Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2412.02458 · Entropy

Three-Phase Confusion Learning

Filippo Caleca, Simone Tibaldi, Elisa Ercolessi

Published Feb 14, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The use of Neural Networks in quantum many-body theory has undergone a formidable rise in recent years. Among the many possible applications, their pattern recognition power can be utilized when dealing with the study of equilibrium phase diagrams. Learning by Confusion has emerged as an interesting and unbiased scheme within this context. This technique involves systematically reassigning labels to the data in various ways, followed by training and testing the Neural Network. While random labeling results in low accuracy, the method reveals a peak in accuracy when the data are correctly and meaningfully partitioned, even if the correct labeling is initially unknown. Here, we propose a generalization of this confusion scheme for systems with more than two phases, for which it was originally proposed. Our construction relies on the use of a slightly different Neural Network: from a binary classifier, we move to a ternary one, which is more suitable to detect systems exhibiting three phases. After introducing this construction, we test it on free and interacting Kitaev chains and on the one-dimensional Extended Hubbard model, consistently achieving results that are compatible with previous works. Our work opens the way to wider use of Learning by Confusion, demonstrating once more the usefulness of Machine Learning to address quantum many-body problems.

DOI
10.3390/e27020199

Related papers

Learning by confusion: The phase diagram of the Holstein model

George Issa, Owen Bradley, Ehsan Khatami +1 more

We employ the ``learning by confusion'' technique, an unsupervised machine learning approach for detecting phase transitions, to analyze quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the two-dimensional Holstein model---a fundamental model for electron-phonon interactions on a lattice. Utilizing a convolutional neural network, we conduct a series of binary classification tasks to identify Holstein critical points based on the neural network's learning accuracy. We further evaluate the effectiveness of various training datasets, including snapshots of phonon fields and other measurements resolved in imaginary time, for predicting distinct phase transitions and crossovers. Our results culminate in the construction of the finite-temperature phase diagram of the Holstein model.

arXiv:2501.04681•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 23, 2025•7 citations

Parameter diagnostics of phases and phase transition learning by neural networks

Philippe Suchsland, Stefan Weßel

We present an analysis of neural network-based machine learning schemes for phases and phase transitions in theoretical condensed matter research, focusing on neural networks with a single hidden layer. Such shallow neural networks were previously found to be efficient in classifying phases and locating phase transitions of various basic model systems. In order to rationalize the emergence of the classification process and for identifying any underlying physical quantities, it is feasible to examine the weight matrices and the convolutional filter kernels that result from the learning process of such shallow networks. Furthermore, we demonstrate how the learning-by-confusing scheme can be used, in combination with a simple threshold-value classification method, to diagnose the learning parameters of neural networks. In particular, we study the classification process of both fully-connected and convolutional neural networks for the two-dimensional Ising model with extended domain wall configurations included in the low-temperature regime. Moreover, we consider the two-dimensional XY model and contrast the performance of the learning-by-confusing scheme and convolutional neural networks trained on bare spin configurations to the case of preprocessed samples with respect to vortex configurations. We discuss these findings in relation to similar recent investigations and possible further applications.

arXiv:1802.09876•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 31, 2018•82 citations

Explorations in machine learning for interacting many-body systems.

Jonathon Matthew Schulz-Beach

Most interacting many-body systems in physics are not analytically solvable. Instead, numerical methods are needed for the study of these complex and high-dimensional problems. At present, there are many interesting problems in strongly correlated systems that remain unsolved with current methods. At the heart of this problem is finding an efficient representation that incorporates symmetries, correlations and general features. \n \nIn the context of computer science, machine learning techniques have had astonishing success at reducing the dimensionality of data. The leading method is through the use of artificial neural networks. These networks have been enormously successful at sifting through vast amounts of data to find patterns and regularities. In a sense, neural networks are themselves a statistical system whose properties are adjusted to mimic the features of the data. By finding an effective low-dimensional representation of the data, machine learning has greatly subdued the curse of dimensionality found in many real-world problems. \n \nIn this Thesis, we apply several machine learning techniques to the study of interacting many-body systems in classical and quantum statistical physics. We explore supervised classification of phases of matter with an emphasis on physical interpretation of the net- work. In doing so, we design a custom network architecture that possesses rotational symmetry as an inductive bias. We further investigate connections between the renormalization group and deep learning through applying a super-resolving neural network to the classical Ising model. Towards experimental efforts, we also repurpose generative machine learning to quantum state tomography for the calibration and testing of quantum devices. We conclude with a latent variable model inspired by near-term quantum algorithms. This maps to a variational Monte Carlo ansatz that produces samples efficiently for interacting quantum systems.

•Sep 3, 2020•0 citations

Learning by confusion approach to identification of discontinuous phase transitions

Monika Richter-Laskowska, Marcin Kurpas, Maciej M. Maśka

Recently, the learning by confusion (LbC) approach has been proposed as a machine learning tool to determine the critical temperature T_{c} of phase transitions without any prior knowledge of its even approximate value. The method has been proven effective, but it has been used only for continuous phase transitions, where the confusion results only from deliberate incorrect labeling of the data. However, in the case of a discontinuous phase transition, additional confusion can result from the coexistence of different phases. To verify whether the confusion scheme can also be used for discontinuous phase transitions, we apply the LbC method to three microscopic models, the Blume-Capel, the q-state Potts, and the Falicov-Kimball models, which undergo continuous or discontinuous phase transitions depending on model parameters. With the help of a simple model, we predict that the phase coexistence present in discontinuous phase transitions can indeed make the neural network more confused and thus decrease its performance. However, numerical calculations performed for the models mentioned above indicate that other aspects of this kind of phase transition are more important and can render the LbC method even less effective. Nevertheless, we demonstrate that in some cases the same aspects allow us to use the LbC method to identify the order of a phase transition.

arXiv:2206.15114•Physical review. E•Aug 7, 2023•17 citations

Machine learning phase transitions with a quantum processor

Alexey Uvarov, Andrey Kardashin, Jacob Biamonte

Machine learning has emerged as a promising approach to unveil properties of many-body systems. Recently proposed as a tool to classify phases of matter, the approach relies on classical simulation methods---such as Monte Carlo---which are known to experience an exponential slowdown when simulating certain quantum systems. To overcome this slowdown while still leveraging machine learning, we propose a variational quantum algorithm which merges quantum simulation and quantum machine learning to classify phases of matter. Our classifier is directly fed labeled states recovered by the variational quantum eigensolver algorithm, thereby avoiding the data-reading slowdown experienced in many applications of quantum enhanced machine learning. We propose families of variational ansatz states that are inspired directly by tensor networks. This allows us to use tools from tensor network theory to explain properties of the phase diagrams the presented quantum algorithm recovers. Finally, we propose a majority vote quantum classifier built from a nearest-neighbor (checkerboard) quantum neural network. This classifier is successfully trained to recognize phases of matter with 99% accuracy for the transverse field Ising model and 94% accuracy for the $XXZ$ model. These findings suggest that a merger between quantum simulation and quantum enhanced machine learning offers a fertile ground to develop computational insights into quantum systems.

arXiv:1906.10155•Physical Review A•Jul 15, 2020•78 citations

Identifying quantum phase transitions with adversarial neural networks

Patrick Huembeli, Alexandre Dauphin, Péter Wittek

The identification of phases of matter is a challenging task, especially in quantum mechanics, where the complexity of the ground state appears to grow exponentially with the size of the system. Traditionally, physicists have to identify the relevant order parameters for the classification of the different phases. We here follow a radically different approach: we address this problem with a state-of-the-art deep learning technique, adversarial domain adaptation. We derive the phase diagram of the whole parameter space starting from a fixed and known subspace using unsupervised learning. This method has the advantage that the input of the algorithm can be directly the ground state without any ad hoc feature engineering. Furthermore, the dimension of the parameter space is unrestricted. More specifically, the input data set contains both labeled and unlabeled data instances. The first kind is a system that admits an accurate analytical or numerical solution, and one can recover its phase diagram. The second type is the physical system with an unknown phase diagram. Adversarial domain adaptation uses both types of data to create invariant feature extracting layers in a deep learning architecture. Once these layers are trained, we can attach an unsupervised learner to the network to find phase transitions. We show the success of this technique by applying it on several paradigmatic models: the Ising model with different temperatures, the Bose-Hubbard model, and the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model with disorder. The method finds unknown transitions successfully and predicts transition points in close agreement with standard methods. This study opens the door to the classification of physical systems where the phase boundaries are complex such as the many-body localization problem or the Bose glass phase.

arXiv:1710.08382•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 11, 2018•128 citations
The use of Neural Networks in quantum many-body theory has undergone a formidable rise in recent years. Among the many possible applications, their pattern recognition power can be utilized when dealing with the study of equilibrium phase diagrams. Learning by Confusion has emerged as an interesting and unbiased scheme within this context. This technique involves systematically reassigning labels to the data in various ways, followed by training and testing the Neural Network. While random labeling results in low accuracy, the method reveals a peak in accuracy when the data are correctly and meaningfully partitioned, even if the correct labeling is initially unknown. Here, we propose a generalization of this confusion scheme for systems with more than two phases, for which it was originally proposed. Our construction relies on the use of a slightly different Neural Network: from a binary classifier, we move to a ternary one, which is more suitable to detect systems exhibiting three phases. After introducing this construction, we test it on free and interacting Kitaev chains and on the one-dimensional Extended Hubbard model, consistently achieving results that are compatible with previous works. Our work opens the way to wider use of Learning by Confusion, demonstrating once more the usefulness of Machine Learning to address quantum many-body problems.
We employ the ``learning by confusion'' technique, an unsupervised machine learning approach for detecting phase transitions, to analyze quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the two-dimensional Holstein model---a fundamental model for electron-phonon interactions on a lattice. Utilizing a convolutional neural network, we conduct a series of binary classification tasks to identify Holstein critical points based on the neural network's learning accuracy. We further evaluate the effectiveness of various training datasets, including snapshots of phonon fields and other measurements resolved in imaginary time, for predicting distinct phase transitions and crossovers. Our results culminate in the construction of the finite-temperature phase diagram of the Holstein model.
We present an analysis of neural network-based machine learning schemes for phases and phase transitions in theoretical condensed matter research, focusing on neural networks with a single hidden layer. Such shallow neural networks were previously found to be efficient in classifying phases and locating phase transitions of various basic model systems. In order to rationalize the emergence of the classification process and for identifying any underlying physical quantities, it is feasible to examine the weight matrices and the convolutional filter kernels that result from the learning process of such shallow networks. Furthermore, we demonstrate how the learning-by-confusing scheme can be used, in combination with a simple threshold-value classification method, to diagnose the learning parameters of neural networks. In particular, we study the classification process of both fully-connected and convolutional neural networks for the two-dimensional Ising model with extended domain wall configurations included in the low-temperature regime. Moreover, we consider the two-dimensional XY model and contrast the performance of the learning-by-confusing scheme and convolutional neural networks trained on bare spin configurations to the case of preprocessed samples with respect to vortex configurations. We discuss these findings in relation to similar recent investigations and possible further applications.
Most interacting many-body systems in physics are not analytically solvable. Instead, numerical methods are needed for the study of these complex and high-dimensional problems. At present, there are many interesting problems in strongly correlated systems that remain unsolved with current methods. At the heart of this problem is finding an efficient representation that incorporates symmetries, correlations and general features. \n \nIn the context of computer science, machine learning techniques have had astonishing success at reducing the dimensionality of data. The leading method is through the use of artificial neural networks. These networks have been enormously successful at sifting through vast amounts of data to find patterns and regularities. In a sense, neural networks are themselves a statistical system whose properties are adjusted to mimic the features of the data. By finding an effective low-dimensional representation of the data, machine learning has greatly subdued the curse of dimensionality found in many real-world problems. \n \nIn this Thesis, we apply several machine learning techniques to the study of interacting many-body systems in classical and quantum statistical physics. We explore supervised classification of phases of matter with an emphasis on physical interpretation of the net- work. In doing so, we design a custom network architecture that possesses rotational symmetry as an inductive bias. We further investigate connections between the renormalization group and deep learning through applying a super-resolving neural network to the classical Ising model. Towards experimental efforts, we also repurpose generative machine learning to quantum state tomography for the calibration and testing of quantum devices. We conclude with a latent variable model inspired by near-term quantum algorithms. This maps to a variational Monte Carlo ansatz that produces samples efficiently for interacting quantum systems.
Recently, the learning by confusion (LbC) approach has been proposed as a machine learning tool to determine the critical temperature T_{c} of phase transitions without any prior knowledge of its even approximate value. The method has been proven effective, but it has been used only for continuous phase transitions, where the confusion results only from deliberate incorrect labeling of the data. However, in the case of a discontinuous phase transition, additional confusion can result from the coexistence of different phases. To verify whether the confusion scheme can also be used for discontinuous phase transitions, we apply the LbC method to three microscopic models, the Blume-Capel, the q-state Potts, and the Falicov-Kimball models, which undergo continuous or discontinuous phase transitions depending on model parameters. With the help of a simple model, we predict that the phase coexistence present in discontinuous phase transitions can indeed make the neural network more confused and thus decrease its performance. However, numerical calculations performed for the models mentioned above indicate that other aspects of this kind of phase transition are more important and can render the LbC method even less effective. Nevertheless, we demonstrate that in some cases the same aspects allow us to use the LbC method to identify the order of a phase transition.
Machine learning has emerged as a promising approach to unveil properties of many-body systems. Recently proposed as a tool to classify phases of matter, the approach relies on classical simulation methods---such as Monte Carlo---which are known to experience an exponential slowdown when simulating certain quantum systems. To overcome this slowdown while still leveraging machine learning, we propose a variational quantum algorithm which merges quantum simulation and quantum machine learning to classify phases of matter. Our classifier is directly fed labeled states recovered by the variational quantum eigensolver algorithm, thereby avoiding the data-reading slowdown experienced in many applications of quantum enhanced machine learning. We propose families of variational ansatz states that are inspired directly by tensor networks. This allows us to use tools from tensor network theory to explain properties of the phase diagrams the presented quantum algorithm recovers. Finally, we propose a majority vote quantum classifier built from a nearest-neighbor (checkerboard) quantum neural network. This classifier is successfully trained to recognize phases of matter with 99% accuracy for the transverse field Ising model and 94% accuracy for the XXZXXZXXZ model. These findings suggest that a merger between quantum simulation and quantum enhanced machine learning offers a fertile ground to develop computational insights into quantum systems.
The identification of phases of matter is a challenging task, especially in quantum mechanics, where the complexity of the ground state appears to grow exponentially with the size of the system. Traditionally, physicists have to identify the relevant order parameters for the classification of the different phases. We here follow a radically different approach: we address this problem with a state-of-the-art deep learning technique, adversarial domain adaptation. We derive the phase diagram of the whole parameter space starting from a fixed and known subspace using unsupervised learning. This method has the advantage that the input of the algorithm can be directly the ground state without any ad hoc feature engineering. Furthermore, the dimension of the parameter space is unrestricted. More specifically, the input data set contains both labeled and unlabeled data instances. The first kind is a system that admits an accurate analytical or numerical solution, and one can recover its phase diagram. The second type is the physical system with an unknown phase diagram. Adversarial domain adaptation uses both types of data to create invariant feature extracting layers in a deep learning architecture. Once these layers are trained, we can attach an unsupervised learner to the network to find phase transitions. We show the success of this technique by applying it on several paradigmatic models: the Ising model with different temperatures, the Bose-Hubbard model, and the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model with disorder. The method finds unknown transitions successfully and predicts transition points in close agreement with standard methods. This study opens the door to the classification of physical systems where the phase boundaries are complex such as the many-body localization problem or the Bose glass phase.