Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2004.13205 · Entropy

Otto Engine: Classical and Quantum Approach

Francisco J. Peña, Oscar Negrete, Natalia Cortés, Patricio F. Vargas

Published Jul 9, 2020• 30 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we analyze the total work extracted and the efficiency of the magnetic Otto cycle in its classic and quantum versions. As a general result, we found that the work and efficiency of the classical engine is always greater than or equal to its quantum counterpart, independent of the working substance. In the classical case, this is due to the fact that the working substance is always in thermodynamic equilibrium at each point of the cycle, maximizing the energy extracted in the adiabatic paths. We apply this analysis to the case of a two-level system, finding that the work and efficiency in both the Otto's quantum and classical cycles are identical, regardless of the working substance, and we obtain similar results for a multilevel system where a linear relationship between the spectrum of energies of the working substance and the external magnetic field is fulfilled. Finally, we show an example of a three-level system in which we compare two zones in the entropy diagram as a function of temperature and magnetic field to find which is the most efficient region when performing a thermodynamic cycle. This work provides a practical way to look for temperature and magnetic field zones in the entropy diagram that can maximize the power extracted from an Otto magnetic engine.

DOI
10.3390/e22070755

Related papers

Comparative study of quantum Otto and Carnot engines powered by a spin working substance

Mahmoud Youssef Abd‐Rabbou, Atta Ur Rahman, Mikhail A. Yurischev +1 more

Quantum Otto and Carnot engines have recently been receiving attention due to their ability to achieve high efficiencies and powers based on the laws of quantum mechanics. This paper discusses the theory, progress, and possible applications of quantum Otto and Carnot engines, such as energy production, cooling, and nanoscale technologies. In particular, we investigate a two-spin Heisenberg system that works as a substance in quantum Otto and Carnot cycles while exposed to an external magnetic field with both Dzyaloshinsky-Moriya and dipole-dipole interactions. The four stages of engine cycles are subject to analysis with respect to the heat exchanges that occur between the hot and cold reservoirs, alongside the work done during each stage. The operating conditions of the heat engine, refrigerator, thermal accelerator, and heater are all achieved. Moreover, our results demonstrate that the laws of thermodynamics are strictly upheld and the Carnot cycle produces more useful work than that of the Otto cycle.

Physical review. E•Sep 7, 2023•34 citations

Efficiency of a quantum Otto heat engine based on a two-level system

Rogério Jorge de Assis

Classical thermodynamics, also called equilibrium thermodynamics, is a theory that deals with macroscopic systems in equilibrium. After its development, other theories emerged to encompass macroscopic out-of-equilibrium systems. Over the past few decades, researchers have developed a new theory to describe also the thermodynamics of microscopic quantum systems, which became known as quantum thermodynamics. An important application of this theory is in the development of heat engines in which the working substance (the substance responsible for transforming heat into work) is a microscopic quantum system. Due to their composition, these devices came to be commonly called quantum heat engines. Notably, recent studies have shown that using an out-of-equilibrium reservoir as a heat source can improve the performance of quantum heat engines, compared to the usual case where the heat source is an equilibrium reservoir (a thermal reservoir). In this context, this thesis presents two studies related to a quantum Otto heat engine whose working substance is a two-level system: in the first study, the engine has a squeezed thermal reservoir as the heat source, while in the second study, the heat source is a reservoir with a negative temperature. Both studies explore the finite-time regime of the expansion and compression stages of the heat engine. The first study shows that the engine efficiency can be greater than the Carnot efficiency in both the quasi-static and finite-time regimes. However, as in the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages degrades the engine efficiency. In its turn, the second study shows that the engine efficiency can surpass the Otto efficiency in the finite-time regime. Here, different from the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages can increase the engine's efficiency. Finally, the present thesis shows an experimental scheme in the nuclear magnetic resonance context able to provide a proof of concept for the engine in the different situations studied.

•Dec 9, 2021•0 citations

Light-matter quantum Otto engine in finite time

G. Alvarado Barrios, F. Albarrán-Arriagada, Francisco J. Peña +2 more

We study a quantum Otto engine at finite time, where the working substance is composed of a two-level system interacting with a harmonic oscillator, described by the quantum Rabi model. We obtain the limit cycle and calculate the total work extracted, efficiency, and power of the engine by numerically solving the master equation describing the open system dynamics. We relate the total work extracted and the efficiency at maximum power with the quantum correlations embedded in the working substance, which we consider through entanglement of formation and quantum discord. Interestingly, we find that the engine can overcome the Curzon-Ahlborn efficiency when the working substance is in the ultrastrong coupling regime. This high-efficiency regime roughly coincides with the cases where the entanglement in the working substance experiences the greatest reduction in the hot isochoric stage. Our results highlight the efficiency performance of correlated working substances for quantum heat engines.

arXiv:2102.10559•Feb 21, 2021•8 citations

Efficiency at maximum power of a heat engine working with a two-level atomic system

Rui Wang, Jianhui Wang, Jizhou He +1 more

We consider the finite-time operation of a quantum heat engine whose working substance is composed of a two-level atomic system. The engine cycle, consisting of two quantum adiabatic and two quantum isochoric (constant-frequency) processes and working between two heat reservoirs at temperatures ${T}_{h}$ and ${T}_{c}$$(<$${T}_{h})$, is a quantum version of the classical Otto cycle. By optimizing the power output with respect to two frequencies, we obtain the efficiency at maximum power output (EMP) and analyze numerically the effects of the times taken for two adiabatic and two isochoric processes on the EMP. In the absence of internally dissipative friction, we find that the EMP is bounded from the upper side by a function of the Carnot efficiency ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}$, ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{+}={\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}^{2}/[{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}\ensuremath{-}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})\mathrm{ln}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})]$, with ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}=1\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}/{T}_{h}$. This analytic expression is confirmed by our exact numerical result and is identical to the one derived in an engine model based on a mesoscopic or macroscopic system. If the internal friction is included, we find that the EMP decreases as the friction coefficient increases.

Physical Review E•Apr 23, 2013•77 citations

Quantum Performance of Thermal Machines over Many Cycles

Gentaro Watanabe A, B. Prasanna Venkatesh, Peter Talkner A +1 more

The performance of quantum heat engines is generally based on the analysis of a single cycle. We challenge this approach by showing that the total work performed by a quantum engine need not be proportional to the number of cycles. Furthermore, optimizing the engine over multiple cycles leads to the identification of scenarios with a quantum enhancement. We demonstrate our findings with a quantum Otto engine based on a two-level system as the working substance that supplies power to an external oscillator.

arXiv:1612.05586•Physical Review Letters•Feb 2, 2017•103 citations

Measurement-based quantum heat engine in a multilevel system

Maron F. Anka, Thiago Rodrigues de Oliveira, Daniel Jonathan

We compare quantum Otto engines based on two different cycle models: a two-bath model, with a standard heat source and sink, and a measurement-based protocol, where the role of heat source is played by a quantum measurement. We furthermore study these cycles using two different "working substances": a single qutrit (spin-1 particle) or a pair of qubits (spin-1/2 particles) interacting via the XXZ Heisenberg interaction. Although both cycle models have the same efficiency when applied on a single-qubit working substance, we find that both can reach higher efficiencies using these more complex working substances by exploiting the existence of "idle" levels, i.e., levels that do not shift while the spins are subjected to a variable magnetic field. Furthermore, with an appropriate choice of measurement, the measurement-based protocol becomes more efficient than the two-bath model.

arXiv:2108.02229•Physical review. E•Nov 23, 2021•46 citations
In this paper, we analyze the total work extracted and the efficiency of the magnetic Otto cycle in its classic and quantum versions. As a general result, we found that the work and efficiency of the classical engine is always greater than or equal to its quantum counterpart, independent of the working substance. In the classical case, this is due to the fact that the working substance is always in thermodynamic equilibrium at each point of the cycle, maximizing the energy extracted in the adiabatic paths. We apply this analysis to the case of a two-level system, finding that the work and efficiency in both the Otto's quantum and classical cycles are identical, regardless of the working substance, and we obtain similar results for a multilevel system where a linear relationship between the spectrum of energies of the working substance and the external magnetic field is fulfilled. Finally, we show an example of a three-level system in which we compare two zones in the entropy diagram as a function of temperature and magnetic field to find which is the most efficient region when performing a thermodynamic cycle. This work provides a practical way to look for temperature and magnetic field zones in the entropy diagram that can maximize the power extracted from an Otto magnetic engine.
Quantum Otto and Carnot engines have recently been receiving attention due to their ability to achieve high efficiencies and powers based on the laws of quantum mechanics. This paper discusses the theory, progress, and possible applications of quantum Otto and Carnot engines, such as energy production, cooling, and nanoscale technologies. In particular, we investigate a two-spin Heisenberg system that works as a substance in quantum Otto and Carnot cycles while exposed to an external magnetic field with both Dzyaloshinsky-Moriya and dipole-dipole interactions. The four stages of engine cycles are subject to analysis with respect to the heat exchanges that occur between the hot and cold reservoirs, alongside the work done during each stage. The operating conditions of the heat engine, refrigerator, thermal accelerator, and heater are all achieved. Moreover, our results demonstrate that the laws of thermodynamics are strictly upheld and the Carnot cycle produces more useful work than that of the Otto cycle.
Classical thermodynamics, also called equilibrium thermodynamics, is a theory that deals with macroscopic systems in equilibrium. After its development, other theories emerged to encompass macroscopic out-of-equilibrium systems. Over the past few decades, researchers have developed a new theory to describe also the thermodynamics of microscopic quantum systems, which became known as quantum thermodynamics. An important application of this theory is in the development of heat engines in which the working substance (the substance responsible for transforming heat into work) is a microscopic quantum system. Due to their composition, these devices came to be commonly called quantum heat engines. Notably, recent studies have shown that using an out-of-equilibrium reservoir as a heat source can improve the performance of quantum heat engines, compared to the usual case where the heat source is an equilibrium reservoir (a thermal reservoir). In this context, this thesis presents two studies related to a quantum Otto heat engine whose working substance is a two-level system: in the first study, the engine has a squeezed thermal reservoir as the heat source, while in the second study, the heat source is a reservoir with a negative temperature. Both studies explore the finite-time regime of the expansion and compression stages of the heat engine. The first study shows that the engine efficiency can be greater than the Carnot efficiency in both the quasi-static and finite-time regimes. However, as in the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages degrades the engine efficiency. In its turn, the second study shows that the engine efficiency can surpass the Otto efficiency in the finite-time regime. Here, different from the usual case, decreasing the time of the expansion and compression stages can increase the engine's efficiency. Finally, the present thesis shows an experimental scheme in the nuclear magnetic resonance context able to provide a proof of concept for the engine in the different situations studied.
We study a quantum Otto engine at finite time, where the working substance is composed of a two-level system interacting with a harmonic oscillator, described by the quantum Rabi model. We obtain the limit cycle and calculate the total work extracted, efficiency, and power of the engine by numerically solving the master equation describing the open system dynamics. We relate the total work extracted and the efficiency at maximum power with the quantum correlations embedded in the working substance, which we consider through entanglement of formation and quantum discord. Interestingly, we find that the engine can overcome the Curzon-Ahlborn efficiency when the working substance is in the ultrastrong coupling regime. This high-efficiency regime roughly coincides with the cases where the entanglement in the working substance experiences the greatest reduction in the hot isochoric stage. Our results highlight the efficiency performance of correlated working substances for quantum heat engines.
We consider the finite-time operation of a quantum heat engine whose working substance is composed of a two-level atomic system. The engine cycle, consisting of two quantum adiabatic and two quantum isochoric (constant-frequency) processes and working between two heat reservoirs at temperatures Th{T}_{h}Th​ and Tc{T}_{c}Tc​(<(<(<Th){T}_{h})Th​), is a quantum version of the classical Otto cycle. By optimizing the power output with respect to two frequencies, we obtain the efficiency at maximum power output (EMP) and analyze numerically the effects of the times taken for two adiabatic and two isochoric processes on the EMP. In the absence of internally dissipative friction, we find that the EMP is bounded from the upper side by a function of the Carnot efficiency ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}$, ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{+}={\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}^{2}/[{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}\ensuremath{-}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})\mathrm{ln}(1\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C})]$, with ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{C}=1\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c}/{T}_{h}$. This analytic expression is confirmed by our exact numerical result and is identical to the one derived in an engine model based on a mesoscopic or macroscopic system. If the internal friction is included, we find that the EMP decreases as the friction coefficient increases.
The performance of quantum heat engines is generally based on the analysis of a single cycle. We challenge this approach by showing that the total work performed by a quantum engine need not be proportional to the number of cycles. Furthermore, optimizing the engine over multiple cycles leads to the identification of scenarios with a quantum enhancement. We demonstrate our findings with a quantum Otto engine based on a two-level system as the working substance that supplies power to an external oscillator.
We compare quantum Otto engines based on two different cycle models: a two-bath model, with a standard heat source and sink, and a measurement-based protocol, where the role of heat source is played by a quantum measurement. We furthermore study these cycles using two different "working substances": a single qutrit (spin-1 particle) or a pair of qubits (spin-1/2 particles) interacting via the XXZ Heisenberg interaction. Although both cycle models have the same efficiency when applied on a single-qubit working substance, we find that both can reach higher efficiencies using these more complex working substances by exploiting the existence of "idle" levels, i.e., levels that do not shift while the spins are subjected to a variable magnetic field. Furthermore, with an appropriate choice of measurement, the measurement-based protocol becomes more efficient than the two-bath model.