Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2212.10652 · Journal of High Energy Physics

Wormholes, geons, and the illusion of the tensor product

Adam Bzowski

Published Mar 30, 2023• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In this paper I argue that the Hilbert space of states of a holographic, traversable wormhole does not factorize into the tensor product of the boundary Hilbert spaces. After presenting the general argument I analyze two examples: the scalar sectors of the BTZ geon and the AdS2 eternal wormhole. Utilizing real-time holography I derive the Hilbert spaces, identify the dual states and evaluate correlation functions. I show that the number of peculiarities associated with the wormhole and black hole physics emerges once the factorization is a priori assumed. This includes null states and null operators, highly entangled vacuum states and the cross-boundary interactions all emerging as avatars of non-factorization.

DOI
10.1007/jhep03(2023)244

Related papers

Breaking the spell of the tensor product

Adam Bzowski

In this essay I argue that the Hilbert space of states dual to a traversable wormhole is smaller than the tensor product of the independent Hilbert spaces of the boundary field theories. From the point of view of semiclassical physics, the decrease in the number of states is perceived as an emergent, non-local interaction stabilizing the wormhole. This presents new possibilities for models of radiating black holes and raises questions about results established under the spell of the tensor product.

arXiv:2104.06425•Apr 13, 2021•1 citation

Multiboundary wormholes and holographic entanglement

Vijay Balasubramanian, Patrick M. Hayden, Alexander Maloney +2 more

The AdS/CFT correspondence relates quantum entanglement between boundary Conformal Field Theories and geometric connections in the dual asymptotically Anti-de Sitter space-time. We consider entangled states in the n-fold tensor product of a 1+1 dimensional CFT Hilbert space defined by the Euclidean path integral over a Riemann surface with n holes. In one region of moduli space, the dual bulk state is a black hole with n asymptotically AdS_3 regions connected by a common wormhole, while in other regions the bulk fragments into disconnected components. We study the entanglement structure and compute the wave function explicitly in the puncture limit of the Riemann surface in terms of CFT n-point functions. We also use AdS minimal surfaces to measure entanglement more generally. In some regions of the moduli space the entanglement is entirely multipartite, though not of the GHZ type. However, even when the bulk is completely connected, in some regions of the moduli space the entanglement is almost entirely bipartite: significant entanglement occurs only between pairs of CFTs. We develop new tools to analyze intrinsically n-partite entanglement, and use these to show that for some wormholes with n similar sized horizons there is intrinsic entanglement between at least n-1 parties, and that the distillable entanglement between the asymptotic regions is at least (n+1)/2 partite.

arXiv:1406.2663•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Sep 5, 2014•172 citations

Symmetry topological field theory entanglement and holographic nonfactorization

Ethan Torres, Xingyang Yu

Given two otherwise decoupled D -dimensional CFTs which possess a common (finite) symmetry subcategory, one can consider entangled boundary states of their ( D + 1 )-dimensional symmetry topological field theories (SymTFTs). This roughly corresponds to performing a gauging of the tensor product of two CFTs, and we call this phenomena “SymTFT entanglement” (or “S entanglement” for short). In the case when these CFTs have semiclassical holographic duals, the S entanglement relates the bulk gauge charges between two otherwise disconnected AdS spacetimes as we highlight in several top-down examples. We show that taking partial traces of such S-entangled states leads to a streamlined approach to preparing ensemble-averaged CFTs in string theory. This ensemble averaging coincides with that generated by α states in the baby universe Hilbert space, and we propose a symmetry-enriched generalization of this Hilbert space via generalized global symmetries. We quantify how this symmetry-governed averaging violates holographic factorization and leads to the emergence of bulk global symmetries. We also consider the eternal (two-sided) AdS black hole geometries, where our SymTFT entanglement considerations imply that there exist refinements of the usual theromofield double state preparation of the system. We show that one may prepare the system in such a way that the total CFT data does not factorize into left and right copies. As anticipated by Marolf and Wall [], we highlight that such considerations are necessary to define the gauge charges of eternal black holes and, in certain cases, can imply that there exist extended bulk objects stretching across the wormhole which cannot be expressed in terms of a product of left and right CFT operators.

arXiv:2510.06319•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Apr 27, 2026•10 citations

Supergravity flows, wormholes and their pseudo-Hermitian holographic duals

Jose M. Begines, Antón F. Faedo, Carlos Hoyos +1 more

We find solutions to consistent truncations of supergravity where some real scalars are analytically extended to imaginary values, ensuring the metric remains real-valued. Among the solutions there are Lorentzian traversable wormholes connecting two asymptotically Anti-de Sitter spacetimes and flows that have a real metric also when uplifted to ten or eleven dimensions. We argue that the holographic duals are pseudo-Hermitian and $PT$-symmetric theories. Wormhole solutions also admit an interpretation as the low-energy theory of two stacks of branes and antibranes after tachyon condensation. The wormhole is then dual to an entangled state of two copies of the theory that lives on a stack of branes. We present some evidence by computing the mutual information between the theories at each boundary and by identifying the Goldstone bosons associated to the breaking of the two copies of Poincaré symmetry to their diagonal subgroup.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2605.16168•May 18, 2026

Wormholes as Quantum Circuits: Holographic Traversability via Double-Trace Coupling — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: Traversable wormholes are not spacetime objects but quantum-information protocols — realized as holographic duals in SYK-type quantum circuits, not gravitational laboratories. MATH: Core equation (Gao–Jafferis–Wall, 2017): the coupling term between left (L) and right (R) boundaries is δS = ∫ dt (q_L(t) q_R(t)) · g² — a double-trace deformation with coupling g. Traversability condition: g > 0 (negative null energy injected via Casimir-like coupling). Key duality: AdS₂ eternal wormhole ↔ thermofield double (TFD) state |TFD⟩ = Σₙ e^(−βEₙ/2)|n⟩_L|n⟩_R. Jafferis et al. (Nature 2022): 9-qubit SYK on Google Sycamore; signal = mutual information I(L:R) > 0 after insertion of probe qubit, measured via out-of-time-order correlators (OTOC). Maldacena–Qi (2018): traversable wormhole ⟺ quantum teleportation protocol; signal-to-noise ∝ e^(−βE) where β = 1/k_BT. CONNECTION: The TFD state's Boltzmann weights e^(−βEₙ/2) form a geometric series — the same structure underlying the golden-rati Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

Wormholes and out-of-time ordered correlators in gauge/gravity duality

Mihailo Čubrović

We calculate the four-wave scattering amplitude in the background of an AdS traversable wormhole in 2+1 dimensions created by a nonlocal coupling of AdS boundaries in the BTZ black hole background. The holographic dual of this setup is a pair of CFTs coupled via a double-trace deformation, the scattering amplitude giving the out-of-time ordered correlator (OTOC) in CFT. Short-living wormholes always exhibit a regime of fast scrambling, saturating the MSS bound for the Lyapunov exponent but in the early-time regime the scrambling can be slower, with a Lyapunov exponent linear in $T$ but below the MSS bound. For long-living (near-eternal) wormholes however the numerics suggests the existence of another regime, with a drastic (exponential) slowdown of scrambling and an exponentially small Lyapunov exponent. Our findings have parallels in the SYK model, and may indicate certain limitations of wormhole teleportation protocols previously studied in the literature.

arXiv:2103.01372•Mar 2, 2021•0 citations
Abstract In this paper I argue that the Hilbert space of states of a holographic, traversable wormhole does not factorize into the tensor product of the boundary Hilbert spaces. After presenting the general argument I analyze two examples: the scalar sectors of the BTZ geon and the AdS2 eternal wormhole. Utilizing real-time holography I derive the Hilbert spaces, identify the dual states and evaluate correlation functions. I show that the number of peculiarities associated with the wormhole and black hole physics emerges once the factorization is a priori assumed. This includes null states and null operators, highly entangled vacuum states and the cross-boundary interactions all emerging as avatars of non-factorization.
In this essay I argue that the Hilbert space of states dual to a traversable wormhole is smaller than the tensor product of the independent Hilbert spaces of the boundary field theories. From the point of view of semiclassical physics, the decrease in the number of states is perceived as an emergent, non-local interaction stabilizing the wormhole. This presents new possibilities for models of radiating black holes and raises questions about results established under the spell of the tensor product.
The AdS/CFT correspondence relates quantum entanglement between boundary Conformal Field Theories and geometric connections in the dual asymptotically Anti-de Sitter space-time. We consider entangled states in the n-fold tensor product of a 1+1 dimensional CFT Hilbert space defined by the Euclidean path integral over a Riemann surface with n holes. In one region of moduli space, the dual bulk state is a black hole with n asymptotically AdS_3 regions connected by a common wormhole, while in other regions the bulk fragments into disconnected components. We study the entanglement structure and compute the wave function explicitly in the puncture limit of the Riemann surface in terms of CFT n-point functions. We also use AdS minimal surfaces to measure entanglement more generally. In some regions of the moduli space the entanglement is entirely multipartite, though not of the GHZ type. However, even when the bulk is completely connected, in some regions of the moduli space the entanglement is almost entirely bipartite: significant entanglement occurs only between pairs of CFTs. We develop new tools to analyze intrinsically n-partite entanglement, and use these to show that for some wormholes with n similar sized horizons there is intrinsic entanglement between at least n-1 parties, and that the distillable entanglement between the asymptotic regions is at least (n+1)/2 partite.
Given two otherwise decoupled D -dimensional CFTs which possess a common (finite) symmetry subcategory, one can consider entangled boundary states of their ( D + 1 )-dimensional symmetry topological field theories (SymTFTs). This roughly corresponds to performing a gauging of the tensor product of two CFTs, and we call this phenomena “SymTFT entanglement” (or “S entanglement” for short). In the case when these CFTs have semiclassical holographic duals, the S entanglement relates the bulk gauge charges between two otherwise disconnected AdS spacetimes as we highlight in several top-down examples. We show that taking partial traces of such S-entangled states leads to a streamlined approach to preparing ensemble-averaged CFTs in string theory. This ensemble averaging coincides with that generated by α states in the baby universe Hilbert space, and we propose a symmetry-enriched generalization of this Hilbert space via generalized global symmetries. We quantify how this symmetry-governed averaging violates holographic factorization and leads to the emergence of bulk global symmetries. We also consider the eternal (two-sided) AdS black hole geometries, where our SymTFT entanglement considerations imply that there exist refinements of the usual theromofield double state preparation of the system. We show that one may prepare the system in such a way that the total CFT data does not factorize into left and right copies. As anticipated by Marolf and Wall [], we highlight that such considerations are necessary to define the gauge charges of eternal black holes and, in certain cases, can imply that there exist extended bulk objects stretching across the wormhole which cannot be expressed in terms of a product of left and right CFT operators.
We find solutions to consistent truncations of supergravity where some real scalars are analytically extended to imaginary values, ensuring the metric remains real-valued. Among the solutions there are Lorentzian traversable wormholes connecting two asymptotically Anti-de Sitter spacetimes and flows that have a real metric also when uplifted to ten or eleven dimensions. We argue that the holographic duals are pseudo-Hermitian and PTPTPT-symmetric theories. Wormhole solutions also admit an interpretation as the low-energy theory of two stacks of branes and antibranes after tachyon condensation. The wormhole is then dual to an entangled state of two copies of the theory that lives on a stack of branes. We present some evidence by computing the mutual information between the theories at each boundary and by identifying the Goldstone bosons associated to the breaking of the two copies of Poincaré symmetry to their diagonal subgroup.
FINDING: Traversable wormholes are not spacetime objects but quantum-information protocols — realized as holographic duals in SYK-type quantum circuits, not gravitational laboratories. MATH: Core equation (Gao–Jafferis–Wall, 2017): the coupling term between left (L) and right (R) boundaries is δS = ∫ dt (q_L(t) q_R(t)) · g² — a double-trace deformation with coupling g. Traversability condition: g > 0 (negative null energy injected via Casimir-like coupling). Key duality: AdS₂ eternal wormhole ↔ thermofield double (TFD) state |TFD⟩ = Σₙ e^(−βEₙ/2)|n⟩_L|n⟩_R. Jafferis et al. (Nature 2022): 9-qubit SYK on Google Sycamore; signal = mutual information I(L:R) > 0 after insertion of probe qubit, measured via out-of-time-order correlators (OTOC). Maldacena–Qi (2018): traversable wormhole ⟺ quantum teleportation protocol; signal-to-noise ∝ e^(−βE) where β = 1/k_BT. CONNECTION: The TFD state's Boltzmann weights e^(−βEₙ/2) form a geometric series — the same structure underlying the golden-rati Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
We calculate the four-wave scattering amplitude in the background of an AdS traversable wormhole in 2+1 dimensions created by a nonlocal coupling of AdS boundaries in the BTZ black hole background. The holographic dual of this setup is a pair of CFTs coupled via a double-trace deformation, the scattering amplitude giving the out-of-time ordered correlator (OTOC) in CFT. Short-living wormholes always exhibit a regime of fast scrambling, saturating the MSS bound for the Lyapunov exponent but in the early-time regime the scrambling can be slower, with a Lyapunov exponent linear in TTT but below the MSS bound. For long-living (near-eternal) wormholes however the numerics suggests the existence of another regime, with a drastic (exponential) slowdown of scrambling and an exponentially small Lyapunov exponent. Our findings have parallels in the SYK model, and may indicate certain limitations of wormhole teleportation protocols previously studied in the literature.