Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1810.05578 · Physical Review A

Thermal processes and state achievability

Paweł Mazurek

Published Apr 10, 2019• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The resource theory of thermal operations aims at describing possible transitions of microscale systems interacting with a macroscale environment under the fundamental assumption of energy conservation. For initial quantum states diagonal in the basis of the local Hamiltonian, these transitions are completely described by thermal processes (TPs), which form a convex set. In this paper, we give a complete characterization of the set of states that can be achieved through TPs, by describing the boundary of the allowed set of states using the so-called thermomajorization curves as a tool. We address the problem of achieving a certain transition through a convex combination of products of extremal TPs. We characterize all extremal TPs by associating them with transportation matrices. It becomes evident that there are extremal TPs that are not required in the implementation of any transition allowed by TPs. The statement holds for every dimension $d\ensuremath{\ge}4$ of the state space. A property of the associated graphs, biplanarity, is identified as the distinguishing feature of these extremal TPs that are required for the arbitrary transition allowed by TPs.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.99.042110

Related papers

Decomposability and convex structure of thermal processes

Paweł Mazurek, Michał Horodecki

We present an example of a thermal process (TP) for a system of d energy levels, which cannot be performed without an instant access to the whole energy space. This TP is uniquely connected with a transition between some states of the system, that cannot be performed without access to the whole energy space even when approximate transitions are allowed. Pursuing the question about the decomposability of TPs into convex combinations of compositions of processes acting non-trivially on smaller subspaces, we investigate transitions within the subspace of states diagonal in the energy basis. For three level systems, we determine the set of extremal points of these operations, as well as the minimal set of operations needed to perform an arbitrary TP, and connect the set of TPs with thermomajorization criterion. We show that the structure of the set depends on temperature, which is associated with the fact that TPs cannot increase deterministically extractable work from a state—the conclusion that holds for arbitrary d level system. We also connect the decomposability problem with detailed balance symmetry of an extremal TPs.

arXiv:1707.06869•New Journal of Physics•Apr 26, 2018•29 citations

Population Capacity and the Geometry of Thermomajorization

F. Meroi, C. Massri, M. Losada +2 more

We characterize quasiclassical state conversion under thermal operations through population capacities: the maximum population that thermal operations can concentrate on each set of energy levels. These capacities form a normalized, nondecreasing submodular rank function whose base polytope is exactly the thermally reachable population region. Their bounds therefore provide a complete system of accessibility constraints. Every nested chain of capacities can be simultaneously saturated by a reachable state, yielding the maximum expectation value of any prescribed observable, including the system Hamiltonian. For a prescribed target, its thermomajorization prefixes suffice to certify exact conversion through at most $n-1$ binary work-extraction probes. For approximate conversion, we construct a distinguished reachable state from active capacity constraints using a weighted principal sequence in $O(n^2 \log n)$ operations. At fixed comparison weights, this state minimizes every weighted convex separable residual cost and realizes a common first contact with the corresponding target-centered smoothing regions. Finally, the optimal trace-distance error equals the largest capacity advantage of the target over the initial state. This gap is attained at a target prefix and equals the largest positive optimized energy-storage deficit among the same binary probes, divided by their energy gap. Thus a common population capacity geometry determines accessibility, observable optimization, conversion certificates, and universal approximation.

quant-pharXiv:2610.35433•Oct 27, 2026•0 citations

The Thermomajorization Polytope and Its Degeneracies

Frederik vom Ende, Emanuel Malvetti

Drawing inspiration from transportation theory, in this work, we introduce the notions of "well-structured" and "stable" Gibbs states and we investigate their implications for quantum thermodynamics and its resource theory approach via thermal operations. It is found that, in the quasi-classical realm, global cyclic state transfers are impossible if and only if the Gibbs state is stable. Moreover, using a geometric approach by studying the so-called thermomajorization polytope, we prove that any subspace in equilibrium can be brought out of equilibrium via thermal operations. Interestingly, the case of some subsystem being in equilibrium can be witnessed via the degenerate extreme points of the thermomajorization polytope, assuming that the Gibbs state of the system is well structured. These physical considerations are complemented by simple new constructions for the polytope's extreme points, as well as for an important class of extremal Gibbs-stochastic matrices.

arXiv:2212.04305•Entropy•Jan 24, 2024•8 citations

Polytopic Quantum Resource Theories: Geometry and Structures

Moein Naseri, Chirag Srivastava, Chandan Datta +2 more

Quantum resource theories provide a unifying framework to quantify, compare, and manipulate quantum resources under well-defined operational constraints. Here, we consider any resource theory where the set of free states can be expressed as a convex combination of a set of quantum states, referred to as extremal states and name them as polytopic quantum resource theories (PQRT). These include some of the most studied resource theories, such as coherence and magic. We formulate a novel tensorial representation of PQRTs that reveals the underlying geometry of these theories and provides insight into the origin of the resources. We further address a fundamental question in resource theories that when two theories should be regarded as physically equivalent, and to this purpose we introduce notions of homomorphism and isomorphism that compare both the structure of free states and the allowed transformations. Using the tools we develop, we find results revealing the geometrical and structural foundations of such theories. Interestingly, we find that all polytopic resource theories with a fixed number of pure extremal points are equivalent under a physical map, up to normalisation. Additionally, we introduce linearly independent polytopic resource theories (resource theory of ``basis-non-convexity''), where the set of extremal free states forms a basis of the quantum density operators. We further study the categorical structures of PQRTs beyond single systems.

quant-pharXiv:2606.00429•Jun 2, 2026•1 citation

Thermal Operations in general are not memoryless

Hanna Wojewódka–Ściążko, Stankiewicz, Maciej, Edgar A. Aguilar +6 more

So-called Thermal Operations seem to describe the most fundamental and reasonable set of operations allowable for state transformations at an ambient inverse temperature $β$. However, a priori, they require experimentalists to manipulate very complex environments and have control over their internal degrees of freedom. For this reason, the community has been working on creating more experimentally-friendly operations. In [Perry, et al., Phys. Rev. X 8, 041049], it was shown that for states diagonal in the energy basis, Thermal Operations can be performed by so-called Coarse Operations, which need just one auxiliary qubit but are otherwise Markovian and classical in spirit. In this work, by providing an explicit counterexample, we show that this one qubit of memory is necessary. We also provide almost full characterization (i.e., full, but with one intriguing exception that remains open) of possible transitions that do not require memory in the case where the system is a qubit. We do this by analyzing arbitrary control sequences comprising level energy changes and partial thermalizations in each step.

arXiv:2009.03110•Sep 7, 2020•3 citations

Gaussian Thermal Operations and The Limits of Algorithmic Cooling

Alessio Serafini, Matteo Lostaglio, S Longden +3 more

The study of thermal operations allows one to investigate the ultimate possibilities of quantum states and of nanoscale thermal machines. Whilst fairly general, these results typically do not apply to continuous variable systems and do not take into account that, in many practically relevant settings, system-environment interactions are effectively bilinear. Here we tackle these issues by focusing on Gaussian quantum states and channels. We provide a complete characterization of the most general Gaussian thermal operation acting on an arbitrary number of bosonic modes, which turn out to be all embeddable in a Markovian dynamics, and derive necessary and sufficient conditions for state transformations under such operations in the single-mode case, encompassing states with nonzero coherence in the energy eigenbasis (i.e., squeezed states). Our analysis leads to a no-go result for the technologically relevant task of algorithmic cooling: We show that it is impossible to reduce the entropy of a system coupled to a Gaussian environment below its own or the environmental temperature, by means of a sequence of Gaussian thermal operations interspersed by arbitrary (even non-Gaussian) unitaries. These findings establish fundamental constraints on the usefulness of Gaussian resources for quantum thermodynamic processes.

arXiv:1909.06123•Physical Review Letters•Jan 2, 2020•38 citations
The resource theory of thermal operations aims at describing possible transitions of microscale systems interacting with a macroscale environment under the fundamental assumption of energy conservation. For initial quantum states diagonal in the basis of the local Hamiltonian, these transitions are completely described by thermal processes (TPs), which form a convex set. In this paper, we give a complete characterization of the set of states that can be achieved through TPs, by describing the boundary of the allowed set of states using the so-called thermomajorization curves as a tool. We address the problem of achieving a certain transition through a convex combination of products of extremal TPs. We characterize all extremal TPs by associating them with transportation matrices. It becomes evident that there are extremal TPs that are not required in the implementation of any transition allowed by TPs. The statement holds for every dimension d\ensuremath≥4d\ensuremath{\ge}4d\ensuremath≥4 of the state space. A property of the associated graphs, biplanarity, is identified as the distinguishing feature of these extremal TPs that are required for the arbitrary transition allowed by TPs.
We present an example of a thermal process (TP) for a system of d energy levels, which cannot be performed without an instant access to the whole energy space. This TP is uniquely connected with a transition between some states of the system, that cannot be performed without access to the whole energy space even when approximate transitions are allowed. Pursuing the question about the decomposability of TPs into convex combinations of compositions of processes acting non-trivially on smaller subspaces, we investigate transitions within the subspace of states diagonal in the energy basis. For three level systems, we determine the set of extremal points of these operations, as well as the minimal set of operations needed to perform an arbitrary TP, and connect the set of TPs with thermomajorization criterion. We show that the structure of the set depends on temperature, which is associated with the fact that TPs cannot increase deterministically extractable work from a state—the conclusion that holds for arbitrary d level system. We also connect the decomposability problem with detailed balance symmetry of an extremal TPs.
We characterize quasiclassical state conversion under thermal operations through population capacities: the maximum population that thermal operations can concentrate on each set of energy levels. These capacities form a normalized, nondecreasing submodular rank function whose base polytope is exactly the thermally reachable population region. Their bounds therefore provide a complete system of accessibility constraints. Every nested chain of capacities can be simultaneously saturated by a reachable state, yielding the maximum expectation value of any prescribed observable, including the system Hamiltonian. For a prescribed target, its thermomajorization prefixes suffice to certify exact conversion through at most n−1n-1n−1 binary work-extraction probes. For approximate conversion, we construct a distinguished reachable state from active capacity constraints using a weighted principal sequence in O(n2log⁡n)O(n^2 \log n)O(n2logn) operations. At fixed comparison weights, this state minimizes every weighted convex separable residual cost and realizes a common first contact with the corresponding target-centered smoothing regions. Finally, the optimal trace-distance error equals the largest capacity advantage of the target over the initial state. This gap is attained at a target prefix and equals the largest positive optimized energy-storage deficit among the same binary probes, divided by their energy gap. Thus a common population capacity geometry determines accessibility, observable optimization, conversion certificates, and universal approximation.
Drawing inspiration from transportation theory, in this work, we introduce the notions of "well-structured" and "stable" Gibbs states and we investigate their implications for quantum thermodynamics and its resource theory approach via thermal operations. It is found that, in the quasi-classical realm, global cyclic state transfers are impossible if and only if the Gibbs state is stable. Moreover, using a geometric approach by studying the so-called thermomajorization polytope, we prove that any subspace in equilibrium can be brought out of equilibrium via thermal operations. Interestingly, the case of some subsystem being in equilibrium can be witnessed via the degenerate extreme points of the thermomajorization polytope, assuming that the Gibbs state of the system is well structured. These physical considerations are complemented by simple new constructions for the polytope's extreme points, as well as for an important class of extremal Gibbs-stochastic matrices.
Quantum resource theories provide a unifying framework to quantify, compare, and manipulate quantum resources under well-defined operational constraints. Here, we consider any resource theory where the set of free states can be expressed as a convex combination of a set of quantum states, referred to as extremal states and name them as polytopic quantum resource theories (PQRT). These include some of the most studied resource theories, such as coherence and magic. We formulate a novel tensorial representation of PQRTs that reveals the underlying geometry of these theories and provides insight into the origin of the resources. We further address a fundamental question in resource theories that when two theories should be regarded as physically equivalent, and to this purpose we introduce notions of homomorphism and isomorphism that compare both the structure of free states and the allowed transformations. Using the tools we develop, we find results revealing the geometrical and structural foundations of such theories. Interestingly, we find that all polytopic resource theories with a fixed number of pure extremal points are equivalent under a physical map, up to normalisation. Additionally, we introduce linearly independent polytopic resource theories (resource theory of ``basis-non-convexity''), where the set of extremal free states forms a basis of the quantum density operators. We further study the categorical structures of PQRTs beyond single systems.
So-called Thermal Operations seem to describe the most fundamental and reasonable set of operations allowable for state transformations at an ambient inverse temperature βββ. However, a priori, they require experimentalists to manipulate very complex environments and have control over their internal degrees of freedom. For this reason, the community has been working on creating more experimentally-friendly operations. In [Perry, et al., Phys. Rev. X 8, 041049], it was shown that for states diagonal in the energy basis, Thermal Operations can be performed by so-called Coarse Operations, which need just one auxiliary qubit but are otherwise Markovian and classical in spirit. In this work, by providing an explicit counterexample, we show that this one qubit of memory is necessary. We also provide almost full characterization (i.e., full, but with one intriguing exception that remains open) of possible transitions that do not require memory in the case where the system is a qubit. We do this by analyzing arbitrary control sequences comprising level energy changes and partial thermalizations in each step.
The study of thermal operations allows one to investigate the ultimate possibilities of quantum states and of nanoscale thermal machines. Whilst fairly general, these results typically do not apply to continuous variable systems and do not take into account that, in many practically relevant settings, system-environment interactions are effectively bilinear. Here we tackle these issues by focusing on Gaussian quantum states and channels. We provide a complete characterization of the most general Gaussian thermal operation acting on an arbitrary number of bosonic modes, which turn out to be all embeddable in a Markovian dynamics, and derive necessary and sufficient conditions for state transformations under such operations in the single-mode case, encompassing states with nonzero coherence in the energy eigenbasis (i.e., squeezed states). Our analysis leads to a no-go result for the technologically relevant task of algorithmic cooling: We show that it is impossible to reduce the entropy of a system coupled to a Gaussian environment below its own or the environmental temperature, by means of a sequence of Gaussian thermal operations interspersed by arbitrary (even non-Gaussian) unitaries. These findings establish fundamental constraints on the usefulness of Gaussian resources for quantum thermodynamic processes.