Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2206.15114 · Physical review. E

Learning by confusion approach to identification of discontinuous phase transitions

Monika Richter-Laskowska, Marcin Kurpas, Maciej M. Maśka

Published Aug 7, 2023• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently, the learning by confusion (LbC) approach has been proposed as a machine learning tool to determine the critical temperature T_{c} of phase transitions without any prior knowledge of its even approximate value. The method has been proven effective, but it has been used only for continuous phase transitions, where the confusion results only from deliberate incorrect labeling of the data. However, in the case of a discontinuous phase transition, additional confusion can result from the coexistence of different phases. To verify whether the confusion scheme can also be used for discontinuous phase transitions, we apply the LbC method to three microscopic models, the Blume-Capel, the q-state Potts, and the Falicov-Kimball models, which undergo continuous or discontinuous phase transitions depending on model parameters. With the help of a simple model, we predict that the phase coexistence present in discontinuous phase transitions can indeed make the neural network more confused and thus decrease its performance. However, numerical calculations performed for the models mentioned above indicate that other aspects of this kind of phase transition are more important and can render the LbC method even less effective. Nevertheless, we demonstrate that in some cases the same aspects allow us to use the LbC method to identify the order of a phase transition.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.108.024113

Related papers

Learning by Confusion Locates a Parametrization-Dependent Fisher Information Maximum

George Issa, Richard T. Scalettar

Learning by confusion (LBC) is a machine-learning method for locating phase transitions without assuming a known order parameter. Its characteristic accuracy curve contains a central maximum that is interpreted as the transition point, but what determines the location and finite-size scaling of this maximum has remained unclear. We derive an exact balance condition for the Bayes-optimal confusion peak and show that, for equilibrium systems with a single swept parameter, the peak closely follows the maximum of the corresponding Fisher information. This immediately gives its finite-size scaling and reveals an unexpected dependence on how the data are sampled: the same configurations arranged on grids uniform in $T$, $\ln T$, or $β=1/T$ can yield different finite-size pseudocritical trajectories. Tests on the Ising, Blume-Capel, Potts, and Baxter-Wu models confirm the prediction across continuous, tricritical, and first-order transitions. Our results identify the statistical quantity measured by LBC and show that finite-size machine-learning estimates can depend on the parametrization of the training data as well as on the underlying physics.

arXiv:2610.34769•Oct 26, 2026•0 citations

Phase probabilities in first-order transitions using machine learning

Diana Sukhoverkhova, Vyacheslav Mozolenko, Щур Лев Николаевич

We set out to explore the possibility of investigating the critical behavior of systems with first-order phase transition using deep machine learning. We propose a machine learning protocol with ternary classification of instantaneous spin configurations using known values of disordered phase energy and ordered phase energy. The trained neural network is used to predict whether a given sample belong to one or another phase of matter. This allows us to estimate for the first time the probability that configurations with a certain energy belong to the ordered phase, coexistence phase, and disordered phase. Based on these probabilities, we obtained estimates of the values of the critical energies and latent heat for the Potts model with 10 and 20 components, which undergoes a strong discontinuous transition. We also found that the probabilities may reflect geometric transitions in the coexistence phase.

arXiv:2411.00733•Physical review. E•Sep 12, 2025•3 citations

Confusion scheme in machine learning detects double phase transitions and quasi-long-range order

Song Sub Lee, Beom Jun Kim

Thanks to the development of machine learning techniques, it has been shown that the supervised learning can be useful to study critical phenomena of various systems. However, the supervised learning cannot be done without labels which require knowledge about critical behavior of the system. To overcome this barrier, unsupervised machine learning methods have been considered and the confusion scheme has been proposed. In this study, we use the confusion scheme of the unsupervised learning and investigate critical behavior of various systems which exhibit single (double) phase transitions with (without) quasi-long-range order. In detail, we choose the two-color Ashkin-Teller model, the XY model, and the eight-state clock model as such systems and snapshots of the spin configurations at various temperatures are collected via Monte Carlo simulations to be used as input data for the unsupervised machine learning. We also put focus on the size dependence of results and validate the availability of the confusion scheme in thermodynamic limit. Our results indicate that the confusion scheme of the unsupervised learning successfully locates the approximate transition points for all models and becomes more accurate as the system size is increased. We also find a characteristic feature of the result which reflects the presence of a quasi-long-range order. We conclude that regardless of the presence of a quasi-long-range order, single and double phase transitions can be detected via the confusion scheme.

Physical review. E•Apr 24, 2019•29 citations

Parameter diagnostics of phases and phase transition learning by neural networks

Philippe Suchsland, Stefan Weßel

We present an analysis of neural network-based machine learning schemes for phases and phase transitions in theoretical condensed matter research, focusing on neural networks with a single hidden layer. Such shallow neural networks were previously found to be efficient in classifying phases and locating phase transitions of various basic model systems. In order to rationalize the emergence of the classification process and for identifying any underlying physical quantities, it is feasible to examine the weight matrices and the convolutional filter kernels that result from the learning process of such shallow networks. Furthermore, we demonstrate how the learning-by-confusing scheme can be used, in combination with a simple threshold-value classification method, to diagnose the learning parameters of neural networks. In particular, we study the classification process of both fully-connected and convolutional neural networks for the two-dimensional Ising model with extended domain wall configurations included in the low-temperature regime. Moreover, we consider the two-dimensional XY model and contrast the performance of the learning-by-confusing scheme and convolutional neural networks trained on bare spin configurations to the case of preprocessed samples with respect to vortex configurations. We discuss these findings in relation to similar recent investigations and possible further applications.

arXiv:1802.09876•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 31, 2018•82 citations

Unsupervised machine learning for identifying phase transition using two-times clustering

Nan Wu, Zhuohan Li, Wanzhou Zhang

In recent years, developing unsupervised machine learning for identifying phase transition is a research direction. In this paper, we introduce a two-times clustering method that can help select perfect configurations from a set of degenerate samples and assign the configuration with labels in a manner of unsupervised machine learning. These perfect configurations can then be used to train a neural network to classify phases. The derivatives of the predicted classification in the phase diagram, show peaks at the phase transition points. The effectiveness of our method is tested for the Ising, Potts, and Blume-Capel models. By using the ordered configuration from two-times clustering, our method can provide a useful way to obtain phase diagrams.

arXiv:2305.17687•May 28, 2023•0 citations

Learning by confusion: The phase diagram of the Holstein model

George Issa, Owen Bradley, Ehsan Khatami +1 more

We employ the ``learning by confusion'' technique, an unsupervised machine learning approach for detecting phase transitions, to analyze quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the two-dimensional Holstein model---a fundamental model for electron-phonon interactions on a lattice. Utilizing a convolutional neural network, we conduct a series of binary classification tasks to identify Holstein critical points based on the neural network's learning accuracy. We further evaluate the effectiveness of various training datasets, including snapshots of phonon fields and other measurements resolved in imaginary time, for predicting distinct phase transitions and crossovers. Our results culminate in the construction of the finite-temperature phase diagram of the Holstein model.

arXiv:2501.04681•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 23, 2025•7 citations
Recently, the learning by confusion (LbC) approach has been proposed as a machine learning tool to determine the critical temperature T_{c} of phase transitions without any prior knowledge of its even approximate value. The method has been proven effective, but it has been used only for continuous phase transitions, where the confusion results only from deliberate incorrect labeling of the data. However, in the case of a discontinuous phase transition, additional confusion can result from the coexistence of different phases. To verify whether the confusion scheme can also be used for discontinuous phase transitions, we apply the LbC method to three microscopic models, the Blume-Capel, the q-state Potts, and the Falicov-Kimball models, which undergo continuous or discontinuous phase transitions depending on model parameters. With the help of a simple model, we predict that the phase coexistence present in discontinuous phase transitions can indeed make the neural network more confused and thus decrease its performance. However, numerical calculations performed for the models mentioned above indicate that other aspects of this kind of phase transition are more important and can render the LbC method even less effective. Nevertheless, we demonstrate that in some cases the same aspects allow us to use the LbC method to identify the order of a phase transition.
Learning by confusion (LBC) is a machine-learning method for locating phase transitions without assuming a known order parameter. Its characteristic accuracy curve contains a central maximum that is interpreted as the transition point, but what determines the location and finite-size scaling of this maximum has remained unclear. We derive an exact balance condition for the Bayes-optimal confusion peak and show that, for equilibrium systems with a single swept parameter, the peak closely follows the maximum of the corresponding Fisher information. This immediately gives its finite-size scaling and reveals an unexpected dependence on how the data are sampled: the same configurations arranged on grids uniform in TTT, ln⁡T\ln TlnT, or β=1/Tβ=1/Tβ=1/T can yield different finite-size pseudocritical trajectories. Tests on the Ising, Blume-Capel, Potts, and Baxter-Wu models confirm the prediction across continuous, tricritical, and first-order transitions. Our results identify the statistical quantity measured by LBC and show that finite-size machine-learning estimates can depend on the parametrization of the training data as well as on the underlying physics.
We set out to explore the possibility of investigating the critical behavior of systems with first-order phase transition using deep machine learning. We propose a machine learning protocol with ternary classification of instantaneous spin configurations using known values of disordered phase energy and ordered phase energy. The trained neural network is used to predict whether a given sample belong to one or another phase of matter. This allows us to estimate for the first time the probability that configurations with a certain energy belong to the ordered phase, coexistence phase, and disordered phase. Based on these probabilities, we obtained estimates of the values of the critical energies and latent heat for the Potts model with 10 and 20 components, which undergoes a strong discontinuous transition. We also found that the probabilities may reflect geometric transitions in the coexistence phase.
Thanks to the development of machine learning techniques, it has been shown that the supervised learning can be useful to study critical phenomena of various systems. However, the supervised learning cannot be done without labels which require knowledge about critical behavior of the system. To overcome this barrier, unsupervised machine learning methods have been considered and the confusion scheme has been proposed. In this study, we use the confusion scheme of the unsupervised learning and investigate critical behavior of various systems which exhibit single (double) phase transitions with (without) quasi-long-range order. In detail, we choose the two-color Ashkin-Teller model, the XY model, and the eight-state clock model as such systems and snapshots of the spin configurations at various temperatures are collected via Monte Carlo simulations to be used as input data for the unsupervised machine learning. We also put focus on the size dependence of results and validate the availability of the confusion scheme in thermodynamic limit. Our results indicate that the confusion scheme of the unsupervised learning successfully locates the approximate transition points for all models and becomes more accurate as the system size is increased. We also find a characteristic feature of the result which reflects the presence of a quasi-long-range order. We conclude that regardless of the presence of a quasi-long-range order, single and double phase transitions can be detected via the confusion scheme.
We present an analysis of neural network-based machine learning schemes for phases and phase transitions in theoretical condensed matter research, focusing on neural networks with a single hidden layer. Such shallow neural networks were previously found to be efficient in classifying phases and locating phase transitions of various basic model systems. In order to rationalize the emergence of the classification process and for identifying any underlying physical quantities, it is feasible to examine the weight matrices and the convolutional filter kernels that result from the learning process of such shallow networks. Furthermore, we demonstrate how the learning-by-confusing scheme can be used, in combination with a simple threshold-value classification method, to diagnose the learning parameters of neural networks. In particular, we study the classification process of both fully-connected and convolutional neural networks for the two-dimensional Ising model with extended domain wall configurations included in the low-temperature regime. Moreover, we consider the two-dimensional XY model and contrast the performance of the learning-by-confusing scheme and convolutional neural networks trained on bare spin configurations to the case of preprocessed samples with respect to vortex configurations. We discuss these findings in relation to similar recent investigations and possible further applications.
In recent years, developing unsupervised machine learning for identifying phase transition is a research direction. In this paper, we introduce a two-times clustering method that can help select perfect configurations from a set of degenerate samples and assign the configuration with labels in a manner of unsupervised machine learning. These perfect configurations can then be used to train a neural network to classify phases. The derivatives of the predicted classification in the phase diagram, show peaks at the phase transition points. The effectiveness of our method is tested for the Ising, Potts, and Blume-Capel models. By using the ordered configuration from two-times clustering, our method can provide a useful way to obtain phase diagrams.
We employ the ``learning by confusion'' technique, an unsupervised machine learning approach for detecting phase transitions, to analyze quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the two-dimensional Holstein model---a fundamental model for electron-phonon interactions on a lattice. Utilizing a convolutional neural network, we conduct a series of binary classification tasks to identify Holstein critical points based on the neural network's learning accuracy. We further evaluate the effectiveness of various training datasets, including snapshots of phonon fields and other measurements resolved in imaginary time, for predicting distinct phase transitions and crossovers. Our results culminate in the construction of the finite-temperature phase diagram of the Holstein model.