Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2209.01612 · Physical Review A

Continuous simultaneous measurement of position and momentum of a particle

Filip Gampel, Mariusz Gajda

Published Jan 20, 2023• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We formulate a model of a quantum particle continuously monitored by detectors measuring simultaneously its position and momentum. We implement the postulate of wave-function collapse by assuming that upon detection the particle is found in one of the meters' states chosen as a discrete subset of coherent states. The dynamics, as observed by the meters, is thus a random sequence of jumps between coherent states. We generate such trajectories using the quantum Monte Carlo wave-function method. For sparsely distributed detectors, we use methods from renewal theory of stochastic processes to obtain some semianalytic results. In particular, the different regimes of dynamics of the free particle are identified and quantitatively discussed: from stroboscopic motion in the case of low interrogation frequency, to delayed dynamics reminiscent of the Zeno effect if monitoring is frequent. For a semicontinuous spatial distribution of meters the emergence of classical trajectories is shown. Their statistical properties are discussed and compared to other detection schemes in which the operation on the system due to measurement corresponds to ``spatial filtering'' of the wave function.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.107.012420

Related papers

Comment on "Continuous simultaneous measurement of position and momentum of a particle"

Adélcio C. Oliveira

In a recent paper, [Gampel, F. and Gajda, M., Phys. Rev. A 107, 012420, (2023)], the authors claimed they are proposing a new model to explain the existence of classical trajectories in the quantum domain. The idea is based on simultaneous position and momentum measurements and a "jump Markov process". Consequently, they have interpreted the emergence of classical trajectories as sets of detection events. They successfully implemented the model for a free particle and for one under a harmonic potential. Here, we show that the continuous observation limit is a realization of a coherent semiclassical expansion; Also, as has already been demonstrated, the jump process is not necessary and is not observable. In other words, the collapse, as they propose, is a non-go theorem; even if it is real, it can not be measured under the needed assumptions to obtain Newtonian classical dynamics.

arXiv:2311.06606•Nov 11, 2023•0 citations

Continuous position measurements and the quantum Zeno effect

M. J. Gagen, Howard M. Wiseman, Gerard J Milburn

We present a model of continuous (in time) position measurements on a quantum system using a single pseudoclassical meter. The nonselective evolution of the system is described by a master equation which is identical to that obtained from previous models. The selective evolution is described by a stochastic nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation. The significance of this equation is that the stochastic term has a physical interpretaion. By carefully choosing the parameters which define the meter and the system-meter coupling, we obtain a meter pointer with well-defined position which undergoes fluctuations. This ``jitter'' in the pointer position gives rise to the stochastic dynamical collapse of the system wave function. By the inclusion of feedback on the meter, the pointer is made to relax towards an appropriate readout. We apply this model to the selective measurement of the position of a particle in a double-well potential. In contrast to a recent claim [H. Fearn and W. E. Lamb, Jr., Phys. Rev. A 46, 1199 (1992)] we show that truly continuous position measurements lead to a quantum Zeno effect in certain parameter regimes. This is manifest by the changing of the particle dynamics from coherent tunneling between the well minima to incoherent flipping, as in a random telegraph. As the measurement strength increases, the average length of time the particle remains stuck in one well increases proportionally.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1993•82 citations

On Repeated Measurements of a Quantum Particle in a Harmonic Potential

Filip Gampel, Mariusz Gajda

We study the evolution of a quantum particle in a harmonic potential whose position and momentum are repeatedly monitored. A back-action of measuring devices is accounted for. Our model utilizes a generalized measurement corresponding to the positive operator-valued measure. We assume that upon measurement, the particle's wavefunction is projected onto one of the possible detector states depending on the observed result. We chose these post-measurement states to be moving Gaussian wavepackets. The wavefunction quantum Monte Carlo formalism is used to simulate single quantum trajectories of the particle. We show how classical trajectories emerge in the course of observation and study in detail the dispersion of position and momentum of the particle.

arXiv:2306.08342•Acta Physica Polonica A•Jun 1, 2023•1 citation

Quantum measurement theory and the quantum Zeno effect

M. J. Gagen

This is a theoretical thesis in the area of quantum measurement theory. Due to the extensive breadth of this field we choose to narrow our focus to examine a particular problem - the quantum Zeno effect (defined below). Quantum measurement theory is introduced in Chap. 1, using the terminology of effects and operations. This approach allows an operational definition of such terms as a state vector, an ensemble, and a measurement device (for instance), and a consideration of interactions between quantum systems and inaccurate measurement devices. We further introduce the quantum trajectories approach to consider the evolution of an individual quantum system subject to measurement. The quantum Zeno effect is introduced in Chap. 2. Any quantum treatment of a measurement interaction must consider the measurement backaction onto the measured system and this backaction will disrupt the free evolution of the system. The quantum Zeno effect occurs in the strong measurement limit where the measurement backaction totally freezes the evolution of the system, thus rendering the measurement useless. The effect is introduced via projective measurements of two level systems subject to measurement of level populations. At this stage we are able to discuss the main questions addressed by this thesis, and present its structure in Chap. 2. We then develop a new measurement model for the interaction between a system and a measurement device in Chap. 3. Our motivation in doing this is to better model the usual laboratory meter, and in our approach the meter dynamics are such that it relaxes towards an appropriate readout of the system parameter of interest. The irreducible quantum noise of the meter introduces fluctuations that drive the stochastic dynamical collapse of the system wavefunction. In our model, the measured system dynamics (if treated selectively) are described by a stochastic, nonlinear Schroedinger equation. A double well system subject to position measurement provides a natural first application for this model. This is done in Chap. 4 where we monitor the coherent tunnelling of a particle from one well to the other. The advantage afforded by considering this system is that it displays differing regimes where the measurement observable (position) is approximated as possessing either, respectively, a continuous or a discrete eigenvalue structure. Thus, we use this one model to explore the quantum Zeno effect in both measurement regimes. The above treatment is of a theoretical measurement model. In Chap. 5 we turn to consider a recent experimental test of the quantum Zeno effect which examined the dynamics of a two level atom subject to pulsed measurements of atomic level populations. We treat a slightly modified experiment in a fully continuous measurement regime. By first unravelling the optical Bloch equations, and second, using the quantum trajectories approach we demonstrate the existence of certain measurement regimes where there is a quantum Zeno effect, and other regimes where no measurement of the atomic populations is being effected at all. Through these results we demonstrate the importance of making a full analysis of the system-detector interaction before any conclusions can be made. In the remainder of the thesis we propose further possible tests of the quantum Zeno effect. In Chap. 6 the evolution of a Rydberg atom exchanging one photon with a single cavity mode subject to measurement is examined. The measurement is made by monitoring the photon number occupancy of the cavity mode using a beam of Rydberg atoms configured so as to perform phase sensitive detection. In the limit of frequent monitoring we show that the free oscillation of the atomic inversion is disrupted, and the atom is trapped close to its initial state. This is the quantum Zeno effect. In Chap. 7 we realize the Zeno effect on two possible systems. We consider first, a two level Jaynes-Cumming atom interacting with a cavity mode, and second, two electromagnetic modes configured as a multi-level parametric frequency converter. These systems interact with another cavity mode via a quadratic coupling system based on four wave mixing, and constructed to be a quantum nondemolition measurement of the photon number. This mode is damped to the environment thus effecting a measurement of the system populations. Again we show that this interaction, can manifest the quantum Zeno effect. Our explicit modelling of the system-detector interaction enables us to show how the effect depends on the resolution time of the detector. Finally, we consider a proposed measurement of the square of the quadrature phase of an electromagnetic mode in Chap. 8. Here, a three mode interaction mediated by a second order nonlinear susceptibility is considered. One mode, the pump, is prepared in a feedback generated photon number state to give insight into the role of pump noise. The other two modes are treated as an angular momentum system, and we show that photon counting on the two mode rotation system effects the above mentioned measurement. In addition, this measurement provides a direct measure of the second order squeezing of the signal. With that we finish our investigation of the quantum Zeno effect using the techniques of quantum measurement theory. However, in the epilogue [Chap. 9] we note that no thesis in quantum measurement theory would be complete without some consideration of the ``meaning attributed to the theory. In the epilogue we take a novel historical approach and examine the method by which metaphysical theories are formed to draw conclusions regarding quantum metaphysics.

•Jun 25, 1993•3 citations

Monitoring the wave function by time continuous position measurement

Thomas Konrad, Andreas Rothe, Francesco Petruccione +1 more

Motivated by the technical requirements of quantum information processing and nanotechnology, the control of individual quantum systems such as single atoms, ions or even photons has become a highly desirable aim.The monitoring of quantum systems-a direct test and in many cases a prerequisite of their control-has been investigated so far only for certain observables such as the position or momentum of quantum particles.Here, we describe a method to monitor in real time the complete state of a quantum particle with unknown initial state moving in a known potential.The method is based on successively updating an estimate by the results of a continuous position measurement.We demonstrate by numerical simulations that even in a chaotic potential tracking the wave function of a particle is possible, and we show with an example that the monitoring scheme appears to be robust against sudden random perturbations.

arXiv:0902.2249•New Journal of Physics•Apr 21, 2010•17 citations

Describing the wave function collapse process with a state-dependent Hamiltonian

Le Hu, Andrew N. Jordan

Abstract Quantum mechanics admits two distinct evolutions: deterministic unitary dynamics governed by the Schrödinger equation and the probabilistic collapse of the wave function. We show that the continuous collapse of a quantum state under measurement can, on a trajectory-by-trajectory basis, be equivalently described as unitary evolution generated by a time- and state-dependent Hermitian Hamiltonian with stochastic parameters. While the ensemble dynamics remains non-unitary, each individual trajectory thus admits a unitary representation. We derive explicit forms of such Hamiltonians for projective measurements on arbitrary n -level systems and for continuous position measurements of a harmonic oscillator, and we propose experimental schemes to test these predictions. Our framework provides a new approach to modeling and controlling continuously monitored quantum systems using only state-dependent unitary resources.

arXiv:2301.09274•Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations•Apr 6, 2026•6 citations
We formulate a model of a quantum particle continuously monitored by detectors measuring simultaneously its position and momentum. We implement the postulate of wave-function collapse by assuming that upon detection the particle is found in one of the meters' states chosen as a discrete subset of coherent states. The dynamics, as observed by the meters, is thus a random sequence of jumps between coherent states. We generate such trajectories using the quantum Monte Carlo wave-function method. For sparsely distributed detectors, we use methods from renewal theory of stochastic processes to obtain some semianalytic results. In particular, the different regimes of dynamics of the free particle are identified and quantitatively discussed: from stroboscopic motion in the case of low interrogation frequency, to delayed dynamics reminiscent of the Zeno effect if monitoring is frequent. For a semicontinuous spatial distribution of meters the emergence of classical trajectories is shown. Their statistical properties are discussed and compared to other detection schemes in which the operation on the system due to measurement corresponds to ``spatial filtering'' of the wave function.
In a recent paper, [Gampel, F. and Gajda, M., Phys. Rev. A 107, 012420, (2023)], the authors claimed they are proposing a new model to explain the existence of classical trajectories in the quantum domain. The idea is based on simultaneous position and momentum measurements and a "jump Markov process". Consequently, they have interpreted the emergence of classical trajectories as sets of detection events. They successfully implemented the model for a free particle and for one under a harmonic potential. Here, we show that the continuous observation limit is a realization of a coherent semiclassical expansion; Also, as has already been demonstrated, the jump process is not necessary and is not observable. In other words, the collapse, as they propose, is a non-go theorem; even if it is real, it can not be measured under the needed assumptions to obtain Newtonian classical dynamics.
We present a model of continuous (in time) position measurements on a quantum system using a single pseudoclassical meter. The nonselective evolution of the system is described by a master equation which is identical to that obtained from previous models. The selective evolution is described by a stochastic nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation. The significance of this equation is that the stochastic term has a physical interpretaion. By carefully choosing the parameters which define the meter and the system-meter coupling, we obtain a meter pointer with well-defined position which undergoes fluctuations. This ``jitter'' in the pointer position gives rise to the stochastic dynamical collapse of the system wave function. By the inclusion of feedback on the meter, the pointer is made to relax towards an appropriate readout. We apply this model to the selective measurement of the position of a particle in a double-well potential. In contrast to a recent claim [H. Fearn and W. E. Lamb, Jr., Phys. Rev. A 46, 1199 (1992)] we show that truly continuous position measurements lead to a quantum Zeno effect in certain parameter regimes. This is manifest by the changing of the particle dynamics from coherent tunneling between the well minima to incoherent flipping, as in a random telegraph. As the measurement strength increases, the average length of time the particle remains stuck in one well increases proportionally.
We study the evolution of a quantum particle in a harmonic potential whose position and momentum are repeatedly monitored. A back-action of measuring devices is accounted for. Our model utilizes a generalized measurement corresponding to the positive operator-valued measure. We assume that upon measurement, the particle's wavefunction is projected onto one of the possible detector states depending on the observed result. We chose these post-measurement states to be moving Gaussian wavepackets. The wavefunction quantum Monte Carlo formalism is used to simulate single quantum trajectories of the particle. We show how classical trajectories emerge in the course of observation and study in detail the dispersion of position and momentum of the particle.
This is a theoretical thesis in the area of quantum measurement theory. Due to the extensive breadth of this field we choose to narrow our focus to examine a particular problem - the quantum Zeno effect (defined below). Quantum measurement theory is introduced in Chap. 1, using the terminology of effects and operations. This approach allows an operational definition of such terms as a state vector, an ensemble, and a measurement device (for instance), and a consideration of interactions between quantum systems and inaccurate measurement devices. We further introduce the quantum trajectories approach to consider the evolution of an individual quantum system subject to measurement. The quantum Zeno effect is introduced in Chap. 2. Any quantum treatment of a measurement interaction must consider the measurement backaction onto the measured system and this backaction will disrupt the free evolution of the system. The quantum Zeno effect occurs in the strong measurement limit where the measurement backaction totally freezes the evolution of the system, thus rendering the measurement useless. The effect is introduced via projective measurements of two level systems subject to measurement of level populations. At this stage we are able to discuss the main questions addressed by this thesis, and present its structure in Chap. 2. We then develop a new measurement model for the interaction between a system and a measurement device in Chap. 3. Our motivation in doing this is to better model the usual laboratory meter, and in our approach the meter dynamics are such that it relaxes towards an appropriate readout of the system parameter of interest. The irreducible quantum noise of the meter introduces fluctuations that drive the stochastic dynamical collapse of the system wavefunction. In our model, the measured system dynamics (if treated selectively) are described by a stochastic, nonlinear Schroedinger equation. A double well system subject to position measurement provides a natural first application for this model. This is done in Chap. 4 where we monitor the coherent tunnelling of a particle from one well to the other. The advantage afforded by considering this system is that it displays differing regimes where the measurement observable (position) is approximated as possessing either, respectively, a continuous or a discrete eigenvalue structure. Thus, we use this one model to explore the quantum Zeno effect in both measurement regimes. The above treatment is of a theoretical measurement model. In Chap. 5 we turn to consider a recent experimental test of the quantum Zeno effect which examined the dynamics of a two level atom subject to pulsed measurements of atomic level populations. We treat a slightly modified experiment in a fully continuous measurement regime. By first unravelling the optical Bloch equations, and second, using the quantum trajectories approach we demonstrate the existence of certain measurement regimes where there is a quantum Zeno effect, and other regimes where no measurement of the atomic populations is being effected at all. Through these results we demonstrate the importance of making a full analysis of the system-detector interaction before any conclusions can be made. In the remainder of the thesis we propose further possible tests of the quantum Zeno effect. In Chap. 6 the evolution of a Rydberg atom exchanging one photon with a single cavity mode subject to measurement is examined. The measurement is made by monitoring the photon number occupancy of the cavity mode using a beam of Rydberg atoms configured so as to perform phase sensitive detection. In the limit of frequent monitoring we show that the free oscillation of the atomic inversion is disrupted, and the atom is trapped close to its initial state. This is the quantum Zeno effect. In Chap. 7 we realize the Zeno effect on two possible systems. We consider first, a two level Jaynes-Cumming atom interacting with a cavity mode, and second, two electromagnetic modes configured as a multi-level parametric frequency converter. These systems interact with another cavity mode via a quadratic coupling system based on four wave mixing, and constructed to be a quantum nondemolition measurement of the photon number. This mode is damped to the environment thus effecting a measurement of the system populations. Again we show that this interaction, can manifest the quantum Zeno effect. Our explicit modelling of the system-detector interaction enables us to show how the effect depends on the resolution time of the detector. Finally, we consider a proposed measurement of the square of the quadrature phase of an electromagnetic mode in Chap. 8. Here, a three mode interaction mediated by a second order nonlinear susceptibility is considered. One mode, the pump, is prepared in a feedback generated photon number state to give insight into the role of pump noise. The other two modes are treated as an angular momentum system, and we show that photon counting on the two mode rotation system effects the above mentioned measurement. In addition, this measurement provides a direct measure of the second order squeezing of the signal. With that we finish our investigation of the quantum Zeno effect using the techniques of quantum measurement theory. However, in the epilogue [Chap. 9] we note that no thesis in quantum measurement theory would be complete without some consideration of the ``meaning attributed to the theory. In the epilogue we take a novel historical approach and examine the method by which metaphysical theories are formed to draw conclusions regarding quantum metaphysics.
Motivated by the technical requirements of quantum information processing and nanotechnology, the control of individual quantum systems such as single atoms, ions or even photons has become a highly desirable aim.The monitoring of quantum systems-a direct test and in many cases a prerequisite of their control-has been investigated so far only for certain observables such as the position or momentum of quantum particles.Here, we describe a method to monitor in real time the complete state of a quantum particle with unknown initial state moving in a known potential.The method is based on successively updating an estimate by the results of a continuous position measurement.We demonstrate by numerical simulations that even in a chaotic potential tracking the wave function of a particle is possible, and we show with an example that the monitoring scheme appears to be robust against sudden random perturbations.
Abstract Quantum mechanics admits two distinct evolutions: deterministic unitary dynamics governed by the Schrödinger equation and the probabilistic collapse of the wave function. We show that the continuous collapse of a quantum state under measurement can, on a trajectory-by-trajectory basis, be equivalently described as unitary evolution generated by a time- and state-dependent Hermitian Hamiltonian with stochastic parameters. While the ensemble dynamics remains non-unitary, each individual trajectory thus admits a unitary representation. We derive explicit forms of such Hamiltonians for projective measurements on arbitrary n -level systems and for continuous position measurements of a harmonic oscillator, and we propose experimental schemes to test these predictions. Our framework provides a new approach to modeling and controlling continuously monitored quantum systems using only state-dependent unitary resources.