This paper provides a systematic study of the operational idea that a quantum “state” is only defined up to what can be distinguished by a chosen family of observables. Concretely, any von Neumann algebra of observables M induces an equivalence relation on pure and mixed states by declaring two preparations indiscernible when they give identical statistics for every observable in M. The corresponding quotient, the Holevo space associated with M, is the effective (relational) state space of the experiment, explicitly dependent on the observer’s available measurements. We analyse the resulting geometry and topology of these quotients, and prove a context-complete classical representation theorem: for every von Neumann algebra M there is a canonical lift a↦â to bounded continuous functions on the Holevo space, reproducing expectation values pointwise. In the commutative case this reduces to ordinary probability theory on the joint spectrum. The framework is illustrated in explicit examples, including position measurements of a free particle and polarisation measurements in the qubit, Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR), and Bell settings. In particular, in the EPR scenario Charlie’s joint observable defines a simplex of joint outcome distributions, whereas the Alice/Bob marginal viewpoint collapses the effective description to a lower-dimensional space by “forgetting” the correlation parameter. We show that by varying the polariser settings, the indiscernibility classes become conjugated (and generically reshuffled), and different settings are typically incompatible at the level of observable algebras.
This paper provides a systematic study of the operational idea that a quantum “state” is only defined up to what can be distinguished by a chosen family of observables. Concretely, any von Neumann algebra of observables M induces an equivalence relation on pure and mixed states by declaring two preparations indiscernible when they give identical statistics for every observable in M. The corresponding quotient, the Holevo space associated with M, is the effective (relational) state space of the experiment, explicitly dependent on the observer’s available measurements. We analyse the resulting geometry and topology of these quotients, and prove a context-complete classical representation theorem: for every von Neumann algebra M there is a canonical lift a↦â to bounded continuous functions on the Holevo space, reproducing expectation values pointwise. In the commutative case this reduces to ordinary probability theory on the joint spectrum. The framework is illustrated in explicit examples, including position measurements of a free particle and polarisation measurements in the qubit, Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR), and Bell settings. In particular, in the EPR scenario Charlie’s joint observable defines a simplex of joint outcome distributions, whereas the Alice/Bob marginal viewpoint collapses the effective description to a lower-dimensional space by “forgetting” the correlation parameter. We show that by varying the polariser settings, the indiscernibility classes become conjugated (and generically reshuffled), and different settings are typically incompatible at the level of observable algebras.
We prove that the Hilbert space description of all joint von Neumann measurements on a quantum state can be reproduced in terms of a single measure space (Ω, F, μ) with a normalized real-valued measure μ, that is, in terms of a new general probability model, the quasi-classical probability model, developed in [Loubenets: J. Math. Phys. 53 (2012), 022201; J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 45 (2012), 185306]. In a quasi-classical probability model for all von Neumann measurements, a random variable models the corresponding quantum observable in all joint measurements and depends only on this quantum observable. This mathematical result sheds a new light on some important issues of quantum randomness discussed in the literature since the seminal article (1935) of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen.
Similarly to quantum states, also quantum measurements can be 'mixed', corresponding to a random choice within an ensemble of measuring apparatuses. Such mixing is equivalent to a sort of hidden variable, which produces a noise of purely classical nature. It is then natural to ask which apparatuses are indecomposable , i.e. do not correspond to any random choice of apparatuses. This problem is interesting not only for foundations, but also for applications, since most optimization strategies give optimal apparatuses that are indecomposable. Mathematically the problem is posed describing each measuring apparatus by a positive operator-valued measure (POVM), which gives the statistics of the outcomes for any input state. The POVMs form a convex set, and in this language the indecomposable apparatuses are represented by extremal points—the analogous of 'pure states' in the convex set of states. Differently from the case of states, however, indecomposable POVMs are not necessarily rank-one, e.g. von Neumann measurements. In this paper we give a complete classification of indecomposable apparatuses (for discrete spectrum), by providing different necessary and sufficient conditions for extremality of POVMs, along with a simple general algorithm for the decomposition of a POVM into extremals. As an interesting application, 'informationally complete' measurements are analysed in this respect. The convex set of POVMs is fully characterized by determining its border in terms of simple algebraic properties of the corresponding POVMs.
The nonlocality of Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) states is discussed in the framework of Weyl algebras. To include all possible limits of expectation values, the associated canonical cyclic representations of EPR states are considered. The momentum and position operators of individual particles do not exist in such representations, which explains the uncertainty principle in these cases. However, there are still one-to-one correspondences between the local Weyl operators associated with individual particles. The local observable algebras of individual particles are Type II1 von Neumann algebras and have numerous projection operators. The states obtained by applying local projection operations to the EPR states have perfect correlations between local subalgebras. Bell’s inequality is maximally violated by these states. The lack of atomic projections of Type II1 von Neumann algebras implies that the EPR states cannot be disentangled by local projection operations.
What theoretical structures characterise our notions of what it means for a whole physical system to be the sum of its parts? We explore various aspects of this question, with emphasise on quantum theory, from the following perspective: A physical theory constitutes the definition of a set of propositions with logical relationships between them such that probabilities can be used to judge the merits of the theory, given empirical evidence. The logical relationships between the propositions characterise our semantic notions such as individuation. We distinguish between the ontological and epistemological notions of individuation. We introduce the notion of ontological individuation within the context of ontological models. A subsystem is defined as a proposition that provides necessary and sufficient information for making useful predictions. This definition to some extent generalises the notions of separability and local causality to define systems that may not be local. It highlights the unified motivations for many assumptions in the literature, such as measurement independence, and points to hidden assumptions of causality and mutual exclusivity that occur when defining systems. An epistemic no-signalling criterion gives rise to a tensor product structure for epistemic systems in quantum theory. We utilise a symmetry emergent from this structure to derive a bound on the observability of a large class of operations, dependent on only the purity of the quantum state. In particular, we derive an upper bound on the trace distance between an untransformed state and the state transformed by any trace preserving, unital operation. Our notions of epistemic systems also relate to distinguishability. It is shown that for measurements of any two (_nite outcome) particle quantum numbers on multi-fermion states, the total uncertainty, minimised over all states, is zero. This is because despite indistinguishability characterised as a constraint on the observable algebra, the appropriate correspondence between states of distinguishable and indistinguishable particles is one where the Hilbert space of indistinguishable particles relates to particles with an extra quantum number such that effective distinguishability can emerge. This Hilbert space is larger than the one for distinguishable particles and hence can (does) contain states for which the uncertainty relations for distinguishable particles are no longer valid. We conclude by arguing that in general, epistemic systems are not necessarily distinguishable; They may be only effectively distinguishable. This would imply a theory of indistinguishable modes. Several motivations are presented and the form of the theory suggested. It is hypothesised that such a theory may provide a relativistic quantum theory, alternative to quantum field theory, that satisfies cluster decomposition.
In this paper the notion of an EPR state for the composite S of two quantum systems S1,S2, relative to S2 and a set 𝒪 of bounded observables of S2, is introduced in the spirit of the classical examples of Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen and Bohm. We restrict ourselves mostly to EPR states of finite norm. The main results are contained in Theorems 3–6 and imply that if EPR states of finite norm relative to (S2,O) exist, then the elements of 𝒪 have discrete probability distributions and the Von Neumann algebra generated by 𝒪 is essentially imbeddable inside S1 by an antiunitary map. The EPR states then correspond to the different imbeddings and certain additional parameters, and are explicitly given by formulas which generalize the famous example of Bohm. If 𝒪 generates all bounded observables, S2 must be of finite dimension and can be imbedded inside S1 by an antiunitary map, and the EPR states relative to S2 are then in canonical bijection with the different imbeddings of S2 inside S1; moreover they are then given by formulas which are exactly those of the generalized Bohm states. The notion of EPR states of infinite norm is also explored and it is shown that the original state of Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen can be realized as a renormalized limit of EPR states of finite quantum systems considered by Weyl, Schwinger, and many others. Finally, a family of states of infinite norm generalizing the Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen example is explicitly given.
We introduce a general witness-based framework for quantifying and operationally activating continuous-variable (CV) resources into discrete-variable (DV) bipartite entanglement or Einstein- Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) steering. For the three standard CV resource theories associated with Wigner negativity (WN), genuine non-Gaussianity (GNG), and standard non-Gaussianity (SNG), we define infinite families of bounded-witness monotones indexed by box constraints on the witness operators. For closed convex free sets, these monotones are faithful, strongly monotonic under free instruments, Lipschitz continuous, and convex. For closed nonconvex free sets, we show that faithfulness requires a two-copy lift and formulate the corresponding strong-monotonicity statement in the lifted theory. We further construct witness-dependent completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) measure-and-prepare channels whose outputs are two-qubit Werner states. For the representative case n = m = 1, the optimal entanglement and EPR steering attainable within this witness-dependent activation family are exactly proportional to the underlying monotones. We illustrate the framework with odd-parity states, pure-loss single-photon states, and Gottesman- Kitaev-Preskill (GKP) states, and derive explicit lower bounds for pure-state GNG and SNG. More broadly, our results show that closed CV free sets admit witness-based quantifiers with a direct operational interpretation in terms of experimentally accessible DV correlations.