arXiv:2611.02135
Detection times are not local observables in quantum field theory
Charis Anastopoulos, Ntina Savvidou
Abstract
Detection times are routinely recorded in quantum experiments. We show that, under natural covariance and consistency requirements, the observables describing these times cannot be algebraically localized in any bounded spacetime region, even when the records themselves are localized. This challenges the identification of algebraic localization with the physical localization of measurements and shows why microcausality alone does not establish non-signalling for measurements in quantum field theory.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether POVMs describing detection timestamps can belong to bounded-region local algebras in relativistic QFT, and what this implies for measurement locality and non-signalling. It considers detection-time effects $\Pi_T(\Delta)$ for $\Delta\subset(0,T]$, with total detection probability at most one, consistency under extending the recording duration, and covariance under forward time translations. The main theorem shows that every such effect annihilates any invariant vector $\Omega$: $\Pi_T(\Delta)\Omega=0$. Covariance makes the invariant-state probability $c_\tau$ identical in successive bins of width $\tau$; normalization gives $Nc_\tau\leq1$ for arbitrary $N$, forcing $c_\tau=0$. Positivity extends this to annihilation of the vector. In Minkowski QFT, the vacuum is separating for bounded-region local algebras by Reeh–Schlieder and locality. Consequently, every nonzero detection-time effect satisfying these assumptions lies outside every bounded-region local algebra. Extensions allow discrete time, covariance after an initial transient, and bounds $\Pi_T((0,T])\leq C(T)I$ with $C(T)/T\to0$. Exact covariance can also be replaced by operator-norm covariance errors whose long-time average vanishes, for interval widths above a fixed resolution scale. The paper discusses photodetection, occurrence-time normalization, and apparatus-based constructions, identifying nonlocality or failures of its assumptions. Its obstruction is conditional on those assumptions, including arbitrarily extendable recording durations; it does not establish signalling. It argues that microcausality alone cannot supply the usual local-Kraus non-signalling proof for these effects. Constructing joint detector probabilities and establishing their causal properties, with controlled approximations and coarse graining, remain open.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 7 pages