Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.37765

Long-Range Toric Code: Finite-Temperature Topological Order in Two Dimensions

Jacopo Gliozzi, Taylor L. Hughes, Kyung-Su Kim

cond-mat.str-elcond-mat.stat-mechquant-phSubmitted Oct 27, 2026• Announced Oct 29, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce two-dimensional toric code models with additional long-range loop interactions. Our models preserve the topologically ordered ground states of the ordinary toric code, while confining anyons at zero temperature. For sufficiently long-ranged interactions, we argue that this confinement persists at finite temperatures, strongly constraining anyon mobility and giving rise to finite-temperature topological order. This topological phase acts as a self-correcting quantum memory and exhibits long-range entanglement. For shorter-ranged interactions, signatures of topological order survive only up to an exponentially large length scale at finite temperature, yielding a partially self-correcting quantum memory.

AI Summary

Can long-range interactions stabilize finite-temperature topological order and passive quantum memory in two dimensions without a superextensive energy spectrum? This paper supplements the toric code with commuting square-loop stabilizers weighted by perimeter as $\ell^{-\alpha}$. The ground-state manifold is unchanged, while the bandwidth remains extensive for $\alpha>1$; interactions have unbounded support and are not $k$-local. Loop counting gives isolated anyon-pair energies growing as $d^{3-\alpha}$ for $2<\alpha<3$, logarithmically for $\alpha=3$, and remaining bounded for $\alpha>3$. For $1<\alpha\leq2$, even nearest-neighbor dipoles have energies diverging with system size; compact quadrupoles instead have finite energy, producing emergent row/column parity constraints. A dilute-excitation analysis predicts that thermal dipoles screen confinement for $2<\alpha\leq3$ beyond $L_{\mathrm{conf}}\sim e^{\beta\Delta_2}$, yielding partial self-correction. For $1<\alpha\leq2$, quadrupoles are argued not to screen confinement, supporting finite-temperature topological order and full self-correction. A quasi-local renormalization-group decoder supplies a related argument for long-range entanglement of low-temperature Gibbs states. Classical Monte Carlo simulations examine specific heat, Wilson loops, decoding errors, and memory lifetimes. Rigorous correlation inequalities establish asymptotic Wilson-loop decay $\langle W_R\rangle\sim\beta/R^\alpha$ for $\alpha>2$. The central $1<\alpha\leq2$ Wilson-loop plateau remains conjectural: only an upper bound, dilute-quadrupole reasoning, and finite-size evidence are supplied. Diverging memory lifetime is likewise not proved; collective logical-error paths and entropic effects remain unresolved. The transition and crossover are not precisely characterized, and numerical sizes cannot establish the asymptotic distinction between full and partial self-correction.

No sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptionsOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The proposed finite-temperature ordered phase relies on a nonzero asymptotic Wilson-loop plateau that is supported heuristically and numerically but remains explicitly conjectured. The claimed fully self-correcting memory has no established diverging logical lifetime because its Arrhenius argument does not control entropy or collective logical-error paths. The Gibbs-state long-range-entanglement argument assumes unestablished cluster statistics and decoder behavior, while its numerical RG test concerns the partially confining regime. The stated simulation normalization contradicts its claimed toric-code energy matching and, when inserted into the paper's confinement-length estimate, gives approximately 2.1 x 10^14 rather than the quoted 10^4.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
12+6 pages, 9+3 figures

Related papers

Finite-Temperature Quantum Topological Order in Three Dimensions

Shu-Tong Zhou, Meng Cheng, Tibor Rakovszky +2 more

We identify a three-dimensional system that exhibits long-range entanglement at sufficiently small but nonzero temperature-it therefore constitutes a quantum topological order at finite temperature. The model of interest is known as the fermionic toric code, a variant of the usual 3D toric code, which admits emergent fermionic pointlike excitations. The fermionic toric code, importantly, possesses an anomalous two-form symmetry, associated with the spacelike Wilson loops of the fermionic excitations. We argue that it is this symmetry that imbues low-temperature thermal states with a novel topological order and long-range entanglement. Based on the current classification of three-dimensional topological orders, we expect that the low-temperature thermal states of the fermionic toric code belong to a phase of matter that, in the context of equilibrium phases of matter, only exists at nonzero temperatures. We conjecture that further examples of topological orders at nonzero temperatures are given by discrete gauge theories with anomalous two-form symmetries. Our Letter therefore opens the door to studying quantum topological order at nonzero temperature in physically realistic dimensions.

arXiv:2503.02928•Physical Review Letters•Jul 1, 2025•23 citations

Toric-boson model: Toward a topological quantum memory at finite temperature

Alioscia Hamma, Claudio Castelnovo, Claudio Chamon

We discuss the existence of stable topological quantum memory at finite temperature. At stake here is the fundamental question of whether it is, in principle, possible to store quantum information for macroscopic times without the intervention from the external world, that is, without error correction. We study the toric code in two dimensions with an additional bosonic field that couples to the defects, in the presence of a generic environment at finite temperature: the toric-boson model. Although the coupling constants for the bare model are not finite in the thermodynamic limit, the model has a finite spectrum. We show that in the topological phase, there is a finite temperature below which open strings are confined and therefore the lifetime of the memory can be made arbitrarily (polynomially) long in system size. The interaction with the bosonic field yields a long-range attractive force between the end points of open strings but leaves closed strings and topological order intact.

arXiv:0812.4622•Physical Review B•Jun 18, 2009•69 citations

Self-correcting quantum memory in a thermal environment

Stefano Chesi, Beat Röthlisberger, Daniel Loss

The ability to store information is of fundamental importance to any computer, be it classical or quantum. To identify systems for quantum memories, which rely, analogously to classical memories, on passive error protection (``self-correction''), is of greatest interest in quantum information science. While systems with topological ground states have been considered to be promising candidates, a large class of them was recently proven unstable against thermal fluctuations. Here, we propose two-dimensional (2D) spin models unaffected by this result. Specifically, we introduce repulsive long-range interactions in the toric code and establish a memory lifetime polynomially increasing with the system size. This remarkable stability is shown to originate directly from the repulsive long-range nature of the interactions. We study the time dynamics of the quantum memory in terms of diffusing anyons and support our analytical results with extensive numerical simulations. Our findings demonstrate that self-correcting quantum memories can exist in 2D at finite temperatures.

arXiv:0908.4264•Physical Review A•Aug 6, 2010•71 citations

Thermalization of topological entropy after a quantum quench

Yu Zeng, Alioscia Hamma, Heng Fan

Topologically ordered quantum phases are robust in the sense that perturbations in the Hamiltonian of the system will not change the topological nature of the ground-state wave function. However, in order to exploit topological order for applications such as self-correcting quantum memories and information processing, these states need to be also robust both dynamically and at finite temperature in the presence of an environment. It is well known that systems like the toric code in two spatial dimensions are fragile in temperature. In this paper, we show a completely analytic treatment of the toric code away from equilibrium, after a quantum quench of the system Hamiltonian. We show that, despite being subject to unitary evolution (and at zero temperature), the long-time behavior of the topological entropy is thermal, therefore vanishing. If the quench preserves a local gauge structure, there is a residual long-lived topological entropy. This also is the thermal behavior in presence of such gauge constraints. The result is obtained by studying the time evolution of the topological 2-R\'enyi entropy in a fully analytical, exact way.

arXiv:1509.08613•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 2, 2016•14 citations

Quantum Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition of the self-dual toric code phase

Guoyi Zhu, Guang-Ming Zhang

In the tensor network representation, a deformed $Z_{2}$ topological ground state wave function is proposed and its norm can be exactly mapped to the two-dimensional solvable Ashkin-Teller (AT) model. Then the topological (toric code) phase with anyonic excitations corresponds to the partial order phase of the AT model, and possible topological phase transitions are precisely determined. With the electric-magnetic self-duality, a novel gapless Coulomb state with quasi-long-range order is obtained via a quantum Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition. The corresponding ground state is a condensate of pairs of logarithmically confined electric charges and magnetic fluxes, and the scaling behavior of various anyon correlations can be exactly derived, revealing the effective interaction between anyons and their condensation. Deformations away from the self-duality drive the Coulomb state into either the gapped Higgs phase or confining phase.

•Jan 29, 2019•0 citations

Topological phases and self-correcting memories in interacting anyon systems

James R. Wootton

Recent studies have shown that topological models with interacting anyonic quasiparticles can be used as self-correcting quantum memories. Here we study the behavior of these models at thermal equilibrium. It is found that the interactions allow topological order to exist at finite temperature, not only in an extension of the ground-state phase, but also in a novel form of topologically ordered phase. Both phases are found to support self-correction in all models considered, and the transition between them corresponds to a change in the scaling of memory lifetime with system size.

arXiv:1305.1808•Physical Review A•Dec 10, 2013•11 citations
We introduce two-dimensional toric code models with additional long-range loop interactions. Our models preserve the topologically ordered ground states of the ordinary toric code, while confining anyons at zero temperature. For sufficiently long-ranged interactions, we argue that this confinement persists at finite temperatures, strongly constraining anyon mobility and giving rise to finite-temperature topological order. This topological phase acts as a self-correcting quantum memory and exhibits long-range entanglement. For shorter-ranged interactions, signatures of topological order survive only up to an exponentially large length scale at finite temperature, yielding a partially self-correcting quantum memory.
Can long-range interactions stabilize finite-temperature topological order and passive quantum memory in two dimensions without a superextensive energy spectrum? This paper supplements the toric code with commuting square-loop stabilizers weighted by perimeter as ℓ−α\ell^{-\alpha}ℓ−α. The ground-state manifold is unchanged, while the bandwidth remains extensive for α>1\alpha>1α>1; interactions have unbounded support and are not kkk-local.
Loop counting gives isolated anyon-pair energies growing as d3−αd^{3-\alpha}d3−α for 2<α<32<\alpha<32<α<3, logarithmically for α=3\alpha=3α=3, and remaining bounded for α>3\alpha>3α>3. For 1<α≤21<\alpha\leq21<α≤2, even nearest-neighbor dipoles have energies diverging with system size; compact quadrupoles instead have finite energy, producing emergent row/column parity constraints. A dilute-excitation analysis predicts that thermal dipoles screen confinement for 2<α≤32<\alpha\leq32<α≤3 beyond Lconf∼eβΔ2L_{\mathrm{conf}}\sim e^{\beta\Delta_2}Lconf​∼eβΔ2​, yielding partial self-correction. For 1<α≤21<\alpha\leq21<α≤2, quadrupoles are argued not to screen confinement, supporting finite-temperature topological order and full self-correction. A quasi-local renormalization-group decoder supplies a related argument for long-range entanglement of low-temperature Gibbs states.
Classical Monte Carlo simulations examine specific heat, Wilson loops, decoding errors, and memory lifetimes. Rigorous correlation inequalities establish asymptotic Wilson-loop decay ⟨WR⟩∼β/Rα\langle W_R\rangle\sim\beta/R^\alpha⟨WR​⟩∼β/Rα for α>2\alpha>2α>2. The central 1<α≤21<\alpha\leq21<α≤2 Wilson-loop plateau remains conjectural: only an upper bound, dilute-quadrupole reasoning, and finite-size evidence are supplied. Diverging memory lifetime is likewise not proved; collective logical-error paths and entropic effects remain unresolved. The transition and crossover are not precisely characterized, and numerical sizes cannot establish the asymptotic distinction between full and partial self-correction.
We identify a three-dimensional system that exhibits long-range entanglement at sufficiently small but nonzero temperature-it therefore constitutes a quantum topological order at finite temperature. The model of interest is known as the fermionic toric code, a variant of the usual 3D toric code, which admits emergent fermionic pointlike excitations. The fermionic toric code, importantly, possesses an anomalous two-form symmetry, associated with the spacelike Wilson loops of the fermionic excitations. We argue that it is this symmetry that imbues low-temperature thermal states with a novel topological order and long-range entanglement. Based on the current classification of three-dimensional topological orders, we expect that the low-temperature thermal states of the fermionic toric code belong to a phase of matter that, in the context of equilibrium phases of matter, only exists at nonzero temperatures. We conjecture that further examples of topological orders at nonzero temperatures are given by discrete gauge theories with anomalous two-form symmetries. Our Letter therefore opens the door to studying quantum topological order at nonzero temperature in physically realistic dimensions.
We discuss the existence of stable topological quantum memory at finite temperature. At stake here is the fundamental question of whether it is, in principle, possible to store quantum information for macroscopic times without the intervention from the external world, that is, without error correction. We study the toric code in two dimensions with an additional bosonic field that couples to the defects, in the presence of a generic environment at finite temperature: the toric-boson model. Although the coupling constants for the bare model are not finite in the thermodynamic limit, the model has a finite spectrum. We show that in the topological phase, there is a finite temperature below which open strings are confined and therefore the lifetime of the memory can be made arbitrarily (polynomially) long in system size. The interaction with the bosonic field yields a long-range attractive force between the end points of open strings but leaves closed strings and topological order intact.
The ability to store information is of fundamental importance to any computer, be it classical or quantum. To identify systems for quantum memories, which rely, analogously to classical memories, on passive error protection (``self-correction''), is of greatest interest in quantum information science. While systems with topological ground states have been considered to be promising candidates, a large class of them was recently proven unstable against thermal fluctuations. Here, we propose two-dimensional (2D) spin models unaffected by this result. Specifically, we introduce repulsive long-range interactions in the toric code and establish a memory lifetime polynomially increasing with the system size. This remarkable stability is shown to originate directly from the repulsive long-range nature of the interactions. We study the time dynamics of the quantum memory in terms of diffusing anyons and support our analytical results with extensive numerical simulations. Our findings demonstrate that self-correcting quantum memories can exist in 2D at finite temperatures.
Topologically ordered quantum phases are robust in the sense that perturbations in the Hamiltonian of the system will not change the topological nature of the ground-state wave function. However, in order to exploit topological order for applications such as self-correcting quantum memories and information processing, these states need to be also robust both dynamically and at finite temperature in the presence of an environment. It is well known that systems like the toric code in two spatial dimensions are fragile in temperature. In this paper, we show a completely analytic treatment of the toric code away from equilibrium, after a quantum quench of the system Hamiltonian. We show that, despite being subject to unitary evolution (and at zero temperature), the long-time behavior of the topological entropy is thermal, therefore vanishing. If the quench preserves a local gauge structure, there is a residual long-lived topological entropy. This also is the thermal behavior in presence of such gauge constraints. The result is obtained by studying the time evolution of the topological 2-R\'enyi entropy in a fully analytical, exact way.
In the tensor network representation, a deformed Z2Z_{2}Z2​ topological ground state wave function is proposed and its norm can be exactly mapped to the two-dimensional solvable Ashkin-Teller (AT) model. Then the topological (toric code) phase with anyonic excitations corresponds to the partial order phase of the AT model, and possible topological phase transitions are precisely determined. With the electric-magnetic self-duality, a novel gapless Coulomb state with quasi-long-range order is obtained via a quantum Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition. The corresponding ground state is a condensate of pairs of logarithmically confined electric charges and magnetic fluxes, and the scaling behavior of various anyon correlations can be exactly derived, revealing the effective interaction between anyons and their condensation. Deformations away from the self-duality drive the Coulomb state into either the gapped Higgs phase or confining phase.
Recent studies have shown that topological models with interacting anyonic quasiparticles can be used as self-correcting quantum memories. Here we study the behavior of these models at thermal equilibrium. It is found that the interactions allow topological order to exist at finite temperature, not only in an extension of the ground-state phase, but also in a novel form of topologically ordered phase. Both phases are found to support self-correction in all models considered, and the transition between them corresponds to a change in the scaling of memory lifetime with system size.