We prove that the Hilbert space description of all joint von Neumann measurements on a quantum state can be reproduced in terms of a single measure space (Ω, F, μ) with a normalized real-valued measure μ, that is, in terms of a new general probability model, the quasi-classical probability model, developed in [Loubenets: J. Math. Phys. 53 (2012), 022201; J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 45 (2012), 185306]. In a quasi-classical probability model for all von Neumann measurements, a random variable models the corresponding quantum observable in all joint measurements and depends only on this quantum observable. This mathematical result sheds a new light on some important issues of quantum randomness discussed in the literature since the seminal article (1935) of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen.
We prove that the Hilbert space description of all joint von Neumann measurements on a quantum state can be reproduced in terms of a single measure space (Ω, F, μ) with a normalized real-valued measure μ, that is, in terms of a new general probability model, the quasi-classical probability model, developed in [Loubenets: J. Math. Phys. 53 (2012), 022201; J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 45 (2012), 185306]. In a quasi-classical probability model for all von Neumann measurements, a random variable models the corresponding quantum observable in all joint measurements and depends only on this quantum observable. This mathematical result sheds a new light on some important issues of quantum randomness discussed in the literature since the seminal article (1935) of Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen.
We prove the existence for each Hilbert space of the two new quasi hidden variable (qHV) models, statistically noncontextual and context-invariant, reproducing all the von Neumann joint probabilities via non-negative values of real-valued measures and all the quantum product expectations—via the qHV (classical-like) average of the product of the corresponding random variables. In a context-invariant model, a quantum observable X can be represented by a variety of random variables satisfying the functional condition required in quantum foundations but each of these random variables equivalently models X under all joint von Neumann measurements, regardless of their contexts. The proved existence of this model negates the general opinion that, in terms of random variables, the Hilbert space description of all the joint von Neumann measurements for dimH≥3 can be reproduced only contextually. The existence of a statistically noncontextual qHV model, in particular, implies that every N-partite quantum state admits a local quasi hidden variable model introduced in Loubenets [J. Math. Phys. 53, 022201 (2012)]. The new results of the present paper point also to the generality of the quasi-classical probability model proposed in Loubenets [J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 45, 185306 (2012)].
We specify for a general correlation scenario a particular type of local quasi hidden variable (LqHV) model (Loubenets 2012 J. Math. Phys. 53 022201)—a deterministic LqHV model, where all joint probability distributions of a correlation scenario are simulated via a single measure space with a normalized bounded real-valued measure not being necessarily positive and random variables, each depending only on a setting of the corresponding measurement at the corresponding site. We prove that an arbitrary multipartite correlation scenario admits a deterministic LqHV model if and only if all its joint probability distributions satisfy the consistency condition, constituting the general nonsignaling condition formulated in Loubenets (2008 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 41 445303). This mathematical result specifies a new probability model that has a measure-theoretic structure resembling the structure of the classical probability model but incorporates the latter only as a particular case. The local version of this quasi-classical probability model covers the probabilistic description of each nonsignaling correlation scenario, in particular, each correlation scenario on a multipartite quantum state.
We propose a formulation of quantum measurement within a modified framework of frames, in which a quantum system - a single qubit - is directly coupled to a classical measurement bit. The qubit is represented as a positive probability distribution over two classical bits, a and a', denoted by p(aa'). The measurement apparatus is described by a classical bit α=±1, initialized in the pure distribution p(α)=21(1+α). The measurement interaction is modeled by a quasi-bistochastic process $ S(bb'β\mid aa'α)$ - a bistochastic map that may include negative transition probabilities, while acting on an entirely positive state space. When this process acts on the joint initial state p(aa′)p(α), it produces a collapsed state p(bb′∣β), yielding the measurement outcome β with the correct quantum-mechanical probability p(β). This approach bypasses the von Neumann chain of infinite couplings by treating the measurement register classically, while capturing the nonclassical nature of measurement through the quasi-bistochastic structure of the interaction.
Quantum probability is a generalization of both classical probability theory and quantum mechanics that allows to describe the probabilistic aspects of quantum mechanics. This generalization is formulated in two steps. First, the theory is reformulated in terms of algebras of functions on probability spaces. Therefore, the notion of a probability space (Ω, ℱ, P) is replaced by the pair (L∞ (Ω), E(.) = ∫Ω. dP) consisting of the commutative von Neumann algebra of bounded random variables and the expectation functional. Then, the commutativity condition is dropped. In this way we arrive at the notion of a (von Neumann) algebraic probability space (N,Φ) consisting of a von Neumann algebra N and a normal (faithful tracial) state Φ. As we have seen this includes classical probability spaces in the form (L∞(Ω), E), it also includes quantum mechanical systems modeled by a Hilbert space H and a pure state ψ ∊ H (or a mixed state ρ ∊ S(H)), if we take N = B(H) and Ф the state defined by Ф(X) = 〈 ψ, X ψ 〉 (or Ф (X) = tr(ρX)) for X ∊ B(H). Note that in this course we shall relax the conditions on N and Φ and work with involutive algebras and positive normalized functionals, that is, *-algebraic probability spaces.
An attempt to extend the postulational basis of quantum theory by introducing correlations between the results of measurements, developed in this article, leads to negative joint probabilities for otherwise meaningful sets of measured values. Since, so far as can be seen, the attempt made is the only one compatible with the theory of random variables, and is incompatible with the structure of Hilbert space, we conclude that correlations are absent. This result, though it is tantamount to a denial of von Neumann's projection postulate and the “reduction of wave packets” on measurement, is nevertheless shown to be entirely satisfactory from the physical point of view.
This paper provides a systematic study of the operational idea that a quantum “state” is only defined up to what can be distinguished by a chosen family of observables. Concretely, any von Neumann algebra of observables M induces an equivalence relation on pure and mixed states by declaring two preparations indiscernible when they give identical statistics for every observable in M. The corresponding quotient, the Holevo space associated with M, is the effective (relational) state space of the experiment, explicitly dependent on the observer’s available measurements. We analyse the resulting geometry and topology of these quotients, and prove a context-complete classical representation theorem: for every von Neumann algebra M there is a canonical lift a↦â to bounded continuous functions on the Holevo space, reproducing expectation values pointwise. In the commutative case this reduces to ordinary probability theory on the joint spectrum. The framework is illustrated in explicit examples, including position measurements of a free particle and polarisation measurements in the qubit, Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR), and Bell settings. In particular, in the EPR scenario Charlie’s joint observable defines a simplex of joint outcome distributions, whereas the Alice/Bob marginal viewpoint collapses the effective description to a lower-dimensional space by “forgetting” the correlation parameter. We show that by varying the polariser settings, the indiscernibility classes become conjugated (and generically reshuffled), and different settings are typically incompatible at the level of observable algebras.