Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2311.06606

Comment on "Continuous simultaneous measurement of position and momentum of a particle"

Adélcio C. Oliveira

Published Nov 11, 2023• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent paper, [Gampel, F. and Gajda, M., Phys. Rev. A 107, 012420, (2023)], the authors claimed they are proposing a new model to explain the existence of classical trajectories in the quantum domain. The idea is based on simultaneous position and momentum measurements and a "jump Markov process". Consequently, they have interpreted the emergence of classical trajectories as sets of detection events. They successfully implemented the model for a free particle and for one under a harmonic potential. Here, we show that the continuous observation limit is a realization of a coherent semiclassical expansion; Also, as has already been demonstrated, the jump process is not necessary and is not observable. In other words, the collapse, as they propose, is a non-go theorem; even if it is real, it can not be measured under the needed assumptions to obtain Newtonian classical dynamics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2311.06606

Related papers

Continuous simultaneous measurement of position and momentum of a particle

Filip Gampel, Mariusz Gajda

We formulate a model of a quantum particle continuously monitored by detectors measuring simultaneously its position and momentum. We implement the postulate of wave-function collapse by assuming that upon detection the particle is found in one of the meters' states chosen as a discrete subset of coherent states. The dynamics, as observed by the meters, is thus a random sequence of jumps between coherent states. We generate such trajectories using the quantum Monte Carlo wave-function method. For sparsely distributed detectors, we use methods from renewal theory of stochastic processes to obtain some semianalytic results. In particular, the different regimes of dynamics of the free particle are identified and quantitatively discussed: from stroboscopic motion in the case of low interrogation frequency, to delayed dynamics reminiscent of the Zeno effect if monitoring is frequent. For a semicontinuous spatial distribution of meters the emergence of classical trajectories is shown. Their statistical properties are discussed and compared to other detection schemes in which the operation on the system due to measurement corresponds to ``spatial filtering'' of the wave function.

arXiv:2209.01612•Physical Review A•Jan 20, 2023•14 citations

Comment on ‘‘Why quantum mechanics cannot be formulated as a Markov process’’

Piotr Garbaczewski, Robert Olkiewicz

In the paper with the above-noted title, D. T. Gillespie [Phys. Rev. A 49, 1607 (1994)] claims that the theory of Markov stochastic processes cannot provide an adequate mathematical framework for quantum mechanics. In conjunction with the specific quantum dynamics considered there, we give a general analysis of the associated dichotomic jump processes. If we assume that Gillespie's ``measurement probabilities'' are the transition probabilities of a stochastic process, then the process must have an invariant (time independent) probability measure. Alternatively, if we demand the probability measure of the process follow the quantally implemented (via the Born statistical postulate) evolution, then we arrive at the jump process which can be interpreted as a Markov process if restricted to a suitable duration time. However, there is no corresponding Markov process consistent with the ${\mathit{Z}}_{2}$ event space assumption, if we require its existence for all times t\ensuremath{\in}${\mathbf{R}}_{+}$. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

arXiv:quant-ph/9601016•Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1996•6 citations

Back to Bohr: Quantum Jumps in Schrödinger’s Wave Mechanics

Rainer Dick

The measurement problem of quantum mechanics concerns the question as to under which circumstances coherent wave evolution becomes disrupted to produce eigenstates of observables, instead of evolving superpositions of eigenstates. The problem already needs to be addressed within wave mechanics, before second quantization, because low-energy interactions can be dominated by particle-preserving potential interactions. We discuss a scattering array of harmonic oscillators, which can detect particles penetrating the array through interaction with a short-range potential. Evolution of the wave function of scattered particles, combined with Heisenberg’s assertion that quantum jumps persist in wave mechanics, indicates that the wave function will collapse around single oscillator sites if the scattering is inelastic, while it will not collapse around single sites for elastic scattering. The Born rule for position observation is then equivalent to the statement that the wave function for inelastic scattering amounts to an epistemic superposition of possible scattering states, in the sense that it describes a sum of probability amplitudes for inelastic scattering off different scattering centers, whereas, at most, one inelastic scattering event can happen at any moment in time. Within this epistemic interpretation of the wave function, the actual underlying inelastic scattering event corresponds to a quantum jump, whereas the continuously evolving wave function only describes the continuous evolution of probability amplitudes for scattering off different sites. Quantum jumps then yield definite position observations, as defined by the spatial resolution of the oscillator array.

arXiv:2406.11005•Quantum Reports•Jul 19, 2024•2 citations

Transition to classical chaos in a coupled quantum system through continuous measurement

Shohini Ghose, Paul M. Alsing, Ivan Deutsch +2 more

Continuous observation of a quantum system yields a measurement record that faithfully reproduces the classically predicted trajectory provided that the measurement is sufficiently strong to localize the state in phase space but weak enough that quantum backaction noise is negligible. We investigate the conditions under which classical dynamics emerges, via a continuous position measurement, for a particle moving in a harmonic well with its position coupled to internal spin. As a consequence of this coupling, we find that classical dynamics emerges only when the position and spin actions are both large compared to $\ensuremath{\hbar}$. These conditions are quantified by placing bounds on the size of the covariance matrix which describes the delocalized quantum coherence over extended regions of phase space. From this result, it follows that a mixed quantum-classical regime (where one subsystem can be treated classically and the other not) does not exist for a continuously observed spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ particle. When the conditions for classicality are satisfied (in the large-spin limit), the quantum trajectories reproduce both the classical periodic orbits as well as the classically chaotic phase space regions. As a quantitative test of this convergence, we compute the largest Lyapunov exponent directly from the measured quantum trajectories and show that it agrees with the classical value.

arXiv:quant-ph/0309093•Physical Review A•May 24, 2004•31 citations

Objective trajectories in hybrid classical-quantum dynamics

Jonathan Oppenheim, Carlo Sparaciari, Barbara Šoda +1 more

Consistent dynamics which couples classical and quantum degrees of freedom exists, provided it is stochastic. This dynamics is linear in the hybrid state, completely positive and trace preserving. One application of this is to study the back-reaction of quantum fields on space-time which does not suffer from the pathologies of the semi-classical equations. Here we introduce several toy models in which to study hybrid classical-quantum evolution, including a qubit coupled to a particle in a potential, and a quantum harmonic oscillator coupled to a classical one. We present an unravelling approach to calculate the dynamics, and provide code to numerically simulate it. Unlike the purely quantum case, the trajectories (or histories) of this unravelling can be unique, conditioned on the classical degrees of freedom for discrete realisations of the dynamics, when different jumps in the classical degrees of freedom are accompanied by the action of unique operators on the quantum system. As a result, the “measurement postulate'' of quantum theory is not needed; quantum systems become classical because they interact with a fundamentally classical field.

arXiv:2011.06009•Quantum•Jan 3, 2023•39 citations

On Repeated Measurements of a Quantum Particle in a Harmonic Potential

Filip Gampel, Mariusz Gajda

We study the evolution of a quantum particle in a harmonic potential whose position and momentum are repeatedly monitored. A back-action of measuring devices is accounted for. Our model utilizes a generalized measurement corresponding to the positive operator-valued measure. We assume that upon measurement, the particle's wavefunction is projected onto one of the possible detector states depending on the observed result. We chose these post-measurement states to be moving Gaussian wavepackets. The wavefunction quantum Monte Carlo formalism is used to simulate single quantum trajectories of the particle. We show how classical trajectories emerge in the course of observation and study in detail the dispersion of position and momentum of the particle.

arXiv:2306.08342•Acta Physica Polonica A•Jun 1, 2023•1 citation
In a recent paper, [Gampel, F. and Gajda, M., Phys. Rev. A 107, 012420, (2023)], the authors claimed they are proposing a new model to explain the existence of classical trajectories in the quantum domain. The idea is based on simultaneous position and momentum measurements and a "jump Markov process". Consequently, they have interpreted the emergence of classical trajectories as sets of detection events. They successfully implemented the model for a free particle and for one under a harmonic potential. Here, we show that the continuous observation limit is a realization of a coherent semiclassical expansion; Also, as has already been demonstrated, the jump process is not necessary and is not observable. In other words, the collapse, as they propose, is a non-go theorem; even if it is real, it can not be measured under the needed assumptions to obtain Newtonian classical dynamics.
We formulate a model of a quantum particle continuously monitored by detectors measuring simultaneously its position and momentum. We implement the postulate of wave-function collapse by assuming that upon detection the particle is found in one of the meters' states chosen as a discrete subset of coherent states. The dynamics, as observed by the meters, is thus a random sequence of jumps between coherent states. We generate such trajectories using the quantum Monte Carlo wave-function method. For sparsely distributed detectors, we use methods from renewal theory of stochastic processes to obtain some semianalytic results. In particular, the different regimes of dynamics of the free particle are identified and quantitatively discussed: from stroboscopic motion in the case of low interrogation frequency, to delayed dynamics reminiscent of the Zeno effect if monitoring is frequent. For a semicontinuous spatial distribution of meters the emergence of classical trajectories is shown. Their statistical properties are discussed and compared to other detection schemes in which the operation on the system due to measurement corresponds to ``spatial filtering'' of the wave function.
In the paper with the above-noted title, D. T. Gillespie [Phys. Rev. A 49, 1607 (1994)] claims that the theory of Markov stochastic processes cannot provide an adequate mathematical framework for quantum mechanics. In conjunction with the specific quantum dynamics considered there, we give a general analysis of the associated dichotomic jump processes. If we assume that Gillespie's ``measurement probabilities'' are the transition probabilities of a stochastic process, then the process must have an invariant (time independent) probability measure. Alternatively, if we demand the probability measure of the process follow the quantally implemented (via the Born statistical postulate) evolution, then we arrive at the jump process which can be interpreted as a Markov process if restricted to a suitable duration time. However, there is no corresponding Markov process consistent with the Z2{\mathit{Z}}_{2}Z2​ event space assumption, if we require its existence for all times t\ensuremath{\in}R+{\mathbf{R}}_{+}R+​. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
The measurement problem of quantum mechanics concerns the question as to under which circumstances coherent wave evolution becomes disrupted to produce eigenstates of observables, instead of evolving superpositions of eigenstates. The problem already needs to be addressed within wave mechanics, before second quantization, because low-energy interactions can be dominated by particle-preserving potential interactions. We discuss a scattering array of harmonic oscillators, which can detect particles penetrating the array through interaction with a short-range potential. Evolution of the wave function of scattered particles, combined with Heisenberg’s assertion that quantum jumps persist in wave mechanics, indicates that the wave function will collapse around single oscillator sites if the scattering is inelastic, while it will not collapse around single sites for elastic scattering. The Born rule for position observation is then equivalent to the statement that the wave function for inelastic scattering amounts to an epistemic superposition of possible scattering states, in the sense that it describes a sum of probability amplitudes for inelastic scattering off different scattering centers, whereas, at most, one inelastic scattering event can happen at any moment in time. Within this epistemic interpretation of the wave function, the actual underlying inelastic scattering event corresponds to a quantum jump, whereas the continuously evolving wave function only describes the continuous evolution of probability amplitudes for scattering off different sites. Quantum jumps then yield definite position observations, as defined by the spatial resolution of the oscillator array.
Continuous observation of a quantum system yields a measurement record that faithfully reproduces the classically predicted trajectory provided that the measurement is sufficiently strong to localize the state in phase space but weak enough that quantum backaction noise is negligible. We investigate the conditions under which classical dynamics emerges, via a continuous position measurement, for a particle moving in a harmonic well with its position coupled to internal spin. As a consequence of this coupling, we find that classical dynamics emerges only when the position and spin actions are both large compared to $\ensuremath{\hbar}$. These conditions are quantified by placing bounds on the size of the covariance matrix which describes the delocalized quantum coherence over extended regions of phase space. From this result, it follows that a mixed quantum-classical regime (where one subsystem can be treated classically and the other not) does not exist for a continuously observed spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ particle. When the conditions for classicality are satisfied (in the large-spin limit), the quantum trajectories reproduce both the classical periodic orbits as well as the classically chaotic phase space regions. As a quantitative test of this convergence, we compute the largest Lyapunov exponent directly from the measured quantum trajectories and show that it agrees with the classical value.
Consistent dynamics which couples classical and quantum degrees of freedom exists, provided it is stochastic. This dynamics is linear in the hybrid state, completely positive and trace preserving. One application of this is to study the back-reaction of quantum fields on space-time which does not suffer from the pathologies of the semi-classical equations. Here we introduce several toy models in which to study hybrid classical-quantum evolution, including a qubit coupled to a particle in a potential, and a quantum harmonic oscillator coupled to a classical one. We present an unravelling approach to calculate the dynamics, and provide code to numerically simulate it. Unlike the purely quantum case, the trajectories (or histories) of this unravelling can be unique, conditioned on the classical degrees of freedom for discrete realisations of the dynamics, when different jumps in the classical degrees of freedom are accompanied by the action of unique operators on the quantum system. As a result, the “measurement postulate'' of quantum theory is not needed; quantum systems become classical because they interact with a fundamentally classical field.
We study the evolution of a quantum particle in a harmonic potential whose position and momentum are repeatedly monitored. A back-action of measuring devices is accounted for. Our model utilizes a generalized measurement corresponding to the positive operator-valued measure. We assume that upon measurement, the particle's wavefunction is projected onto one of the possible detector states depending on the observed result. We chose these post-measurement states to be moving Gaussian wavepackets. The wavefunction quantum Monte Carlo formalism is used to simulate single quantum trajectories of the particle. We show how classical trajectories emerge in the course of observation and study in detail the dispersion of position and momentum of the particle.