Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2104.06425

Breaking the spell of the tensor product

Adam Bzowski

Published Apr 13, 2021• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this essay I argue that the Hilbert space of states dual to a traversable wormhole is smaller than the tensor product of the independent Hilbert spaces of the boundary field theories. From the point of view of semiclassical physics, the decrease in the number of states is perceived as an emergent, non-local interaction stabilizing the wormhole. This presents new possibilities for models of radiating black holes and raises questions about results established under the spell of the tensor product.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2104.06425

Related papers

Wormholes, geons, and the illusion of the tensor product

Adam Bzowski

Abstract In this paper I argue that the Hilbert space of states of a holographic, traversable wormhole does not factorize into the tensor product of the boundary Hilbert spaces. After presenting the general argument I analyze two examples: the scalar sectors of the BTZ geon and the AdS2 eternal wormhole. Utilizing real-time holography I derive the Hilbert spaces, identify the dual states and evaluate correlation functions. I show that the number of peculiarities associated with the wormhole and black hole physics emerges once the factorization is a priori assumed. This includes null states and null operators, highly entangled vacuum states and the cross-boundary interactions all emerging as avatars of non-factorization.

arXiv:2212.10652•Journal of High Energy Physics•Mar 30, 2023•4 citations

Tensor networks for black hole interiors: non-isometries, quantum extremal surfaces, and wormholes

Gracemarie Bueller, Oliver Dewolfe A, Kenneth Higginbotham

A bstract We use hyperbolic tensor networks to construct a holographic map for black hole interiors that adds a notion of locality to the non-isometric codes proposed by Akers, Engelhardt, Harlow, Penington, and Vardhan. We use tools provided by these networks to study the relationship between non-isometries and quantum extremal surfaces behind the horizon. Furthermore, we introduce a limited notion of dynamics for these interior tensor networks based on the qudit models introduced by Akers et al., and study the evolution of quantum extremal surfaces in an evaporating black hole. We also find a tensor network description of a wormhole connecting the black hole interior to the radiation, providing a mechanism for interior states and operators to be encoded in the radiation after the Page time. As a particular case, we construct a tensor network realization of the backwards-forwards maps recently proposed to incorporate non-trivial effective dynamics in dynamical constructions of these non-isometric black hole codes.

arXiv:2407.01666•Journal of High Energy Physics•Oct 1, 2024•6 citations

Negative energies and the breakdown of bulk geometry

John Preskill, Mykhaylo Usatyuk, Shreya Vardhan

One central question in quantum gravity is to understand how and why predictions from semiclassical gravity can break down in regimes with low spacetime curvature. One diagnostic of such a breakdown is that states which are orthonormal at the semiclassical level can receive large corrections to their inner products from quantum fluctuations. We study this effect by examining inner products in pure 2D JT gravity. Previous work showed that black hole states with long interiors exhibit a breakdown at length scales of order $e^{S_0}$, where $S_0$ is a parameter analogous to $1/G_N$ in higher dimensions. This breakdown is caused by the discreteness of the spectrum of the dual boundary random matrix theory. We show that the full sum over quantum fluctuations indicates a more dramatic breakdown at parametrically shorter lengths of order $e^{S_0/3}$. In the dual boundary description, these corrections arise from negative energy states appearing in rare members of the random matrix ensemble. These results demonstrate that non-perturbative effects can invalidate the semiclassical description at much smaller length scales than previously expected, providing a new mechanism for the breakdown of effective gravitational theories.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2603.25782•Mar 30, 2026

The smallest interacting universe

Modjtaba Shokrian Zini, Adam R. Brown, Michael Hartley Freedman

Abstract We study a mechanism by which the most basic structures of quantum physics can emerge from the most meager of starting points, a Hilbert space, lacking any preassigned structure such as a tensor decomposition, and a loss function. In a simple toy model of the universe, we hypothesize a fundamental loss functional for the combined Hamiltonian and quantum state, and then minimize this loss functional by gradient descent. We find that this minimization gives rise to a co-emergence of locality, i.e. a tensor product structure simultaneously respected by both the Hamiltonian and the state, suggesting that locality can emerge by a process analogous to spontaneous symmetry breaking. We discuss the relevance of this program to the arrow of time problem. In our toy model, we interpret the emergence of a tensor factorization as the appearance of individual degrees of freedom within a previously undifferentiated (raw) Hilbert space. Earlier work [5, 6] looked at the emergence of locality in Hamiltonians only, and in that context found strong numerical confirmation of the hypothesis that raw Hilbert spaces of dim = n are unstable and prefer to settle on tensor factorization when n is not prime, expressing, for example, n = pq, and in [6] even primes were seen to “factor” after first shedding a small summand, e.g. 7 = 1 + 2 · 3. This was found in the context of a rather general potential functional F on the space of metrics {gij} on $$ \mathfrak{su} $$ su (n), the Lie algebra of symmetries. This emergence of qunits through operator-level spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) may help us understand why the world seems to consist of myriad interacting degrees of freedom. But understanding why the universe has an initial Hamiltonian H0 with a many-body structure is of limited conceptual value unless the initial state, ∣ψ0〉, is also structured by this tensor decomposition. Here we adapt F to become a functional on {g, | ψ0〉} = (metrics) × (initial states), and find SSB now produces a conspiracy between g and ∣ψ0〉, where they simultaneously attain low entropy by jointly settling on the same qubit decomposition. Extreme scaling of the computational problem has confined us to studying ℂ4 breaking to ℂ2 ⊗ ℂ2 and ℂ8 breaking to ℂ2 ⊗ ℂ4 or ℂ2 ⊗ ℂ2 ⊗ ℂ2.

arXiv:2208.00944•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jan 16, 2023•2 citations

Tensor network models of unitary black hole evaporation

Samuel Leutheusser, Mark Van Raamsdonk B

We introduce a general class of toy models to study the quantum information-theoretic properties of black hole radiation. The models are governed by a set of isometries that specify how microstates of the black hole at a given energy evolve to entangled states of a tensor product black-hole/radiation Hilbert space. The final state of the black hole radiation is conveniently summarized by a tensor network built from these isometries. We introduce a set of quantities generalizing the Renyi entropies that provide a complete set of bipartite/multipartite entanglement measures, and give a general formula for the average of these over initial black hole states in terms of the isometries defining the model. For models where the dimension of the final tensor product radiation Hilbert space is the same as that of the space of initial black hole microstates, the entanglement structure is universal, independent of the choice of isometries. In the more general case, we find that models which best capture the “information-free” property of black hole horizons are those whose isometries are tensors corresponding to states of tripartite systems with maximally mixed subsystems.

arXiv:1611.08613•Journal of High Energy Physics•Aug 1, 2017•10 citations

On the emergence of preferred structures in quantum theory

Antoine Soulas, Guilherme Franzmann, Andrea Di Biagio

We assess the possibilities offered by Hilbert space fundamentalism, an attitude towards quantum physics according to which all physical structures (e.g. subsystems, locality, spacetime, preferred observables) should emerge from minimal quantum ingredients (typically a Hilbert space, Hamiltonian, and state). As a case study, we first mainly focus on the specific question of whether the Hamiltonian can uniquely determine a tensor product structure, a crucial challenge in the growing field of quantum mereology. The present paper reviews, clarifies, and critically examines two apparently conflicting theorems by Cotler et al. and Stoica. We resolve the tension, show how the former has been widely misinterpreted and why the latter is correct only in some weaker version. We then propose a correct mathematical way to address the general problem of preferred structures in quantum theory, relative to the characterization of emergent objects by unitary-invariant properties. Finally, we apply this formalism in the particular case we started with, and show that a Hamiltonian and a state are enough structure to uniquely select a preferred tensor product structure.

quant-pharXiv:2512.07468•Dec 9, 2025•10 citations
In this essay I argue that the Hilbert space of states dual to a traversable wormhole is smaller than the tensor product of the independent Hilbert spaces of the boundary field theories. From the point of view of semiclassical physics, the decrease in the number of states is perceived as an emergent, non-local interaction stabilizing the wormhole. This presents new possibilities for models of radiating black holes and raises questions about results established under the spell of the tensor product.
Abstract In this paper I argue that the Hilbert space of states of a holographic, traversable wormhole does not factorize into the tensor product of the boundary Hilbert spaces. After presenting the general argument I analyze two examples: the scalar sectors of the BTZ geon and the AdS2 eternal wormhole. Utilizing real-time holography I derive the Hilbert spaces, identify the dual states and evaluate correlation functions. I show that the number of peculiarities associated with the wormhole and black hole physics emerges once the factorization is a priori assumed. This includes null states and null operators, highly entangled vacuum states and the cross-boundary interactions all emerging as avatars of non-factorization.
A bstract We use hyperbolic tensor networks to construct a holographic map for black hole interiors that adds a notion of locality to the non-isometric codes proposed by Akers, Engelhardt, Harlow, Penington, and Vardhan. We use tools provided by these networks to study the relationship between non-isometries and quantum extremal surfaces behind the horizon. Furthermore, we introduce a limited notion of dynamics for these interior tensor networks based on the qudit models introduced by Akers et al., and study the evolution of quantum extremal surfaces in an evaporating black hole. We also find a tensor network description of a wormhole connecting the black hole interior to the radiation, providing a mechanism for interior states and operators to be encoded in the radiation after the Page time. As a particular case, we construct a tensor network realization of the backwards-forwards maps recently proposed to incorporate non-trivial effective dynamics in dynamical constructions of these non-isometric black hole codes.
One central question in quantum gravity is to understand how and why predictions from semiclassical gravity can break down in regimes with low spacetime curvature. One diagnostic of such a breakdown is that states which are orthonormal at the semiclassical level can receive large corrections to their inner products from quantum fluctuations. We study this effect by examining inner products in pure 2D JT gravity. Previous work showed that black hole states with long interiors exhibit a breakdown at length scales of order eS0e^{S_0}eS0​, where S0S_0S0​ is a parameter analogous to 1/GN1/G_N1/GN​ in higher dimensions. This breakdown is caused by the discreteness of the spectrum of the dual boundary random matrix theory. We show that the full sum over quantum fluctuations indicates a more dramatic breakdown at parametrically shorter lengths of order eS0/3e^{S_0/3}eS0​/3. In the dual boundary description, these corrections arise from negative energy states appearing in rare members of the random matrix ensemble. These results demonstrate that non-perturbative effects can invalidate the semiclassical description at much smaller length scales than previously expected, providing a new mechanism for the breakdown of effective gravitational theories.
Abstract We study a mechanism by which the most basic structures of quantum physics can emerge from the most meager of starting points, a Hilbert space, lacking any preassigned structure such as a tensor decomposition, and a loss function. In a simple toy model of the universe, we hypothesize a fundamental loss functional for the combined Hamiltonian and quantum state, and then minimize this loss functional by gradient descent. We find that this minimization gives rise to a co-emergence of locality, i.e. a tensor product structure simultaneously respected by both the Hamiltonian and the state, suggesting that locality can emerge by a process analogous to spontaneous symmetry breaking. We discuss the relevance of this program to the arrow of time problem. In our toy model, we interpret the emergence of a tensor factorization as the appearance of individual degrees of freedom within a previously undifferentiated (raw) Hilbert space. Earlier work [5, 6] looked at the emergence of locality in Hamiltonians only, and in that context found strong numerical confirmation of the hypothesis that raw Hilbert spaces of dim = n are unstable and prefer to settle on tensor factorization when n is not prime, expressing, for example, n = pq, and in [6] even primes were seen to “factor” after first shedding a small summand, e.g. 7 = 1 + 2 · 3. This was found in the context of a rather general potential functional F on the space of metrics {gij} on su \mathfrak{su} su su (n), the Lie algebra of symmetries. This emergence of qunits through operator-level spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) may help us understand why the world seems to consist of myriad interacting degrees of freedom. But understanding why the universe has an initial Hamiltonian H0 with a many-body structure is of limited conceptual value unless the initial state, ∣ψ0〉, is also structured by this tensor decomposition. Here we adapt F to become a functional on {g, | ψ0〉} = (metrics) × (initial states), and find SSB now produces a conspiracy between g and ∣ψ0〉, where they simultaneously attain low entropy by jointly settling on the same qubit decomposition. Extreme scaling of the computational problem has confined us to studying ℂ4 breaking to ℂ2 ⊗ ℂ2 and ℂ8 breaking to ℂ2 ⊗ ℂ4 or ℂ2 ⊗ ℂ2 ⊗ ℂ2.
We introduce a general class of toy models to study the quantum information-theoretic properties of black hole radiation. The models are governed by a set of isometries that specify how microstates of the black hole at a given energy evolve to entangled states of a tensor product black-hole/radiation Hilbert space. The final state of the black hole radiation is conveniently summarized by a tensor network built from these isometries. We introduce a set of quantities generalizing the Renyi entropies that provide a complete set of bipartite/multipartite entanglement measures, and give a general formula for the average of these over initial black hole states in terms of the isometries defining the model. For models where the dimension of the final tensor product radiation Hilbert space is the same as that of the space of initial black hole microstates, the entanglement structure is universal, independent of the choice of isometries. In the more general case, we find that models which best capture the “information-free” property of black hole horizons are those whose isometries are tensors corresponding to states of tripartite systems with maximally mixed subsystems.
We assess the possibilities offered by Hilbert space fundamentalism, an attitude towards quantum physics according to which all physical structures (e.g. subsystems, locality, spacetime, preferred observables) should emerge from minimal quantum ingredients (typically a Hilbert space, Hamiltonian, and state). As a case study, we first mainly focus on the specific question of whether the Hamiltonian can uniquely determine a tensor product structure, a crucial challenge in the growing field of quantum mereology. The present paper reviews, clarifies, and critically examines two apparently conflicting theorems by Cotler et al. and Stoica. We resolve the tension, show how the former has been widely misinterpreted and why the latter is correct only in some weaker version. We then propose a correct mathematical way to address the general problem of preferred structures in quantum theory, relative to the characterization of emergent objects by unitary-invariant properties. Finally, we apply this formalism in the particular case we started with, and show that a Hamiltonian and a state are enough structure to uniquely select a preferred tensor product structure.