We identify an operational principle that singles out Projection-Valued Measures (PVMs) among general Positive Operator-Valued Measures (POVMs), bridging the modern quantum measurement theory and the traditional formulation based on projective measurements of physical observables. We reformulate Ozawa's intersubjectivity condition, which requires inter-observer agreement of the measurement outcomes, in a quantitative manner within the framework of generalized probabilistic theories. We prove that (i) a POVM is a PVM if and only if its every coarse-graining is intersubjective, and (ii) a system is classical if and only if intersubjectivity is preserved under any coarse-graining, establishing a complete characterization of the physical observables and the classical theory. Furthermore, measurements with intersubjectivity are sufficiently rich for the informational tasks of state tomography and state discrimination, testifying to its operational significance in quantum and beyond information processing.
We identify an operational principle that singles out Projection-Valued Measures (PVMs) among general Positive Operator-Valued Measures (POVMs), bridging the modern quantum measurement theory and the traditional formulation based on projective measurements of physical observables. We reformulate Ozawa's intersubjectivity condition, which requires inter-observer agreement of the measurement outcomes, in a quantitative manner within the framework of generalized probabilistic theories. We prove that (i) a POVM is a PVM if and only if its every coarse-graining is intersubjective, and (ii) a system is classical if and only if intersubjectivity is preserved under any coarse-graining, establishing a complete characterization of the physical observables and the classical theory. Furthermore, measurements with intersubjectivity are sufficiently rich for the informational tasks of state tomography and state discrimination, testifying to its operational significance in quantum and beyond information processing.
In the heart of every physical theory lies measurement theory. While classical measurements are passive probes, QMs can be viewed as active physical processes that shape the available information. Depending on the measurement type, different aspects of the information about a system are retrieved. All possible measurements in quantum physics are described by mathematical objects called Positive Operator-Valued Measures (POVMs). The most familiar standard measurements are called Projective-Valued Measures (PVMs) and make up a subset of POVMs. The complementary subset of POVMs is non-projective. However, some non-projective POVMs can be expressed as a probabilistic mixture of PVMs. Such POVMs are called projectively simulable, while non-simulable POVMs are genuinely non-projective. These can be made projectively simulable by adding noise to the measurements. If a genuinely non-projective POVM requires a large amount of noise before it becomes projectively simulable, it is more non-projective than a POVM that requires less noise. Hence, the degree of non-projectiveness is determined by the required noise strength. The act of measuring a quantum system changes the quantum state. While quantum measurements only take into account the readable classical output value, quantum instruments account for both the classical outcome and the post-measurement state. Hence, instruments are associated with measurements, and in an analogous way, projective and projectively simulable instruments can be defined. For many purposes, non-projective POVMs are more useful than PVMs, and the more non-projective a POVM is, the greater the advantage of using them over PVMs. Therefore, the aim of the thesis is to investigate the genuinely non-projective POVMs. More precisely, the degree of non-projectiveness in qubit POVMs is studied. This is done by convex optimization, specifically by solving semidefinite programs. Furthermore, the thesis addresses the open problem of finding the most non-projective qubit quantum instrument by a witness-based see-saw algorithm.
QBism’s foundational statement that “the outcome of a measurement ofan observable is personal” is in direct contradiction with Ozawa’sIntersubjectivity Theorem (OIT). The latter (proven within the quantummeasurement theory) states that two observers, agents within the QBismterminology, performing joint measurements of the same observable A on asystem S in the state ψ should get the same outcome A = x. In Ozawa’s terminology,this outcome is intersubjective and it can’t be treated as personal.This is the strong objection to QBism which can’t survive without updatingits principles. The essential aspect in understanding of the OIT impact onQBism’s foundations takes the notion of quantum observable. We discussthe difference between the accurate, von Neumann, and inaccurate, noisy,quantum observables which are represented by the projection valued measures(PVMs) and positive operator valued measures (POVMs), respectively.Moreover, we discuss the OIT impact on the Copenhagen interpretation ofquantum mechanics.
Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) has recently been extended from projective measurements to a POVM-native formulation in which relational events are identified with effects. That extension removes an unnecessary restriction to sharp measurements and gives RQM a natural way to represent weak, noisy, and continuous outcomes. A further distinction is nevertheless required. For a fixed input state, a POVM effect determines the probability of a reported outcome, whereas a general quantum instrument also determines the conditional transformation associated with that outcome. These representational levels are not equivalent. The single-Kraus update displayed in the current POVM-native formulation describes efficient outcome operations, while a general instrument permits arbitrary completely positive trace-nonincreasing operations. More fundamentally, fixing an effect leaves the compatible conditional continuation maximally underdetermined: for a fixed input state and a nonzero effect with nonzero outcome probability, every posterior density operator can arise from a quantum operation with that same effect. A noisy-detector model exhibits the distinction without exotic assumptions, and Kraus fine-graining cannot remove it unless the refinement is physically recorded. The consequence is constructive rather than eliminative. Effects can continue to individuate local relational events, but temporal continuation requires instrument-level structure, while interperspectival sharedness requires a process-level warrant appropriate to the task by which facts are compared. The resulting hierarchy preserves the central motivation of POVM-native RQM while fixing the scope of what an effect can represent.
The projection postulate and spectral representation of observables remain central in quantum theory but describe only an idealized measurement limit. Realistic measurements may be inefficient, unsharp, weak, indirect, adaptive, destructive, or informationally incomplete. Positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs) provide the probability rule for processes, whereas quantum instruments specify state transformation. This review traces the hierarchy from von Neumann projective measurement to generalized measurement, emphasizing distinctions among effects, instruments, channels, and implementations. Naimark dilation realizes arbitrary POVMs through unitary coupling to an ancillary meter and projective readout. Stinespring dilation represents completely positive trace-preserving dynamics by unitary evolution on an enlarged system followed by partial trace. A qubit–ancilla interaction yields a partial-measurement instrument, its POVM effects, and its information–disturbance trade-off. It compares projective, generalized, and ancilla-mediated schemes; examines compatibility, instrument incompatibility, and disturbance; and surveys applications to state discrimination, tomography, control, and error correction. Recent developments in dynamic-circuit measurements and noisy-POVM compatibility are integrated with questions concerning measurement back-action and outcome definiteness. The review stresses that a POVM does not uniquely determine state update, dilation theorems establish realizability rather than unique mechanisms, and operational measurement theory does not settle definite outcomes, arguing quantum instruments provide a complete description of measurement.
Various forms of optimality for quantum observables described as normalized positive-operator-valued measures (POVMs) are studied in this paper. We give characterizations for observables that determine the values of the measured quantity with probabilistic certainty or a state of the system before or after the measurement. We investigate observables that are free from noise caused by classical post-processing, mixing, or pre-processing of quantum nature. Especially, a complete characterization of pre-processing and post-processing clean observables is given, and necessary and sufficient conditions are imposed on informationally complete POVMs within the set of pure states. We also discuss joint and sequential measurements of optimal quantum observables.
In many a traditional physics textbook, a quantum measurement is defined as a projective measurement represented by a Hermitian operator. In quantum information theory, however, the concept of a measurement is dealt with in complete generality and we are therefore forced to confront the more general notion of positive-operator valued measures (POVMs), which suffice to describe all measurements that can be implemented in quantum experiments. We study the (in)compatibility of such POVMs and show that quantum theory realizes all possible (in)compatibility relations among sets of POVMs. This is in contrast to the restricted case of projective measurements for which commutativity is essentially equivalent to compatibility. Our result therefore points out a fundamental feature with respect to the (in)compatibility of quantum observables that has no analog in the case of projective measurements.