Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.04556

Feedback-Induced Advantage in Quantum Clockworks

Jakob Miller, Paul Erker

quant-phSubmitted Mar 4, 2026• Announced Mar 6, 2026• 1 citation
v1 · Mar 4, 2026v2 · Sep 30, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Atomic frequency standards have achieved steadily increasing precision over the past seventy years, enabled in part by feedback mechanisms that stabilise their output. In parallel, the timekeeping capabilities of quantum systems have been explored within the recently developed ticking-clock framework, which models clocks as dynamical systems producing a stochastic sequence of ticks. However, a theoretical description that unifies these perspectives and incorporates feedback into autonomous quantum clocks has been lacking. We introduce a framework for feedback-controlled clockworks in which classical information extracted from the tick sequence is used to influence the subsequent dynamics of the clock. We show that such feedback preserves the core structural features of self-timing and clockwork independence that characterise autonomous ticking clocks. We further identify the signal-to-noise ratio $\mathfrak{S}$ as the fundamental figure of merit for assessing the performance of feedback-controlled clocks. Applying our framework to two representative architectures, we prove that classical clockworks cannot surpass the optimal signal-to-noise ratio achievable without feedback. In contrast, for quantum clockworks we present numerical evidence that feedback can provide a genuine performance enhancement, improving the maximal attainable signal-to-noise ratio. These results establish feedback as a potentially essential ingredient in pushing the fundamental limits of timekeeping in the quantum regime.

Comments
25 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Exponential gain in clock precision using quantum correlated ticks

Florian Meier, Yuri Minoguchi, Gianmichele Blasi +2 more

Creating precise timing devices at ultra-short time scales is not just an important technological challenge, but confronts us with foundational questions about timekeeping's ultimate precision limits. Research on clocks has either focused on long-term stability using an oscillator stabilized by a level transition, limiting precision at short timescales, or on making individual stochastic ticks as precise as possible. Here, we prove the viability of a conceptually different avenue: the autonomous self-correction of consecutive ticks by quantum correlations. This provides a new paradigm that integrates the advantages and insights from quantum transport theory to operate clocks at ultra-short timescales. We fully solve a model of coupled quantum systems and show how the emergent Pauli exclusion principle correlates the clock at the quantum level yielding an exponential advantage in precision. We furthermore demonstrate through simulations with realistic imperfections that this remarkable gain in precision remains stable providing a roadmap for implementation with contemporary quantum technologies.

quant-pharXiv:2601.10785•Physical Review X•Jan 19, 2026•5 citations

Performance of stochastic clocks in the Alternate Ticks Game

Sandra Stupar, Christian Klumpp, Renato Renner +1 more

In standard quantum theory, time is not an observable. It enters as a parameter in the Schrödinger equation, but there is no measurement operator associated to it. Nevertheless, one may take an operational viewpoint and regard time as the information one can read from clocks. The Alternate Ticks Game, introduced in arXiv:1506.01373, is a completely operational means to quantify the accuracy of time scales generated by clocks. The idea is to count the number of ticks that two copies of a clock can produce until they run out of synchronisation. Here we investigate the performance of stochastic clocks in this game. These are clocks which are classical in the sense that they do not exploit quantum coherence. Our results support earlier conjectures that their accuracy grows linearly in the size of the clockwork, measured in terms of the dimension of the associated Hilbert space. In particular, we derive explicit bounds on the accuracy of a natural class of stochastic clocks, the stochastic ladder clocks.

arXiv:1806.08812•Jun 22, 2018•8 citations

Quantum Speed Limit and Quantum Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation under Feedback Control

Yunoki, Hayato, Yoshihiko Hasegawa

Fundamental trade-off relations, such as quantum speed limit and quantum thermodynamic uncertainty relation, describe the performance limits of quantum systems by imposing that improvements in speed or precision necessitate a substantial thermodynamic cost. Quantum feedback control, which is a pivotal technique for manipulating quantum dynamics based on measurement outcomes, is widely employed to enhance system performance. Nevertheless, its impact on these fundamental bounds remains an open question. This work elucidates this influence by establishing a theoretical framework for quantum speed limit and quantum thermodynamic uncertainty relation under a paradigmatic Markovian feedback protocol. We derive general inequalities incorporating the effects of feedback control on speed and precision. Through numerical simulations on a simple two-level system and quantum error correction, a key application of quantum feedback control, we validate our derived bounds and demonstrate that feedback control can indeed improve both speed and precision beyond those achievable limits in uncontrolled systems. Next, to elucidate the mechanism behind these improvements and the qualitative difference from uncontrolled dynamics, we analyze the governing thermodynamic costs, which are the fundamental quantities that constrain speed and precision, within a simple model. Our analysis reveals that feedback can improve the time scaling order of these costs. This modification of the dynamical scaling is the origin of the qualitative performance gain, signifying that the feedback-induced improvements of performance are not merely quantitative but represent a fundamental shift. Consequently, our work offers a comprehensive understanding of how feedback control impacts the fundamental limits on the speed and precision of quantum systems, providing crucial insights for designing high-performance quantum technologies.

arXiv:2502.09081•Feb 13, 2025•12 citations

Ticking-clock performance enhanced by nonclassical temporal correlations

Costantino Budroni, Giuseppe Vitagliano, Mischa P. Woods

We investigate the role of nonclassical temporal correlations in enhancing the performance of ticking clocks in a discrete-time scenario. We show that the problem of optimal models for ticking clocks is related to the violation of Leggett-Garg-type temporal inequalities formulated in terms of, possibly invasive, sequential measurements, but on a system with a bounded memory capacity. Ticking clocks inspire the derivation of a family of temporal inequalities showing a gap between classical and quantum correlations, despite involving no input. We show that quantum ticking-clock models achieving accuracy beyond the classical bound are also those violating Leggett-Garg-type temporal inequalities for finite sequences and we investigate their continuous-time limit. Interestingly, we show that optimal classical clock models in the discrete-time scenario do not have a well-defined continuous-time limit, a feature that is absent in quantum models.

arXiv:2005.04241•Physical Review Research•Jul 15, 2021•14 citations

Using coherent feedback for a periodic clock

Stefan Zeppetzauer, Leonardo Assis Morais, Xin He +2 more

A driven linear oscillator and a feedback mechanism are two necessary elements of any classical periodic clock. Here, we introduce a fully quantum clock using a driven oscillator in the quantum regime and coherent quantum feedback. We show that if we treat the model semiclassically, this system supports limit cycles, or self-sustained oscillations, as needed for a periodic clock. We then analyze the noise of the system quantum mechanically and prove that the accuracy of this clock is higher compared with the clock implemented with the classical measurement feedback. We experimentally implement the model using two superconducting cavities with incorporated Josephson junctions and microwave circulators for the realization of the quantum feedback. We confirm the appearance of the limit cycle and study the clock accuracy both in frequency and time domains. Under specific conditions of noisy driving, we observe that the clock oscillations are more coherent than the drive, pointing towards the implementation of a quantum autonomous clock.

arXiv:2410.22926•Physical Review Applied•Sep 16, 2025•2 citations

A quantum ticking self-oscillator using delayed feedback

Yanan Liu, William J. Munro, Jason Twamley

Abstract Self-sustained oscillators (SSOs) is a commonly used method to generate classical clock signals and SSOs using delayed feedback have been developed commercially which possess ultra-low phase noise and drift. Research into the development of quantum self-oscillation, where one can also have a periodic and regular output tick, that can be used to control quantum and classical devices has received much interest and quantum SSOs so far studied suffer from phase diffusion which leads to the smearing out of the quantum oscillator over the entire limit cycle in phase space seriously degrading the system’s ability to perform as a self-oscillation. In this paper, we explore quantum versions of time-delayed SSOs, which has the potentials to develop a ticking quantum clock. We first design a linear quantum SSO which exhibits perfect oscillation without phase diffusion. We then explore a nonlinear delayed quantum SSO but find it exhibits dephasing similar to previously studied non-delayed systems.

arXiv:2307.14567•New Journal of Physics•Nov 29, 2023•1 citation
Atomic frequency standards have achieved steadily increasing precision over the past seventy years, enabled in part by feedback mechanisms that stabilise their output. In parallel, the timekeeping capabilities of quantum systems have been explored within the recently developed ticking-clock framework, which models clocks as dynamical systems producing a stochastic sequence of ticks. However, a theoretical description that unifies these perspectives and incorporates feedback into autonomous quantum clocks has been lacking. We introduce a framework for feedback-controlled clockworks in which classical information extracted from the tick sequence is used to influence the subsequent dynamics of the clock. We show that such feedback preserves the core structural features of self-timing and clockwork independence that characterise autonomous ticking clocks. We further identify the signal-to-noise ratio S\mathfrak{S}S as the fundamental figure of merit for assessing the performance of feedback-controlled clocks. Applying our framework to two representative architectures, we prove that classical clockworks cannot surpass the optimal signal-to-noise ratio achievable without feedback. In contrast, for quantum clockworks we present numerical evidence that feedback can provide a genuine performance enhancement, improving the maximal attainable signal-to-noise ratio. These results establish feedback as a potentially essential ingredient in pushing the fundamental limits of timekeeping in the quantum regime.
Creating precise timing devices at ultra-short time scales is not just an important technological challenge, but confronts us with foundational questions about timekeeping's ultimate precision limits. Research on clocks has either focused on long-term stability using an oscillator stabilized by a level transition, limiting precision at short timescales, or on making individual stochastic ticks as precise as possible. Here, we prove the viability of a conceptually different avenue: the autonomous self-correction of consecutive ticks by quantum correlations. This provides a new paradigm that integrates the advantages and insights from quantum transport theory to operate clocks at ultra-short timescales. We fully solve a model of coupled quantum systems and show how the emergent Pauli exclusion principle correlates the clock at the quantum level yielding an exponential advantage in precision. We furthermore demonstrate through simulations with realistic imperfections that this remarkable gain in precision remains stable providing a roadmap for implementation with contemporary quantum technologies.
In standard quantum theory, time is not an observable. It enters as a parameter in the Schrödinger equation, but there is no measurement operator associated to it. Nevertheless, one may take an operational viewpoint and regard time as the information one can read from clocks. The Alternate Ticks Game, introduced in arXiv:1506.01373, is a completely operational means to quantify the accuracy of time scales generated by clocks. The idea is to count the number of ticks that two copies of a clock can produce until they run out of synchronisation. Here we investigate the performance of stochastic clocks in this game. These are clocks which are classical in the sense that they do not exploit quantum coherence. Our results support earlier conjectures that their accuracy grows linearly in the size of the clockwork, measured in terms of the dimension of the associated Hilbert space. In particular, we derive explicit bounds on the accuracy of a natural class of stochastic clocks, the stochastic ladder clocks.
Fundamental trade-off relations, such as quantum speed limit and quantum thermodynamic uncertainty relation, describe the performance limits of quantum systems by imposing that improvements in speed or precision necessitate a substantial thermodynamic cost. Quantum feedback control, which is a pivotal technique for manipulating quantum dynamics based on measurement outcomes, is widely employed to enhance system performance. Nevertheless, its impact on these fundamental bounds remains an open question. This work elucidates this influence by establishing a theoretical framework for quantum speed limit and quantum thermodynamic uncertainty relation under a paradigmatic Markovian feedback protocol. We derive general inequalities incorporating the effects of feedback control on speed and precision. Through numerical simulations on a simple two-level system and quantum error correction, a key application of quantum feedback control, we validate our derived bounds and demonstrate that feedback control can indeed improve both speed and precision beyond those achievable limits in uncontrolled systems. Next, to elucidate the mechanism behind these improvements and the qualitative difference from uncontrolled dynamics, we analyze the governing thermodynamic costs, which are the fundamental quantities that constrain speed and precision, within a simple model. Our analysis reveals that feedback can improve the time scaling order of these costs. This modification of the dynamical scaling is the origin of the qualitative performance gain, signifying that the feedback-induced improvements of performance are not merely quantitative but represent a fundamental shift. Consequently, our work offers a comprehensive understanding of how feedback control impacts the fundamental limits on the speed and precision of quantum systems, providing crucial insights for designing high-performance quantum technologies.
We investigate the role of nonclassical temporal correlations in enhancing the performance of ticking clocks in a discrete-time scenario. We show that the problem of optimal models for ticking clocks is related to the violation of Leggett-Garg-type temporal inequalities formulated in terms of, possibly invasive, sequential measurements, but on a system with a bounded memory capacity. Ticking clocks inspire the derivation of a family of temporal inequalities showing a gap between classical and quantum correlations, despite involving no input. We show that quantum ticking-clock models achieving accuracy beyond the classical bound are also those violating Leggett-Garg-type temporal inequalities for finite sequences and we investigate their continuous-time limit. Interestingly, we show that optimal classical clock models in the discrete-time scenario do not have a well-defined continuous-time limit, a feature that is absent in quantum models.
A driven linear oscillator and a feedback mechanism are two necessary elements of any classical periodic clock. Here, we introduce a fully quantum clock using a driven oscillator in the quantum regime and coherent quantum feedback. We show that if we treat the model semiclassically, this system supports limit cycles, or self-sustained oscillations, as needed for a periodic clock. We then analyze the noise of the system quantum mechanically and prove that the accuracy of this clock is higher compared with the clock implemented with the classical measurement feedback. We experimentally implement the model using two superconducting cavities with incorporated Josephson junctions and microwave circulators for the realization of the quantum feedback. We confirm the appearance of the limit cycle and study the clock accuracy both in frequency and time domains. Under specific conditions of noisy driving, we observe that the clock oscillations are more coherent than the drive, pointing towards the implementation of a quantum autonomous clock.
Abstract Self-sustained oscillators (SSOs) is a commonly used method to generate classical clock signals and SSOs using delayed feedback have been developed commercially which possess ultra-low phase noise and drift. Research into the development of quantum self-oscillation, where one can also have a periodic and regular output tick, that can be used to control quantum and classical devices has received much interest and quantum SSOs so far studied suffer from phase diffusion which leads to the smearing out of the quantum oscillator over the entire limit cycle in phase space seriously degrading the system’s ability to perform as a self-oscillation. In this paper, we explore quantum versions of time-delayed SSOs, which has the potentials to develop a ticking quantum clock. We first design a linear quantum SSO which exhibits perfect oscillation without phase diffusion. We then explore a nonlinear delayed quantum SSO but find it exhibits dephasing similar to previously studied non-delayed systems.