Predicting quantum measurement outcomes for a local observer makes sense before, but not after, the measurement. However, for a remote observer, predicting measurement outcomes even after measurement remains a valid question. We define remote predictability as the degree to which one observer can predict a measurement outcome of a spatially separated observer, given full knowledge of the shared quantum state and measurement setting. We show that the remote predictability before and after the measurement remains the same for product states, whereas it increases for all pure entangled states and for some classically correlated states. Perfect remote predictability for arbitrary projective measurements occurs only for maximally entangled states among all pure states, underscoring their special role. Comparing pure entangled states with their dephased versions, we find that dephasing on one subsystem can enhance remote predictability for a broad class of states and measurements - a counterintuitive, noise-induced advantage that vanishes for maximally entangled states under any projective measurement.
Comments
11 pages, 1 figure; Revised title and corresponding modifications to the abstract, introduction, and conclusion
Predicting quantum measurement outcomes for a local observer makes sense before, but not after, the measurement. However, for a remote observer, predicting measurement outcomes even after measurement remains a valid question. We define remote predictability as the degree to which one observer can predict a measurement outcome of a spatially separated observer, given full knowledge of the shared quantum state and measurement setting. We show that the remote predictability before and after the measurement remains the same for product states, whereas it increases for all pure entangled states and for some classically correlated states. Perfect remote predictability for arbitrary projective measurements occurs only for maximally entangled states among all pure states, underscoring their special role. Comparing pure entangled states with their dephased versions, we find that dephasing on one subsystem can enhance remote predictability for a broad class of states and measurements - a counterintuitive, noise-induced advantage that vanishes for maximally entangled states under any projective measurement.
A central aspect of quantum information is that correlations between spacelike separated observers sharing entangled states cannot be reproduced by local hidden variable (LHV) models, a phenomenon known as Bell nonlocality. If one wishes to explain such correlations by classical means, a natural possibility is to allow communication between the parties. In particular, LHV models augmented with two bits of classical communication can explain the correlations of any two-qubit state. Would this still hold if communication is restricted to measurement outcomes? While in certain scenarios with a finite number of inputs the answer is yes, we prove that if a model must reproduce all projective measurements, then for any qubit-qudit state the answer is no. In fact, a qubit-qudit under projective measurements admits an LHV model with outcome communication if and only if it already admits an LHV model without communication. On the other hand, we also show that when restricted sets of measurements are considered (for instance, when the qubit measurements are in the upper hemisphere of the Bloch ball), outcome communication does offer an advantage. This exemplifies that trivial properties in standard LHV scenarios, such as deterministic measurements and outcome-relabelling, play a crucial role in the outcome communication scenario.
Nonclassicality, defined through nonpositivity of quasiprobability distributions such as the Wigner and Kirkwood-Dirac distributions, underlies key quantum advantages. We show that it can be remotely activated: local measurements by a correlated partner alone can drive a party whose reduced state is classical into a genuinely nonclassical conditional state. For two-qubit systems we obtain closed forms for the maximal single-branch effect and for its probability-weighted average under the best two-outcome projective measurement, the latter proven optimal over all measurements when the shared state carries no local bias. Local noise on the steered party, evaluated relative to its own noise-updated reference basis, can enhance the effect when non-unital and misaligned with that party's axis, whereas no unital channel ever helps. This nonclassicality is shown to unlock, for the same reference observable, anomalous weak values unavailable to the unsteered state under arbitrary postselection. An exactly solvable hybrid qubit-oscillator model shows the same mechanism generates Wigner negativity. These results identify measurement-induced steering as an operational resource for remotely activating nonclassicality.
Intrinsic quantum randomness is produced when a projective measurement on a given basis is implemented on a pure state that is not an element of the basis. The prepared state and implemented measurement are perfectly known, yet the measured result cannot be deterministically predicted. In realistic situations, however, measurements and state preparation are always noisy, which introduces a component of stochasticity in the outputs that is not a consequence of the intrinsic randomness of quantum theory. Operationally, this stochasticity is modeled through classical or quantum correlations with an eavesdropper, Eve, whose goal is to make the best guess about the outcomes produced in the experiment. In this Letter, we study Eve's maximum guessing probability when she is allowed to have correlations with both the state and the measurement. We show that, unlike the case of projective measurements (as it was already known) or pure states (as we prove), in the setting of generalized measurements and mixed states, Eve's guessing probability differs depending on whether she can prepare classically or quantumly correlated strategies.
One of the major remaining questions concerning foundations of the quantum mechanical theory is how superpositions are measured such that definite outcomes are obtained. Here a resolution to that issue is proposed. It is shown how to obtain state vectors associated with measurements on the separated subystems of an entangled state, revealing how a single wavefunction encodes a special kind of set of statistical measurement outcomes. The result explains why measurements on the subsystems give definite outcomes and why measurements on one subsystem are correlated with those on the other. It is therefore concluded that the theory of quantum mechanics, without nonlinearities or \emph{ad hoc} assertions, can explain both the mechanism of state vector collapse and the reason for the paradoxical nonlocal correlations between separated subsystems. The theory also explains why nonlocal correlations do not require any kind of interaction between the subsystems.
A local measurement on one member of an entangled composite system is said to change the distant member's state instantaneously. Taken without qualification, this is misleading. A selective measurement changes the conditional state assigned to the remote subsystem once a local outcome is specified; a non-selective measurement, where that outcome is ignored, leaves the remote reduced density operator unchanged. This distinction reconciles quantum state update with operational no-signalling and provides the setting for Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen steering. This review develops measurement using density operators, completely positive instruments, Kraus representations, partial traces, conditional states, and steering assemblages. It derives the invariance of remote marginal statistics under local trace-preserving operations and contrasts this with Bell-local factorization. It examines the hierarchy among entanglement, steering, and Bell nonlocality, joint measurability, remote state preparation, and one-sided device-independent protocols. The article considers spacelike-separated measurements, microcausality in relativistic quantum theory, and ontological readings of selective state update offered by Everettian, Bohmian, collapse, and relational approaches. Decoherence is treated as the process through which local outcomes become records, while quantum Darwinism accounts for their redundant local accessibility. It highlights gaps in literature, and concludes that entanglement permits nonclassical conditional correlations, but local measurement supplies no controllable superluminal signal.
The entangled states of composite quantum systems are well studied. The particle-like nature of these systems also means that, while entangled, they can be physically separated and measurements performed on the separated subsystems. Measurements on the separated subsystems A and B should pertain to vectors in the local Hilbert space of each subsystem, but to date it has not been clear how to elucidate the relevant states of the separated subsystems because it is not obvious how to resolve them from states given in the tensor product basis, except for the separable states. Here it is shown that the projections of any general entangled state that are detected by measurements on the separated subsystems can be obtained considering the corresponding (cosets of) states in the free vector space from which the tensor product space is defined. The result eliminates the need to invoke random collapse, and from this perspective nonlocality arises because of the way measurements on each separated subsystem projects possible measurement outcomes.