Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2405.14687 · Physical Review Letters

Quantum Thermodynamic Derivation of the Energy Resolution Limit in Magnetometry

Iannis K. Kominis

Published Dec 26, 2024• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It was recently demonstrated that a multitude of realizations of several magnetic sensing technologies satisfy the energy resolution limit, which connects a quantity composed by the variance of the magnetic field estimate, the sensor volume and the measurement time, and having units of action, with ℏ. A first-principles derivation of this limit is still elusive. We here present such a derivation based on quantum thermodynamic arguments. We show that the energy resolution limit is a result of quantum thermodynamic work necessarily associated with quantum measurement and Landauer erasure, the work being exchanged with the magnetic field. We apply these considerations to atomic magnetometers, diamond magnetometers, and SQUIDs, spanning an energy resolution from 10^{0}ℏ to 10^{7}ℏ. This connection between quantum thermodynamics and magnetometry can help advance quantum sensing technologies towards even more sensitive devices.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.133.263201

Related papers

Colloquium : Quantum limits to the energy resolution of magnetic field sensors

Morgan W. Mitchell, Silvana Palacios

Magnetometry, that is, the measurement of magnetic fields, has applications that range from brain imaging to exploration of the outer Solar System. The best magnetometry technologies achieve a sensitivity close to Planck's constant, the number that appears in the Heisenberg uncertainty relation. This Colloquium reviews what is known about quantum mechanical limits on field sensing, and identifies new sensing approaches that may break the current impasse in magnetic sensitivity.

arXiv:1905.00618•Reviews of Modern Physics•Apr 28, 2020•137 citations

Metabolic quantum limit to the information capacity of magnetoencephalography

E. Gkoudinakis, S. Li, I. K. Kominis

Magnetoencephalography measures the magnetic fields generated by neural currents using quantum sensors such as superconducting quantum interference devices and atomic magnetometers. Here we combine the energy resolution limit of magnetic sensing with the metabolic power available to neural currents to derive a technology-independent bound on the information capacity of MEG. The bound factorizes into geometry, metabolism, and Planck's constant, and gives an estimated maximum information rate of 2.2~Mbit/s for representative human-brain parameters. Further, we show that the externally measurable magnetic field has a finite angular bandwidth, with high multipole components being geometrically attenuated and falling below the quantum-limited noise floor. This yields an information-limited spatial scale of order $1~{\rm cm}$ and renders the accessible measurement space effectively finite-dimensional. The energy resolution limit therefore defines an information-theoretic Nyquist scale for magnetoencephalography, beyond which denser spatial sampling provides redundant measurements rather than additional recoverable information. Since the energy resolution limit also makes the noise variance grow linearly with measurement bandwidth, temporal and spatial bandwidths compete, producing a fundamental spatio-temporal trade-off. These results show how quantum-limited measurements constrain the observable complexity and information content of noninvasive brain imaging, providing a quantitative link between fundamental physics and neuroscience.

physics.bio-phCross-listedarXiv:2511.06401•Physical Review Research•Nov 11, 2025•0 citations

Surpassing the Energy Resolution Limit with Ferromagnetic Torque Sensors

Andrea Vinante, Chris Timberlake, Dmitry Budker +3 more

We discuss the fundamental noise limitations of a ferromagnetic torque sensor based on a levitated magnet in the tipping regime. We evaluate the optimal magnetic field resolution taking into account the thermomechanical noise and the mechanical detection noise at the standard quantum limit. We find that the energy resolution limit, pointed out in recent literature as a relevant benchmark for most classes of magnetometers, can be surpassed by many orders of magnitude. Moreover, similarly to the case of a ferromagnetic gyroscope, it is also possible to surpass the standard quantum limit for magnetometry with independent spins, arising from spin-projection noise. Our finding indicates that magnetomechanical systems optimized for magnetometry can achieve a magnetic field resolution per unit volume several orders of magnitude better than any conventional magnetometer. We discuss possible implications, focusing on fundamental physics problems such as the search for exotic interactions beyond the standard model.

arXiv:2104.14425•Physical Review Letters•Aug 10, 2021•34 citations

The hunt for mineral resources with quantum magnetometers

Ronny Stolz, M. Schiffler, Michael Becken +2 more

Abstract Quantum sensing provides advanced technologies which significantly improve sensitivity and accuracy for sensing changes of motion, gravity, electric and magnetic field. Therein, quantum sensors for the detection of magnetic fields, so-called quantum magnetometers, are one of the most promising technological realizations. We firstly will provide a brief overview on methods in geophysical exploration benefitting from quantum magnetometers with resolution at the physical and technical limit. We will introduce recent developments on SQUID and OPM based sensors as specific implementations of a quantum magnetometer systems and application examples.

tm - Technisches Messen•Dec 14, 2023•10 citations

Single-domain Bose condensate magnetometer achieves energy resolution per bandwidth below ℏ

Silvana Palacios, Pau Gomez, Simon Coop +3 more

Significance Energy resolution per bandwidth E R is a cross-technology figure of merit that quantifies the combined spatial, temporal, and field resolution of a magnetic sensor. Today’s best-developed magnetometer technologies, including superconducting quantum interference devices, spin-exchange relaxation-free Rb vapors, and nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond, are limited by quantum noise to E R ≳ ℏ . Meanwhile, important sensing applications, e.g., noninvasive discrimination of individual brain events, would be enabled by E R < ℏ . This situation has motivated proposals for sensors operating by new physical principles. Our result, E R = 0.075 ( 16 ) ℏ , far beyond the best possible performance of established sensor technologies, confirms the potential of this class of proposed sensors. The result opens horizons for condensed matter, neuroscience, and tests of fundamental physics.

arXiv:2108.11716•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Feb 7, 2022•24 citations

dc Quantum Magnetometry below the Ramsey Limit

A. A. Wood, Alastair D. Stacey, A. Martin

We demonstrate quantum sensing of dc magnetic fields that exceeds the sensitivity of conventional ${T}_{2}^{\ensuremath{\ast}}$-limited dc magnetometry by more than an order of magnitude. We use nitrogen-vacancy centers in a diamond rotating at periods comparable to the spin coherence time, and characterize the dependence of magnetic sensitivity on measurement time and rotation speed. Our method up-converts only the dc field of interest and preserves the quantum coherence of the sensor. These results definitively improve the sensitivity of a quantum magnetometer to dc fields, demonstrating that sensitivity below the ${T}_{2}^{\ensuremath{\ast}}$ limit is possible and can be applied to any diamond magnetometer where ${T}_{2}\ensuremath{\gg}{T}_{2}^{\ensuremath{\ast}}$ to yield an order-of-magnitude sensitivity improvement.

arXiv:2203.14230•Physical Review Applied•Nov 7, 2022•13 citations
It was recently demonstrated that a multitude of realizations of several magnetic sensing technologies satisfy the energy resolution limit, which connects a quantity composed by the variance of the magnetic field estimate, the sensor volume and the measurement time, and having units of action, with ℏ. A first-principles derivation of this limit is still elusive. We here present such a derivation based on quantum thermodynamic arguments. We show that the energy resolution limit is a result of quantum thermodynamic work necessarily associated with quantum measurement and Landauer erasure, the work being exchanged with the magnetic field. We apply these considerations to atomic magnetometers, diamond magnetometers, and SQUIDs, spanning an energy resolution from 10^{0}ℏ to 10^{7}ℏ. This connection between quantum thermodynamics and magnetometry can help advance quantum sensing technologies towards even more sensitive devices.
Magnetoencephalography measures the magnetic fields generated by neural currents using quantum sensors such as superconducting quantum interference devices and atomic magnetometers. Here we combine the energy resolution limit of magnetic sensing with the metabolic power available to neural currents to derive a technology-independent bound on the information capacity of MEG. The bound factorizes into geometry, metabolism, and Planck's constant, and gives an estimated maximum information rate of 2.2~Mbit/s for representative human-brain parameters. Further, we show that the externally measurable magnetic field has a finite angular bandwidth, with high multipole components being geometrically attenuated and falling below the quantum-limited noise floor. This yields an information-limited spatial scale of order 1 cm1~{\rm cm}1 cm and renders the accessible measurement space effectively finite-dimensional. The energy resolution limit therefore defines an information-theoretic Nyquist scale for magnetoencephalography, beyond which denser spatial sampling provides redundant measurements rather than additional recoverable information. Since the energy resolution limit also makes the noise variance grow linearly with measurement bandwidth, temporal and spatial bandwidths compete, producing a fundamental spatio-temporal trade-off. These results show how quantum-limited measurements constrain the observable complexity and information content of noninvasive brain imaging, providing a quantitative link between fundamental physics and neuroscience.
We discuss the fundamental noise limitations of a ferromagnetic torque sensor based on a levitated magnet in the tipping regime. We evaluate the optimal magnetic field resolution taking into account the thermomechanical noise and the mechanical detection noise at the standard quantum limit. We find that the energy resolution limit, pointed out in recent literature as a relevant benchmark for most classes of magnetometers, can be surpassed by many orders of magnitude. Moreover, similarly to the case of a ferromagnetic gyroscope, it is also possible to surpass the standard quantum limit for magnetometry with independent spins, arising from spin-projection noise. Our finding indicates that magnetomechanical systems optimized for magnetometry can achieve a magnetic field resolution per unit volume several orders of magnitude better than any conventional magnetometer. We discuss possible implications, focusing on fundamental physics problems such as the search for exotic interactions beyond the standard model.
Abstract Quantum sensing provides advanced technologies which significantly improve sensitivity and accuracy for sensing changes of motion, gravity, electric and magnetic field. Therein, quantum sensors for the detection of magnetic fields, so-called quantum magnetometers, are one of the most promising technological realizations. We firstly will provide a brief overview on methods in geophysical exploration benefitting from quantum magnetometers with resolution at the physical and technical limit. We will introduce recent developments on SQUID and OPM based sensors as specific implementations of a quantum magnetometer systems and application examples.
Significance Energy resolution per bandwidth E R is a cross-technology figure of merit that quantifies the combined spatial, temporal, and field resolution of a magnetic sensor. Today’s best-developed magnetometer technologies, including superconducting quantum interference devices, spin-exchange relaxation-free Rb vapors, and nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond, are limited by quantum noise to E R ≳ ℏ . Meanwhile, important sensing applications, e.g., noninvasive discrimination of individual brain events, would be enabled by E R < ℏ . This situation has motivated proposals for sensors operating by new physical principles. Our result, E R = 0.075 ( 16 ) ℏ , far beyond the best possible performance of established sensor technologies, confirms the potential of this class of proposed sensors. The result opens horizons for condensed matter, neuroscience, and tests of fundamental physics.
We demonstrate quantum sensing of dc magnetic fields that exceeds the sensitivity of conventional ${T}_{2}^{\ensuremath{\ast}}$-limited dc magnetometry by more than an order of magnitude. We use nitrogen-vacancy centers in a diamond rotating at periods comparable to the spin coherence time, and characterize the dependence of magnetic sensitivity on measurement time and rotation speed. Our method up-converts only the dc field of interest and preserves the quantum coherence of the sensor. These results definitively improve the sensitivity of a quantum magnetometer to dc fields, demonstrating that sensitivity below the ${T}_{2}^{\ensuremath{\ast}}$ limit is possible and can be applied to any diamond magnetometer where ${T}_{2}\ensuremath{\gg}{T}_{2}^{\ensuremath{\ast}}$ to yield an order-of-magnitude sensitivity improvement.