A serious objection made by Wallstrom against quantum interpretations based flow variables, in particular Nelsonian stochastics, is their empirical inequivalence with quantum theory: They are unable to obtain a quantization condition for flows around zeros which is automatically fulfilled by the wave function. It is found that the quantization condition follows from a simple additional postulate: The Laplace operator of the density has to be finite and positive at zeros of the density. This postulate is a quite natural consequence of subquantum theories, as far as they conform to a simple principle of minimal distortion of the quantum solutions. 1. The problem and a proposal for its solution 1.1. Quantum interpretations based on flow variables. There is a remarkable class of interpretations of quantum theory based on variables often named “hydrodynamic”, which I prefer to name “flow variables” – a density ρ(q) and a velocity field v(q). The velocity field has a potential
A serious objection made by Wallstrom against quantum interpretations based flow variables, in particular Nelsonian stochastics, is their empirical inequivalence with quantum theory: They are unable to obtain a quantization condition for flows around zeros which is automatically fulfilled by the wave function. It is found that the quantization condition follows from a simple additional postulate: The Laplace operator of the density has to be finite and positive at zeros of the density. This postulate is a quite natural consequence of subquantum theories, as far as they conform to a simple principle of minimal distortion of the quantum solutions.
Wallstrom has argued that quantum interpretations which construct the wave function starting from Madelung variables
ψ(q)=ρ(q)exp(ℏiS(q)), in particular, many variants of Nelsonian stochastics, are not equivalent to quantum theory. Accepting this, we explicitly add the physical restriction
(∀q∈Q)∣ψ(q)∣2>0 in the configuration space representation to quantum theory. The resulting theories depend on the choice of the configuration space
Q. The restriction adds possibilities to falsify such theories, making them preferable following Popper's criterion of empirical content until they have been really falsified. Considering the case of a relativistic scalar field, we argue that it is reasonable to expect that the variant based on particle ontology can be (or even has been already) falsified, while to falsify the variant based on field ontology seems much harder, if not impossible. If correct, switching to a field ontology seems a reasonable choice for interpretations based on Madelung variables to circumvent the Wallstrom objection.