Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.09154 · Entropy

Operational Constraints in Quantum Otto Engines: Energy-Gap Modulation and Majorization

Sachin Sonkar, Ramandeep S. Johal

Published Jun 12, 2025• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The performance of a quantum Otto engine is analyzed with regard to the constraints on the modulation of energy gaps relative to the changes in probability distributions at the two given heat reservoirs. We performed a detailed analysis with a generic three-level system (3LS), which serves as a non-trivial working medium with two energy gaps. A three-level Otto engine becomes feasible if at least one energy gap shrinks during the first quantum adiabatic stage. The operating regimes are derived for each allowed energy gap modulation, and majorization is observed to play a crucial role in determining the engine operation. This results in an enhanced Otto efficiency when the probability distributions fulfill the majorization condition. Finally, we show that our formalism applies to a swap engine based on a working medium composed of two 3LSs.

DOI
10.3390/e27060625

Related papers

Spin-based quantum Otto engines and majorization

Sachin Sonkar, Ramandeep S. Johal

The concept of majorization is explored as a tool to characterize the performance of a quantum Otto engine in the quasistatic regime. For a working substance in the form of a single spin of arbitrary magnitude, majorization yields a necessary and sufficient condition for the operation of the Otto engine, provided the canonical distribution of the working medium at the hot reservoir is majorized by its canonical distribution at the cold reservoir. We extend our analysis for two scenarios: a three-level atom and a bipartite system consisting of spin 1/2 interacting with an arbitrary spin via an isotropic Heisenberg exchange interaction. For both these cases, we find that while a majorization condition implies positive work extraction, it only yields sufficient conditions for the engine operation. Finally, we study the local thermodynamics of spins in the case of the bipartite system and infer an upper bound on the quantum Otto efficiency using the majorization relation.

arXiv:2210.02402•Physical Review A•Mar 31, 2023•12 citations

Quantum Heat Engines with Complex Working Media, Complete Otto Cycles and Heuristics

Ramandeep S. Johal, Venu Mehta

Quantum thermal machines make use of non-classical thermodynamic resources, one of which include interactions between elements of the quantum working medium. In this paper, we examine the performance of a quasi-static quantum Otto engine based on two spins of arbitrary magnitudes subject to an external magnetic field and coupled via an isotropic Heisenberg exchange interaction. It has been shown earlier that the said interaction provides an enhancement of cycle efficiency, with an upper bound that is tighter than the Carnot efficiency. However, the necessary conditions governing engine performance and the relevant upper bound for efficiency are unknown for the general case of arbitrary spin magnitudes. By analyzing extreme case scenarios, we formulate heuristics to infer the necessary conditions for an engine with uncoupled as well as coupled spin model. These conditions lead us to a connection between performance of quantum heat engines and the notion of majorization. Furthermore, the study of complete Otto cycles inherent in the average cycle also yields interesting insights into the average performance.

arXiv:2107.12302•Entropy•Sep 1, 2021•15 citations

Improving performance of quantum heat engines using modified Otto cycle

B S Revathy, Harsh Sharma, Uma Divakaran

Abstract The efficiency of a quantum heat engine is maximum when the unitary strokes of the quantum Otto cycle are adiabatic. On the other hand, this may not be always possible due to small energy gaps in the system, especially at the critical point (CP) where the gap between the ground state and the first excited state vanishes and the system gets excited. With the aim to regain this lost adiabaticity, we modify one of the unitary strokes of the Otto cycle by allowing the system to first evolve with a time dependent Hamiltonian as in the case of a usual Otto cycle, followed by an additional evolution with a different time independent Hamiltonian so that the system reaches a less excited state. This will help in increasing the magnitude of the heat absorbed from the hot bath so that the work output and efficiency of the engine can be increased. We demonstrate this method using an integrable model and a non-integrable model as the working medium and discuss the generality and limitations of this method. In the case of a two spin system, the optimal value for the time till which the system needs to be freely evolved is calculated analytically in the adiabatic limit. The results show that implementing this modified unitary stroke significantly improves the work output and efficiency of the engine, especially when it crosses the CP.

arXiv:2302.07003•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 28, 2024•4 citations

Efficiency of a quantum Otto heat engine based on a two-level system

Rogério Jorge de Assis

Classical thermodynamics, also called equilibrium thermodynamics, is a theory that deals with macroscopic systems in equilibrium. After its development, other theories emerged to encompass macroscopic out-of-equilibrium systems. Over the past few decades, researchers have developed a new theory to describe also the thermodynamics of microscopic quantum systems, which became known as quantum thermodynamics. An important application of this theory is in the development of heat engines in which the working substance (the substance responsible for transforming heat into work) is a microscopic quantum system. Due to their composition, these devices came to be commonly called quantum heat engines. Notably, recent studies have shown that using an out-of-equilibrium reservoir as a heat source can improve the performance of quantum heat engines, compared to the usual case where the heat source is an equilibrium reservoir (a thermal reservoir). In this context, this thesis presents two studies related to a quantum Otto heat engine whose working substance is a two-level system: in the first study, the engine has a squeezed thermal reservoir as the heat source, while in the second study, the heat source is a reservoir with a negative temperature. Both studies explore the finite-time regime of the expansion and compression stages of the heat engine. The first study shows that the engine efficiency can be greater than the Carnot efficiency in both the quasi-static and finite-time regimes. However, as in the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages degrades the engine efficiency. In its turn, the second study shows that the engine efficiency can surpass the Otto efficiency in the finite-time regime. Here, different from the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages can increase the engine's efficiency. Finally, the present thesis shows an experimental scheme in the nuclear magnetic resonance context able to provide a proof of concept for the engine in the different situations studied.

•Dec 9, 2021•0 citations

Optimal work extraction in measurement-based quantum Otto engines: Non-adiabaticity and generalized measurements can be beneficial

Arunabha Das, Sayan Mondal, Debarupa Saha +1 more

Measurement-based quantum heat engines have attracted significant interest as alternatives to conventional thermal engines, as they replace the hot thermal reservoir with quantum measurements, thereby offering greater controllability and simpler implementation. Motivated by these advantages, we investigate a measurement-driven quantum Otto engine with a qubit working substance and study the optimal work extractable from such engines, including whether their performance can surpass that of conventional quantum Otto cycles. We analyze the engine in both the infinite-time (adiabatic) and finite-time (non-adiabatic) regimes, considering two distinct implementations obtained through optimization over all projection-valued measurements (PVMs) and over all two-outcome positive operator-valued measurements (POVMs). We show that measurement-based engines can outperform conventional quantum Otto engines within specific parameter regimes and that POVM-based engines can yield higher optimal work extraction than PVM-based ones. Furthermore, by incorporating the thermodynamic cost associated with resetting the auxiliary system required for POVM implementation, we demonstrate that the resulting net work output can still exceed that of PVM-based engines under suitable conditions on the spectral gaps and cold bath temperature. We also identify regimes in which non-adiabatic implementations can yield higher work output and efficiency than their adiabatic counterparts. Our study provides operational guidelines for designing improved measurement-driven quantum Otto engines.

quant-pharXiv:2605.22583•May 22, 2026•0 citations

Otto Engine: Classical and Quantum Approach

Francisco J. Peña, Oscar Negrete, Natalia Cortés +1 more

In this paper, we analyze the total work extracted and the efficiency of the magnetic Otto cycle in its classic and quantum versions. As a general result, we found that the work and efficiency of the classical engine is always greater than or equal to its quantum counterpart, independent of the working substance. In the classical case, this is due to the fact that the working substance is always in thermodynamic equilibrium at each point of the cycle, maximizing the energy extracted in the adiabatic paths. We apply this analysis to the case of a two-level system, finding that the work and efficiency in both the Otto's quantum and classical cycles are identical, regardless of the working substance, and we obtain similar results for a multilevel system where a linear relationship between the spectrum of energies of the working substance and the external magnetic field is fulfilled. Finally, we show an example of a three-level system in which we compare two zones in the entropy diagram as a function of temperature and magnetic field to find which is the most efficient region when performing a thermodynamic cycle. This work provides a practical way to look for temperature and magnetic field zones in the entropy diagram that can maximize the power extracted from an Otto magnetic engine.

arXiv:2004.13205•Entropy•Jul 9, 2020•30 citations
The performance of a quantum Otto engine is analyzed with regard to the constraints on the modulation of energy gaps relative to the changes in probability distributions at the two given heat reservoirs. We performed a detailed analysis with a generic three-level system (3LS), which serves as a non-trivial working medium with two energy gaps. A three-level Otto engine becomes feasible if at least one energy gap shrinks during the first quantum adiabatic stage. The operating regimes are derived for each allowed energy gap modulation, and majorization is observed to play a crucial role in determining the engine operation. This results in an enhanced Otto efficiency when the probability distributions fulfill the majorization condition. Finally, we show that our formalism applies to a swap engine based on a working medium composed of two 3LSs.
The concept of majorization is explored as a tool to characterize the performance of a quantum Otto engine in the quasistatic regime. For a working substance in the form of a single spin of arbitrary magnitude, majorization yields a necessary and sufficient condition for the operation of the Otto engine, provided the canonical distribution of the working medium at the hot reservoir is majorized by its canonical distribution at the cold reservoir. We extend our analysis for two scenarios: a three-level atom and a bipartite system consisting of spin 1/2 interacting with an arbitrary spin via an isotropic Heisenberg exchange interaction. For both these cases, we find that while a majorization condition implies positive work extraction, it only yields sufficient conditions for the engine operation. Finally, we study the local thermodynamics of spins in the case of the bipartite system and infer an upper bound on the quantum Otto efficiency using the majorization relation.
Quantum thermal machines make use of non-classical thermodynamic resources, one of which include interactions between elements of the quantum working medium. In this paper, we examine the performance of a quasi-static quantum Otto engine based on two spins of arbitrary magnitudes subject to an external magnetic field and coupled via an isotropic Heisenberg exchange interaction. It has been shown earlier that the said interaction provides an enhancement of cycle efficiency, with an upper bound that is tighter than the Carnot efficiency. However, the necessary conditions governing engine performance and the relevant upper bound for efficiency are unknown for the general case of arbitrary spin magnitudes. By analyzing extreme case scenarios, we formulate heuristics to infer the necessary conditions for an engine with uncoupled as well as coupled spin model. These conditions lead us to a connection between performance of quantum heat engines and the notion of majorization. Furthermore, the study of complete Otto cycles inherent in the average cycle also yields interesting insights into the average performance.
Abstract The efficiency of a quantum heat engine is maximum when the unitary strokes of the quantum Otto cycle are adiabatic. On the other hand, this may not be always possible due to small energy gaps in the system, especially at the critical point (CP) where the gap between the ground state and the first excited state vanishes and the system gets excited. With the aim to regain this lost adiabaticity, we modify one of the unitary strokes of the Otto cycle by allowing the system to first evolve with a time dependent Hamiltonian as in the case of a usual Otto cycle, followed by an additional evolution with a different time independent Hamiltonian so that the system reaches a less excited state. This will help in increasing the magnitude of the heat absorbed from the hot bath so that the work output and efficiency of the engine can be increased. We demonstrate this method using an integrable model and a non-integrable model as the working medium and discuss the generality and limitations of this method. In the case of a two spin system, the optimal value for the time till which the system needs to be freely evolved is calculated analytically in the adiabatic limit. The results show that implementing this modified unitary stroke significantly improves the work output and efficiency of the engine, especially when it crosses the CP.
Classical thermodynamics, also called equilibrium thermodynamics, is a theory that deals with macroscopic systems in equilibrium. After its development, other theories emerged to encompass macroscopic out-of-equilibrium systems. Over the past few decades, researchers have developed a new theory to describe also the thermodynamics of microscopic quantum systems, which became known as quantum thermodynamics. An important application of this theory is in the development of heat engines in which the working substance (the substance responsible for transforming heat into work) is a microscopic quantum system. Due to their composition, these devices came to be commonly called quantum heat engines. Notably, recent studies have shown that using an out-of-equilibrium reservoir as a heat source can improve the performance of quantum heat engines, compared to the usual case where the heat source is an equilibrium reservoir (a thermal reservoir). In this context, this thesis presents two studies related to a quantum Otto heat engine whose working substance is a two-level system: in the first study, the engine has a squeezed thermal reservoir as the heat source, while in the second study, the heat source is a reservoir with a negative temperature. Both studies explore the finite-time regime of the expansion and compression stages of the heat engine. The first study shows that the engine efficiency can be greater than the Carnot efficiency in both the quasi-static and finite-time regimes. However, as in the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages degrades the engine efficiency. In its turn, the second study shows that the engine efficiency can surpass the Otto efficiency in the finite-time regime. Here, different from the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages can increase the engine's efficiency. Finally, the present thesis shows an experimental scheme in the nuclear magnetic resonance context able to provide a proof of concept for the engine in the different situations studied.
Measurement-based quantum heat engines have attracted significant interest as alternatives to conventional thermal engines, as they replace the hot thermal reservoir with quantum measurements, thereby offering greater controllability and simpler implementation. Motivated by these advantages, we investigate a measurement-driven quantum Otto engine with a qubit working substance and study the optimal work extractable from such engines, including whether their performance can surpass that of conventional quantum Otto cycles. We analyze the engine in both the infinite-time (adiabatic) and finite-time (non-adiabatic) regimes, considering two distinct implementations obtained through optimization over all projection-valued measurements (PVMs) and over all two-outcome positive operator-valued measurements (POVMs). We show that measurement-based engines can outperform conventional quantum Otto engines within specific parameter regimes and that POVM-based engines can yield higher optimal work extraction than PVM-based ones. Furthermore, by incorporating the thermodynamic cost associated with resetting the auxiliary system required for POVM implementation, we demonstrate that the resulting net work output can still exceed that of PVM-based engines under suitable conditions on the spectral gaps and cold bath temperature. We also identify regimes in which non-adiabatic implementations can yield higher work output and efficiency than their adiabatic counterparts. Our study provides operational guidelines for designing improved measurement-driven quantum Otto engines.
In this paper, we analyze the total work extracted and the efficiency of the magnetic Otto cycle in its classic and quantum versions. As a general result, we found that the work and efficiency of the classical engine is always greater than or equal to its quantum counterpart, independent of the working substance. In the classical case, this is due to the fact that the working substance is always in thermodynamic equilibrium at each point of the cycle, maximizing the energy extracted in the adiabatic paths. We apply this analysis to the case of a two-level system, finding that the work and efficiency in both the Otto's quantum and classical cycles are identical, regardless of the working substance, and we obtain similar results for a multilevel system where a linear relationship between the spectrum of energies of the working substance and the external magnetic field is fulfilled. Finally, we show an example of a three-level system in which we compare two zones in the entropy diagram as a function of temperature and magnetic field to find which is the most efficient region when performing a thermodynamic cycle. This work provides a practical way to look for temperature and magnetic field zones in the entropy diagram that can maximize the power extracted from an Otto magnetic engine.