Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.13711 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Entanglement Rényi negativity across the finite-temperature transition in the O ( 3 ) universality class

Dong-Xu Liu, Yi-Ming Ding, Zhe Wang, Zheng Yan

Published May 29, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The fate of quantum entanglement at finite-temperature phase transitions remains an open question, particularly for continuous symmetry breaking where zero-temperature Goldstone modes generate long-range correlations. Using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we investigate the third Rényi negativity across the O(3) transition in the three-dimensional Heisenberg antiferromagnet. The first such study for a thermal critical point with continuous symmetry. We uncover two fundamental results. First, the negativity exhibits a pure area law at the critical point, with the subleading constant term vanishing within statistical uncertainty. This demonstrates that thermal fluctuations completely destroy the long-range entanglement present at zero temperature. The divergent classical correlation length leaves no imprint on quantum entanglement itself. Second, despite this absence of singular behavior in the negativity, its temperature derivative follows the exact scaling of the specific heat, yielding critical exponents -α/ν=0.190(1) and 1/ν=1.350(5) in precise agreement with the O(3) universality class. Our work establishes that while quantum entanglement is blind to thermal criticality, its thermodynamic derivatives encode the full universal scaling, revealing an unexpected connection between entanglement and classical phase transitions. Furthermore, this also provides further evidence that Rényi negativity can still effectively shield classical correlations in systems with continuous symmetry.

DOI
10.1103/j3g1-wrpl

Related papers

Entanglement Renyi Negativity across a Finite Temperature Transition: A Monte Carlo study

Kai-Hsin Wu, Tsung-Cheng Lu, Chia-Min Chung +2 more

Quantum entanglement is fragile to thermal fluctuations, which raises the question whether finite temperature phase transitions support long-range entanglement similar to their zero temperature counterparts. Here we use quantum Monte Carlo simulations to study the third Renyi negativity, a generalization of entanglement negativity, as a proxy of mixed-state entanglement in the 2D transverse field Ising model across its finite temperature phase transition. We find that the area-law coefficient of the Renyi negativity is singular across the transition, while its subleading constant is zero within the statistical error. This indicates that the entanglement is short-range at the critical point despite a divergent correlation length. Renyi negativity in several exactly solvable models also shows qualitative similarities to that in the 2D transverse field Ising model.

arXiv:1912.03313•Physical Review Letters•Sep 30, 2020•63 citations

Entanglement and classical fluctuations at finite-temperature critical points

Sascha Wald, Raúl Arias, Vincenzo Alba

Abstract We investigate several entanglement-related quantities at finite-temperature criticality in the three-dimensional quantum spherical model, both as a function of temperature T and of the quantum parameter g , which measures the strength of quantum fluctuations. While the von Neumann and the Rényi entropies exhibit a volume-law for any g and T , the mutual information obeys an area law. The prefactors of the volume-law and of the area-law are regular across the transition, reflecting that universal singular terms vanish at the transition. This implies that the mutual information is dominated by nonuniversal contributions. This hampers its use as a witness of criticality, at least in the spherical model. We also study the logarithmic negativity. For any value of g , T , the negativity exhibits an area-law. The negativity vanishes deep in the paramagnetic phase, it is larger at small temperature, and it decreases upon increasing the temperature. For any g , it exhibits the so-called sudden death, i.e. it is exactly zero for large enough T . The vanishing of the negativity defines a ‘death line’, which we characterise analytically at small g . Importantly, for any finite T the area-law prefactor is regular across the transition, whereas it develops a cusp-like singularity in the limit . Finally, we consider the single-particle entanglement and negativity spectra. The vast majority of the levels are regular across the transition. Only the larger ones exhibit singularities. These are related to the presence of a zero mode, which reflects the symmetry breaking. This implies the presence of sub-leading singular terms in the entanglement entropies. Interestingly, since the larger levels do not contribute to the negativity, sub-leading singular corrections are expected to be suppressed for the negativity.

arXiv:1911.02575•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Mar 1, 2020•39 citations

Finite-Size Scaling Theory of Rényi Thermal Entropy for Second-Order, First-Order, and Weakly First-Order Quantum Phase Transitions

Zhe Wang, Yanzhang Zhu, Chunhao Guo +4 more

Establishing the nature of a quantum phase transition in finite-size simulations—whether continuous, first order, or weakly first order—is a fundamental challenge in quantum many-body computation. The weakly first-order transition is particularly elusive: its anomalously large correlation length invariably mimics a continuous critical point at accessible system sizes, and no unified finite-size scaling theory has existed to distinguish these scenarios under realistic computational constraints. In this work, we address this problem by introducing a finite-size scaling framework based on the Rényi thermal entropy (RTE) and its derivative (DRTE). We derive the finite-size scaling forms for the RTE and DRTE at continuous, first-order, and weakly first-order quantum phase transitions and show that the DRTE isolates the universal contribution of the free energy and strengthens the characteristics of various phase transitions in finite sizes. Using quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we demonstrate accurate data collapse and extraction of critical exponents at ( 2 + 1 )-dimensional O ( N ) critical points. Most importantly, the DRTE provides a definitive signature of weakly first-order transitions at visitable sizes—a zero crossing and a double-peak structure—which we observe in the debated deconfined quantum criticality candidates such as the J − Q and SU(8) J 1 − J 2 models. Our approach offers a general, order-parameter-agnostic, and numerically efficient diagnostic tool, resolving long-standing ambiguities between continuous and weakly first-order scenarios in the finite-size simulations.

arXiv:2506.16111•Physical Review X•Oct 6, 2026•4 citations

Scaling of Entanglement Entropy at Deconfined Quantum Criticality

Jiarui Zhao, Yan-Cheng Wang, Zheng Yan +2 more

We develop a nonequilibrium increment method to compute the Rényi entanglement entropy and investigate its scaling behavior at the deconfined critical (DQC) point via large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. To benchmark the method, we first show that, at a conformally invariant critical point of O(3) transition, the entanglement entropy exhibits universal scaling behavior of area law with logarithmic corner corrections, and the obtained correction exponent represents the current central charge of the critical theory. Then we move on to the deconfined quantum critical point, where we still observe similar scaling behavior, but with a very different exponent. Namely, the corner correction exponent is found to be negative. Such a negative exponent is in sharp contrast with the positivity condition of the Rényi entanglement entropy, which holds for unitary conformal field theories (CFTs). Our results unambiguously reveal fundamental differences between DQC and quantum critical points described by unitary CFTs.

arXiv:2107.06305•Physical Review Letters•Jan 3, 2022•102 citations

Critical Temperature and the Transition from Quantum to Classical Order Parameter Fluctuations in the Three-Dimensional Heisenberg Antiferromagnet

Anders W. Sandvik

We present results of extensive quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the three-dimensional $S\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}1/2$ Heisenberg antiferromagnet. Finite-size scaling of the spin stiffness and the sublattice magnetization gives the critical temperature ${T}_{\mathrm{c}}/J\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}0.946\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.001$. The critical behavior is consistent with the classical 3D Heisenberg universality class, as expected. We discuss the general nature of the transition from quantum mechanical to classical (thermal) order parameter fluctuations at a continuous ${T}_{\mathrm{c}}>0$ phase transition.

arXiv:cond-mat/9804234•Physical Review Letters•Jun 8, 1998•112 citations

Criticality on Rényi Defects at (2+1)$D$ O(3) Quantum Critical Points

Yanzhang Zhu, Zhe Wang, Meng Cheng +1 more

At a quantum critical point, the universal scaling behavior of Rényi entanglement entropy is controlled by the universality class of the codimension-two Rényi (or conical) defects in the infrared theory. In this work we perform a systematic study of critical correlations along Rényi defect lines in (2+1)$D$ quantum spin models realizing quantum phase transitions described by the O(3) Wilson-Fisher universality class, using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We present numerical evidence that, for a fixed Rényi index $n$, there exist multiple Rényi defect universality classes, with distinct critical exponents for the O(3) order parameter on the defect. These universality classes are realized by choosing microscopically different entanglement cuts in lattice models, which we classify as ordinary, special and extraordinary according to their relation to surface criticality. For the extraordinary entanglement cut, we further find evidence for a phase transition on the defect as a function of the Rényi index. Our results highlight the key role of defect universality classes in determining the universal scaling of Rényi entropy, and provide a framework for understanding the previously observed dependence of Rényi entropy scaling on microscopic lattice details.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2605.00104•Physical Review Letters•May 4, 2026•5 citations
The fate of quantum entanglement at finite-temperature phase transitions remains an open question, particularly for continuous symmetry breaking where zero-temperature Goldstone modes generate long-range correlations. Using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we investigate the third Rényi negativity across the O(3) transition in the three-dimensional Heisenberg antiferromagnet. The first such study for a thermal critical point with continuous symmetry. We uncover two fundamental results. First, the negativity exhibits a pure area law at the critical point, with the subleading constant term vanishing within statistical uncertainty. This demonstrates that thermal fluctuations completely destroy the long-range entanglement present at zero temperature. The divergent classical correlation length leaves no imprint on quantum entanglement itself. Second, despite this absence of singular behavior in the negativity, its temperature derivative follows the exact scaling of the specific heat, yielding critical exponents -α/ν=0.190(1) and 1/ν=1.350(5) in precise agreement with the O(3) universality class. Our work establishes that while quantum entanglement is blind to thermal criticality, its thermodynamic derivatives encode the full universal scaling, revealing an unexpected connection between entanglement and classical phase transitions. Furthermore, this also provides further evidence that Rényi negativity can still effectively shield classical correlations in systems with continuous symmetry.
Quantum entanglement is fragile to thermal fluctuations, which raises the question whether finite temperature phase transitions support long-range entanglement similar to their zero temperature counterparts. Here we use quantum Monte Carlo simulations to study the third Renyi negativity, a generalization of entanglement negativity, as a proxy of mixed-state entanglement in the 2D transverse field Ising model across its finite temperature phase transition. We find that the area-law coefficient of the Renyi negativity is singular across the transition, while its subleading constant is zero within the statistical error. This indicates that the entanglement is short-range at the critical point despite a divergent correlation length. Renyi negativity in several exactly solvable models also shows qualitative similarities to that in the 2D transverse field Ising model.
Abstract We investigate several entanglement-related quantities at finite-temperature criticality in the three-dimensional quantum spherical model, both as a function of temperature T and of the quantum parameter g , which measures the strength of quantum fluctuations. While the von Neumann and the Rényi entropies exhibit a volume-law for any g and T , the mutual information obeys an area law. The prefactors of the volume-law and of the area-law are regular across the transition, reflecting that universal singular terms vanish at the transition. This implies that the mutual information is dominated by nonuniversal contributions. This hampers its use as a witness of criticality, at least in the spherical model. We also study the logarithmic negativity. For any value of g , T , the negativity exhibits an area-law. The negativity vanishes deep in the paramagnetic phase, it is larger at small temperature, and it decreases upon increasing the temperature. For any g , it exhibits the so-called sudden death, i.e. it is exactly zero for large enough T . The vanishing of the negativity defines a ‘death line’, which we characterise analytically at small g . Importantly, for any finite T the area-law prefactor is regular across the transition, whereas it develops a cusp-like singularity in the limit . Finally, we consider the single-particle entanglement and negativity spectra. The vast majority of the levels are regular across the transition. Only the larger ones exhibit singularities. These are related to the presence of a zero mode, which reflects the symmetry breaking. This implies the presence of sub-leading singular terms in the entanglement entropies. Interestingly, since the larger levels do not contribute to the negativity, sub-leading singular corrections are expected to be suppressed for the negativity.
Establishing the nature of a quantum phase transition in finite-size simulations—whether continuous, first order, or weakly first order—is a fundamental challenge in quantum many-body computation. The weakly first-order transition is particularly elusive: its anomalously large correlation length invariably mimics a continuous critical point at accessible system sizes, and no unified finite-size scaling theory has existed to distinguish these scenarios under realistic computational constraints. In this work, we address this problem by introducing a finite-size scaling framework based on the Rényi thermal entropy (RTE) and its derivative (DRTE). We derive the finite-size scaling forms for the RTE and DRTE at continuous, first-order, and weakly first-order quantum phase transitions and show that the DRTE isolates the universal contribution of the free energy and strengthens the characteristics of various phase transitions in finite sizes. Using quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we demonstrate accurate data collapse and extraction of critical exponents at ( 2 + 1 )-dimensional O ( N ) critical points. Most importantly, the DRTE provides a definitive signature of weakly first-order transitions at visitable sizes—a zero crossing and a double-peak structure—which we observe in the debated deconfined quantum criticality candidates such as the J − Q and SU(8) J 1 − J 2 models. Our approach offers a general, order-parameter-agnostic, and numerically efficient diagnostic tool, resolving long-standing ambiguities between continuous and weakly first-order scenarios in the finite-size simulations.
We develop a nonequilibrium increment method to compute the Rényi entanglement entropy and investigate its scaling behavior at the deconfined critical (DQC) point via large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. To benchmark the method, we first show that, at a conformally invariant critical point of O(3) transition, the entanglement entropy exhibits universal scaling behavior of area law with logarithmic corner corrections, and the obtained correction exponent represents the current central charge of the critical theory. Then we move on to the deconfined quantum critical point, where we still observe similar scaling behavior, but with a very different exponent. Namely, the corner correction exponent is found to be negative. Such a negative exponent is in sharp contrast with the positivity condition of the Rényi entanglement entropy, which holds for unitary conformal field theories (CFTs). Our results unambiguously reveal fundamental differences between DQC and quantum critical points described by unitary CFTs.
We present results of extensive quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the three-dimensional S=1/2S\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}1/2S=1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet. Finite-size scaling of the spin stiffness and the sublattice magnetization gives the critical temperature ${T}_{\mathrm{c}}/J\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}0.946\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.001$. The critical behavior is consistent with the classical 3D Heisenberg universality class, as expected. We discuss the general nature of the transition from quantum mechanical to classical (thermal) order parameter fluctuations at a continuous Tc>0{T}_{\mathrm{c}}>0Tc​>0 phase transition.
Criticality on Rényi Defects at (2+1)DDD O(3) Quantum Critical Points
At a quantum critical point, the universal scaling behavior of Rényi entanglement entropy is controlled by the universality class of the codimension-two Rényi (or conical) defects in the infrared theory. In this work we perform a systematic study of critical correlations along Rényi defect lines in (2+1)DDD quantum spin models realizing quantum phase transitions described by the O(3) Wilson-Fisher universality class, using large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We present numerical evidence that, for a fixed Rényi index nnn, there exist multiple Rényi defect universality classes, with distinct critical exponents for the O(3) order parameter on the defect. These universality classes are realized by choosing microscopically different entanglement cuts in lattice models, which we classify as ordinary, special and extraordinary according to their relation to surface criticality. For the extraordinary entanglement cut, we further find evidence for a phase transition on the defect as a function of the Rényi index. Our results highlight the key role of defect universality classes in determining the universal scaling of Rényi entropy, and provide a framework for understanding the previously observed dependence of Rényi entropy scaling on microscopic lattice details.