The Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is widely regarded as a promising algorithm for calculating ground states of quantum systems that are intractable for classical computers. This promise is typically motivated by the hope of mitigating the exponential growth of Hilbert space with system size. Here we scrutinize how the computational cost of adaptive VQE scales with the size of the target system. We demonstrate that the Rényi entropy derived from classical simulations predicts the required number of adaptive iterations of VQE with high accuracy ($R^2 \approx 0.99$). We validate this on a benchmarking set of more than 20 different molecules with active spaces ranging from four to ten orbitals. For these molecules, we find an exponential scaling of the number of adaptive iterations, and in turn, of the circuit depth with the system size. We therefore conclude that it is unlikely that VQE in its current form is able to simulate large molecular systems with high fidelity without exponential resource requirements.
The Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) is widely regarded as a promising algorithm for calculating ground states of quantum systems that are intractable for classical computers. This promise is typically motivated by the hope of mitigating the exponential growth of Hilbert space with system size. Here we scrutinize how the computational cost of adaptive VQE scales with the size of the target system. We demonstrate that the Rényi entropy derived from classical simulations predicts the required number of adaptive iterations of VQE with high accuracy (R2≈0.99). We validate this on a benchmarking set of more than 20 different molecules with active spaces ranging from four to ten orbitals. For these molecules, we find an exponential scaling of the number of adaptive iterations, and in turn, of the circuit depth with the system size. We therefore conclude that it is unlikely that VQE in its current form is able to simulate large molecular systems with high fidelity without exponential resource requirements.
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm designed for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware to estimate eigenvalues of many-body Hamiltonians. Unlike fully quantum approaches such as quantum phase estimation (QPE), VQE trades deep coherent circuits for repeated state preparation, measurement, and classical optimization, making it more compatible with limited qubit counts and finite coherence times. Recent developments have focused on reducing quantum resource requirements while retaining chemically meaningful wavefunction structure. In this paper, we examine recent progress in VQE methods for molecular electronic structure with an emphasis on three themes: (i) strategies for circuit and ansatz complexity reduction, including adaptive and selectively screened approaches, (ii) chemically motivated workflows that combine VQE with orbital optimization, fragmentation, and localized active-space ideas to better address strong correlation, and (iii) extensions of VQE to excited-state calculations. Throughout, we emphasize the tradeoffs among parameter count, gate depth, symmetry preservation, measurement overhead, and classical preprocessing, and discuss where these approaches may become most useful for chemically challenging active spaces. We also highlight benchmarking considerations for assessing both accuracy and resource requirements, and conclude with a perspective on regimes in which VQE may offer the greatest long-term value, particularly multireference active spaces and low-lying excited-state manifolds.
Quantum chemistry is envisioned as an early and disruptive application for quantum computers. Yet, closer scrutiny of the proposed algorithms shows that there are considerable difficulties along the way. Here, we propose two criteria for evaluating two leading quantum approaches for finding the ground state of molecules. The first criterion applies to the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) algorithm. It sets an upper bound to the level of imprecision/decoherence that can be tolerated in quantum hardware as a function of the targeted precision, the number of gates and the typical energy contribution from states populated by decoherence processes. We find that decoherence is highly detrimental to the accuracy of VQE and performing relevant chemistry calculations would require performances that are expected for fault-tolerant quantum computers, not mere noisy hardware, even with advanced error mitigation techniques. Physically, the sensitivity of VQE to decoherence originates from the fact that, in VQE, the spectrum of the studied molecule has no correlation with the spectrum of the quantum hardware used to perform the computation. The second criterion applies to the quantum phase estimation (QPE) algorithm, which is often presented as the go-to replacement of VQE upon availability of (noiseless) fault-tolerant quantum computers. QPE requires an input state with a large enough overlap with the sought-after ground state. We provide a criterion to estimate quantitatively this overlap based on the energy and the energy variance of said input state. Using input states from a variety of state-of-the-art classical methods, we show that the scaling of this overlap with system size does display the standard orthogonality catastrophe, namely an exponential suppression with system size. This in turns leads to an exponentially reduced QPE success probability.
Electronic structure calculations become computationally expensive on classical computers as electron correlation increases. Quantum computing offers a promising alternative through hybrid quantum-classical Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) on Noisy-Intermediate Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices. The choice of ansatz plays a pivotal role in the performance and scalability of the VQE, yet selecting an optimal ansatz remains challenging. Existing approaches including chemically inspired ansatz, adaptive schemes and Hardware Efficient Ansätze (HEA) lack a unified comparison. This gap makes the scalability and trade-offs of each method unclear for varying molecular sizes. This work presents a systematic benchmarking study comparing Unitary Couples Cluster Singles and Doubles Ansatz (UCCSD), fermionic ADAPT-VQE, BasicPCA HEA, and Excitation Preserving HEA across molecules of varying size like H2, LiH, N2. We evaluate trade-offs among circuit depth, parameter count, ground-state energy error, and NISQ feasibility. ADAPT-VQE achieves accuracy comparable to UCCSD with lower resource overhead, but becomes impractical for modest system sizes ($\sim$10 electrons) due to increasing circuit complexity. In contrast, HEA reduces hardware costs but requires more parameters and sacrifices accuracy, with performance strongly dependent on molecular size. The Excitation Preserving ansatz remains below chemical accuracy for H2 and LiH, and fails for N2, underscoring the need to balance expressibility and trainability. Overall, these results highlight key trade-offs between accuracy and resource efficiency across VQE ansätze, emphasizing the need to improve ADAPT-VQE scalability and HEA accuracy while addressing optimization challenges for near-term quantum hardware.
Quantum chemistry is one of the most promising applications of quantum computers in the near future. For noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, the quantum-classical hybrid framework based on the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) has become the method of choice. In the literature, there are many different variants of VQE, but it is not known which one is optimal for a given molecule. For this purpose, we perform a thorough benchmarking on more than ten different kinds of VQE ansatzes (in systems up to 30 qubits), based on their performance on the energy accuracy, runtime until convergence, and number of parameters. Our results show that the ADAPT ansatz can be used to obtain more accurate energy for small systems (below 14 qubits), but it costs much more computational resources. For larger molecules, UCCSD0 has better performance. However, all the tested ansatzes can hardly reach chemical accuracy at stretched bond lengths. Our results were obtained using MindSpore Quantum, where the codes and the benchmarking toolkit are publicly available at Gitee.
Abstract Variational quantum eigensolvers (VQEs) are leading candidates to demonstrate near-term quantum advantage. Here, we conduct density-matrix simulations of leading gate-based VQEs for a range of molecules. We numerically quantify their level of tolerable depolarizing gate-errors. We find that: (i) The best-performing VQEs require gate-error probabilities between 10−6 and 10−4 (10−4 and 10−2 with error mitigation) to predict, within chemical accuracy, ground-state energies of small molecules with 4 − 14 orbitals. (ii) ADAPT-VQEs that construct ansatz circuits iteratively outperform fixed-circuit VQEs. (iii) ADAPT-VQEs perform better with circuits constructed from gate-efficient rather than physically-motivated elements. (iv) The maximally-allowed gate-error probability, pc, for any VQE to achieve chemical accuracy decreases with the number NII of noisy two-qubit gates as pc∼∝NII−1 p c ∝ ~ N II − 1 . Additionally, pc decreases with system size, even with error mitigation, implying that larger molecules require even lower gate-errors. Thus, quantum advantage via gate-based VQEs is unlikely unless gate-error probabilities are decreased by orders of magnitude.
Current quantum computers are limited in the number of qubits and coherence time, constraining the algorithms executable with sufficient fidelity. The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is an algorithm to find an approximate ground state of a quantum system and is expected to work on even such a device. The deep VQE [K. Fujii, et al., arXiv:2007.10917] is an extension of the original VQE algorithm, which takes a divide-and-conquer approach to relax the hardware requirement. While the deep VQE is successfully applied for spin models and periodic material, its validity on a molecule, where the Hamiltonian is highly nonlocal in the qubit basis, is still unexplored. Here, we discuss the performance of the deep VQE algorithm applied to quantum chemistry problems. Specifically, we examine different subspace-forming methods and compare their accuracy and complexity on a 10 H-atom treelike molecule as well as a 13 H-atom version. Additionally, we examine the performance on the natural occurring molecule retinal. This work also proposes multiple methods to lower the number of qubits required to calculate the ground state of a molecule. We find that the deep VQE can simulate the electron-correlation energy of the ground state to an error of below 1%, thus helping us to reach chemical accuracy in some cases. The accuracy differences and qubits' reduction highlights the basis creation method's impact on the deep VQE.