code subject to single-qubit Pauli-ZZZ rotations followed by syndrome measurements, and a Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ paramagnet subject to strongly symmetric decoherence. Increasing the rotation angle drives a transition from a decodable phase to a \emph{partially decodable} critical phase in the code, and from a strongly symmetric phase to a phase with \emph{algebraic} Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ strong-to-weak spontaneous symmetry breaking (SWSSB) in the dual paramagnet. We develop a common description of these phenomena in terms of a weakly coupled SO(n)\mathrm{SO}(n)SO(n) nonlinear sigma model in the replica limit n→1n\to1n→1. Taking this replica limit analytically, we derive universal signatures of the critical phase: an optimal Pauli decoding fidelity that approaches a universal function of the system's aspect ratio in the thermodynamic limit, and a dual fidelity correlator that decays as a universal power law. These observables relate to correlations of twist operators in the sigma model description. Large-scale numerical simulations confirm these analytical predictions. We also argue that the algebraic SWSSB phase cannot be realized by any Pauli dephasing channel acting on the Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2}Z2​ paramagnet. We probe this "non-classical" character through the output state's sensitivity to well-separated Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2}Z2​ fluxes inserted in the initial state, which reveals persistent coherence between distinct Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2}Z2​ charge trajectories at long distances.
We study the surface code under uniform coherent ZZZ rotations exp⁡(iθZ)\exp{(iθZ)}exp(iθZ) followed by perfect syndrome measurements, a setting known to exhibit strong finite-size effects that complicate the extraction of the asymptotic decoding threshold. We identify finite-size behavior of both Pauli decoding measures and the coherent information with two characteristic lengths: an algebraic ballistic-crossover scale dba∼1/βRαd_{\mathrm{ba}}\sim 1/β_R^αdba​∼1/βRα​ (α=1α=1α=1 for odd ddd and α=2α=2α=2 for even ddd) and a much larger renormalization-group scale dRG∼exp⁡(C/βR4)d_\mathrm{RG}\sim \exp{(C/β^{4}_R)}dRG​∼exp(C/βR4​), where βR=−12ln⁡tan⁡θβ_R=-\tfrac{1}{2}\ln\tanθβR​=−21​lntanθ and ddd is the system size. As θθθ approaches the ballistic SWAP point π/4π/4π/4, the two length scales diverge at very different rates, leaving a broad intermediate regime dba≪d≪dRGd_{\mathrm{ba}}\ll d\ll d_\mathrm{RG}dba​≪d≪dRG​ in which these quantities show substantial finite-size drift and approximate plateaus. To establish the microscopic basis of this crossover picture, we derive a leading inter-flavor quartic interaction of order βR2β_R^2βR2​ in the replicated Majorana theory, which provides a route to the class-D nonlinear sigma model. The resulting marginal RG flow motivates the scaling variable X4=βR4ln⁡dX_4=β_R^4\ln dX4​=βR4​lnd, in which free-fermion simulations show approximate collapse of decoding measures. These results are consistent with a Pauli-decoding threshold at θc=π/4θ_c=π/4θc​=π/4 in the thermodynamic limit. For any even ddd, we prove that maximum-likelihood Pauli decoding maximizes entanglement fidelity over all deterministic syndrome-conditioned quantum recoveries, and that its decoding threshold attains the quantum-optimal limit, coinciding with the one defined by coherent information.
Topological stabilizer codes, such as the toric and surface codes, are leading candidates for fault-tolerant quantum computation. While their decodability under stochastic noise has been extensively studied, the effects of coherent errors, which involve quantum interference, remain less explored. In this work, we study the decodability of toric codes on honeycomb and square lattices subject to XXX- and ZZZ-type coherent errors generated by the XXX- and ZZZ-rotations on each qubit. We establish a duality between these decoding problems and 1+1D monitored dynamics of non-interacting Majorana fermions. This duality shows that the Altland-Zirnbauer symmetry class of the dual Majorana dynamics governs the universal structure of the decodability phase diagram. We show that the honeycomb-lattice toric code (hTC) with XXX-type error is dual to class-DIII dynamics, while the hTC with ZZZ-type error and the square-lattice toric code (sTC) with both error types are dual to class-D dynamics. The key distinction arises from time-reversal symmetry. In class DIII, the generic transition out of the decodable phase is dual to a measurement-induced transition between dynamical phases with area-law and logarithmic entanglement scaling. In contrast, in class D, the generic decodability transition corresponds to a transition between two topologically distinct area-law phases. To explore these transitions in microscopic models, we consider hTC and sTC with XXX-type errors as representatives and introduce a minimal two-parameter coherent error model with spatially varying rotation angles. Using analytical and numerical methods, we map out the decodability phase diagrams and characterize the universal behavior of the transitions. We find that the decodability of sTC is more vulnerable to spatially varying coherent errors than uniform ones.
Threshold analyses of quantum error-correcting codes are well established for stochastic error models, in which errors occur randomly with given probabilities. However, errors in actual devices can also be coherent, such as unwanted ZZZ rotations due to imperfect control, which are not captured by stochastic error models. For the surface code, numerical studies have indicated threshold behavior even under coherent errors, but a rigorous proof of threshold existence is lacking. Here we prove that a positive threshold for coherent ZZZ-rotation errors exists for quantum low-density parity-check codes with a bounded number of logical qubits, including the surface code and other topological codes. Specifically, we show that the maximum-likelihood Pauli recovery suppresses the entanglement infidelity exponentially in the code distance up to a prefactor linear in the number of physical qubits whenever the rotation angles lie below a constant that is independent of the code size. The proof combines Fourier analysis to retain the interference among the amplitudes of coherent errors with the cluster expansion of abstract polymer models. Our results expand the theoretical foundation of quantum error correction and offer a statistical-mechanical description of quantum error correction beyond stochastic errors.
The surface code, one of the leading candidates for quantum error correction, is known to protect encoded quantum information against stochastic, i.e., incoherent errors. The protection against coherent errors, such as from unwanted gate rotations, is however understood only for special cases, such as rotations about the X or Z axes. Here we consider generic single-qubit coherent errors in the surface code, i.e., rotations by angle α about an axis that can be chosen arbitrarily. We develop a statistical mechanical mapping for such errors and perform entanglement analysis in transfer matrix space to numerically establish the existence of an error-correcting phase, which we chart in a subspace of rotation axes to estimate the corresponding maximum-likelihood thresholds α th . The classical statistical mechanics model we derive is a random-bond Ising model with complex couplings and four-spin interactions (i.e., a complex-coupled Ashkin-Teller model). The error-correcting phase, α < α th , where the logical error rate decreases exponentially with code distance, is shown to correspond in transfer matrix space to a gapped one-dimensional quantum Hamiltonian exhibiting spontaneous breaking of a Z 2 symmetry. Our numerical results rest on two key ingredients: (i) we show that the state evolution under the transfer matrix, a nonunitary ( 1 + 1 ) -dimensional quantum circuit, can be efficiently numerically simulated using matrix product states; and (ii) based on this approach, we also develop an algorithm to (approximately) sample syndromes based on their Born probability. The α th values we find show that the maximum-likelihood thresholds for coherent errors are larger than those for the corresponding incoherent errors (from the Pauli twirl), and significantly exceed the values found using minimum weight perfect matching.
The maximum likelihood (ML) decoder in the two-dimensional surface code with generic unitary errors is governed by a statistical mechanics model with complex weights, which can be simulated via (1+1)D transfer matrix contraction. Information loss with an increasing error rate manifests as a ferromagnetic-to-paramagnetic transition in the contraction dynamics. In this work, we establish entanglement as a separate obstruction to decoding; it can undergo a transition from area- to volume-law scaling in the transfer matrix contraction with increasing unitary error rate. In particular, the volume-law entanglement can coexist with ferromagnetic order, giving rise to a phase in which the encoded information is retained yet is effectively undecodable. We numerically simulate the ML decoding in the surface code subject to both single- and two-qubit Pauli-X rotations and obtain a phase diagram that contains a ferromagnetic area-law, a paramagnetic volume-law, and a potential ferromagnetic volume-law phase. We further show that, starting from the paramagnetic volume-law phase, tilting the single-qubit rotation away from the X-axis couples the stat-mech models for X and Z errors and can lead to a ferromagnetic volume-law phase in which, although Z errors remain in principle correctable, the encoded classical information is hard to recover. To perform numerical simulations, we develop an algorithm for syndrome sampling based on an isometric tensor network representation of the surface code.