Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.10410

Entanglement in C$^*$-algebras: tensor products of state spaces

Magdalena Musat, Mikael Rørdam

math.OAmath.FAquant-phSubmitted Dec 11, 2025• Announced Dec 12, 2025• Revised Jul 25, 2026 (v5)
v1 · Dec 11, 2025v2 · Dec 13, 2025v3 · Feb 11, 2026v4 · Apr 14, 2026v5 · Jul 25, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We analyze the Namioka-Phelps minimal and maximal tensor products of compact convex sets which arise as the state spaces of unital C$^*$-algebras. Relatedly, we study entanglement in (infinite dimensional) C$^*$-algebras. While the minimal Namioka-Phelps tensor product of the state spaces of two C$^*$-algebras is the well-known set of separable (= un-entangled) states on the (minimal) tensor product of the C$^*$-algebras, we also describe the more elusive maximal Namioka-Phelps tensor product of state spaces of C$^*$-algebras. We show that the minimal and maximal tensor products of state spaces of C$^*$-algebras agree precisely when one of the two C$^*$-algebras is commutative, which confirms Barker's conjecture in the case where the compact convex sets are state paces of C$^*$-algebras. Further, the Namioka-Phelps tensor product of the trace simplexes of two or more unital C$^*$-algebras is shown to be the trace simplex of the (minimal or maximal) tensor product of the C$^*$-algebras. This enables a systematic way of determining the trace simplex of a tensor product of C$^*$-algebras.

Comments
27 pages. This version has undergone significant revisions, including correcting a wrong statement about tensor products of Poulsen simplexes

Related papers

On the notion of entanglement in Hilbert spaces

Александр Семенович Холево, Максим Евгеньевич Широков, Reinhard F. Werner

A density operator (state) on a tensor product H ⊗ K of Hilbert spaces is separable if it is in the convex closure of the subset of all tensor product states. Non-separable states are called entangled. These concepts are of great importance in quantum information theory, but they have been studied in depth only in the finite-dimensional context [1]. In this note we give a general integral representation for separable states and provide the first example of separable states that are not countably decomposable. We also prove a structure theorem for quantum communication channels that are entanglement-breaking, generalizing the finite-dimensional result of [2]. In the finite-dimensional case such channels can be characterized as having a Stinespring–Kraus representation (3) with operators Vj of rank 1. The above example implies the existence of infinite-dimensional entanglement-breaking channels having no such representation. In what follows,H,K,... are separable Hilbert spaces, T(H) is the Banach space of trace-class operators and S(H) is the convex subset of all density operators on H. For brevity we shall also call them states, having in mind that a density operator ρ uniquely determines a normal state on the algebra B(H) of all bounded operators on H. Equipped with the trace-norm topology, S(H) is a complete separable metric space. If π is a Borel probability measure on S(H), then

Russian Mathematical Surveys•Apr 30, 2005•50 citations

Coupling capacity in C*-algebras

Adam Skalski, Ivan G. Todorov, Lyudmila B. Turowska

Given two unital C*-algebras equipped with states and a positive operator in the enveloping von Neumann algebra of their minimal tensor product, we define three parameters that measure the capacity of the operator to align with a coupling of the two given states. Further, we establish a duality formula that shows the equality of two of the parameters for operators in the minimal tensor product of the relevant C*-algebras. In the context of abelian C*-algebras, our parameters are related to quantitative versions of Arveson's null set theorem and to dualities considered in the theory of optimal transport. On the other hand, restricting to matrix algebras we recover and generalize quantum versions of Strassen's theorem. We show that in the latter case our parameters can detect maximal entanglement and separability.

arXiv:2211.02401•Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh Section A Mathematics•Sep 7, 2023•1 citation

The cross states of a composite quantum system: separability and entanglement in any Hilbert space dimension

Paolo Aniello

We introduce a class of states of a composite quantum system, the so-called cross states, that turn out to play a major role in the theory of entanglement for a genuinely infinite-dimensional bipartite system. In the case where at least one of the Hilbert spaces of the bipartition is finite-dimensional, all states are cross states, whereas, in the genuinely infinite-dimensional setting where the dimension of both Hilbert spaces is not finite, the cross states form a trace-norm dense, convex, proper subset of the set of all states. In the latter case, the cross states can be regarded as those physical states that possess a finite amount of entanglement; accordingly, all separable states are of this kind. We prove that, for any Hilbert space dimension, the separable states can be characterized as those cross states that minimize a suitable norm, i.e., the projective norm associated with the projective tensor product of two trace classes; all other cross states are density operators belonging to the projective tensor product space. This is a generalization of the classical cross norm criterion of separability. Finally, we define an extended real-valued entanglement function and study its main properties. Coherently with the interpretation of cross states as finitely entangled states, this function is finite, and coincides with the projective norm, precisely on the cross states of the system.

arXiv:2602.18125•Feb 20, 2026•0 citations

On Tsirelson pairs of C*-algebras

Isaac Goldbring, Bradd Hart

We introduce the notion of a Tsirelson pair of C*-algebras, which is a pair of C*-algebras for which the space of quantum strategies obtained by using states on the minimal tensor product of the pair is dense in the space of quantum strategies obtained by using states on the maximal tensor product. We exhibit a number of examples of such pairs that are “nontrivial” in the sense that the minimal tensor product and the maximal tensor product of the pair are not isomorphic. For example, we prove that any pair containing a C*-algebra with Kirchberg’s QWEP property is a Tsirelson pair. We then introduce the notion of a C*-algebra with the Tsirelson property (TP) and establish a number of closure properties for this class. We also show that the class of C*-algebras with the TP forms an elementary class (in the sense of model theory), but that this class does not admit an effective axiomatization.

arXiv:2210.15509•Reviews in Mathematical Physics•May 13, 2023•4 citations

On the Extremality of the Tensor Product of Quantum Channels

James Miller S. T. da Silva

Completely positive and trace preserving (CPT) maps are important for Quantum Information Theory, because they describe a broad class of of transformations of quantum states. There are also two other related classes of maps, the unital completely positive (UCP) maps and the unital completely positive and trace preserving (UCPT) maps. For these three classes, the maps from a finite dimensional Hilbert space $X$ to another one $Y$ is a compact convex set and, as such, it is the convex hull of its extreme points. The extreme points of these convex sets are yet not well understood. In this article we investigate the preservation of extremality under the tensor product. We prove that extremality is preserved for CPT or UCP maps, but for UCPT it is not always preserved.

arXiv:2305.05795•May 9, 2023•0 citations

Tensor products of convex sets and the volume of separable states on N qudits

Guillaume Aubrun, Stanisław J. Szarek

This paper deals with estimating the volume of the set of separable mixed quantum states when the dimension of the state space grows to infinity. This has been studied recently for qubits; here we consider larger particles and conclude that, in all cases, the proportion of the states that are separable is superexponentially small in the dimension of the set. We also show that the partial transpose criterion becomes imprecise when the dimension increases, and that the lower bound ${6}^{\ensuremath{-}N∕2}$ on the (Hilbert-Schmidt) inradius of the set of separable states on $N$ qubits obtained recently by Gurvits and Barnum is essentially optimal. We employ standard tools of classical convexity, high-dimensional probability, and geometry of Banach spaces. One relatively nonstandard point is a formal introduction of the concept of projective tensor products of convex bodies, and an initial study of this concept.

arXiv:quant-ph/0503221•Physical Review A•Feb 14, 2006•75 citations
Entanglement in C∗^*∗-algebras: tensor products of state spaces
We analyze the Namioka-Phelps minimal and maximal tensor products of compact convex sets which arise as the state spaces of unital C∗^*∗-algebras. Relatedly, we study entanglement in (infinite dimensional) C∗^*∗-algebras. While the minimal Namioka-Phelps tensor product of the state spaces of two C∗^*∗-algebras is the well-known set of separable (= un-entangled) states on the (minimal) tensor product of the C∗^*∗-algebras, we also describe the more elusive maximal Namioka-Phelps tensor product of state spaces of C∗^*∗-algebras. We show that the minimal and maximal tensor products of state spaces of C∗^*∗-algebras agree precisely when one of the two C∗^*∗-algebras is commutative, which confirms Barker's conjecture in the case where the compact convex sets are state paces of C∗^*∗-algebras.
Further, the Namioka-Phelps tensor product of the trace simplexes of two or more unital C∗^*∗-algebras is shown to be the trace simplex of the (minimal or maximal) tensor product of the C∗^*∗-algebras. This enables a systematic way of determining the trace simplex of a tensor product of C∗^*∗-algebras.
A density operator (state) on a tensor product H ⊗ K of Hilbert spaces is separable if it is in the convex closure of the subset of all tensor product states. Non-separable states are called entangled. These concepts are of great importance in quantum information theory, but they have been studied in depth only in the finite-dimensional context [1]. In this note we give a general integral representation for separable states and provide the first example of separable states that are not countably decomposable. We also prove a structure theorem for quantum communication channels that are entanglement-breaking, generalizing the finite-dimensional result of [2]. In the finite-dimensional case such channels can be characterized as having a Stinespring–Kraus representation (3) with operators Vj of rank 1. The above example implies the existence of infinite-dimensional entanglement-breaking channels having no such representation. In what follows,H,K,... are separable Hilbert spaces, T(H) is the Banach space of trace-class operators and S(H) is the convex subset of all density operators on H. For brevity we shall also call them states, having in mind that a density operator ρ uniquely determines a normal state on the algebra B(H) of all bounded operators on H. Equipped with the trace-norm topology, S(H) is a complete separable metric space. If π is a Borel probability measure on S(H), then
Given two unital C*-algebras equipped with states and a positive operator in the enveloping von Neumann algebra of their minimal tensor product, we define three parameters that measure the capacity of the operator to align with a coupling of the two given states. Further, we establish a duality formula that shows the equality of two of the parameters for operators in the minimal tensor product of the relevant C*-algebras. In the context of abelian C*-algebras, our parameters are related to quantitative versions of Arveson's null set theorem and to dualities considered in the theory of optimal transport. On the other hand, restricting to matrix algebras we recover and generalize quantum versions of Strassen's theorem. We show that in the latter case our parameters can detect maximal entanglement and separability.
We introduce a class of states of a composite quantum system, the so-called cross states, that turn out to play a major role in the theory of entanglement for a genuinely infinite-dimensional bipartite system. In the case where at least one of the Hilbert spaces of the bipartition is finite-dimensional, all states are cross states, whereas, in the genuinely infinite-dimensional setting where the dimension of both Hilbert spaces is not finite, the cross states form a trace-norm dense, convex, proper subset of the set of all states. In the latter case, the cross states can be regarded as those physical states that possess a finite amount of entanglement; accordingly, all separable states are of this kind. We prove that, for any Hilbert space dimension, the separable states can be characterized as those cross states that minimize a suitable norm, i.e., the projective norm associated with the projective tensor product of two trace classes; all other cross states are density operators belonging to the projective tensor product space. This is a generalization of the classical cross norm criterion of separability. Finally, we define an extended real-valued entanglement function and study its main properties. Coherently with the interpretation of cross states as finitely entangled states, this function is finite, and coincides with the projective norm, precisely on the cross states of the system.
We introduce the notion of a Tsirelson pair of C*-algebras, which is a pair of C*-algebras for which the space of quantum strategies obtained by using states on the minimal tensor product of the pair is dense in the space of quantum strategies obtained by using states on the maximal tensor product. We exhibit a number of examples of such pairs that are “nontrivial” in the sense that the minimal tensor product and the maximal tensor product of the pair are not isomorphic. For example, we prove that any pair containing a C*-algebra with Kirchberg’s QWEP property is a Tsirelson pair. We then introduce the notion of a C*-algebra with the Tsirelson property (TP) and establish a number of closure properties for this class. We also show that the class of C*-algebras with the TP forms an elementary class (in the sense of model theory), but that this class does not admit an effective axiomatization.
Completely positive and trace preserving (CPT) maps are important for Quantum Information Theory, because they describe a broad class of of transformations of quantum states. There are also two other related classes of maps, the unital completely positive (UCP) maps and the unital completely positive and trace preserving (UCPT) maps. For these three classes, the maps from a finite dimensional Hilbert space XXX to another one YYY is a compact convex set and, as such, it is the convex hull of its extreme points. The extreme points of these convex sets are yet not well understood. In this article we investigate the preservation of extremality under the tensor product. We prove that extremality is preserved for CPT or UCP maps, but for UCPT it is not always preserved.
This paper deals with estimating the volume of the set of separable mixed quantum states when the dimension of the state space grows to infinity. This has been studied recently for qubits; here we consider larger particles and conclude that, in all cases, the proportion of the states that are separable is superexponentially small in the dimension of the set. We also show that the partial transpose criterion becomes imprecise when the dimension increases, and that the lower bound ${6}^{\ensuremath{-}N∕2}$ on the (Hilbert-Schmidt) inradius of the set of separable states on NNN qubits obtained recently by Gurvits and Barnum is essentially optimal. We employ standard tools of classical convexity, high-dimensional probability, and geometry of Banach spaces. One relatively nonstandard point is a formal introduction of the concept of projective tensor products of convex bodies, and an initial study of this concept.