Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.17713 · Quantum

Certified bounds on optimization problems in quantum theory

Younes Naceur, Jie Wang, Victor Magron, Antonio Acín

quant-phcs.SCmath.OCSubmitted Dec 19, 2025• Announced Dec 22, 2025• 7 citations• Revised Oct 26, 2026 (v2)
v1 · Dec 19, 2025v2 · Oct 26, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Semidefinite relaxations of polynomial optimization have become a central tool for addressing the non-convex optimization problems over non-commutative operators that are ubiquitous in quantum information theory and, more in general, quantum physics. Yet, as these global relaxation methods are solved numerically, the bounds issued by the semidefinite solver can - and often do - exceed the global optimum, undermining their certifiability. To counter this issue, we introduce a framework for extracting rigorous certified bounds on non-commutative optimization problems from inexact numerical data, and apply it to several paradigmatic problems in quantum information theory. An extension to sparsity and symmetry-adapted semidefinite relaxations is also provided and compared to the general dense scheme. Our results establish rational post-processing as a practical route to reliable certification, pushing semidefinite optimization toward a certifiable standard for quantum information science.

Comments
30 pages, 11 figures

Related papers

SDP bounds on quantum codes: rational certificates

Gerard Anglès Munné, Felix Huber

A fundamental problem in quantum coding theory is to determine the maximum size of quantum codes of given block length and distance. A recent work introduced bounds based on semidefinite programming, strengthening the well-known quantum linear programming bounds. However, floating-point inaccuracies prevent the extraction of rigorous non-existence proofs from the numerical methods. Here, we address this by providing rational infeasibility certificates for a range of quantum codes. Using a clustered low-rank solver with heuristic rounding to algebraic expressions, we can improve upon $18$ upper bounds on the maximum size of $n$-qubit codes with $6 \leq n \leq 19$. Our work highlights the practicality and scalability of semidefinite programming for quantum coding bounds.

quant-pharXiv:2603.19901•Mar 23, 2026•5 citations

Convergent Relaxations of Polynomial Optimization Problems with Noncommuting Variables

S. Pironio, Miguel Navascués, A. Acín

We consider optimization problems with polynomial inequality constraints in noncommuting variables. These noncommuting variables are viewed as bounded operators on a Hilbert space whose dimension is not fixed and the associated polynomial inequalities as semidefinite positivity constraints. Such problems arise naturally in quantum theory and quantum information science. To solve them, we introduce a hierarchy of semidefinite programming relaxations which generates a monotone sequence of lower bounds that converges to the optimal solution. We also introduce a criterion to detect whether the global optimum is reached at a given relaxation step and show how to extract a global optimizer from the solution of the corresponding semidefinite programming problem.

arXiv:0903.4368•SIAM Journal on Optimization•Jan 1, 2010•225 citations

Optimization Techniques in Quantum Information

Benjamin Desef

This thesis focuses on the intersection of mathematical and computational optimization and quantum information. Main contributions are open-source software code: A hybrid approach mixing "traditional" nonconvex and convex methods can make difficult problems more accessible. A demonstration of how to efficiently implement such an algorithm, avoiding interfacial bottlenecks, is provided, finding optimal protocols to establish entanglement through a lossy channel. The central software package developed addresses polynomial optimization problems. Many problems naturally involve only a polynomial objective and constraint polynomials. Such problems can automatically be cast into semidefinite programs that provide a hierarchy of outer approximations. The resulting problems are often so large and scale so unfavorably with respect to the variable number and degree involved that the boundary of the doable is reached quickly. However, technical progress both in hardware and algorithms has pushed this boundary - but software frameworks for polynomial optimization have not followed in the same manner, often now making them the bottleneck that before was the solver. The package PolynomialOptimization.jl developed during this thesis aims to fill the gap and provide a very resource-efficient intermediate layer together with a wide number of algorithms to reduce the problem size, and naturally supporting complex numbers and semidefinite constraints ubiquitous in quantum information problems. Its application on an entanglement distribution problem is demonstrated, showing that even relaxations with semidefinite matrices of three- and four-digit size can be solved conveniently. Finally, a new way to calculate interior-point barriers for the cone of sums-of-squares matrices in a nearly time-optimal way is developed, whose efficient implementation has the potential of further reducing resource consumption.

quant-pharXiv:2512.15831•Dec 18, 2025•1 citation

SymDPoly: symmetry-adapted moment relaxations for noncommutative polynomial optimization

Denis Rosset

Semidefinite relaxations are widely used to compute upper bounds on the objective of optimization problems involving noncommutative polynomials. Such optimization problems are prevalent in quantum information. We present an algorithm able to discover automatically and exploit the symmetries present in the problem formulation. We also provide an open source software library written in Scala ( https://denisrosset.github.io/symdpoly ) that computes symmetry-adapted semidefinite relaxations with interfaces to a variety of open-source and commercial semidefinite solvers. We discuss the advantages of symmetrization, namely reductions in memory use, computation time, and increase in the solution precision.

arXiv:1808.09598•Aug 29, 2018•19 citations

Semidefinite block-matrix relaxations for computing quantum correlations

Nicola D'Alessandro, Carles Roch i Carceller, Armin Tavakoli

Bounding the correlations predicted by quantum theory is an important challenge in quantum information science. Today's leading approach is semidefinite programming relaxations, but existing methods still cannot account for many relevant types of constraints. Here, we propose a semidefinite relaxation methodology that can incorporate a breadth of constraints needed in various quantum correlation problems, thereby generalising the seminal Navascués-Pironio-Acín hierarchy. It yields useful results at reasonable computational cost. We showcase the methodology and its features by using it to address five different quantum information problems. These are (i) entanglement witnessing from imperfect measurement devices, (ii) certifying measurements from fidelity-constrained sources, (iii) computing dimensionality in genuine multi-particle entangled states, (iv) benchmarking dimensionality for state preparation devices, and (v) finding uncertainty relations for nearly anti-commuting observables. These applications reflect both the usefulness and versatility of the methodology, as well as its potential for broader relevance in the field.

quant-pharXiv:2603.19388•Physical Review X•Mar 23, 2026•5 citations

Partially-Commutative Polynomial Optimization

Abhishek Mishra, Moisés Bermejo Morán, Stefano Pironio

Semidefinite programming hierarchies for commutative and non-commutative polynomial optimization represent a powerful computational tool with many applications in quantum information. In such applications, a given variable is typically not either commuting or non-commuting with all other variables, but instead commutes with some variables and does not commute with others, i.e., the variables satisfy some partial commutation relations. While such partial commutation relations can always be incorporated in a fully non-commutative setting through suitable linear constraints in the semidefinite programming relaxations, exploiting their algebraic properties from the onset can result in more compact relaxations. This leads us to introduce partially-commutative polynomial optimization, a framework that encompasses commutative and non-commutative polynomial optimization, allowing for arbitrary commutation relations among the variables. We point out that the underlying algebraic structure is that of a partially-commutative monoid. We present and review several key aspects of such monoids and show how they can be used to build SDP relaxations for partially-commutative polynomial optimization problems in which the partial commutations are natively implemented in the monomial structure, without the need of additional linear constraints.

quant-pharXiv:2607.08841•Jul 13, 2026•0 citations
Semidefinite relaxations of polynomial optimization have become a central tool for addressing the non-convex optimization problems over non-commutative operators that are ubiquitous in quantum information theory and, more in general, quantum physics. Yet, as these global relaxation methods are solved numerically, the bounds issued by the semidefinite solver can - and often do - exceed the global optimum, undermining their certifiability. To counter this issue, we introduce a framework for extracting rigorous certified bounds on non-commutative optimization problems from inexact numerical data, and apply it to several paradigmatic problems in quantum information theory. An extension to sparsity and symmetry-adapted semidefinite relaxations is also provided and compared to the general dense scheme. Our results establish rational post-processing as a practical route to reliable certification, pushing semidefinite optimization toward a certifiable standard for quantum information science.
A fundamental problem in quantum coding theory is to determine the maximum size of quantum codes of given block length and distance. A recent work introduced bounds based on semidefinite programming, strengthening the well-known quantum linear programming bounds. However, floating-point inaccuracies prevent the extraction of rigorous non-existence proofs from the numerical methods. Here, we address this by providing rational infeasibility certificates for a range of quantum codes. Using a clustered low-rank solver with heuristic rounding to algebraic expressions, we can improve upon 181818 upper bounds on the maximum size of nnn-qubit codes with 6≤n≤196 \leq n \leq 196≤n≤19. Our work highlights the practicality and scalability of semidefinite programming for quantum coding bounds.
We consider optimization problems with polynomial inequality constraints in noncommuting variables. These noncommuting variables are viewed as bounded operators on a Hilbert space whose dimension is not fixed and the associated polynomial inequalities as semidefinite positivity constraints. Such problems arise naturally in quantum theory and quantum information science. To solve them, we introduce a hierarchy of semidefinite programming relaxations which generates a monotone sequence of lower bounds that converges to the optimal solution. We also introduce a criterion to detect whether the global optimum is reached at a given relaxation step and show how to extract a global optimizer from the solution of the corresponding semidefinite programming problem.
This thesis focuses on the intersection of mathematical and computational optimization and quantum information. Main contributions are open-source software code: A hybrid approach mixing "traditional" nonconvex and convex methods can make difficult problems more accessible. A demonstration of how to efficiently implement such an algorithm, avoiding interfacial bottlenecks, is provided, finding optimal protocols to establish entanglement through a lossy channel. The central software package developed addresses polynomial optimization problems. Many problems naturally involve only a polynomial objective and constraint polynomials. Such problems can automatically be cast into semidefinite programs that provide a hierarchy of outer approximations. The resulting problems are often so large and scale so unfavorably with respect to the variable number and degree involved that the boundary of the doable is reached quickly. However, technical progress both in hardware and algorithms has pushed this boundary - but software frameworks for polynomial optimization have not followed in the same manner, often now making them the bottleneck that before was the solver. The package PolynomialOptimization.jl developed during this thesis aims to fill the gap and provide a very resource-efficient intermediate layer together with a wide number of algorithms to reduce the problem size, and naturally supporting complex numbers and semidefinite constraints ubiquitous in quantum information problems. Its application on an entanglement distribution problem is demonstrated, showing that even relaxations with semidefinite matrices of three- and four-digit size can be solved conveniently. Finally, a new way to calculate interior-point barriers for the cone of sums-of-squares matrices in a nearly time-optimal way is developed, whose efficient implementation has the potential of further reducing resource consumption.
Semidefinite relaxations are widely used to compute upper bounds on the objective of optimization problems involving noncommutative polynomials. Such optimization problems are prevalent in quantum information. We present an algorithm able to discover automatically and exploit the symmetries present in the problem formulation. We also provide an open source software library written in Scala ( https://denisrosset.github.io/symdpoly ) that computes symmetry-adapted semidefinite relaxations with interfaces to a variety of open-source and commercial semidefinite solvers. We discuss the advantages of symmetrization, namely reductions in memory use, computation time, and increase in the solution precision.
Bounding the correlations predicted by quantum theory is an important challenge in quantum information science. Today's leading approach is semidefinite programming relaxations, but existing methods still cannot account for many relevant types of constraints. Here, we propose a semidefinite relaxation methodology that can incorporate a breadth of constraints needed in various quantum correlation problems, thereby generalising the seminal Navascués-Pironio-Acín hierarchy. It yields useful results at reasonable computational cost. We showcase the methodology and its features by using it to address five different quantum information problems. These are (i) entanglement witnessing from imperfect measurement devices, (ii) certifying measurements from fidelity-constrained sources, (iii) computing dimensionality in genuine multi-particle entangled states, (iv) benchmarking dimensionality for state preparation devices, and (v) finding uncertainty relations for nearly anti-commuting observables. These applications reflect both the usefulness and versatility of the methodology, as well as its potential for broader relevance in the field.
Semidefinite programming hierarchies for commutative and non-commutative polynomial optimization represent a powerful computational tool with many applications in quantum information. In such applications, a given variable is typically not either commuting or non-commuting with all other variables, but instead commutes with some variables and does not commute with others, i.e., the variables satisfy some partial commutation relations. While such partial commutation relations can always be incorporated in a fully non-commutative setting through suitable linear constraints in the semidefinite programming relaxations, exploiting their algebraic properties from the onset can result in more compact relaxations. This leads us to introduce partially-commutative polynomial optimization, a framework that encompasses commutative and non-commutative polynomial optimization, allowing for arbitrary commutation relations among the variables. We point out that the underlying algebraic structure is that of a partially-commutative monoid. We present and review several key aspects of such monoids and show how they can be used to build SDP relaxations for partially-commutative polynomial optimization problems in which the partial commutations are natively implemented in the monomial structure, without the need of additional linear constraints.