Feedback oscillators, consisting of an amplifier whose output is partially fed back to its input, provide stable references for standardization and synchronization. Notably, the laser is such an oscillator whose performance can be limited by quantum fluctuations. The resulting frequency instability, quantified by the Schawlow-Townes formula, sets a limit to laser linewidth. Here, we show that the Schawlow-Townes formula applies universally to feedback oscillators beyond lasers. This is because it arises from quantum noise added by the amplifier and out-coupler in the feedback loop. Tracing the precise origin of quantum noise in an oscillator informs techniques to systematically evade it: we show how squeezing and entanglement can enable sub-Schawlow-Townes linewidth feedback oscillators. Our analysis clarifies the quantum limits to the stability of feedback oscillators in general, derives a standard quantum limit (SQL) for all such devices, and quantifies the efficacy of quantum strategies in realizing sub-SQL oscillators.
A recent
S-matrix-based theory of the quantum-limited linewidth, which is applicable to general lasers, including spatially nonuniform laser cavities operating above threshold, is analyzed in various limits. For broadband gain, a simple interpretation of the Petermann and bad-cavity factors is presented in terms of geometric relations between the zeros and poles of the
S matrix. When there is substantial dispersion, on the frequency scale of the cavity lifetime, the theory yields a generalization of the bad-cavity factor, which was previously derived for spatially uniform one-dimensional lasers. This effect can lead to sub--Schawlow-Townes linewidths in lasers with very narrow gain widths. We derive a formula for the linewidth in terms of the lasing mode functions, which has accuracy comparable to the previous formula involving the residue of the lasing pole. These results for the quantum-limited linewidth are valid even in the regime of strong line pulling and spatial hole burning, where the linewidth cannot be factorized into independent Petermann and bad-cavity factors.
We derive the quantum-limited linewidth of a bad-cavity laser, where the cavity-loss rate can be comparable to or larger than the gain bandwidth. We allow for incomplete inversion and arbitrary mirror losses and show how the position-dependent gain, refractive index, and populations co-determine the laser linewidth. The result obtained factorizes in parts that have straightforward physical interpretations. In the bad-cavity regime the laser linewidth is shown to be reduced as compared to the Schawlow-Townes expression as a result of anomalous dispersion associated with the optical gain. Saturation is shown to lead to a power-independent contribution to the laser linewidth; the magnitude of this contribution depends critically on the assumed pumping and decay rates.
For more than half a century, the standard quantum limit (SQL) was thought to limit the laser coherence
C -- the number of photons emitted from the laser into the beam in one coherence time -- to a scaling
Θ(μ2), where
μ is the mean number of optical-frequency excitations stored inside the laser. However, recently it has been shown [Baker et al., Nat. Phys. 17, 179 (2021)] that the Heisenberg limit -- an achievable ultimate limit set by quantum mechanics for the task of producing a beam with the standard properties of a laser beam -- is
C=Θ(μ4), a quadratic enhancement. So far, proposals to demonstrate beyond-SQL scaling of
C have been limited to circuit QED, at microwave frequencies (i.e., a maser). Here, we introduce a class of generalized far-above-threshold (FAT) laser models, obtained by replacing the ordinary bosonic lowering operator
a^ by a general lowering operator
L^ in the superoperators appearing in the master equation that governs the FAT laser dynamics. We then show that an optical-frequency superradiant laser in the bad-cavity limit, with feedback-controlled collective pumping, realizes one such model, in which
L^ is identified with the collective superradiant lowering operator
J^. This model can surpass the SQL scaling, with the coherence exhibiting a scaling as large as
C=Θ(μ8/3) in the optimal parameter regime. Here, in the bad-cavity limit,
μ≈N/2, where
N is the number of superradiant atoms.
Feedback oscillators, such as lasers and masers, serve as time references in modern computing, communication, and measurement. Quantum fluctuations ultimately limit their phase stability and ability to keep time precisely; in the absence of quantum engineering, their phase stability is bounded by a standard quantum limit (SQL). Techniques to improve the frequency stability of feedback oscillators beyond the SQL have been theorized, but have not yet been demonstrated. We demonstrate an opto-electronic oscillator (OEO), a type of feedback oscillator, with phase stability approaching the SQL. We then engineer the OEO's quantum state to improve its phase stability, thereby demonstrating the essential principle quantum-enhancement of feedback oscillators. Similar techniques may be employed to evade the SQL in other feedback oscillators such as masers and lasers.