Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2508.20837 · Physical Review A

Quantum telegraph behavior without photons

Truong‐Son Van, Daniel N. Maienshein, David W. Snoke

Published Mar 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that a simple model of non-Hermitian noise gives rise to the telegraph switching behavior seen in experiments with single qubits, without any reference to the existence of photons as corpuscles. This lends support to a continuous collapse interpretation of quantum mechanics, but can also be viewed as a model of continuous detection of a steady-state process in the incoherent limit. We show explicitly that such a system obeys the Born rule for particle counting statistics, even though no particle behavior has been invoked at any point in the calculation.

DOI
10.1103/t4rs-ncw8

Related papers

Telegraph signals as a solution to the time dependent Schrödinger equation

D. Drakova, G. Doyen

A particle switching between two sides of a symmetric system in interaction with a continuum exhibits a telegraph-like time development without the need of the Born-Bohr principle of reduction on eigenstates of the measuring equipment. The origin of the telegraph signal is a very weak local coupling of the particle to the continuum which is connected with an enormous slow down of the particle motion. The proposed mechanism might serve as a useful simple model for studying decoherence effects due to coupling to the environment.

arXiv:1204.5606•Apr 25, 2012•3 citations

Entanglement, Interference and Correlations of Qubits without Wavefunction Collapse and Action at a Distance

Sermet Yücel

We propose a corpuscular framework in which qubits possess individually defined states and single-event probabilities, based on an extension of the Born rule to single events. The extended rule provides a dynamical account of measurement at the single-event level. It reproduces quantum-mechanical joint probabilities through constraints on admissible joint states, replacing factorization over shared variables and relaxing the measurement-independence assumption underlying Bell-type analyses while maintaining independence of the source and measurement settings. Correlations arise from constraints imposed by the preparation and measurement configurations, without invoking dynamical non-local influence. The framework applies to arbitrary entangled states, including Bell, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger, and W states. Interference emerges as a statistical effect of indivisible corpuscles where visibility diminishes after sequential beam splitting, providing an experimental test distinguishing it from standard quantum mechanics.

•May 21, 2026•0 citations

A Model to Interpret the Collapse of a Number of States

Fernando Pimentel

Once measured, a simple quantum system collapses into one state. Before that, it can be in a superposition of several states. Though these exist in a probabilistic interpretation, we often say that "the particle was in several states and collapsed to one". Although the theory and experiments agree to this, it is counter-intuitive. We give a model that delivers a possible viewpoint to overcome that strangeness. We introduce two computation ideas to interpret this apparent variation of the number of states and model its counting: computation without zero, and computing state probabilities as projections in probability dimensions of the particle positions. We bypass the physics and mathematical formalism involved, focusing not on the states and their physics, but solely on the counting of the “number of states”, given its strangeness. This model is a simplification for discussion purposes. From an arithmetical point of view, our findings suggest a conservation law for the number of states, before and after a measurement, in favor of a convergent quantum and classical physics interpretation.

•Nov 29, 2023•0 citations

How a wave function can collapse without violating Schroedinger's equation, and how to understand Born's rule

Gerard ’t Hooft

It is often claimed that the collapse of the wave function and Born's rule to interpret the square of the norm as a probability, have to be introduced as separate axioms in quantum mechanics besides the Schroedinger equation. Here we show that this is not true in certain models where quantum behavior can be attributed to underlying deterministic equations. It is argued that indeed the apparent spontaneous collapse of wave functions and Born's rule are features that strongly point towards determinism underlying quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1112.1811•Dec 8, 2011•36 citations

Foundations of quantum physics III. Measurement

Arnold Neumaier

This paper presents the measurement problem from the point of view of the thermal interpretation of quantum physics introduced in Part II. The measurement of a Hermitian quantity $A$ is regarded as giving an uncertain value approximating the q-expectation $\langle A\rangle$ rather than (as tradition wanted to have it) as an exact revelation of an eigenvalue of $A$. Single observations of microscopic systems are (except under special circumstances) very uncertain measurements only. The thermal interpretation * treats detection events as a statistical measurement of particle beam intensity. * claims that the particle concept is only asymptotically valid, under conditions where particles are essentially free. * claims that the unmodeled environment influences the results enough to cause all randomness in quantum physics. * allows one to derive Born's rule for scattering and in the limit of ideal measurements; but in general, only part of Born's rule holds exactly: Whenever a quantity A with zero uncertainty is measured exactly, its value is an eigenvalue of A. * has no explicit collapse -- the latter emerges approximately in non-isolated subsystems. * gives a valid interpretation of systems modeled by a quantum-classical dynamics. * explains the peculiar features of the Copenhagen interpretation (lacking realism between measurements) and the minimal statistical interpretation (lacking realism for the single case) where these interpretations apply -- in the microscopic domain. The thermal interpretation is an interpretation of quantum physics that is in principle refutable by theoretical arguments leading to a negative answer to a number of open issues collected at the end of the paper, since there is plenty of experimental evidence for each of the points mentioned there.

arXiv:1902.10782•Feb 27, 2019•6 citations

Decoherence of a qubit due to either a quantum fluctuator, or classical telegraph noise

Henry James Wold, Håkon Brox, Y. M. Galperin +1 more

We study the domain of applicability of the classical telegraph noise model in the study of decoherence in qubits. We investigate the decoherence of a qubit coupled to either a quantum fluctuator, a quantum two-level system (TLS) again coupled to an environment, or to a classical fluctuator modeled by random telegraph noise. In order to do this, we construct a model for the quantum fluctuator where we can adjust the temperature of its environment, and the decoherence rate independently. The model has a well-defined classical limit at any temperature and this corresponds to the appropriate random telegraph process, which is symmetric at high temperatures and becomes asymmetric at low temperatures. We find that the difference in the qubit decoherence rates predicted by the two models depends on the ratio between the qubit-fluctuator coupling and the decoherence rate in the pointer basis of the fluctuator. This is then the relevant parameter, which determines whether the fluctuator, has to be treated quantum mechanically or can be replaced by a classical telegraph process. We also compare the mutual information between the qubit and the fluctuator in the classical and the quantum model.

arXiv:1206.2174•Physical Review B•Nov 5, 2012•48 citations
We show that a simple model of non-Hermitian noise gives rise to the telegraph switching behavior seen in experiments with single qubits, without any reference to the existence of photons as corpuscles. This lends support to a continuous collapse interpretation of quantum mechanics, but can also be viewed as a model of continuous detection of a steady-state process in the incoherent limit. We show explicitly that such a system obeys the Born rule for particle counting statistics, even though no particle behavior has been invoked at any point in the calculation.
A particle switching between two sides of a symmetric system in interaction with a continuum exhibits a telegraph-like time development without the need of the Born-Bohr principle of reduction on eigenstates of the measuring equipment. The origin of the telegraph signal is a very weak local coupling of the particle to the continuum which is connected with an enormous slow down of the particle motion. The proposed mechanism might serve as a useful simple model for studying decoherence effects due to coupling to the environment.
We propose a corpuscular framework in which qubits possess individually defined states and single-event probabilities, based on an extension of the Born rule to single events. The extended rule provides a dynamical account of measurement at the single-event level. It reproduces quantum-mechanical joint probabilities through constraints on admissible joint states, replacing factorization over shared variables and relaxing the measurement-independence assumption underlying Bell-type analyses while maintaining independence of the source and measurement settings. Correlations arise from constraints imposed by the preparation and measurement configurations, without invoking dynamical non-local influence. The framework applies to arbitrary entangled states, including Bell, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger, and W states. Interference emerges as a statistical effect of indivisible corpuscles where visibility diminishes after sequential beam splitting, providing an experimental test distinguishing it from standard quantum mechanics.
Once measured, a simple quantum system collapses into one state. Before that, it can be in a superposition of several states. Though these exist in a probabilistic interpretation, we often say that "the particle was in several states and collapsed to one". Although the theory and experiments agree to this, it is counter-intuitive. We give a model that delivers a possible viewpoint to overcome that strangeness. We introduce two computation ideas to interpret this apparent variation of the number of states and model its counting: computation without zero, and computing state probabilities as projections in probability dimensions of the particle positions. We bypass the physics and mathematical formalism involved, focusing not on the states and their physics, but solely on the counting of the “number of states”, given its strangeness. This model is a simplification for discussion purposes. From an arithmetical point of view, our findings suggest a conservation law for the number of states, before and after a measurement, in favor of a convergent quantum and classical physics interpretation.
It is often claimed that the collapse of the wave function and Born's rule to interpret the square of the norm as a probability, have to be introduced as separate axioms in quantum mechanics besides the Schroedinger equation. Here we show that this is not true in certain models where quantum behavior can be attributed to underlying deterministic equations. It is argued that indeed the apparent spontaneous collapse of wave functions and Born's rule are features that strongly point towards determinism underlying quantum mechanics.
This paper presents the measurement problem from the point of view of the thermal interpretation of quantum physics introduced in Part II. The measurement of a Hermitian quantity AAA is regarded as giving an uncertain value approximating the q-expectation ⟨A⟩\langle A\rangle⟨A⟩ rather than (as tradition wanted to have it) as an exact revelation of an eigenvalue of AAA. Single observations of microscopic systems are (except under special circumstances) very uncertain measurements only. The thermal interpretation * treats detection events as a statistical measurement of particle beam intensity. * claims that the particle concept is only asymptotically valid, under conditions where particles are essentially free. * claims that the unmodeled environment influences the results enough to cause all randomness in quantum physics. * allows one to derive Born's rule for scattering and in the limit of ideal measurements; but in general, only part of Born's rule holds exactly: Whenever a quantity A with zero uncertainty is measured exactly, its value is an eigenvalue of A. * has no explicit collapse -- the latter emerges approximately in non-isolated subsystems. * gives a valid interpretation of systems modeled by a quantum-classical dynamics. * explains the peculiar features of the Copenhagen interpretation (lacking realism between measurements) and the minimal statistical interpretation (lacking realism for the single case) where these interpretations apply -- in the microscopic domain. The thermal interpretation is an interpretation of quantum physics that is in principle refutable by theoretical arguments leading to a negative answer to a number of open issues collected at the end of the paper, since there is plenty of experimental evidence for each of the points mentioned there.
We study the domain of applicability of the classical telegraph noise model in the study of decoherence in qubits. We investigate the decoherence of a qubit coupled to either a quantum fluctuator, a quantum two-level system (TLS) again coupled to an environment, or to a classical fluctuator modeled by random telegraph noise. In order to do this, we construct a model for the quantum fluctuator where we can adjust the temperature of its environment, and the decoherence rate independently. The model has a well-defined classical limit at any temperature and this corresponds to the appropriate random telegraph process, which is symmetric at high temperatures and becomes asymmetric at low temperatures. We find that the difference in the qubit decoherence rates predicted by the two models depends on the ratio between the qubit-fluctuator coupling and the decoherence rate in the pointer basis of the fluctuator. This is then the relevant parameter, which determines whether the fluctuator, has to be treated quantum mechanically or can be replaced by a classical telegraph process. We also compare the mutual information between the qubit and the fluctuator in the classical and the quantum model.