Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.21350

The Inverse Born Rule Equivalence. On the Informational Limits of Real-Valued Amplitude Encodings and the Measurement of Quantum Advantage in Data Embeddings

Sebastian Zając, Jacob L. Cybulski, Bartosz Dziewit, Tomasz Kulpa

quant-phSubmitted Feb 24, 2026• Announced Feb 26, 2026• 0 citations• Revised Jun 14, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Feb 24, 2026v2 · Jun 14, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

When does quantum data encoding provide genuine quantum advantage, and when does it merely rephrase a classically solvable problem? We prove an \emph{Equivalence Theorem} demonstrating that any encoding mapping classical data to real-valued amplitudes, $\vertψ_c\rangle = \sum_i c_i \vert i\rangle$ with $c_i \in \mathbb{R}$ and $\sum_i c_i^2 = 1$, composed with a data-independent parameterised unitary and computational-basis measurement, yields exactly the class of classical quadratic forms. We identify the geometric mechanism driving this collapse: the restriction to $\mathbb{R}$ forces a vanishing Berry connection, removing the complex phases required for data-dependent quantum interference. To operationalize this boundary, we introduce encoding diagnostics -- phase complexity $C[Φ]$ and mode-wise von Neumann mutual information $I[Φ]$ -- and link them to the information-geometric excess $Δg$. We show that for all real-valued encodings, $Δg = 0$ identically. We term the misidentification of such models as evidence of quantum computational power the \emph{Inverse Born Rule Fallacy}. Supported by numerical experiments, our results establish that complex-phase structure is a strictly necessary condition for data-driven (Type~B) quantum advantage.

Related papers

The Isomorphism of Complex Numbers and Latent Worlds 0; From Coding Stability to Modal Necessity

changzheng zhou, ZIQING zhou

This paper constructs a derivation framework for quantum mechanics starting from a physical encoder in a finite-temperature heat bath, without relying onprior quantum assumptions. By strictly distinguishing the signal space from thestate-label space, and adopting information conservation and computability as operational axioms, we prove that the steady-state power response of the encoder isuniquely locked by thermodynamic stability to a positive-definite quadratic formon the signal space. This quadratic form, via the parallelogram law, a posterioriinduces an inner product, which is then pulled back by the encoding map to a metric on the state space. Linearity arises from the composability of physical inputsand injectivity of the encoding map, rather than from causal inference of energy response. Under the requirement of algebraic closure, we analyse the thermodynamiccosts of octonions and quaternions: the non-associativity of octonions necessitatesthe introduction of exceptional constraint algebras for composite-system construction, whose maintenance generates irreversible entropy production exceeding theLandauer limit; the non-commutativity of quaternions leads to ambiguity in spectral decomposition and potential path-dependent entropy production, for which arigorous statistical mechanical derivation is yet to be completed. The complex fieldemerges as the unique natural choice, being the only scalar algebra that simultaneously satisfies finite-dimensionality, algebraic closure, associativity, commutativity,and normed divisibility. The Born rule is not derived from thermodynamic powerweights, but emerges as the unique self-consistent frequency assignment for thecontext-independent response of the encoder, supported by a Gleason-type uniqueness argument and the law of large numbers. Latent-world information is defined asthe difference between Shannon entropy and von Neumann entropy; its geometryis exactly the restriction of the Bures metric along off-diagonal generators, corresponding to a scaled version of the Killing form of the adjoint Lie algebra, and itsdynamics follows a decoherence-driven exponential decay equation, directly interfacing with the master equations of open quantum systems. Finally, we proposefalsifiable experimental predictions comparing the information-energy efficiency ofcomplex encoders with real-number quantum mechanics (RQM), and establish astatistical hypothesis-testing framework.

•Jun 16, 2026•0 citations

Born's Rule from Record-Formation Constraints: A Conditional Uniqueness Theorem

Moses Rahnama

We prove a conditional uniqueness theorem for projective measurements on pure states: given the \( L^2 \) Hilbert space structure of quantum mechanics, the Born rule \( P = |\psi|^2 \) is the only outcome-local probability assignment compatible with five operational postulates (outcome-locality, normalization, phase independence of the classical record, tensor product factorization, and continuity), with interference consistency used only as a post-hoc check. Physically, the theorem addresses a boundary problem: amplitudes support interference and cancellation before measurement, whereas a stabilized classical record cannot retain the full relative-phase distinction structure in accessible form. Irreversible record formation motivates this phase-insensitivity requirement, although no thermodynamic quantity enters the formal proof. Mathematically, phase independence reduces the map to a function of modulus, factorization and continuity force a power law, and consistency with \( L^2 \) normalization fixes the exponent to \( 2 \). Within this framework, the squared modulus is the unique classicalization map from phase-sensitive amplitudes to accessible record weights. The result is complementary in physical motivation to Gleason-type derivations but narrower in scope: it is confined to the pure-state projective setting and does not derive the general trace rule for mixed states and POVMs.

•Apr 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Probability as an Application of Data Compression Principles

Allan F. Randall

Realist, no-collapse interpretations of quantum mechanics, such as Everett's, face the probability problem: how to justify the norm-squared (Born) rule from the wavefunction alone. While any basis-independent measure can only be norm-squared (due to the Gleason-Busch Theorem) this fact conflicts with various popular, non-wavefunction-based phenomenological measures - such as observer, outcome or world counting - that are frequently demanded of Everettians. These alternatives conflict, however, with the wavefunction realism upon which Everett's approach rests, which seems to call for an objective, basis-independent measure based only on wavefunction amplitudes. The ability of quantum probabilities to destructively interfere with each other, however, makes it difficult to see how probabilities can be derived solely from amplitudes in an intuitively appealing way. I argue that the use of algorithmic probability can solve this problem, since the objective, single-case probability measure that wavefunction realism demands is exactly what algorithmic information theory was designed to provide. The result is an intuitive account of complex-valued amplitudes, as coefficients in an optimal lossy data compression, such that changes in algorithmic information content (entropy deltas) are associated with phenomenal transitions.

arXiv:1606.06802•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Jun 21, 2016•1 citation

Unity Survives Distinction: The Born Rule as Quadratic Closure Hilbert Geometry, Refinement Consistency, and Intrinsic Closure

Eric Needham

Unity Survives Distinction develops a structural interpretation of the Born rule as the quadratic law by which the unity of a quantum state is preserved across operational distinction. For a normalized state |ψ⟩ and a complete projective measurement {Π_j}, Hilbert-space Pythagoras gives: 1 = ||ψ||² = Σ_j ||Π_jψ||² = Σ_j ⟨ψ|Π_j|ψ⟩ The Born weights are therefore not merely numerical assignments attached to outcomes. They are the non-negative quadratic quantities through which the norm of one complex state is distributed across an exhaustive family of orthogonal alternatives without loss of totality. The paper extends this structure to compatible nested refinements and generalized measurements. Under refinement, probability closure is preserved through the zero-residual identity: P_α = Σ_k P_αk For a generalized measurement effect E, the same internal quadratic structure is expressed as: P(E) = ⟨ψ|E|ψ⟩ = ||E^(1/2)ψ||² The paper distinguishes this quantum claim from ordinary classical additivity. Additivity alone is measure-theoretic and is not uniquely quantum. The specifically quantum architecture lies in the conjunction of complex amplitudes, conjugate quadratic form, global-phase invariance, interference-sensitive recombination, operator-defined measurement contexts, and exact preservation of the total norm. Gleason’s theorem and related results for effects and positive operator-valued measures are used to explain why, under standard noncontextual additivity assumptions, the trace form of quantum probability is essentially forced rather than arbitrarily selected. Within the ENSO framework, this structure is formulated as Born intrinsic closure: fixed unity, zero refinement residual, and an internal quadratic witness. The paper does not claim a new formula for the Born rule, a new proof of Gleason’s theorem, or a derivation of Hilbert space from pre-quantum principles. It develops the structural and interpretive significance of established quantum mathematics. Its central conclusion is: The Born rule is the quadratic law by which unity survives distinction.

•Aug 2, 2026•0 citations

Preprint: Resolution-Limited Distinguishability Selects the Born Rule

淳多 瀬川

This record provides a preprint version of a manuscript submitted for publication. The origin of the Born rule remains a central open problem in the foundations of quantum theory. While previous approaches derive the quadratic probability rule from structural, decision-theoretic, or measure-theoretic assumptions, the physical origin of these assumptions is not always transparent. In this work, we propose that observational resolution provides a fundamental constraint on distinguishability, which in turn restricts admissible probability measures. We introduce a resolution-based observational framework in which finite resolution induces coarse-graining and suppresses phase information below a characteristic scale. We show that consistency under resolution-limited coarse-graining selects a quadratic probability structure. In particular, only the quadratic form remains stable under phase averaging while reproducing additive behavior in the classical limit. We further demonstrate that this structure is naturally connected to the quadratic mapping from complex state space to observable quantities, as realized in spinorial representations of three-dimensional geometry. These results suggest that the Born rule can be understood as a structural consequence of resolution-limited observation. This version corresponds to a manuscript submitted to Physical Review X. Version 2: Major revision focusing on the emergence of the Born rule under resolution-limited observation. The manuscript has been restructured for journal submission.

•Apr 19, 2026•0 citations

Born's Rule from Record-Formation Constraints: A Thermodynamic-Information Axiomatics

Moses Rahnama

Given the standard Hilbert space structure of quantum mechanics (including L^2 normalization from unitary dynamics), we show that the Born rule P = |psi|^2 is the unique probability rule compatible with phase-independent record formation. The derivation uses one thermodynamic axiom (classical records cannot retain quantum phase, an irreversible operation with Landauer cost k_B T ln 2 per bit) together with three structural axioms (normalization, tensor product factorization, continuity) and an operational interference consistency condition. The squared modulus is the unique function satisfying all five constraints; alternative powers |alpha|^n with n != 2 fail because the L^2 unit sphere is not an L^n unit sphere. This result complements Gleason's theorem: where Gleason proves the Born rule is mathematically necessary given non-contextuality, we identify the physical mechanism (phase information loss during record formation at finite temperature) that makes it realizable. The L^2 structure itself is not derived here; it is inherited from the requirement that unitary evolution preserve the inner product. The contribution is to show that, conditional on that structure, thermodynamics selects the squared modulus as the unique admissible probability map.

•Feb 15, 2026•0 citations
When does quantum data encoding provide genuine quantum advantage, and when does it merely rephrase a classically solvable problem?
We prove an \emph{Equivalence Theorem} demonstrating that any encoding mapping classical data to real-valued amplitudes, ∣ψc⟩=∑ici∣i⟩\vertψ_c\rangle = \sum_i c_i \vert i\rangle∣ψc​⟩=∑i​ci​∣i⟩ with ci∈Rc_i \in \mathbb{R}ci​∈R and ∑ici2=1\sum_i c_i^2 = 1∑i​ci2​=1, composed with a data-independent parameterised unitary and computational-basis measurement, yields exactly the class of classical quadratic forms. We identify the geometric mechanism driving this collapse: the restriction to R\mathbb{R}R forces a vanishing Berry connection, removing the complex phases required for data-dependent quantum interference. To operationalize this boundary, we introduce encoding diagnostics -- phase complexity C[Φ]C[Φ]C[Φ] and mode-wise von Neumann mutual information I[Φ]I[Φ]I[Φ] -- and link them to the information-geometric excess ΔgΔgΔg. We show that for all real-valued encodings, Δg=0Δg = 0Δg=0 identically. We term the misidentification of such models as evidence of quantum computational power the \emph{Inverse Born Rule Fallacy}. Supported by numerical experiments, our results establish that complex-phase structure is a strictly necessary condition for data-driven (Type~B) quantum advantage.
This paper constructs a derivation framework for quantum mechanics starting from a physical encoder in a finite-temperature heat bath, without relying onprior quantum assumptions. By strictly distinguishing the signal space from thestate-label space, and adopting information conservation and computability as operational axioms, we prove that the steady-state power response of the encoder isuniquely locked by thermodynamic stability to a positive-definite quadratic formon the signal space. This quadratic form, via the parallelogram law, a posterioriinduces an inner product, which is then pulled back by the encoding map to a metric on the state space. Linearity arises from the composability of physical inputsand injectivity of the encoding map, rather than from causal inference of energy response. Under the requirement of algebraic closure, we analyse the thermodynamiccosts of octonions and quaternions: the non-associativity of octonions necessitatesthe introduction of exceptional constraint algebras for composite-system construction, whose maintenance generates irreversible entropy production exceeding theLandauer limit; the non-commutativity of quaternions leads to ambiguity in spectral decomposition and potential path-dependent entropy production, for which arigorous statistical mechanical derivation is yet to be completed. The complex fieldemerges as the unique natural choice, being the only scalar algebra that simultaneously satisfies finite-dimensionality, algebraic closure, associativity, commutativity,and normed divisibility. The Born rule is not derived from thermodynamic powerweights, but emerges as the unique self-consistent frequency assignment for thecontext-independent response of the encoder, supported by a Gleason-type uniqueness argument and the law of large numbers. Latent-world information is defined asthe difference between Shannon entropy and von Neumann entropy; its geometryis exactly the restriction of the Bures metric along off-diagonal generators, corresponding to a scaled version of the Killing form of the adjoint Lie algebra, and itsdynamics follows a decoherence-driven exponential decay equation, directly interfacing with the master equations of open quantum systems. Finally, we proposefalsifiable experimental predictions comparing the information-energy efficiency ofcomplex encoders with real-number quantum mechanics (RQM), and establish astatistical hypothesis-testing framework.
We prove a conditional uniqueness theorem for projective measurements on pure states: given the L2 L^2 L2 Hilbert space structure of quantum mechanics, the Born rule P=∣ψ∣2 P = |\psi|^2 P=∣ψ∣2 is the only outcome-local probability assignment compatible with five operational postulates (outcome-locality, normalization, phase independence of the classical record, tensor product factorization, and continuity), with interference consistency used only as a post-hoc check. Physically, the theorem addresses a boundary problem: amplitudes support interference and cancellation before measurement, whereas a stabilized classical record cannot retain the full relative-phase distinction structure in accessible form. Irreversible record formation motivates this phase-insensitivity requirement, although no thermodynamic quantity enters the formal proof. Mathematically, phase independence reduces the map to a function of modulus, factorization and continuity force a power law, and consistency with L2 L^2 L2 normalization fixes the exponent to 2 2 2. Within this framework, the squared modulus is the unique classicalization map from phase-sensitive amplitudes to accessible record weights. The result is complementary in physical motivation to Gleason-type derivations but narrower in scope: it is confined to the pure-state projective setting and does not derive the general trace rule for mixed states and POVMs.
Realist, no-collapse interpretations of quantum mechanics, such as Everett's, face the probability problem: how to justify the norm-squared (Born) rule from the wavefunction alone. While any basis-independent measure can only be norm-squared (due to the Gleason-Busch Theorem) this fact conflicts with various popular, non-wavefunction-based phenomenological measures - such as observer, outcome or world counting - that are frequently demanded of Everettians. These alternatives conflict, however, with the wavefunction realism upon which Everett's approach rests, which seems to call for an objective, basis-independent measure based only on wavefunction amplitudes. The ability of quantum probabilities to destructively interfere with each other, however, makes it difficult to see how probabilities can be derived solely from amplitudes in an intuitively appealing way. I argue that the use of algorithmic probability can solve this problem, since the objective, single-case probability measure that wavefunction realism demands is exactly what algorithmic information theory was designed to provide. The result is an intuitive account of complex-valued amplitudes, as coefficients in an optimal lossy data compression, such that changes in algorithmic information content (entropy deltas) are associated with phenomenal transitions.
Unity Survives Distinction develops a structural interpretation of the Born rule as the quadratic law by which the unity of a quantum state is preserved across operational distinction. For a normalized state |ψ⟩ and a complete projective measurement {Π_j}, Hilbert-space Pythagoras gives: 1 = ||ψ||² = Σ_j ||Π_jψ||² = Σ_j ⟨ψ|Π_j|ψ⟩ The Born weights are therefore not merely numerical assignments attached to outcomes. They are the non-negative quadratic quantities through which the norm of one complex state is distributed across an exhaustive family of orthogonal alternatives without loss of totality. The paper extends this structure to compatible nested refinements and generalized measurements. Under refinement, probability closure is preserved through the zero-residual identity: P_α = Σ_k P_αk For a generalized measurement effect E, the same internal quadratic structure is expressed as: P(E) = ⟨ψ|E|ψ⟩ = ||E^(1/2)ψ||² The paper distinguishes this quantum claim from ordinary classical additivity. Additivity alone is measure-theoretic and is not uniquely quantum. The specifically quantum architecture lies in the conjunction of complex amplitudes, conjugate quadratic form, global-phase invariance, interference-sensitive recombination, operator-defined measurement contexts, and exact preservation of the total norm. Gleason’s theorem and related results for effects and positive operator-valued measures are used to explain why, under standard noncontextual additivity assumptions, the trace form of quantum probability is essentially forced rather than arbitrarily selected. Within the ENSO framework, this structure is formulated as Born intrinsic closure: fixed unity, zero refinement residual, and an internal quadratic witness. The paper does not claim a new formula for the Born rule, a new proof of Gleason’s theorem, or a derivation of Hilbert space from pre-quantum principles. It develops the structural and interpretive significance of established quantum mathematics. Its central conclusion is: The Born rule is the quadratic law by which unity survives distinction.
This record provides a preprint version of a manuscript submitted for publication. The origin of the Born rule remains a central open problem in the foundations of quantum theory. While previous approaches derive the quadratic probability rule from structural, decision-theoretic, or measure-theoretic assumptions, the physical origin of these assumptions is not always transparent. In this work, we propose that observational resolution provides a fundamental constraint on distinguishability, which in turn restricts admissible probability measures. We introduce a resolution-based observational framework in which finite resolution induces coarse-graining and suppresses phase information below a characteristic scale. We show that consistency under resolution-limited coarse-graining selects a quadratic probability structure. In particular, only the quadratic form remains stable under phase averaging while reproducing additive behavior in the classical limit. We further demonstrate that this structure is naturally connected to the quadratic mapping from complex state space to observable quantities, as realized in spinorial representations of three-dimensional geometry. These results suggest that the Born rule can be understood as a structural consequence of resolution-limited observation. This version corresponds to a manuscript submitted to Physical Review X. Version 2: Major revision focusing on the emergence of the Born rule under resolution-limited observation. The manuscript has been restructured for journal submission.
Given the standard Hilbert space structure of quantum mechanics (including L^2 normalization from unitary dynamics), we show that the Born rule P = |psi|^2 is the unique probability rule compatible with phase-independent record formation. The derivation uses one thermodynamic axiom (classical records cannot retain quantum phase, an irreversible operation with Landauer cost k_B T ln 2 per bit) together with three structural axioms (normalization, tensor product factorization, continuity) and an operational interference consistency condition. The squared modulus is the unique function satisfying all five constraints; alternative powers |alpha|^n with n != 2 fail because the L^2 unit sphere is not an L^n unit sphere. This result complements Gleason's theorem: where Gleason proves the Born rule is mathematically necessary given non-contextuality, we identify the physical mechanism (phase information loss during record formation at finite temperature) that makes it realizable. The L^2 structure itself is not derived here; it is inherited from the requirement that unitary evolution preserve the inner product. The contribution is to show that, conditional on that structure, thermodynamics selects the squared modulus as the unique admissible probability map.