Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.16286

What Kind of World Supports Darwinian Evolution? Quantum Foundational Options

Partha Ghose

quant-phSubmitted Feb 18, 2026• Announced Feb 19, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Darwinian evolution requires (i) heritable records, (ii) repeatable copying with variation, and (iii) routine irreversibility. Categorical quantum mechanics (CQM) makes precise why ``copy'' and ``delete'' are not generic quantum operations: they exist only for a realized \emph{classical data} sector (a preferred basis/observable; a commutative structure). Decoherence explains how a pointer basis can be selected dynamically, but it does not by itself select a unique outcome. This motivates a neutral presentation of the main ontological options (unique-history, decohered multiplicity, agent-relative facticity, and a stochastic foundation with variable diffusion). We also note the relevance of the ``agency constraint'' argued by Adlam-McQueen-Waegell: in a strictly coherent, basis-unselected ``purely quantum'' regime, minimal agency fails due to no-cloning and linearity, which sharpens the role of classical resources for record-based processes. Extended Wigner's Friend scenarios then serve as a stress test, since they treat ``friends'' simultaneously as coherent quantum systems and as agents possessing stable records. Finally, a stochastic-mechanics foundation (with variable diffusion) offers a continuous bridge between quantum and classical regimes, and suggests a principled way to implement measurement update as conditioning plus a time-symmetric minimal-change rule.

Comments
8 pages, one line diagram

Related papers

Individuality as the complement of objectivity: a coherent-information theory of who can inherit a quantum system

Jose Miguel Hernandez-Perez

Quantum Darwinism explains why the world agrees about a system: redundant classical records make its pointer observable objective. We ask the complementary question, what it would take for a region of the world to be the continuation of a system rather than a description of it, and organize the answer around one quantity, the coherent information of the history channel from an origin to a region, I(R > X)=S(X)-S(RX) on the Choi state of the dynamics. For a pure global state this is log d minus what the rest of the world knows about the origin, so inheriting is that everybody else be ignorant, and objectivity and individuality are complementary. From this one quantity, three standard facts (strong subadditivity, global purity, data processing) and four ways of cutting the world (space, time, body versus records, and large scale) we obtain the following. Uniqueness of the heir and its causal-clique shape in spacetime; the size of the minimal heir in terms of Darwinian redundancy, with the constant kappa(0.1)=0.026, its form in the currency of recording strength for unequal witnesses, where the bound needs no exchangeability hypothesis, and a shared-secret environment that separates objectivity from heritability; a classification of interactions by degradability, under which pointer interactions never produce an heir. A realization theorem for what two disjoint regions can jointly inherit: their maximal correctable algebras commute, every commuting pair with a multiplicity matrix is realized as the maximal pair of an explicit channel, and what the two regions hold in common is always abelian, of dimension the number of connected components of a bipartite graph that the channel fixes -- so that the shareable part of an ancestry is exactly its classical part. An exact Zeno law for bodies whose dynamics does not commute with what is recorded, whose extended-body form is a classical Markov chain with unistochastic transition matrix and whose criterion is quantum non-demolition, and, for imperfect records, the fact that a perfect record is NOT the fastest way to take a body's identity: the loss is fastest at an interior record strength, where its rate exceeds the perfect-record rate by a factor 2/theta in the rotation angle; a budget inequality under which a lineage that acts on the world spends itself, with a closed frontier for qubits by convexity and a non-convexity for qudits. An existence criterion via information-preserving structures; a de-ordering lemma for biographies in indefinite causal order; and a security formulation in which exclusivity is the privacy of the root's classical record. Most of the physics is other people's and every theorem is attributed in place; Section 1.3 lists one by one what is not, with the realization theorem at the head of that list, and two companion notes carry the two longest proofs. We report, with equal weight, what was tried and fell: a proposed dynamical law of non-inheritance, a dynamical selection of subsystems, and a localization diagnostic, all retracted after adversarial review, and we propose a measurement of the minimal heir on an existing superconducting quantum-Darwinism platform.

•Sep 16, 2026•0 citations

Agency cannot be a purely quantum phenomenon

Emily Adlam, Kelvin J. McQueen, Mordecai Waegell

What are the physical requirements for agency? We investigate whether a purely quantum system (one evolving unitarily in a coherent regime without decoherence or collapse) can satisfy three minimal conditions for agency: an agent must be able to create a world-model, use it to evaluate the likely consequences of alternative actions, and reliably perform the action that maximizes expected utility. We show that the first two conditions conflict with the no-cloning theorem, which forbids copying unknown quantum states: world-model construction requires copying information from the environment, and deliberation requires copying the world-model to assess multiple actions. Approximate cloning strategies do not permit sufficient fidelity or generality for agency to be viable in purely quantum systems. The third agency condition also fails due to the linearity of quantum dynamics. These results imply four key consequences. First, agency requires significant classical resources, placing clear constraints on its physical basis. Second, they provide insight into how classical agents emerge within a quantum universe. Third, they show that quantum computers cannot straightforwardly simulate agential behavior without significant classical components. Finally, they challenge quantum theories of agency, free will, and consciousness.

arXiv:2510.13247•Oct 15, 2025•4 citations

Quantum Theory of the Classical: Einselection, Envariance, Quantum Darwinism and Extantons

Wojciech Hubert Zurek

Core quantum postulates including the superposition principle and the unitarity of evolutions are natural and strikingly simple. I show that—when supplemented with a limited version of predictability (captured in the textbook accounts by the repeatability postulate)—these core postulates can account for all the symptoms of classicality. In particular, both objective classical reality and elusive information about reality arise, via quantum Darwinism, from the quantum substrate. This approach shares with the Relative State Interpretation of Everett the view that collapse of the wavepacket reflects perception of the state of the rest of the Universe relative to the state of observer’s records. However, our “let quantum be quantum” approach poses questions absent in Bohr’s Copenhagen Interpretation that relied on the preexisting classical domain. Thus, one is now forced to seek preferred, predictable, hence effectively classical but ultimately quantum states that allow observers keep reliable records. Without such (i) preferred basis relative states are simply “too relative”, and the ensuing basis ambiguity makes it difficult to identify events (e.g., measurement outcomes). Moreover, universal validity of quantum theory raises the issue of (ii) the origin of Born’s rule, pk=|ψk|2, relating probabilities and amplitudes (that is simply postulated in textbooks). Last not least, even preferred pointer states (defined by einselection—environment—induced superselection)—are still quantum. Therefore, unlike classical states that exist objectively, quantum states of an individual system cannot be found out by an initially ignorant observer through direct measurement without being disrupted. So, to complete the ‘quantum theory of the classical’ one must identify (iii) quantum origin of objective existence and explain how the information about objectively existing states can appear to be essentially inconsequential for them (as it does for states in Newtonian physics) and yet matter in other settings (e.g., thermodynamics). I show how the mathematical structure of quantum theory supplemented by the only uncontroversial measurement postulate (that demands immediate repeatability—hence, predictability) leads to preferred states. These (i) pointer states correspond to measurement outcomes. Their stability is a prerequisite for objective existence of effectively classical states and for events such as quantum jumps. Events at hand, one can now enquire about their probability—the probability of a pointer state (or of a measurement record). I show that the symmetry of entangled states—(ii) entanglement—assisted invariance or envariance—implies Born’s rule. Envariance also accounts for the loss of phase coherence between pointer states. Thus, decoherence can be traced to symmetries of entanglement and understood without its usual tool—reduced density matrices. A simple and manifestly noncircular derivation of pk=|ψk|2 follows. Monitoring of the system by its environment in course of decoherence typically leaves behind multiple copies of its pointer states in the environment. Only pointer states can survive decoherence and can spawn such plentiful information-theoretic progeny. This (iii) quantum Darwinism allows observers to use environment as a witness—to find out pointer states indirectly, leaving systems of interest untouched. Quantum Darwinism shows how epistemic and ontic (coexisting in epiontic quantum state) separate into robust objective existence of pointer states and detached information about them, giving rise to extantons—composite objects with system of interest in the core and multiple records of its pointer states in the halo comprising of environment subsystems (e.g., photons) which disseminates that information throughout the Universe.

arXiv:2208.09019•Entropy•Oct 24, 2022•71 citations

Coherence Selection as a Distinct Macroscopic Mechanism Beyond Energy and Entropy

Jonah Brent

Quantum Darwinism explains the emergence of objective classical reality through redundant proliferation of information into the environment. While successful in symmetric, weakly noisy settings, the framework implicitly assumes that redundancy alone guarantees macroscopic stability. In this work, we demonstrate that redundancy and decoherence are insufficient to stabilize classical outcomes in the presence of irreversible record formation, asymmetric noise, or heterogeneous constraints. We introduce coherence selection as a distinct macroscopic mechanism operating at the level of histories rather than instantaneous states. Coherence selection acts as a structural filter on admissible histories, favoring those that maintain mutual consistency among redundant records under irreversible constraint. We show that Quantum Darwinism emerges as a special symmetric limit of this broader framework. Outside that limit, coherence selection is required to prevent fragmentation of macroscopic records. We identify regimes where coherence, rather than energy or entropy, dominates macroscopic outcomes, derive qualitative stability criteria, and propose falsifiable experimental tests. These results elevate coherence selection from a descriptive framework to a necessary macroscopic mechanism underlying persistent classicality.

•Jan 22, 2026•0 citations

It from I: Observers are Agents

C. G. Trahern

In a recent analysis, Adlam, McQueen, and Waegell (arXiv:2510.13247) argue that agency cannot be a purely quantum phenomenon, demonstrating that world-model construction, deliberation over alternative actions, and reliable action selection require classical resources to circumvent the quantum no-cloning theorem and the linearity of unitary dynamics. In this note, we compare their decision-theoretic conditions for agency against the operator-algebraic architecture of the "It from I" framework. While we concur with their primary conclusion that agency requires a classical resource, we suggest that such a resource—and its associated preferred basis—need not emerge via external environmental decoherence (einselection) or state collapse. Within the "It from I" framework, every active Observer (O = M ⊗ B) equipped with an internal utility architecture acts as an Agent across two complementary levels: first, the Body (B) autogenously establishes a preferred orthogonal measurement basis via its metabolically funded collective mode (the Handle), while the unitary Cerf-Adami perceptual chain (W ↔ B ↔ M) generates a diagonal reduced Mind-Body density matrix ρ_MB that provides the classical resource required for decision-theoretic agency; second, the joint Mind-Body (M ⊗ B) Anti-Zeno state purification (𝒫 → 1) elevates those Body-prepared deliberative states into conscious awareness, explaining why the quantum mechanics is not redundant and how an agent consciously experiences its decisions within a globally unitary block universe.

•Nov 15, 2026•0 citations

Classical selection and quantum Darwinism

Wojciech Hubert Zurek

Zurek replies: Repeatability is a textbook postulate—not mine, as the comment by Alexia Auffèves and Philippe Grangier suggests. However, I like the idea of a “context,” provided its origin is quantum. Using an ab initio classical apparatus (made out of quantum atoms!) to supply a context is inconsistent. The Copenhagen interpretation used it as an ingenious and successful ad hoc fix, but it cannot be a fundamental solution. The inability to delineate a quantum–classical boundary makes matters worse. Textbooks adopt such a “shut up and calculate” ploy to paper over the inconsistency of their axioms.Quantum Darwinism and decoherence favor quasi-classical pointer states, accessible indirectly to many observers via the imprints they deposit in the environment. Pointer states in turn depend on the quantum context provided by the environment. They emerge from a quantum substrate and supply context for the quantum states of microsystems.Quantum theory is universally valid. Quantum Darwinism and decoherence explain why macrosystems behave classically: Decoherence limits the validity of the quantum principle of superposition. Preferred states are a compromise between amplification, which calls for many copies of the original, and the no-cloning theorem. An unknown state can’t be cloned, but decoherence can amplify pointer states and disseminate information about them throughout the environment.Observers access only environment fragments, hence they extract only classical information. Quantum coherence, as explained in my article, is out of reach. Observers will agree about states communicated by environment fragments, but only data about pointer states can be shared.11. M. Zwolak, W. H. Zurek, Sci. Rep. 3, 1729 (2013); https://doi.org/10.1038/srep01729A. Streltsov, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 040401 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.040401 Objective existence arises from epiontic—that is, epistemic and ontological—quantum states via the proliferation of information. Robust, quasi-classical branches and elusive information about them both emerge via amplification-like decoherence.Deducing the measurement postulates—Born’s rule and hermiticity of observables—from a simple, self-consistent credo is an advance. The assumptions, that states inhabit Hilbert space and evolve unitarily, should be judged by what follows from them and not by an intuitive appeal to classical prejudices. After all, counterintuitive assumptions—for example, that the speed of light is independent of an observer’s motion—have led to deep and valid consequences.The comment by Ruth Kastner states that phase randomness is key for decoherence and quantum Darwinism and that it is unlikely. Both are incorrect: Random phases between states are typical when phases can be defined. Moreover, random phases aren’t essential for decoherence; an outflow of information suffices. Indeed, standard models—for example, of quantum Brownian motion—often employ environments in equilibrium, for which phases are undefined and the question of their randomness is ill-posed. An initial correlation with the environment complicates calculations,22. L. D. Romero, J. P. Paz, Phys. Rev. A 55, 4070 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.55.4070 but it does not eliminate decoherence. As difficulties encountered by quantum computing research show, decoherence is generic and hard to avoid.Quantum Darwinism requires more than decoherence; it relies on an environment that can store and communicate information. Solar radiation enables that,33. C. J. Riedel, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 020404 (2010); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.105.020404New J. Phys. 13, 073038 (2011); https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/13/7/073038M. Zwolak, C. J. Riedel, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 140406 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.140406 since the Sun is a localized photon source. Quantum Darwinism is impossible in a completely equilibrated environment, whose subsystems cannot store information.The question of how to define systems is indeed of interest, and I have noted it before.44. W. H. Zurek, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. A 356, 1793 (1998); https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.1998.0250Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.75.715 The answer must go beyond decoherence: What constitutes a system depends on interactions that make or break it; molecules, for example, would fall apart if atomic interactions weakened.There is no reason to complicate matters by making the definition of a system part of the measurement problem. Systems are there from the start—Schrödinger’s cat is obviously distinct from the nucleus that determines the cat’s fate—and their presence alone does not solve the problem. Indeed, the measurement problem disappears absent a system distinct from a measuring apparatus. Quantum evolution of a universe without parts is deterministic. There is no apparatus to record a definite outcome and so no need to talk about measurement outcomes: There is literally nothing to explain. Recognizing the role of the environment—as another system—is then natural in seeking answers.I am in good company when accused of the H-theorem “mistake.” Still, Ludwig Boltzmann dealt with the evolution of a many-body system that is classical and isolated. In that classical setting, probability was a fault of an observer ignorant of the system’s precise state. Boltzmann’s Stosszahlansatz postulates uncorrelated trajectories and is a way of representing that ignorance. Although the Boltzmann equation is useful, calling on Stosszahlansatz to prove the H-theorem—that is, the second law of thermodynamics—was suspect. Evolution is deterministic and reversible, so while observers’ ignorance may increase, microscopic entropy of the closed system cannot change. Moreover, the information and hence ignorance of observers is irrelevant for classical dynamics.As I show in my article, in our quantum world probabilities arise via entanglement. A single photon that escapes with information about the fate of Schrödinger’s cat is enough to decohere the cat’s state. An observer can never catch up with the photon, so reversibility of the equations of motion notwithstanding, information loss can be irreversible for prosaic yet compelling reasons. The resulting entropy production can be accounted for by decoherence.55. W. H. Zurek, J. P. Paz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2508 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.72.2508The whole measurement (or Schrödinger’s cat) setup starts far from equilibrium. Quantum Darwinism and decoherence show why, in such nonequilibrium multipartite settings, pointer states—and not their superpositions—survive and information about them is amplified and recorded in many copies by the environment. Both the nonequilibrium setting and the division of the universe into systems are needed to state the problem. When certain assumptions are needed to state the problem, surely they can be used to solve it.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. M. Zwolak, W. H. Zurek, Sci. Rep. 3, 1729 (2013); https://doi.org/10.1038/srep01729, Google ScholarCrossrefA. Streltsov, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 040401 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.040401, , Google ScholarCrossref2. L. D. Romero, J. P. Paz, Phys. Rev. A 55, 4070 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.55.4070, Google ScholarCrossref3. C. J. Riedel, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 020404 (2010); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.105.020404, Google ScholarCrossrefNew J. Phys. 13, 073038 (2011); https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/13/7/073038, , Google ScholarCrossrefM. Zwolak, C. J. Riedel, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 140406 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.140406, , Google ScholarCrossref4. W. H. Zurek, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. A 356, 1793 (1998); https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.1998.0250, Google ScholarCrossrefRev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.75.715, , Google ScholarCrossref5. W. H. Zurek, J. P. Paz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2508 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.72.2508, Google ScholarCrossref© 2015 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Apr 30, 2015•10 citations
Darwinian evolution requires (i) heritable records, (ii) repeatable copying with variation, and (iii) routine irreversibility. Categorical quantum mechanics (CQM) makes precise why copy'' and delete'' are not generic quantum operations: they exist only for a realized \emph{classical data} sector (a preferred basis/observable; a commutative structure). Decoherence explains how a pointer basis can be selected dynamically, but it does not by itself select a unique outcome. This motivates a neutral presentation of the main ontological options (unique-history, decohered multiplicity, agent-relative facticity, and a stochastic foundation with variable diffusion). We also note the relevance of the agency constraint'' argued by Adlam-McQueen-Waegell: in a strictly coherent, basis-unselected purely quantum'' regime, minimal agency fails due to no-cloning and linearity, which sharpens the role of classical resources for record-based processes. Extended Wigner's Friend scenarios then serve as a stress test, since they treat ``friends'' simultaneously as coherent quantum systems and as agents possessing stable records. Finally, a stochastic-mechanics foundation (with variable diffusion) offers a continuous bridge between quantum and classical regimes, and suggests a principled way to implement measurement update as conditioning plus a time-symmetric minimal-change rule.
Quantum Darwinism explains why the world agrees about a system: redundant classical records make its pointer observable objective. We ask the complementary question, what it would take for a region of the world to be the continuation of a system rather than a description of it, and organize the answer around one quantity, the coherent information of the history channel from an origin to a region, I(R > X)=S(X)-S(RX) on the Choi state of the dynamics. For a pure global state this is log d minus what the rest of the world knows about the origin, so inheriting is that everybody else be ignorant, and objectivity and individuality are complementary. From this one quantity, three standard facts (strong subadditivity, global purity, data processing) and four ways of cutting the world (space, time, body versus records, and large scale) we obtain the following. Uniqueness of the heir and its causal-clique shape in spacetime; the size of the minimal heir in terms of Darwinian redundancy, with the constant kappa(0.1)=0.026, its form in the currency of recording strength for unequal witnesses, where the bound needs no exchangeability hypothesis, and a shared-secret environment that separates objectivity from heritability; a classification of interactions by degradability, under which pointer interactions never produce an heir. A realization theorem for what two disjoint regions can jointly inherit: their maximal correctable algebras commute, every commuting pair with a multiplicity matrix is realized as the maximal pair of an explicit channel, and what the two regions hold in common is always abelian, of dimension the number of connected components of a bipartite graph that the channel fixes -- so that the shareable part of an ancestry is exactly its classical part. An exact Zeno law for bodies whose dynamics does not commute with what is recorded, whose extended-body form is a classical Markov chain with unistochastic transition matrix and whose criterion is quantum non-demolition, and, for imperfect records, the fact that a perfect record is NOT the fastest way to take a body's identity: the loss is fastest at an interior record strength, where its rate exceeds the perfect-record rate by a factor 2/theta in the rotation angle; a budget inequality under which a lineage that acts on the world spends itself, with a closed frontier for qubits by convexity and a non-convexity for qudits. An existence criterion via information-preserving structures; a de-ordering lemma for biographies in indefinite causal order; and a security formulation in which exclusivity is the privacy of the root's classical record. Most of the physics is other people's and every theorem is attributed in place; Section 1.3 lists one by one what is not, with the realization theorem at the head of that list, and two companion notes carry the two longest proofs. We report, with equal weight, what was tried and fell: a proposed dynamical law of non-inheritance, a dynamical selection of subsystems, and a localization diagnostic, all retracted after adversarial review, and we propose a measurement of the minimal heir on an existing superconducting quantum-Darwinism platform.
What are the physical requirements for agency? We investigate whether a purely quantum system (one evolving unitarily in a coherent regime without decoherence or collapse) can satisfy three minimal conditions for agency: an agent must be able to create a world-model, use it to evaluate the likely consequences of alternative actions, and reliably perform the action that maximizes expected utility. We show that the first two conditions conflict with the no-cloning theorem, which forbids copying unknown quantum states: world-model construction requires copying information from the environment, and deliberation requires copying the world-model to assess multiple actions. Approximate cloning strategies do not permit sufficient fidelity or generality for agency to be viable in purely quantum systems. The third agency condition also fails due to the linearity of quantum dynamics. These results imply four key consequences. First, agency requires significant classical resources, placing clear constraints on its physical basis. Second, they provide insight into how classical agents emerge within a quantum universe. Third, they show that quantum computers cannot straightforwardly simulate agential behavior without significant classical components. Finally, they challenge quantum theories of agency, free will, and consciousness.
Core quantum postulates including the superposition principle and the unitarity of evolutions are natural and strikingly simple. I show that—when supplemented with a limited version of predictability (captured in the textbook accounts by the repeatability postulate)—these core postulates can account for all the symptoms of classicality. In particular, both objective classical reality and elusive information about reality arise, via quantum Darwinism, from the quantum substrate. This approach shares with the Relative State Interpretation of Everett the view that collapse of the wavepacket reflects perception of the state of the rest of the Universe relative to the state of observer’s records. However, our “let quantum be quantum” approach poses questions absent in Bohr’s Copenhagen Interpretation that relied on the preexisting classical domain. Thus, one is now forced to seek preferred, predictable, hence effectively classical but ultimately quantum states that allow observers keep reliable records. Without such (i) preferred basis relative states are simply “too relative”, and the ensuing basis ambiguity makes it difficult to identify events (e.g., measurement outcomes). Moreover, universal validity of quantum theory raises the issue of (ii) the origin of Born’s rule, pk=|ψk|2, relating probabilities and amplitudes (that is simply postulated in textbooks). Last not least, even preferred pointer states (defined by einselection—environment—induced superselection)—are still quantum. Therefore, unlike classical states that exist objectively, quantum states of an individual system cannot be found out by an initially ignorant observer through direct measurement without being disrupted. So, to complete the ‘quantum theory of the classical’ one must identify (iii) quantum origin of objective existence and explain how the information about objectively existing states can appear to be essentially inconsequential for them (as it does for states in Newtonian physics) and yet matter in other settings (e.g., thermodynamics). I show how the mathematical structure of quantum theory supplemented by the only uncontroversial measurement postulate (that demands immediate repeatability—hence, predictability) leads to preferred states. These (i) pointer states correspond to measurement outcomes. Their stability is a prerequisite for objective existence of effectively classical states and for events such as quantum jumps. Events at hand, one can now enquire about their probability—the probability of a pointer state (or of a measurement record). I show that the symmetry of entangled states—(ii) entanglement—assisted invariance or envariance—implies Born’s rule. Envariance also accounts for the loss of phase coherence between pointer states. Thus, decoherence can be traced to symmetries of entanglement and understood without its usual tool—reduced density matrices. A simple and manifestly noncircular derivation of pk=|ψk|2 follows. Monitoring of the system by its environment in course of decoherence typically leaves behind multiple copies of its pointer states in the environment. Only pointer states can survive decoherence and can spawn such plentiful information-theoretic progeny. This (iii) quantum Darwinism allows observers to use environment as a witness—to find out pointer states indirectly, leaving systems of interest untouched. Quantum Darwinism shows how epistemic and ontic (coexisting in epiontic quantum state) separate into robust objective existence of pointer states and detached information about them, giving rise to extantons—composite objects with system of interest in the core and multiple records of its pointer states in the halo comprising of environment subsystems (e.g., photons) which disseminates that information throughout the Universe.
Quantum Darwinism explains the emergence of objective classical reality through redundant proliferation of information into the environment. While successful in symmetric, weakly noisy settings, the framework implicitly assumes that redundancy alone guarantees macroscopic stability. In this work, we demonstrate that redundancy and decoherence are insufficient to stabilize classical outcomes in the presence of irreversible record formation, asymmetric noise, or heterogeneous constraints. We introduce coherence selection as a distinct macroscopic mechanism operating at the level of histories rather than instantaneous states. Coherence selection acts as a structural filter on admissible histories, favoring those that maintain mutual consistency among redundant records under irreversible constraint. We show that Quantum Darwinism emerges as a special symmetric limit of this broader framework. Outside that limit, coherence selection is required to prevent fragmentation of macroscopic records. We identify regimes where coherence, rather than energy or entropy, dominates macroscopic outcomes, derive qualitative stability criteria, and propose falsifiable experimental tests. These results elevate coherence selection from a descriptive framework to a necessary macroscopic mechanism underlying persistent classicality.
In a recent analysis, Adlam, McQueen, and Waegell (arXiv:2510.13247) argue that agency cannot be a purely quantum phenomenon, demonstrating that world-model construction, deliberation over alternative actions, and reliable action selection require classical resources to circumvent the quantum no-cloning theorem and the linearity of unitary dynamics. In this note, we compare their decision-theoretic conditions for agency against the operator-algebraic architecture of the "It from I" framework. While we concur with their primary conclusion that agency requires a classical resource, we suggest that such a resource—and its associated preferred basis—need not emerge via external environmental decoherence (einselection) or state collapse. Within the "It from I" framework, every active Observer (O = M ⊗ B) equipped with an internal utility architecture acts as an Agent across two complementary levels: first, the Body (B) autogenously establishes a preferred orthogonal measurement basis via its metabolically funded collective mode (the Handle), while the unitary Cerf-Adami perceptual chain (W ↔ B ↔ M) generates a diagonal reduced Mind-Body density matrix ρ_MB that provides the classical resource required for decision-theoretic agency; second, the joint Mind-Body (M ⊗ B) Anti-Zeno state purification (𝒫 → 1) elevates those Body-prepared deliberative states into conscious awareness, explaining why the quantum mechanics is not redundant and how an agent consciously experiences its decisions within a globally unitary block universe.
Zurek replies: Repeatability is a textbook postulate—not mine, as the comment by Alexia Auffèves and Philippe Grangier suggests. However, I like the idea of a “context,” provided its origin is quantum. Using an ab initio classical apparatus (made out of quantum atoms!) to supply a context is inconsistent. The Copenhagen interpretation used it as an ingenious and successful ad hoc fix, but it cannot be a fundamental solution. The inability to delineate a quantum–classical boundary makes matters worse. Textbooks adopt such a “shut up and calculate” ploy to paper over the inconsistency of their axioms.Quantum Darwinism and decoherence favor quasi-classical pointer states, accessible indirectly to many observers via the imprints they deposit in the environment. Pointer states in turn depend on the quantum context provided by the environment. They emerge from a quantum substrate and supply context for the quantum states of microsystems.Quantum theory is universally valid. Quantum Darwinism and decoherence explain why macrosystems behave classically: Decoherence limits the validity of the quantum principle of superposition. Preferred states are a compromise between amplification, which calls for many copies of the original, and the no-cloning theorem. An unknown state can’t be cloned, but decoherence can amplify pointer states and disseminate information about them throughout the environment.Observers access only environment fragments, hence they extract only classical information. Quantum coherence, as explained in my article, is out of reach. Observers will agree about states communicated by environment fragments, but only data about pointer states can be shared.11. M. Zwolak, W. H. Zurek, Sci. Rep. 3, 1729 (2013); https://doi.org/10.1038/srep01729A. Streltsov, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 040401 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.040401 Objective existence arises from epiontic—that is, epistemic and ontological—quantum states via the proliferation of information. Robust, quasi-classical branches and elusive information about them both emerge via amplification-like decoherence.Deducing the measurement postulates—Born’s rule and hermiticity of observables—from a simple, self-consistent credo is an advance. The assumptions, that states inhabit Hilbert space and evolve unitarily, should be judged by what follows from them and not by an intuitive appeal to classical prejudices. After all, counterintuitive assumptions—for example, that the speed of light is independent of an observer’s motion—have led to deep and valid consequences.The comment by Ruth Kastner states that phase randomness is key for decoherence and quantum Darwinism and that it is unlikely. Both are incorrect: Random phases between states are typical when phases can be defined. Moreover, random phases aren’t essential for decoherence; an outflow of information suffices. Indeed, standard models—for example, of quantum Brownian motion—often employ environments in equilibrium, for which phases are undefined and the question of their randomness is ill-posed. An initial correlation with the environment complicates calculations,22. L. D. Romero, J. P. Paz, Phys. Rev. A 55, 4070 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.55.4070 but it does not eliminate decoherence. As difficulties encountered by quantum computing research show, decoherence is generic and hard to avoid.Quantum Darwinism requires more than decoherence; it relies on an environment that can store and communicate information. Solar radiation enables that,33. C. J. Riedel, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 020404 (2010); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.105.020404New J. Phys. 13, 073038 (2011); https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/13/7/073038M. Zwolak, C. J. Riedel, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 140406 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.140406 since the Sun is a localized photon source. Quantum Darwinism is impossible in a completely equilibrated environment, whose subsystems cannot store information.The question of how to define systems is indeed of interest, and I have noted it before.44. W. H. Zurek, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. A 356, 1793 (1998); https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.1998.0250Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.75.715 The answer must go beyond decoherence: What constitutes a system depends on interactions that make or break it; molecules, for example, would fall apart if atomic interactions weakened.There is no reason to complicate matters by making the definition of a system part of the measurement problem. Systems are there from the start—Schrödinger’s cat is obviously distinct from the nucleus that determines the cat’s fate—and their presence alone does not solve the problem. Indeed, the measurement problem disappears absent a system distinct from a measuring apparatus. Quantum evolution of a universe without parts is deterministic. There is no apparatus to record a definite outcome and so no need to talk about measurement outcomes: There is literally nothing to explain. Recognizing the role of the environment—as another system—is then natural in seeking answers.I am in good company when accused of the H-theorem “mistake.” Still, Ludwig Boltzmann dealt with the evolution of a many-body system that is classical and isolated. In that classical setting, probability was a fault of an observer ignorant of the system’s precise state. Boltzmann’s Stosszahlansatz postulates uncorrelated trajectories and is a way of representing that ignorance. Although the Boltzmann equation is useful, calling on Stosszahlansatz to prove the H-theorem—that is, the second law of thermodynamics—was suspect. Evolution is deterministic and reversible, so while observers’ ignorance may increase, microscopic entropy of the closed system cannot change. Moreover, the information and hence ignorance of observers is irrelevant for classical dynamics.As I show in my article, in our quantum world probabilities arise via entanglement. A single photon that escapes with information about the fate of Schrödinger’s cat is enough to decohere the cat’s state. An observer can never catch up with the photon, so reversibility of the equations of motion notwithstanding, information loss can be irreversible for prosaic yet compelling reasons. The resulting entropy production can be accounted for by decoherence.55. W. H. Zurek, J. P. Paz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2508 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.72.2508The whole measurement (or Schrödinger’s cat) setup starts far from equilibrium. Quantum Darwinism and decoherence show why, in such nonequilibrium multipartite settings, pointer states—and not their superpositions—survive and information about them is amplified and recorded in many copies by the environment. Both the nonequilibrium setting and the division of the universe into systems are needed to state the problem. When certain assumptions are needed to state the problem, surely they can be used to solve it.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. M. Zwolak, W. H. Zurek, Sci. Rep. 3, 1729 (2013); https://doi.org/10.1038/srep01729, Google ScholarCrossrefA. Streltsov, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 040401 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.111.040401, , Google ScholarCrossref2. L. D. Romero, J. P. Paz, Phys. Rev. A 55, 4070 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.55.4070, Google ScholarCrossref3. C. J. Riedel, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 020404 (2010); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.105.020404, Google ScholarCrossrefNew J. Phys. 13, 073038 (2011); https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/13/7/073038, , Google ScholarCrossrefM. Zwolak, C. J. Riedel, W. H. Zurek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 140406 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.140406, , Google ScholarCrossref4. W. H. Zurek, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. A 356, 1793 (1998); https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.1998.0250, Google ScholarCrossrefRev. Mod. Phys. 75, 715 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.75.715, , Google ScholarCrossref5. W. H. Zurek, J. P. Paz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2508 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.72.2508, Google ScholarCrossref© 2015 American Institute of Physics.