Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2210.14368 · npj Quantum Information

High-fidelity trapped-ion qubit operations with scalable photonic modulators

Craig Hogle, D. Dominguez, Mark Dong, Andrew Jay Leenheer, Hayden McGuinness, Brandon Ruzic, Matt Eichenfield, Daniel Stick

Published Jul 26, 2023• 36 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Experiments with trapped ions and neutral atoms typically employ optical modulators in order to control the phase, frequency, and amplitude of light directed to individual atoms. These elements are expensive, bulky, consume substantial power, and often rely on free-space I/O channels, all of which pose scaling challenges. To support many-ion systems like trapped-ion quantum computers or miniaturized deployable devices like clocks and sensors, these elements must ultimately be microfabricated, ideally monolithically with the trap to avoid losses associated with optical coupling between physically separate components. In this work we design, fabricate, and test an optical modulator capable of monolithic integration with a surface-electrode ion trap. These devices consist of piezo-optomechanical photonic integrated circuits configured as multi-stage Mach-Zehnder modulators that are used to control the intensity of light delivered to a single trapped ion on a separate chip. We use quantum tomography employing hundreds of multi-gate sequences to enhance the sensitivity of the fidelity to the types and magnitudes of gate errors relevant to quantum computing and better characterize the performance of the modulators, ultimately measuring single qubit gate fidelities that exceed 99.7%.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-023-00737-1

Related papers

Engineering Solutions to Scale Up Trapped-Ion System

Le Minh Anh Nguyen

Trapped-ion quantum processors offer some of the lowest gate error rates among qubit platforms, encoding quantum information in ionic energy levels and entangling qubits via shared motional modes. Despite this maturity, scaling to large numbers of qubits while maintaining high-fidelity control remains a central challenge. This thesis addresses two key bottlenecks in laser-based trapped-ion systems: trap geometry and laser delivery. The first contribution is a quantitative framework for evaluating trap geometries with respect to scalability, applied to three electrode designs: a conventional surface trap, a ``gnd-surface'' multi-wafer trap, and a symmetric ``cross-rf'' multi-wafer trap. Multi-wafer designs, particularly the cross-rf trap, show substantial improvements in harmonicity, trap depth, radial trap frequency, and heating rate. However, the gnd-surface trap is identified as the most promising path to scaling due to its significantly simpler fabrication. The second contribution is the initial implementation of a photonic integrated circuit (PIC) for scalable laser delivery to ions. Operating at 729 nm, the PIC supports slow thermal tuning and fast nanosecond-scale modulation, with a pathtoward FPGA integration. Coupling of a frequency-stabilized laser into the PIC was demonstrated. Together, these contributions advance a modular architecture for trapped-ion quantum computation in which trap geometry and optical control are each independently engineered for large-scale operation.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

A broadband, individually addressing two- and three-dimensional photonic integrated circuit for trapped-ion qubit control

Daniel Klawson, Yiyang Zhi, Bingran You +21 more

Trapped ions provide a high-fidelity platform for quantum information processing, yet delivery of multiple, distinct wavelengths across large networks of interaction zones remains a bottleneck. Conventional free-space light delivery lacks scalability, while on-chip grating couplers suffer from narrow operational bandwidth that increases circuit footprint and optical interfacing complexity. Here we show a broadband photonic integrated circuit capable of addressing individual ions. The circuit combines a planar waveguide lens with a micromirror fabricated using two-photon polymerization at wafer scale. This implementation can address three individual ions from $λ$ = 405 - 880 nm with -27 dB average intensity crosstalk at $5\,μ\mathrm{m}$ pitch. We trap $^{40}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}$ and $^{138}\mathrm{Ba}^{+}$ ions above such devices, characterize optical crosstalk with barium ions, and demonstrate individual repumping of calcium ions. This monolithic photonic architecture brings broadband addressing in an on-chip modality to trapped-ion technology. More generally, integrating additive manufacturing into quantum devices is poised to unlock expanded design space for implementing novel quantum architectures.

quant-pharXiv:2607.25062•Jul 29, 2026•0 citations

Using CMOS-compatible optical modulators to solve I/O challenges in trapped-ion quantum computing

Daniel Stick, D. Dominguez, Matt Eichenfield +4 more

Most trapped-ion quantum computers confine ions using precise voltages applied to electrodes and manipulate their internal states and execute quantum logic operations using focused laser beams. The prevailing approach to scaling these systems from current sizes that use tens of ions to ones with several orders of magnitude more ions relies on the lithographic fabrication of larger electrode arrays as well as on-chip integrated waveguides for delivering light to each individual ion. This approach solves the crosstalk problem that is inherent to free-space light delivery, but it does not address the input/output problem associated with coupling many optical signals to the on-chip waveguides. Here we describe an approach that uses CMOS-compatible optical modulators that can substantially address this challenge, and analyze its architectural implications.

Technical digest - International Electron Devices Meeting/Technical digest•Dec 6, 2025•0 citations

Individual trapped-ion addressing with adjoint-optimized multimode photonic circuits

Melika Momenzadeh, Ke Sun, Qiming Wu +4 more

Trapped-ion quantum computing requires precise optical control for individual qubit manipulation. However, conventional free-space optics face challenges in alignment stability and scalability as the number of qubits increases. Integrated photonics offers a promising alternative, providing miniaturized optical systems on a chip. Here, we propose a design for a multimode photonic circuit integrated with a surface-electrode ion trap capable of targeted and reconfigurable light delivery. Three closely positioned ions can be addressed using a focusing grating coupler that emits multimode light through electrode openings to ions trapped 68 μm above the chip. Simulations show that the couplers achieve a diffraction-limited spot with a 4.3 μm beam waist along the trap axis and 2.2 μm perpendicular to the trap axis. Controlled interference of the TE 00 and TE 10 modes results in crosstalk of –20 dB to –30 dB at ion separations of 5–8 μm when addressing ions individually, and down to –60 dB when two of the three ions are addressed simultaneously. Additionally, the higher-order TE modes can offer a novel mechanism for driving spin-motion coupling transitions, potentially enabling alternative approaches to quantum gates and simulations. The proposed integrated platform offers a viable path for constructing large-scale trapped-ion systems, leveraging the benefits of nanophotonic design for precise and reliable ion manipulation.

arXiv:2505.08997•npj Nanophotonics•Jan 27, 2026•6 citations

High Fidelity Single Qubit Manipulation in a Microfabricated Ion Trap

Emily Mount

The trapped atomic ion qubits feature desirable properties for use in a quantum computer such as long coherence times, high qubit readout fidelity, and universal logic gates. While these essential properties have been demonstrated, the ability to scale a trapped ion quantum system has not yet been shown. The challenge of scaling the system calls for methods to realize high-fidelity logic gates in scalable trap structures. Surface electrode ion traps, that are microfabricated from a silicon substrate, provide a scalable platform for trapping ion qubits only if high-fidelity operations are achievable in these structures. Here, we present a system for trapping and manipulating ions in a scalable surface trap. Trapping times exceeding 20 minutes without laser cooling, and heating rates as low as 0.8 quanta/ms indicate stable trapping conditions in these microtraps. Coherence times of more than one second verify adequate qubit and control field stability. We demonstrate low-error single-qubit gates performed using stimulated Raman transitions driven by lasers that are tightly focused on the ion qubit. Digital feedback loops are implemented to control the driving field's amplitude and frequency. Gate errors are measured using a randomized benchmarking protocol for single qubit gates, where residual amplitude error in the control beam is compensated using various pulse sequence techniques. Using pulse compensation, we demonstrate single qubit gates with an average error per randomized Clifford group gate of $3.6(3)\\times10^{-4}$, which is below the fault-tolerant threshold for some error-correction schemes.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

Low cross-talk optical addressing of trapped-ion qubits using a novel integrated photonic chip

Ana Sotirova, Bangshan Sun, Jamie Leppard +10 more

Abstract Individual optical addressing in chains of trapped atomic ions requires the generation of many small, closely spaced beams with low cross-talk. Furthermore, implementing parallel operations necessitates phase, frequency, and amplitude control of each individual beam. Here, we present a scalable method for achieving all of these capabilities using a high-performance integrated photonic chip coupled to a network of optical fibre components. The chip design results in very low cross-talk between neighbouring channels even at the micrometre-scale spacing by implementing a very high refractive index contrast between the channel core and cladding. Furthermore, the photonic chip manufacturing procedure is highly flexible, allowing for the creation of devices with an arbitrary number of channels as well as non-uniform channel spacing at the chip output. We present the system used to integrate the chip within our ion trap apparatus and characterise the performance of the full individual addressing setup using a single trapped ion as a light-field sensor. Our measurements showed intensity cross-talk below ~10 –3 across the chip, with minimum observed cross-talk as low as ~10 –5 .

arXiv:2310.13419•Light Science & Applications•Aug 20, 2024•30 citations
Abstract Experiments with trapped ions and neutral atoms typically employ optical modulators in order to control the phase, frequency, and amplitude of light directed to individual atoms. These elements are expensive, bulky, consume substantial power, and often rely on free-space I/O channels, all of which pose scaling challenges. To support many-ion systems like trapped-ion quantum computers or miniaturized deployable devices like clocks and sensors, these elements must ultimately be microfabricated, ideally monolithically with the trap to avoid losses associated with optical coupling between physically separate components. In this work we design, fabricate, and test an optical modulator capable of monolithic integration with a surface-electrode ion trap. These devices consist of piezo-optomechanical photonic integrated circuits configured as multi-stage Mach-Zehnder modulators that are used to control the intensity of light delivered to a single trapped ion on a separate chip. We use quantum tomography employing hundreds of multi-gate sequences to enhance the sensitivity of the fidelity to the types and magnitudes of gate errors relevant to quantum computing and better characterize the performance of the modulators, ultimately measuring single qubit gate fidelities that exceed 99.7%.
Trapped-ion quantum processors offer some of the lowest gate error rates among qubit platforms, encoding quantum information in ionic energy levels and entangling qubits via shared motional modes. Despite this maturity, scaling to large numbers of qubits while maintaining high-fidelity control remains a central challenge. This thesis addresses two key bottlenecks in laser-based trapped-ion systems: trap geometry and laser delivery. The first contribution is a quantitative framework for evaluating trap geometries with respect to scalability, applied to three electrode designs: a conventional surface trap, a ``gnd-surface'' multi-wafer trap, and a symmetric ``cross-rf'' multi-wafer trap. Multi-wafer designs, particularly the cross-rf trap, show substantial improvements in harmonicity, trap depth, radial trap frequency, and heating rate. However, the gnd-surface trap is identified as the most promising path to scaling due to its significantly simpler fabrication. The second contribution is the initial implementation of a photonic integrated circuit (PIC) for scalable laser delivery to ions. Operating at 729 nm, the PIC supports slow thermal tuning and fast nanosecond-scale modulation, with a pathtoward FPGA integration. Coupling of a frequency-stabilized laser into the PIC was demonstrated. Together, these contributions advance a modular architecture for trapped-ion quantum computation in which trap geometry and optical control are each independently engineered for large-scale operation.
Trapped ions provide a high-fidelity platform for quantum information processing, yet delivery of multiple, distinct wavelengths across large networks of interaction zones remains a bottleneck. Conventional free-space light delivery lacks scalability, while on-chip grating couplers suffer from narrow operational bandwidth that increases circuit footprint and optical interfacing complexity. Here we show a broadband photonic integrated circuit capable of addressing individual ions. The circuit combines a planar waveguide lens with a micromirror fabricated using two-photon polymerization at wafer scale. This implementation can address three individual ions from λλλ = 405 - 880 nm with -27 dB average intensity crosstalk at 5 μm5\,μ\mathrm{m}5μm pitch. We trap 40Ca+^{40}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}40Ca+ and 138Ba+^{138}\mathrm{Ba}^{+}138Ba+ ions above such devices, characterize optical crosstalk with barium ions, and demonstrate individual repumping of calcium ions. This monolithic photonic architecture brings broadband addressing in an on-chip modality to trapped-ion technology. More generally, integrating additive manufacturing into quantum devices is poised to unlock expanded design space for implementing novel quantum architectures.
Most trapped-ion quantum computers confine ions using precise voltages applied to electrodes and manipulate their internal states and execute quantum logic operations using focused laser beams. The prevailing approach to scaling these systems from current sizes that use tens of ions to ones with several orders of magnitude more ions relies on the lithographic fabrication of larger electrode arrays as well as on-chip integrated waveguides for delivering light to each individual ion. This approach solves the crosstalk problem that is inherent to free-space light delivery, but it does not address the input/output problem associated with coupling many optical signals to the on-chip waveguides. Here we describe an approach that uses CMOS-compatible optical modulators that can substantially address this challenge, and analyze its architectural implications.
Trapped-ion quantum computing requires precise optical control for individual qubit manipulation. However, conventional free-space optics face challenges in alignment stability and scalability as the number of qubits increases. Integrated photonics offers a promising alternative, providing miniaturized optical systems on a chip. Here, we propose a design for a multimode photonic circuit integrated with a surface-electrode ion trap capable of targeted and reconfigurable light delivery. Three closely positioned ions can be addressed using a focusing grating coupler that emits multimode light through electrode openings to ions trapped 68 μm above the chip. Simulations show that the couplers achieve a diffraction-limited spot with a 4.3 μm beam waist along the trap axis and 2.2 μm perpendicular to the trap axis. Controlled interference of the TE 00 and TE 10 modes results in crosstalk of –20 dB to –30 dB at ion separations of 5–8 μm when addressing ions individually, and down to –60 dB when two of the three ions are addressed simultaneously. Additionally, the higher-order TE modes can offer a novel mechanism for driving spin-motion coupling transitions, potentially enabling alternative approaches to quantum gates and simulations. The proposed integrated platform offers a viable path for constructing large-scale trapped-ion systems, leveraging the benefits of nanophotonic design for precise and reliable ion manipulation.
The trapped atomic ion qubits feature desirable properties for use in a quantum computer such as long coherence times, high qubit readout fidelity, and universal logic gates. While these essential properties have been demonstrated, the ability to scale a trapped ion quantum system has not yet been shown. The challenge of scaling the system calls for methods to realize high-fidelity logic gates in scalable trap structures. Surface electrode ion traps, that are microfabricated from a silicon substrate, provide a scalable platform for trapping ion qubits only if high-fidelity operations are achievable in these structures. Here, we present a system for trapping and manipulating ions in a scalable surface trap. Trapping times exceeding 20 minutes without laser cooling, and heating rates as low as 0.8 quanta/ms indicate stable trapping conditions in these microtraps. Coherence times of more than one second verify adequate qubit and control field stability. We demonstrate low-error single-qubit gates performed using stimulated Raman transitions driven by lasers that are tightly focused on the ion qubit. Digital feedback loops are implemented to control the driving field's amplitude and frequency. Gate errors are measured using a randomized benchmarking protocol for single qubit gates, where residual amplitude error in the control beam is compensated using various pulse sequence techniques. Using pulse compensation, we demonstrate single qubit gates with an average error per randomized Clifford group gate of 3.6(3)times10−43.6(3)\\times10^{-4}3.6(3)times10−4, which is below the fault-tolerant threshold for some error-correction schemes.
Abstract Individual optical addressing in chains of trapped atomic ions requires the generation of many small, closely spaced beams with low cross-talk. Furthermore, implementing parallel operations necessitates phase, frequency, and amplitude control of each individual beam. Here, we present a scalable method for achieving all of these capabilities using a high-performance integrated photonic chip coupled to a network of optical fibre components. The chip design results in very low cross-talk between neighbouring channels even at the micrometre-scale spacing by implementing a very high refractive index contrast between the channel core and cladding. Furthermore, the photonic chip manufacturing procedure is highly flexible, allowing for the creation of devices with an arbitrary number of channels as well as non-uniform channel spacing at the chip output. We present the system used to integrate the chip within our ion trap apparatus and characterise the performance of the full individual addressing setup using a single trapped ion as a light-field sensor. Our measurements showed intensity cross-talk below ~10 –3 across the chip, with minimum observed cross-talk as low as ~10 –5 .