Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2212.04305 · Entropy

The Thermomajorization Polytope and Its Degeneracies

Frederik vom Ende, Emanuel Malvetti

Published Jan 24, 2024• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Drawing inspiration from transportation theory, in this work, we introduce the notions of "well-structured" and "stable" Gibbs states and we investigate their implications for quantum thermodynamics and its resource theory approach via thermal operations. It is found that, in the quasi-classical realm, global cyclic state transfers are impossible if and only if the Gibbs state is stable. Moreover, using a geometric approach by studying the so-called thermomajorization polytope, we prove that any subspace in equilibrium can be brought out of equilibrium via thermal operations. Interestingly, the case of some subsystem being in equilibrium can be witnessed via the degenerate extreme points of the thermomajorization polytope, assuming that the Gibbs state of the system is well structured. These physical considerations are complemented by simple new constructions for the polytope's extreme points, as well as for an important class of extremal Gibbs-stochastic matrices.

DOI
10.3390/e26020106

Related papers

Polytopic Quantum Resource Theories: Geometry and Structures

Moein Naseri, Chirag Srivastava, Chandan Datta +2 more

Quantum resource theories provide a unifying framework to quantify, compare, and manipulate quantum resources under well-defined operational constraints. Here, we consider any resource theory where the set of free states can be expressed as a convex combination of a set of quantum states, referred to as extremal states and name them as polytopic quantum resource theories (PQRT). These include some of the most studied resource theories, such as coherence and magic. We formulate a novel tensorial representation of PQRTs that reveals the underlying geometry of these theories and provides insight into the origin of the resources. We further address a fundamental question in resource theories that when two theories should be regarded as physically equivalent, and to this purpose we introduce notions of homomorphism and isomorphism that compare both the structure of free states and the allowed transformations. Using the tools we develop, we find results revealing the geometrical and structural foundations of such theories. Interestingly, we find that all polytopic resource theories with a fixed number of pure extremal points are equivalent under a physical map, up to normalisation. Additionally, we introduce linearly independent polytopic resource theories (resource theory of ``basis-non-convexity''), where the set of extremal free states forms a basis of the quantum density operators. We further study the categorical structures of PQRTs beyond single systems.

quant-pharXiv:2606.00429•Jun 2, 2026•1 citation

Thermal processes and state achievability

Paweł Mazurek

The resource theory of thermal operations aims at describing possible transitions of microscale systems interacting with a macroscale environment under the fundamental assumption of energy conservation. For initial quantum states diagonal in the basis of the local Hamiltonian, these transitions are completely described by thermal processes (TPs), which form a convex set. In this paper, we give a complete characterization of the set of states that can be achieved through TPs, by describing the boundary of the allowed set of states using the so-called thermomajorization curves as a tool. We address the problem of achieving a certain transition through a convex combination of products of extremal TPs. We characterize all extremal TPs by associating them with transportation matrices. It becomes evident that there are extremal TPs that are not required in the implementation of any transition allowed by TPs. The statement holds for every dimension $d\ensuremath{\ge}4$ of the state space. A property of the associated graphs, biplanarity, is identified as the distinguishing feature of these extremal TPs that are required for the arbitrary transition allowed by TPs.

arXiv:1810.05578•Physical Review A•Apr 10, 2019•12 citations

Gibbs state postulate from dynamical stability

Vjosa Blakaj, Matthias C. Caro, Anouar Kouraich +2 more

Gibbs states play a central role in quantum statistical mechanics as the standard description of thermal equilibrium. Traditionally, their use is justified either by a heuristic, a posteriori reasoning, or by derivations based on notions of typicality or passivity. In this work, we show that Gibbs states are completely characterized by assuming dynamical stability of the system itself and of the system in weak contact with an arbitrary environment. This builds on and strengthens a result by Frigerio, Gorini, and Verri (1986), who derived Gibbs states from dynamical stability using an additional assumption that they referred to as the "zeroth law of thermodynamics", as it concerns a nested dynamical stability of a triple of systems. We prove that this "zeroth law" is redundant and that an environment consisting solely of harmonic oscillators is sufficient to single out Gibbs states as the only dynamically stable states.

math-phCross-listedarXiv:2512.13451•Annales Henri Poincaré•Dec 16, 2025•1 citation

Quantum Thermodynamics

Gilad Gour

Chapter 17 delves into quantum thermodynamics, building on the concepts introduced in the resource theory of nonuniformity. This chapter focuses on thermal states and athermality as resources within the quantum domain, emphasizing the significance of Gibbs states and their role in quantum statistical mechanics. It outlines the operational framework for thermal operations, setting the stage for discussions on energy conservation and the second law of thermodynamics in quantum systems. A key aspect of the chapter is the exploration of quasi-classical athermality, illustrating how quantum states deviate from thermal equilibrium when the state of the system commutes with its Hamiltonian. In the fully quantum domain, the chapter introduces closed formulas for quantifying athermality, such as the athermality cost and distillable athermality, both in the single-shot and the asymptotic domains. These measures provide a quantitative understanding of the efficiency of thermal operations and the potential for work extraction or consumption.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 10, 2025•0 citations

Decomposability and convex structure of thermal processes

Paweł Mazurek, Michał Horodecki

We present an example of a thermal process (TP) for a system of d energy levels, which cannot be performed without an instant access to the whole energy space. This TP is uniquely connected with a transition between some states of the system, that cannot be performed without access to the whole energy space even when approximate transitions are allowed. Pursuing the question about the decomposability of TPs into convex combinations of compositions of processes acting non-trivially on smaller subspaces, we investigate transitions within the subspace of states diagonal in the energy basis. For three level systems, we determine the set of extremal points of these operations, as well as the minimal set of operations needed to perform an arbitrary TP, and connect the set of TPs with thermomajorization criterion. We show that the structure of the set depends on temperature, which is associated with the fact that TPs cannot increase deterministically extractable work from a state—the conclusion that holds for arbitrary d level system. We also connect the decomposability problem with detailed balance symmetry of an extremal TPs.

arXiv:1707.06869•New Journal of Physics•Apr 26, 2018•29 citations

Thermal Operations from Informational Equilibrium

Seok Hyung Lie, Jeongrak Son, Paul Boës +2 more

Thermal operations are quantum channels that play a central role in deriving thermodynamic limitations in quantum systems. However, they were originally defined by implementation procedures rather than by fundamental principles. Alternative models of thermal processes have been proposed, but they obscure the resources required for implementation. Here, we identify the universal principle that separates these models. We show that thermal operations are uniquely characterized by a purely quantum information-theoretic property, which we call informational equilibrium. This formulation does not assume a particular Hamiltonian or even a notion of temperature: a channel is a thermal operation precisely when it leaves its environment invariant whenever the system is prepared in equilibrium. In this way, the usual energetic description of equilibrium (i.e., Gibbs states) emerges as a representation of an underlying informational constraint. Extending this framework, we note that enforcing environment invariance for all system inputs leads to catalytic channels, which idealize perfectly reusable heat baths. This informational equilibrium perspective culminates in a hierarchy for doubly-stochastic quantum channels, with strict separations between the classes. Our refined hierarchy sharpens the failure of the Birkhoff-von Neumann theorem in the quantum regime, and highlights the richer structural landscape of quantum channels compared to classical stochastic processes that cannot be captured by state-convertibility relations.

arXiv:2507.16637•Physical Review Letters•Jun 24, 2026•4 citations
Drawing inspiration from transportation theory, in this work, we introduce the notions of "well-structured" and "stable" Gibbs states and we investigate their implications for quantum thermodynamics and its resource theory approach via thermal operations. It is found that, in the quasi-classical realm, global cyclic state transfers are impossible if and only if the Gibbs state is stable. Moreover, using a geometric approach by studying the so-called thermomajorization polytope, we prove that any subspace in equilibrium can be brought out of equilibrium via thermal operations. Interestingly, the case of some subsystem being in equilibrium can be witnessed via the degenerate extreme points of the thermomajorization polytope, assuming that the Gibbs state of the system is well structured. These physical considerations are complemented by simple new constructions for the polytope's extreme points, as well as for an important class of extremal Gibbs-stochastic matrices.
Quantum resource theories provide a unifying framework to quantify, compare, and manipulate quantum resources under well-defined operational constraints. Here, we consider any resource theory where the set of free states can be expressed as a convex combination of a set of quantum states, referred to as extremal states and name them as polytopic quantum resource theories (PQRT). These include some of the most studied resource theories, such as coherence and magic. We formulate a novel tensorial representation of PQRTs that reveals the underlying geometry of these theories and provides insight into the origin of the resources. We further address a fundamental question in resource theories that when two theories should be regarded as physically equivalent, and to this purpose we introduce notions of homomorphism and isomorphism that compare both the structure of free states and the allowed transformations. Using the tools we develop, we find results revealing the geometrical and structural foundations of such theories. Interestingly, we find that all polytopic resource theories with a fixed number of pure extremal points are equivalent under a physical map, up to normalisation. Additionally, we introduce linearly independent polytopic resource theories (resource theory of ``basis-non-convexity''), where the set of extremal free states forms a basis of the quantum density operators. We further study the categorical structures of PQRTs beyond single systems.
The resource theory of thermal operations aims at describing possible transitions of microscale systems interacting with a macroscale environment under the fundamental assumption of energy conservation. For initial quantum states diagonal in the basis of the local Hamiltonian, these transitions are completely described by thermal processes (TPs), which form a convex set. In this paper, we give a complete characterization of the set of states that can be achieved through TPs, by describing the boundary of the allowed set of states using the so-called thermomajorization curves as a tool. We address the problem of achieving a certain transition through a convex combination of products of extremal TPs. We characterize all extremal TPs by associating them with transportation matrices. It becomes evident that there are extremal TPs that are not required in the implementation of any transition allowed by TPs. The statement holds for every dimension $d\ensuremath{\ge}4$ of the state space. A property of the associated graphs, biplanarity, is identified as the distinguishing feature of these extremal TPs that are required for the arbitrary transition allowed by TPs.
Gibbs states play a central role in quantum statistical mechanics as the standard description of thermal equilibrium. Traditionally, their use is justified either by a heuristic, a posteriori reasoning, or by derivations based on notions of typicality or passivity. In this work, we show that Gibbs states are completely characterized by assuming dynamical stability of the system itself and of the system in weak contact with an arbitrary environment. This builds on and strengthens a result by Frigerio, Gorini, and Verri (1986), who derived Gibbs states from dynamical stability using an additional assumption that they referred to as the "zeroth law of thermodynamics", as it concerns a nested dynamical stability of a triple of systems. We prove that this "zeroth law" is redundant and that an environment consisting solely of harmonic oscillators is sufficient to single out Gibbs states as the only dynamically stable states.
Chapter 17 delves into quantum thermodynamics, building on the concepts introduced in the resource theory of nonuniformity. This chapter focuses on thermal states and athermality as resources within the quantum domain, emphasizing the significance of Gibbs states and their role in quantum statistical mechanics. It outlines the operational framework for thermal operations, setting the stage for discussions on energy conservation and the second law of thermodynamics in quantum systems. A key aspect of the chapter is the exploration of quasi-classical athermality, illustrating how quantum states deviate from thermal equilibrium when the state of the system commutes with its Hamiltonian. In the fully quantum domain, the chapter introduces closed formulas for quantifying athermality, such as the athermality cost and distillable athermality, both in the single-shot and the asymptotic domains. These measures provide a quantitative understanding of the efficiency of thermal operations and the potential for work extraction or consumption.
We present an example of a thermal process (TP) for a system of d energy levels, which cannot be performed without an instant access to the whole energy space. This TP is uniquely connected with a transition between some states of the system, that cannot be performed without access to the whole energy space even when approximate transitions are allowed. Pursuing the question about the decomposability of TPs into convex combinations of compositions of processes acting non-trivially on smaller subspaces, we investigate transitions within the subspace of states diagonal in the energy basis. For three level systems, we determine the set of extremal points of these operations, as well as the minimal set of operations needed to perform an arbitrary TP, and connect the set of TPs with thermomajorization criterion. We show that the structure of the set depends on temperature, which is associated with the fact that TPs cannot increase deterministically extractable work from a state—the conclusion that holds for arbitrary d level system. We also connect the decomposability problem with detailed balance symmetry of an extremal TPs.
Thermal operations are quantum channels that play a central role in deriving thermodynamic limitations in quantum systems. However, they were originally defined by implementation procedures rather than by fundamental principles. Alternative models of thermal processes have been proposed, but they obscure the resources required for implementation. Here, we identify the universal principle that separates these models. We show that thermal operations are uniquely characterized by a purely quantum information-theoretic property, which we call informational equilibrium. This formulation does not assume a particular Hamiltonian or even a notion of temperature: a channel is a thermal operation precisely when it leaves its environment invariant whenever the system is prepared in equilibrium. In this way, the usual energetic description of equilibrium (i.e., Gibbs states) emerges as a representation of an underlying informational constraint. Extending this framework, we note that enforcing environment invariance for all system inputs leads to catalytic channels, which idealize perfectly reusable heat baths. This informational equilibrium perspective culminates in a hierarchy for doubly-stochastic quantum channels, with strict separations between the classes. Our refined hierarchy sharpens the failure of the Birkhoff-von Neumann theorem in the quantum regime, and highlights the richer structural landscape of quantum channels compared to classical stochastic processes that cannot be captured by state-convertibility relations.