arXiv:2602.01043 · Philosophy of Science
A Deflationary Account of Quantum Theory and its Implications for the Complex Numbers
Jacob A. Barandes
Abstract
Why does quantum theory need the complex numbers? With a view toward answering this question, I argue that the usual Hilbert-space formalism is a special case of the general method of Markovian embeddings. I then describe the `indivisible interpretation' of quantum theory, according to which a quantum system can be regarded as an `indivisible' stochastic process unfolding in an old-fashioned configuration space, with wave functions and other exotic Hilbert-space ingredients demoted from having an ontological status. The complex numbers end up being necessary to ensure that the Hilbert-space formalism is indeed a Markovian embedding.
AI Summary
The paper asks why quantum theory uses complex numbers and proposes interpreting its Hilbert-space formalism as a Markovian embedding of an underlying “indivisible” stochastic process. Such a process specifies configuration probabilities and transition matrices without requiring stochastic factorization through every intermediate time. Wave functions are treated as mathematical encodings rather than physical ontology. The argument combines examples of Markovian embeddings with the Strocchi–Heslot reformulation of Schrödinger dynamics as classical Hamiltonian evolution of $N$ coupled oscillators with $2N$ real variables. For the stochastic-to-quantum construction, transition probabilities are written as $\Gamma_{ij}=|\Theta_{ij}|^2$. If $\Gamma$ is unistochastic, $\Theta$ can be unitary; otherwise, a Kraus construction and Stinespring dilation yield an enlarged unitary representation, with stated dimension bound $N'\leq N^3$. A sufficiently smooth unitary family gives a Schrödinger equation through $H(t)=i\dot U(t)U^\dagger(t)$. The proposed role of complex numbers follows from the fact that, for $N>2$, unistochastic matrices need not be orthostochastic. Conversely, the paper assigns a stochastic transition matrix $\Gamma_{ij}(t\leftarrow0)=|U_{ij}(t\leftarrow0)|^2$ to unitary quantum evolution in a chosen basis. It argues that measurement probabilities are retained when apparatus and environments are included and the basis captures pointer configurations. Detailed measurement analysis and broader correspondence results are deferred to other work. The construction requires enlargement for general stochastic matrices and smoothness to obtain differential dynamics; claims concerning the measurement problem and causal locality are interpretive conclusions, with the latter supported by separate work.
Central claim may not hold: The claimed necessity of complex numbers is not established: every column-stochastic matrix has a real orthogonal dilation reproducing its transition probabilities after auxiliary configurations are marginalized, so fixed-dimension nonorthostochasticity is insufficient. The proposed embedding represents transitions from one selected conditioning time but does not establish simultaneous reproduction of all conditioning-time transition maps allowed by the stated stochastic-process axioms. The displayed Strocchi–Heslot Hamiltonian has the wrong sign on its imaginary-Hamiltonian cross term and therefore does not reproduce the stated Schrödinger equation when B is nonzero.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Journal reference
- Philosophy of Science (2026)
- DOI
- 10.1017/psa.2026.10245
- Comments
- 18 pages, no figures