Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2309.14424 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Instanton confinement-deconfinement transitions: Stability of pseudogap phases and topological order

Predrag Nikolić

Published Apr 16, 2024• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We explore the stability of certain many-body quantum states which may exist at zero or finite temperatures, may lack long-range order and even topological order, and still are thermodynamically distinct from uncorrelated disordered phases. We sharply characterize such states by the conservation of topological charge, or equivalently confinement of instantons, using a generalization of the Wilson loop and the correlation length of an emergent gauge field. Our main conclusions are (i) topological orders can exist at finite temperatures, (ii) relativistic liquids of topological defects can also exist as stable phases at finite temperatures, and (iii) there are two universality classes of instanton suppression. We also relate the instanton dynamics to the problem of the pseudogap state in underdoped cuprates. A universal experimental signature of the instanton deconfinement transition is a change of the quantum noise spectrum, which can perhaps be measured in some situations, for example, via a quantum anomaly, or indirectly detected with a specific heat jump. The method of analysis is a functional renormalization group that generalizes the Coulomb gas treatment of Kosterlitz and Thouless to arbitrary interactions and dimensions. In particular, we construct an exact nonperturbative technique for confining interactions between instantons that introduce irreparable infrared divergences in the standard perturbative approaches.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.109.165132

Related papers

Pseudogap phases, chiral anomaly, and topological order with quantum loop entanglement

Predrag Nikolić

A many-body quantum system whose topological defects are conserved, abundant, and mobile is a correlated quantum liquid. Since topological defects can be classified by homotopy groups, each homotopy identifies a class of quantum liquids. Here we explore the quantum liquids based on the ${\ensuremath{\pi}}_{3}({S}^{2})$ homotopy group, i.e., Hopf fibration. Their topologically nontrivial dynamics emerges from the interlinking between magnetic flux or skyrmion loops in the charge and spin sectors respectively. We lay down a field theory foundation for analyzing such states by naturally incorporating the well-known framing regularization into the theory, and constructing the appropriate topological Lagrangian terms. We show that at least two strongly correlated phases of interlinked loops can exist in $d=3$ spatial dimensions at zero and low-finite temperatures. These phases are closely related to the chiral quantum anomaly and do not have an obvious topological order, but they are distinguished from the trivial disordered phase by a generalization of the Wilson loop operator. In $d=4$ spatial dimensions, interlinked loops are able to produce topological order at zero temperature, featuring charge, angular momentum, and braiding fractionalization. We discuss some possible experimental signatures of loop entanglement in the quantum noise of charge currents.

arXiv:2310.01493•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 26, 2024•1 citation

Diagnosing deconfinement and topological order

Karol Gregor, David A. Huse, Roderich Moessner +1 more

Topological or deconfined phases are characterized by emergent, weakly fluctuating, gauge fields. In condensed matter settings, they inevitably come coupled to excitations that carry the corresponding gauge charges which invalidate the standard diagnostic of deconfinement—the Wilson loop. Inspired by a mapping between symmetric sponges and the deconfined phase of the Z 2 gauge theory, we construct a diagnostic for deconfinement that has the interpretation of a line tension. One operator version of this diagnostic turns out to be the Fredenhagen–Marcu order parameter known to lattice gauge theorists and we show that a different version is best suited to condensed matter systems. We discuss generalizations of the diagnostic, use it to establish the existence of finite temperature topological phases in d ⩾3 dimensions and show that multiplets of the diagnostic are useful in settings with multiple phases, such as U (1) gauge theories with charge q matter. (Additionally, we present an exact reduction of the partition function of the toric code in general dimensions to a well-studied problem.)

arXiv:1011.4187•New Journal of Physics•Feb 11, 2011•86 citations

Topological order, emergent gauge fields, and Fermi surface reconstruction

Subir Sachdev A

This review describes how topological order associated with the presence of emergent gauge fields can reconstruct Fermi surfaces of metals, even in the absence of translational symmetry breaking. We begin with an introduction to topological order using Wegner's quantum [Formula: see text] gauge theory on the square lattice: the topological state is characterized by the expulsion of defects, carrying [Formula: see text] magnetic flux. The interplay between topological order and the breaking of global symmetry is described by the non-zero temperature statistical mechanics of classical XY models in dimension D = 3; such models also describe the zero temperature quantum phases of bosons with short-range interactions on the square lattice at integer filling. The topological state is again characterized by the expulsion of certain defects, in a state with fluctuating symmetry-breaking order, along with the presence of emergent gauge fields. The phase diagrams of the [Formula: see text] gauge theory and the XY models are obtained by embedding them in U(1) gauge theories, and by studying their Higgs and confining phases. These ideas are then applied to the single-band Hubbard model on the square lattice. A SU(2) gauge theory describes the fluctuations of spin-density-wave order, and its phase diagram is presented by analogy to the XY models. We obtain a class of zero temperature metallic states with fluctuating spin-density wave order, topological order associated with defect expulsion, deconfined emergent gauge fields, reconstructed Fermi surfaces (with 'chargon' or electron-like quasiparticles), but no broken symmetry. We conclude with the application of such metallic states to the pseudogap phase of the cuprates, and note the recent comparison with numerical studies of the Hubbard model and photoemission observations of the electron-doped cuprates. In a detour, we also discuss the influence of Berry phases, and how they can lead to deconfined quantum critical points: this applies to bosons on the square lattice at half-integer filling, and to quantum dimer models.

arXiv:1801.01125•Reports on Progress in Physics•Sep 13, 2018•237 citations

Deconfined Thermal Phase Transitions with $Z_2$ Gauge Structures

Eun-Gook Moon

Fathoming deconfined phases is one of the key issues in modern condensed matter. Striking many-body effects including massive quantum entanglement and coherence may be realized as manifested in quantum spin liquids and topological orders. Here, we demonstrate that deconfined phases even host exotic thermal phase transitions, dubbed deconfined thermal transitions. Constructing a $Z_2$ lattice gauge model with strong interactions between $Z_2$ gauge fluxes, we prove the existence of a thermal phase transition between deconfined and confined phases in two spatial dimensions in sharp contrast to its absence in the Wegner model. Incorporating deconfined fermions, it is shown that gapless excitations from Fermi surfaces endow line-tension to $Z_2$ gauge fluxes at zero temperature, and we argue that a deconfined thermal transition with deconfined fermions may be interpreted as a hidden order transition with thermal gap-opening in Fermi surfaces. Moreover, it is shown that symmetry breaking transitions in deconfined phases may be unconventional. Global $Z_2$ and $U(1)$ symmetry breaking transitions in deconfined phases may be in the same universality class, which is impossible under the conventional Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm. Characteristic signatures of the transitions in experiments and candidate strongly correlated systems such as Kitaev materials are also discussed.

arXiv:1812.05621•Dec 13, 2018•4 citations

Long-Range Toric Code: Finite-Temperature Topological Order in Two Dimensions

Jacopo Gliozzi, Taylor L. Hughes, Kyung-Su Kim

We introduce two-dimensional toric code models with additional long-range loop interactions. Our models preserve the topologically ordered ground states of the ordinary toric code, while confining anyons at zero temperature. For sufficiently long-ranged interactions, we argue that this confinement persists at finite temperatures, strongly constraining anyon mobility and giving rise to finite-temperature topological order. This topological phase acts as a self-correcting quantum memory and exhibits long-range entanglement. For shorter-ranged interactions, signatures of topological order survive only up to an exponentially large length scale at finite temperature, yielding a partially self-correcting quantum memory.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2610.37765•Oct 29, 2026•0 citations

Confinement-deconfinement transition and spin correlations in a generalized Kitaev model

Saptarshi Mandal, Subhro Bhattacharjee, K. Sengupta +2 more

We present a spin model, namely, the Kitaev model augmented by a loop term and perturbed by an Ising Hamiltonian, and show that it exhibits both confinement-deconfinement transitions from spin liquid to antiferromagnetic/spin-chain/ferromagnetic phases and topological quantum phase transitions between gapped and gapless spin-liquid phases. We develop a fermionic resonating-valence-bonds (RVB) mean-field theory to chart out the phase diagram of the model and estimate the stability of its spin-liquid phases, which might be relevant for attempts to realize the model in optical lattices and other spin systems. We present an analytical mean-field theory to study the confinement-deconfinement transition for large coefficient of the loop term and show that this transition is first order within such mean-field analysis in this limit. We also conjecture that in some other regimes, the confinement-deconfinement transitions in the model, predicted to be first order within the mean-field theory, may become second order via a defect condensation mechanism. Finally, we present a general classification of the perturbations to the Kitaev model on the basis of their effect on it's spin correlation functions and derive a necessary and sufficient condition, within the regime of validity of perturbation theory, for the spin correlators to exhibit a long-ranged power-law behavior in the presence of such perturbations. Our results reproduce those of Tikhonov et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 067203 (2011)] as a special case.

arXiv:1101.1388•Physical Review B•Oct 17, 2011•32 citations
We explore the stability of certain many-body quantum states which may exist at zero or finite temperatures, may lack long-range order and even topological order, and still are thermodynamically distinct from uncorrelated disordered phases. We sharply characterize such states by the conservation of topological charge, or equivalently confinement of instantons, using a generalization of the Wilson loop and the correlation length of an emergent gauge field. Our main conclusions are (i) topological orders can exist at finite temperatures, (ii) relativistic liquids of topological defects can also exist as stable phases at finite temperatures, and (iii) there are two universality classes of instanton suppression. We also relate the instanton dynamics to the problem of the pseudogap state in underdoped cuprates. A universal experimental signature of the instanton deconfinement transition is a change of the quantum noise spectrum, which can perhaps be measured in some situations, for example, via a quantum anomaly, or indirectly detected with a specific heat jump. The method of analysis is a functional renormalization group that generalizes the Coulomb gas treatment of Kosterlitz and Thouless to arbitrary interactions and dimensions. In particular, we construct an exact nonperturbative technique for confining interactions between instantons that introduce irreparable infrared divergences in the standard perturbative approaches.
A many-body quantum system whose topological defects are conserved, abundant, and mobile is a correlated quantum liquid. Since topological defects can be classified by homotopy groups, each homotopy identifies a class of quantum liquids. Here we explore the quantum liquids based on the ${\ensuremath{\pi}}_{3}({S}^{2})$ homotopy group, i.e., Hopf fibration. Their topologically nontrivial dynamics emerges from the interlinking between magnetic flux or skyrmion loops in the charge and spin sectors respectively. We lay down a field theory foundation for analyzing such states by naturally incorporating the well-known framing regularization into the theory, and constructing the appropriate topological Lagrangian terms. We show that at least two strongly correlated phases of interlinked loops can exist in d=3d=3d=3 spatial dimensions at zero and low-finite temperatures. These phases are closely related to the chiral quantum anomaly and do not have an obvious topological order, but they are distinguished from the trivial disordered phase by a generalization of the Wilson loop operator. In d=4d=4d=4 spatial dimensions, interlinked loops are able to produce topological order at zero temperature, featuring charge, angular momentum, and braiding fractionalization. We discuss some possible experimental signatures of loop entanglement in the quantum noise of charge currents.
Topological or deconfined phases are characterized by emergent, weakly fluctuating, gauge fields. In condensed matter settings, they inevitably come coupled to excitations that carry the corresponding gauge charges which invalidate the standard diagnostic of deconfinement—the Wilson loop. Inspired by a mapping between symmetric sponges and the deconfined phase of the Z 2 gauge theory, we construct a diagnostic for deconfinement that has the interpretation of a line tension. One operator version of this diagnostic turns out to be the Fredenhagen–Marcu order parameter known to lattice gauge theorists and we show that a different version is best suited to condensed matter systems. We discuss generalizations of the diagnostic, use it to establish the existence of finite temperature topological phases in d ⩾3 dimensions and show that multiplets of the diagnostic are useful in settings with multiple phases, such as U (1) gauge theories with charge q matter. (Additionally, we present an exact reduction of the partition function of the toric code in general dimensions to a well-studied problem.)
This review describes how topological order associated with the presence of emergent gauge fields can reconstruct Fermi surfaces of metals, even in the absence of translational symmetry breaking. We begin with an introduction to topological order using Wegner's quantum [Formula: see text] gauge theory on the square lattice: the topological state is characterized by the expulsion of defects, carrying [Formula: see text] magnetic flux. The interplay between topological order and the breaking of global symmetry is described by the non-zero temperature statistical mechanics of classical XY models in dimension D = 3; such models also describe the zero temperature quantum phases of bosons with short-range interactions on the square lattice at integer filling. The topological state is again characterized by the expulsion of certain defects, in a state with fluctuating symmetry-breaking order, along with the presence of emergent gauge fields. The phase diagrams of the [Formula: see text] gauge theory and the XY models are obtained by embedding them in U(1) gauge theories, and by studying their Higgs and confining phases. These ideas are then applied to the single-band Hubbard model on the square lattice. A SU(2) gauge theory describes the fluctuations of spin-density-wave order, and its phase diagram is presented by analogy to the XY models. We obtain a class of zero temperature metallic states with fluctuating spin-density wave order, topological order associated with defect expulsion, deconfined emergent gauge fields, reconstructed Fermi surfaces (with 'chargon' or electron-like quasiparticles), but no broken symmetry. We conclude with the application of such metallic states to the pseudogap phase of the cuprates, and note the recent comparison with numerical studies of the Hubbard model and photoemission observations of the electron-doped cuprates. In a detour, we also discuss the influence of Berry phases, and how they can lead to deconfined quantum critical points: this applies to bosons on the square lattice at half-integer filling, and to quantum dimer models.
Deconfined Thermal Phase Transitions with Z2Z_2Z2​ Gauge Structures
Fathoming deconfined phases is one of the key issues in modern condensed matter. Striking many-body effects including massive quantum entanglement and coherence may be realized as manifested in quantum spin liquids and topological orders. Here, we demonstrate that deconfined phases even host exotic thermal phase transitions, dubbed deconfined thermal transitions. Constructing a Z2Z_2Z2​ lattice gauge model with strong interactions between Z2Z_2Z2​ gauge fluxes, we prove the existence of a thermal phase transition between deconfined and confined phases in two spatial dimensions in sharp contrast to its absence in the Wegner model. Incorporating deconfined fermions, it is shown that gapless excitations from Fermi surfaces endow line-tension to Z2Z_2Z2​ gauge fluxes at zero temperature, and we argue that a deconfined thermal transition with deconfined fermions may be interpreted as a hidden order transition with thermal gap-opening in Fermi surfaces. Moreover, it is shown that symmetry breaking transitions in deconfined phases may be unconventional. Global Z2Z_2Z2​ and U(1)U(1)U(1) symmetry breaking transitions in deconfined phases may be in the same universality class, which is impossible under the conventional Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson paradigm. Characteristic signatures of the transitions in experiments and candidate strongly correlated systems such as Kitaev materials are also discussed.
We introduce two-dimensional toric code models with additional long-range loop interactions. Our models preserve the topologically ordered ground states of the ordinary toric code, while confining anyons at zero temperature. For sufficiently long-ranged interactions, we argue that this confinement persists at finite temperatures, strongly constraining anyon mobility and giving rise to finite-temperature topological order. This topological phase acts as a self-correcting quantum memory and exhibits long-range entanglement. For shorter-ranged interactions, signatures of topological order survive only up to an exponentially large length scale at finite temperature, yielding a partially self-correcting quantum memory.
We present a spin model, namely, the Kitaev model augmented by a loop term and perturbed by an Ising Hamiltonian, and show that it exhibits both confinement-deconfinement transitions from spin liquid to antiferromagnetic/spin-chain/ferromagnetic phases and topological quantum phase transitions between gapped and gapless spin-liquid phases. We develop a fermionic resonating-valence-bonds (RVB) mean-field theory to chart out the phase diagram of the model and estimate the stability of its spin-liquid phases, which might be relevant for attempts to realize the model in optical lattices and other spin systems. We present an analytical mean-field theory to study the confinement-deconfinement transition for large coefficient of the loop term and show that this transition is first order within such mean-field analysis in this limit. We also conjecture that in some other regimes, the confinement-deconfinement transitions in the model, predicted to be first order within the mean-field theory, may become second order via a defect condensation mechanism. Finally, we present a general classification of the perturbations to the Kitaev model on the basis of their effect on it's spin correlation functions and derive a necessary and sufficient condition, within the regime of validity of perturbation theory, for the spin correlators to exhibit a long-ranged power-law behavior in the presence of such perturbations. Our results reproduce those of Tikhonov et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 067203 (2011)] as a special case.