Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2206.12976 · Physical Review Letters

Test of Causal Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics by Ramsey Interferometry with a Trapped Ion

Joseph Broz, Bingran You, Sumanta Khan, Hartmut Häffner, David E. Kaplan, Surjeet Rajendran

Published May 15, 2023• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum mechanics requires the time evolution of the wave function to be linear. While this feature has been associated with the preservation of causality, a consistent causal nonlinear theory was recently developed. Interestingly, this theory is unavoidably sensitive to the full physical spread of the wave function, rendering existing experimental tests for nonlinearities inapplicable. Here, using well-controlled motional superpositions of a trapped ion, we set a stringent limit of 5.4×10^{-12} on the magnitude of the unitless scaling factor ε[over ˜]_{γ} for the predicted causal nonlinear perturbation.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.130.200201

Related papers

Experimental Limit on Nonlinear State-Dependent Terms in Quantum Theory

Mark Polkovnikov, A. V. Gramolin, David E. Kaplan +2 more

Linear time evolution is one of the fundamental postulates of quantum theory. Past theoretical attempts to introduce nonlinearity into quantum evolution have violated causality. However, a recent theory has introduced nonlinear state-dependent terms in quantum field theory, preserving causality [D. E. Kaplan and S. Rajendran, Phys. Rev. D 105, 055002 (2022)PRVDAQ2470-001010.1103/PhysRevD.105.055002]. We report the results of an experiment that searches for such terms. Our approach, inspired by the Everett many-worlds interpretation of quantum theory, correlates a binary macroscopic classical voltage with the outcome of a projective measurement of a quantum bit, prepared in a coherent superposition state. Measurement results are recorded in a bit string, which is used to control a voltage switch. Presence of a nonzero voltage reading in cases of no applied voltage is the experimental signature of a nonlinear state-dependent shift of the electromagnetic field operator. We implement blinded measurement and data analysis with three control bit strings. Control of systematic effects is realized by producing one of the control bit strings with a classical random-bit generator. The other two bit strings are generated by measurements performed on a superconducting qubit in an IBM Quantum processor and on a ^{15}N nuclear spin in a nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond. Our measurements find no evidence for electromagnetic quantum state-dependent nonlinearity. We set a bound on the parameter that quantifies this nonlinearity |ε_{γ}|<4.7×10^{-11}, at 90% confidence level.

arXiv:2204.11875•Physical Review Letters•Jan 25, 2023•16 citations

Time Does Not Go Quantum: Background-Amplitude Sampling Explains the Predicted Ion Clock Blurring

J. Zuhars

A response to Pikovski et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett., 2026), who predict that a trapped ion in a motional superposition will exhibit measurable clock-transition blurring, interpreted as evidence that time itself exists in quantum superposition. We show that the identical observable arises in a framework where the tick rate is set by the local amplitude of a decaying background field (Zuhars, The Self-Interacting Universe, 2026). The ion's motional wavepacket samples different background amplitudes at different spatial positions, producing the same phase spread without requiring time to be a quantum observable. The two interpretations make a distinguishable experimental prediction: varying the trap frequency while holding the quantum state fixed produces different scaling in the two frameworks. We identify the specific signature and propose the test.

•May 15, 2026•0 citations

Causal framework for nonlinear quantum mechanics

David E. Kaplan, Surjeet Rajendran

We add nonlinear and state-dependent terms to quantum field theory. We show that the resulting low-energy theory, nonlinear quantum mechanics, is causal, preserves probability and permits a consistent description of the process of measurement. We explore the consequences of such terms and show that nonlinear quantum effects can be observed in macroscopic systems even in the presence of decoherence. We find that current experimental bounds on these nonlinearities are weak and propose several experimental methods to significantly probe these effects. The locally exploitable effects of these nonlinearities have enormous technological implications. For example, they would allow large-scale parallelization of computing (in fact, any other effort) and enable quantum sensing beyond the standard quantum limit. We also expose a fundamental vulnerability of any nonlinear modification of quantum mechanics---these modifications are highly sensitive to cosmic history and their locally exploitable effects can dynamically disappear if the observed universe has a tiny overlap with the overall quantum state of the universe, as is predicted in conventional inflationary cosmology. We identify observables that should persist in this case and discuss opportunities to detect them in cosmic ray experiments, tests of strong field general relativity and current probes of the equation of state of the universe. Nonlinear quantum mechanics also enables novel gravitational phenomena and may open new directions to solve the black hole information problem and to uncover the theory underlying quantum field theory and gravitation.

arXiv:2106.10576•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 4, 2022•49 citations

Precision Tests of Quantum Mechanics

Steven Weinberg

It is proposed to set stringent limits on possible nonlinear corrections to ordinary quantum mechanics by searching for the detuning of resonant transitions. A suggested nonlinear generalization of quantum mechanics is used to show that such detuning would be expected in the rf transition in $^{9}\mathrm{Be}^{+}$ ions that is used to set frequency standards. Measurements at the National Bureau of Standards already set limits of order ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}21}$ on the fraction of the energy of the $^{9}\mathrm{Be}$ nucleus that could be due to nonlinear corrections to quantum mechanics, with good prospects of improving this by 2-3 orders of magnitude.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 30, 1989•376 citations

Observation of dynamic processes demonstrated in a trapped-ion quantum simulator

Hasse, Florian

Achieving control over physical systems down to individual quanta is central for advancing our understanding of nature and enabling emerging quantum technologies. Trapped-ion systems provide a powerful platform offering exceptional control over internal and external degrees of freedom and allowing the study of both fundamental and applied aspects of quantum dynamics. This thesis introduces an experimental toolbox, centered on problem-tailored modifications of Ramsey interferometry, for observing and manipulating dynamic processes with high temporal and spatial resolution, showcased in a trapped-ion quantum simulator. Using this versatile approach, we bridge quantum metrology and quantum thermodynamics – from tracking the motional wave packet evolution of a single ion in phase space to observing time-(in)dependent energy-level renormalizations in ultra-strongly coupled open systems. A central innovation of this thesis is the development of a stroboscopic measurement technique that establishes and maintains coherence among four oscillators: a global microwave reference, an ultraviolet polarization-gradient traveling-wave light field, and the spin and motional states of a single trapped ion. This architecture, spanning a phase-stable frequency range of more than nine orders of magnitude, enables superresolved, back-action-free tracking of motional wave packets in phase-space. In this way, we achieve noise floors of 1.8(2) nm for position and 8(2) zN μs for momentum on sub-100-nanosecond timescales. This precision enables quantum-enhanced diagnostics, non-classical state preparation, and fine-grained phase-space control, with broad implications for entanglement generation, quantum interferometry, and quantum sensing. In a complementary study, we exploit the trapped-ion system as a testbed for probing fundamental quantum interactions: We experimentally simulate a strongly coupled open quantum system, where dressed electronic states represent the system and a single motional mode serves as its environment. We observe time-dependent energy shifts up to 15% of the bare transition frequency, induced solely by ultra-strong system-environment coupling. These shifts, anticipated to be a general feature of all quantum platforms across all coupling regimes, are accurately described by the minimal-dissipation ansatz and interpreted as generalized, time-resolved Lamb shifts. Together, the results of this thesis extend the frontier of trapped-ion quantum simulation: The integration of Ramsey interferometry, stroboscopic techniques, and strong-coupling simulations offers a high-resolution window into diverse aspects of quantum dynamics. This work enables advanced studies – including squeezed states, analogues of relativistic effects such as Hawking radiation and the physics of the early universe, and autonomous quantum engines.

•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

Control and Measurement of a Single-Ion Quantum Harmonic Oscillator

Katherine C. McCormick

A trapped-ion harmonic oscillator represents a rich and well-controlled platform for tests of quantum physics, with applications to quantum simulations, quantum sensing, and quantum information processing. Owing to its net charge, the ion's motion is affected by changes in the electric potential. Consequently, electric field and potential curvature noise will limit the coherence of the ion's harmonic oscillation. While in some respects, this serves as a limitation in the performance of the trapped ion system (for example, in the fidelity of two-qubit gates or quantum simulations with motional quanta), it also opens an opportunity to use the ion as a precise field sensor and to use engineered quantum states of motion to enhance the sensitivity to these fields beyond the standard quantum limit (SQL). This thesis describes the implementation of such applications on a single beryllium ion confined in a Paul trap. In the thesis, I present the theory of an ideal harmonic oscillator and the implementation of this system using the motion of a single trapped ion, including producing special quantum states of motion; these states include the energy eigenstates of the harmonic oscillator, called number states, up to n=100, superpositions of number states of the form (1/√2)(|0> + |n>), with n up to 18, and coherently displaced number states with an average occupation up to approximately 300. I describe how we use these quantum states of motion for precise sensing of fluctuations of the harmonic oscillator frequency. The sensitivity of the (1/√2)(|0> + |n>) state ideally follows the 1/n Heisenberg scaling for frequency sensitivity. Additionally, I describe investigations of the spectrum of motional frequency noise using a series of coherent displacements of the motion of the ion, with features similar to Ramsey and dynamical decoupling sequences for two-level systems. While these displaced states don't improve sensitivity over the SQL, they can be simply and rapidly implemented with trapped ions. I discuss extensions to all of these experiments, including to multiple ions in a new trap designed to confine 3 or 4 ions in individually tunable potential wells.

•Jan 1, 2019•1 citation
Quantum mechanics requires the time evolution of the wave function to be linear. While this feature has been associated with the preservation of causality, a consistent causal nonlinear theory was recently developed. Interestingly, this theory is unavoidably sensitive to the full physical spread of the wave function, rendering existing experimental tests for nonlinearities inapplicable. Here, using well-controlled motional superpositions of a trapped ion, we set a stringent limit of 5.4×10^{-12} on the magnitude of the unitless scaling factor ε[over ˜]_{γ} for the predicted causal nonlinear perturbation.
Linear time evolution is one of the fundamental postulates of quantum theory. Past theoretical attempts to introduce nonlinearity into quantum evolution have violated causality. However, a recent theory has introduced nonlinear state-dependent terms in quantum field theory, preserving causality [D. E. Kaplan and S. Rajendran, Phys. Rev. D 105, 055002 (2022)PRVDAQ2470-001010.1103/PhysRevD.105.055002]. We report the results of an experiment that searches for such terms. Our approach, inspired by the Everett many-worlds interpretation of quantum theory, correlates a binary macroscopic classical voltage with the outcome of a projective measurement of a quantum bit, prepared in a coherent superposition state. Measurement results are recorded in a bit string, which is used to control a voltage switch. Presence of a nonzero voltage reading in cases of no applied voltage is the experimental signature of a nonlinear state-dependent shift of the electromagnetic field operator. We implement blinded measurement and data analysis with three control bit strings. Control of systematic effects is realized by producing one of the control bit strings with a classical random-bit generator. The other two bit strings are generated by measurements performed on a superconducting qubit in an IBM Quantum processor and on a ^{15}N nuclear spin in a nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond. Our measurements find no evidence for electromagnetic quantum state-dependent nonlinearity. We set a bound on the parameter that quantifies this nonlinearity |ε_{γ}|<4.7×10^{-11}, at 90% confidence level.
A response to Pikovski et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett., 2026), who predict that a trapped ion in a motional superposition will exhibit measurable clock-transition blurring, interpreted as evidence that time itself exists in quantum superposition. We show that the identical observable arises in a framework where the tick rate is set by the local amplitude of a decaying background field (Zuhars, The Self-Interacting Universe, 2026). The ion's motional wavepacket samples different background amplitudes at different spatial positions, producing the same phase spread without requiring time to be a quantum observable. The two interpretations make a distinguishable experimental prediction: varying the trap frequency while holding the quantum state fixed produces different scaling in the two frameworks. We identify the specific signature and propose the test.
We add nonlinear and state-dependent terms to quantum field theory. We show that the resulting low-energy theory, nonlinear quantum mechanics, is causal, preserves probability and permits a consistent description of the process of measurement. We explore the consequences of such terms and show that nonlinear quantum effects can be observed in macroscopic systems even in the presence of decoherence. We find that current experimental bounds on these nonlinearities are weak and propose several experimental methods to significantly probe these effects. The locally exploitable effects of these nonlinearities have enormous technological implications. For example, they would allow large-scale parallelization of computing (in fact, any other effort) and enable quantum sensing beyond the standard quantum limit. We also expose a fundamental vulnerability of any nonlinear modification of quantum mechanics---these modifications are highly sensitive to cosmic history and their locally exploitable effects can dynamically disappear if the observed universe has a tiny overlap with the overall quantum state of the universe, as is predicted in conventional inflationary cosmology. We identify observables that should persist in this case and discuss opportunities to detect them in cosmic ray experiments, tests of strong field general relativity and current probes of the equation of state of the universe. Nonlinear quantum mechanics also enables novel gravitational phenomena and may open new directions to solve the black hole information problem and to uncover the theory underlying quantum field theory and gravitation.
It is proposed to set stringent limits on possible nonlinear corrections to ordinary quantum mechanics by searching for the detuning of resonant transitions. A suggested nonlinear generalization of quantum mechanics is used to show that such detuning would be expected in the rf transition in 9Be+^{9}\mathrm{Be}^{+}9Be+ ions that is used to set frequency standards. Measurements at the National Bureau of Standards already set limits of order ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}21}$ on the fraction of the energy of the 9Be^{9}\mathrm{Be}9Be nucleus that could be due to nonlinear corrections to quantum mechanics, with good prospects of improving this by 2-3 orders of magnitude.
Achieving control over physical systems down to individual quanta is central for advancing our understanding of nature and enabling emerging quantum technologies. Trapped-ion systems provide a powerful platform offering exceptional control over internal and external degrees of freedom and allowing the study of both fundamental and applied aspects of quantum dynamics. This thesis introduces an experimental toolbox, centered on problem-tailored modifications of Ramsey interferometry, for observing and manipulating dynamic processes with high temporal and spatial resolution, showcased in a trapped-ion quantum simulator. Using this versatile approach, we bridge quantum metrology and quantum thermodynamics – from tracking the motional wave packet evolution of a single ion in phase space to observing time-(in)dependent energy-level renormalizations in ultra-strongly coupled open systems. A central innovation of this thesis is the development of a stroboscopic measurement technique that establishes and maintains coherence among four oscillators: a global microwave reference, an ultraviolet polarization-gradient traveling-wave light field, and the spin and motional states of a single trapped ion. This architecture, spanning a phase-stable frequency range of more than nine orders of magnitude, enables superresolved, back-action-free tracking of motional wave packets in phase-space. In this way, we achieve noise floors of 1.8(2) nm for position and 8(2) zN μs for momentum on sub-100-nanosecond timescales. This precision enables quantum-enhanced diagnostics, non-classical state preparation, and fine-grained phase-space control, with broad implications for entanglement generation, quantum interferometry, and quantum sensing. In a complementary study, we exploit the trapped-ion system as a testbed for probing fundamental quantum interactions: We experimentally simulate a strongly coupled open quantum system, where dressed electronic states represent the system and a single motional mode serves as its environment. We observe time-dependent energy shifts up to 15% of the bare transition frequency, induced solely by ultra-strong system-environment coupling. These shifts, anticipated to be a general feature of all quantum platforms across all coupling regimes, are accurately described by the minimal-dissipation ansatz and interpreted as generalized, time-resolved Lamb shifts. Together, the results of this thesis extend the frontier of trapped-ion quantum simulation: The integration of Ramsey interferometry, stroboscopic techniques, and strong-coupling simulations offers a high-resolution window into diverse aspects of quantum dynamics. This work enables advanced studies – including squeezed states, analogues of relativistic effects such as Hawking radiation and the physics of the early universe, and autonomous quantum engines.
A trapped-ion harmonic oscillator represents a rich and well-controlled platform for tests of quantum physics, with applications to quantum simulations, quantum sensing, and quantum information processing. Owing to its net charge, the ion's motion is affected by changes in the electric potential. Consequently, electric field and potential curvature noise will limit the coherence of the ion's harmonic oscillation. While in some respects, this serves as a limitation in the performance of the trapped ion system (for example, in the fidelity of two-qubit gates or quantum simulations with motional quanta), it also opens an opportunity to use the ion as a precise field sensor and to use engineered quantum states of motion to enhance the sensitivity to these fields beyond the standard quantum limit (SQL). This thesis describes the implementation of such applications on a single beryllium ion confined in a Paul trap. In the thesis, I present the theory of an ideal harmonic oscillator and the implementation of this system using the motion of a single trapped ion, including producing special quantum states of motion; these states include the energy eigenstates of the harmonic oscillator, called number states, up to n=100, superpositions of number states of the form (1/√2)(|0> + |n>), with n up to 18, and coherently displaced number states with an average occupation up to approximately 300. I describe how we use these quantum states of motion for precise sensing of fluctuations of the harmonic oscillator frequency. The sensitivity of the (1/√2)(|0> + |n>) state ideally follows the 1/n Heisenberg scaling for frequency sensitivity. Additionally, I describe investigations of the spectrum of motional frequency noise using a series of coherent displacements of the motion of the ion, with features similar to Ramsey and dynamical decoupling sequences for two-level systems. While these displaced states don't improve sensitivity over the SQL, they can be simply and rapidly implemented with trapped ions. I discuss extensions to all of these experiments, including to multiple ions in a new trap designed to confine 3 or 4 ions in individually tunable potential wells.