Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2204.11875 · Physical Review Letters

Experimental Limit on Nonlinear State-Dependent Terms in Quantum Theory

Mark Polkovnikov, A. V. Gramolin, David E. Kaplan, Surjeet Rajendran, Alexander O. Sushkov

Published Jan 25, 2023• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Linear time evolution is one of the fundamental postulates of quantum theory. Past theoretical attempts to introduce nonlinearity into quantum evolution have violated causality. However, a recent theory has introduced nonlinear state-dependent terms in quantum field theory, preserving causality [D. E. Kaplan and S. Rajendran, Phys. Rev. D 105, 055002 (2022)PRVDAQ2470-001010.1103/PhysRevD.105.055002]. We report the results of an experiment that searches for such terms. Our approach, inspired by the Everett many-worlds interpretation of quantum theory, correlates a binary macroscopic classical voltage with the outcome of a projective measurement of a quantum bit, prepared in a coherent superposition state. Measurement results are recorded in a bit string, which is used to control a voltage switch. Presence of a nonzero voltage reading in cases of no applied voltage is the experimental signature of a nonlinear state-dependent shift of the electromagnetic field operator. We implement blinded measurement and data analysis with three control bit strings. Control of systematic effects is realized by producing one of the control bit strings with a classical random-bit generator. The other two bit strings are generated by measurements performed on a superconducting qubit in an IBM Quantum processor and on a ^{15}N nuclear spin in a nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond. Our measurements find no evidence for electromagnetic quantum state-dependent nonlinearity. We set a bound on the parameter that quantifies this nonlinearity |ε_{γ}|<4.7×10^{-11}, at 90% confidence level.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.130.040202

Related papers

Improved bound on nonlinear quantum mechanics using a cryogenic radio frequency experiment

Oleksandr Melnychuk, Bianca Giaccone, Nicholas Bornman +9 more

There are strong arguments that quantum mechanics may be nonlinear in its dynamics. A discovery of nonlinearity would hint at a novel understanding of the interplay between gravity and quantum field theory, for example. As such, experiments searching for potential nonlinear effects in the electromagnetic sector are important. Here we outline such an experiment, consisting of a stream of random bits (which were generated using Rigetti's Aspen-M-3 chip) as input to an RF signal generator coupled to a cryogenic detector. Projective measurements of the qubit state, which is originally prepared in an equal superposition, serve as the random binary output of a signal generator. Thereafter, spectral analysis of the RF detector would yield a detectable excess signal predicted to arise from such a nonlinear effect. A comparison between the projective measurements of the quantum bits vs the classical baseline showed no power excess. This sets a new limit on the electromagnetic nonlinearity parameter $|ε| \lessapprox 1.15 \times 10^{-12}$, at a 90.0% confidence level. This is the most stringent limit on nonlinear quantum mechanics thus far and an improvement by nearly a factor of 50 over the previous experimental limit.

arXiv:2411.09611•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jun 19, 2025•3 citations

Causal framework for nonlinear quantum mechanics

David E. Kaplan, Surjeet Rajendran

We add nonlinear and state-dependent terms to quantum field theory. We show that the resulting low-energy theory, nonlinear quantum mechanics, is causal, preserves probability and permits a consistent description of the process of measurement. We explore the consequences of such terms and show that nonlinear quantum effects can be observed in macroscopic systems even in the presence of decoherence. We find that current experimental bounds on these nonlinearities are weak and propose several experimental methods to significantly probe these effects. The locally exploitable effects of these nonlinearities have enormous technological implications. For example, they would allow large-scale parallelization of computing (in fact, any other effort) and enable quantum sensing beyond the standard quantum limit. We also expose a fundamental vulnerability of any nonlinear modification of quantum mechanics---these modifications are highly sensitive to cosmic history and their locally exploitable effects can dynamically disappear if the observed universe has a tiny overlap with the overall quantum state of the universe, as is predicted in conventional inflationary cosmology. We identify observables that should persist in this case and discuss opportunities to detect them in cosmic ray experiments, tests of strong field general relativity and current probes of the equation of state of the universe. Nonlinear quantum mechanics also enables novel gravitational phenomena and may open new directions to solve the black hole information problem and to uncover the theory underlying quantum field theory and gravitation.

arXiv:2106.10576•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 4, 2022•49 citations

Test of Causal Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics by Ramsey Interferometry with a Trapped Ion

Joseph Broz, Bingran You, Sumanta Khan +3 more

Quantum mechanics requires the time evolution of the wave function to be linear. While this feature has been associated with the preservation of causality, a consistent causal nonlinear theory was recently developed. Interestingly, this theory is unavoidably sensitive to the full physical spread of the wave function, rendering existing experimental tests for nonlinearities inapplicable. Here, using well-controlled motional superpositions of a trapped ion, we set a stringent limit of 5.4×10^{-12} on the magnitude of the unitless scaling factor ε[over ˜]_{γ} for the predicted causal nonlinear perturbation.

arXiv:2206.12976•Physical Review Letters•May 15, 2023•15 citations

NUNTIUS: an Everett-phone test on a public quantum processor. The sensor in the world where nothing was fired does not feel the drive fired in the other. A registered experiment

Bernd Westrick

If quantum mechanics had a state-dependent, nonlinear term of the kind proposed by Kaplan and Rajendran (Phys. Rev. D 105, 055002), the two outcomes of a measurement would not be closed to each other: what is done in one outcome would appear in the other as a weak background field, a possibility first noted by Polchinski for Weinberg's nonlinear theory (the "Everett phone"). In linear quantum mechanics, in any interpretation, the effect is exactly zero. Laboratory experiments have bounded the electromagnetic parameter at the level of 10^-11 to 10^-12. This deposit holds a test of the same effect in which the measurement, the sender and the receiver are two qubits and the control electronics of one publicly accessible processor. On the IBM Heron processor ibm_fez a switch qubit is measured inside the circuit. If it reads 1, the controller fires N signed pi pulses (N = 200 to 1600) on a sensor qubit 25 edges away; if it reads 0, the sensor rests for exactly the same time on the y axis of its Bloch sphere, where a small rotation about x appears linearly in <Z>. A leak would rotate the resting sensor by epsilon p N pi with the sign of the drive, p being the Born weight of the outcome in which the drive was fired (1/2 and 2/3). The session has four arms: the measurement arm; a classical twin in which the switch is prepared instead of being in superposition (the same pulses and feed-forward, no other outcome); a sender check; and the response of the sensor to a real rotation injected over the window, measured in the same session. The sensor and the switch were chosen at submission by a registered rule from a scan job. Which of the two sign labels is the + sign was sealed before the first job and opened after the lines were formed. Lines, thresholds, the layout rule and the analysis were fixed and hashed before the first job (registration SHA-256 fbdec5d40b76af84b1fc0d98f71ee0d534f454a1ea96052ba5059077ce16d134; a first version was replaced before any job ran under it and is part of the deposit). Results, as they fell: 1060 circuits, 844,000 shots, 11 jobs run back to back in five minutes. The slope is epsilon = (+0.8 +- 4.5) x 10^-6, 0.18 standard errors from zero; |epsilon| < 8.2 x 10^-6 (90 %). The silent sender, the classical twin and the split by the preceding shot are flat at all eight settings (at most 1.9, 1.7 and 1.3 standard errors against a registered limit of 4), the sender check separates the two signs (0.82 and 0.65 against a floor of 0.5), and the response of the sensor was 0.90, 0.86, 0.79, 0.62 for the four windows. All nine binding lines and the four attestation lines held. The bound is five to six orders of magnitude weaker than the laboratory bounds on the same parameter and competes with none of them. What the experiment adds is the place: the test runs on a public device, the sensor listens within microseconds of the measurement, and anyone with access to such a processor can run it again. Nothing here is a statement about the existence of other worlds. The deposit holds the registration and its superseded first version, the shared module with the circuits, the design and the estimators, the model and registration script, the runner, the verdict script, the logs of two preliminary looks on the device, the rehearsal of the whole session on the noiseless simulator under the hashed registration, the session log with the bits of every shot of every circuit in the order of execution, the seal file, the verdict (formed once), the ledger, the write-up (nuntius_paper_v1.pdf) and the scripts and figures that build it. Licence: CC BY 4.0.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Experimental realization of more quantum randomness generation based on non-projective measurement

Chenxi Liu, Jian Li, Tongjun Liu +3 more

Abstract Quantum random numbers are fundamental resources ( Rev. Mod. Phys. 89 015004) for the fields of communications and information security. Usually, projective measurements can be applied on a two-qubit entangled state to generate quantum random numbers. However, it cannot certify more than one bit of randomness for one set of measurements. On contrast, non-projective measurements in-principle may be able to generate more random bits, and therefore show some merits among present methods. Here, we report the implementation of a quantum random number generator based on a symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measure. In our experiment, we prepare a maximally entangled state of two-qubits through spontaneous parametric down-conversion processes, and observe the violation of Gisin’s elegant Bell inequality with the value of 6.8138 ± 0.0822, exceeding the classical bound of 6. Through randomness extractors, including a Toeplitz extractor and a parallel linear feedback shift register based extractor, we finally extract a random string with an autocorrelation coefficient below 10 −3 and the string can pass all randomness tests of the National Institute of Science and Technology (NIST).

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Apr 5, 2019•2 citations

Quantum Information Theory: Exploring the Influence of Nonlinear Collapse on Quantum State Evolution and Measurement

Jincheng Zhang

Quantum information theory explores the fundamental principles governing the manipulation and utilization of quantum states. A crucial aspect of this field is the concept of non-linear collapse, a process that fundamentally alters the quantum state upon measurement. This paper investigates the impact of non-linear collapse on quantum state evolution and measurement results, specifically focusing on its implications for quantum algorithm design. We propose a novel quantum algorithm leveraging the principles of non-linear collapse to achieve enhanced quantum information processing efficiency. This work will detail the development of a quantum state evolution model incorporating non-linear collapse, highlighting its potential to accelerate quantum computation and offer a new approach to quantum information handling. This research represents a significant step towards refining quantum algorithms and pushing the boundaries of quantum information processing.

•Sep 7, 2026•0 citations
Linear time evolution is one of the fundamental postulates of quantum theory. Past theoretical attempts to introduce nonlinearity into quantum evolution have violated causality. However, a recent theory has introduced nonlinear state-dependent terms in quantum field theory, preserving causality [D. E. Kaplan and S. Rajendran, Phys. Rev. D 105, 055002 (2022)PRVDAQ2470-001010.1103/PhysRevD.105.055002]. We report the results of an experiment that searches for such terms. Our approach, inspired by the Everett many-worlds interpretation of quantum theory, correlates a binary macroscopic classical voltage with the outcome of a projective measurement of a quantum bit, prepared in a coherent superposition state. Measurement results are recorded in a bit string, which is used to control a voltage switch. Presence of a nonzero voltage reading in cases of no applied voltage is the experimental signature of a nonlinear state-dependent shift of the electromagnetic field operator. We implement blinded measurement and data analysis with three control bit strings. Control of systematic effects is realized by producing one of the control bit strings with a classical random-bit generator. The other two bit strings are generated by measurements performed on a superconducting qubit in an IBM Quantum processor and on a ^{15}N nuclear spin in a nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond. Our measurements find no evidence for electromagnetic quantum state-dependent nonlinearity. We set a bound on the parameter that quantifies this nonlinearity |ε_{γ}|<4.7×10^{-11}, at 90% confidence level.
There are strong arguments that quantum mechanics may be nonlinear in its dynamics. A discovery of nonlinearity would hint at a novel understanding of the interplay between gravity and quantum field theory, for example. As such, experiments searching for potential nonlinear effects in the electromagnetic sector are important. Here we outline such an experiment, consisting of a stream of random bits (which were generated using Rigetti's Aspen-M-3 chip) as input to an RF signal generator coupled to a cryogenic detector. Projective measurements of the qubit state, which is originally prepared in an equal superposition, serve as the random binary output of a signal generator. Thereafter, spectral analysis of the RF detector would yield a detectable excess signal predicted to arise from such a nonlinear effect. A comparison between the projective measurements of the quantum bits vs the classical baseline showed no power excess. This sets a new limit on the electromagnetic nonlinearity parameter ∣ε∣⪅1.15×10−12|ε| \lessapprox 1.15 \times 10^{-12}∣ε∣⪅1.15×10−12, at a 90.0% confidence level. This is the most stringent limit on nonlinear quantum mechanics thus far and an improvement by nearly a factor of 50 over the previous experimental limit.
We add nonlinear and state-dependent terms to quantum field theory. We show that the resulting low-energy theory, nonlinear quantum mechanics, is causal, preserves probability and permits a consistent description of the process of measurement. We explore the consequences of such terms and show that nonlinear quantum effects can be observed in macroscopic systems even in the presence of decoherence. We find that current experimental bounds on these nonlinearities are weak and propose several experimental methods to significantly probe these effects. The locally exploitable effects of these nonlinearities have enormous technological implications. For example, they would allow large-scale parallelization of computing (in fact, any other effort) and enable quantum sensing beyond the standard quantum limit. We also expose a fundamental vulnerability of any nonlinear modification of quantum mechanics---these modifications are highly sensitive to cosmic history and their locally exploitable effects can dynamically disappear if the observed universe has a tiny overlap with the overall quantum state of the universe, as is predicted in conventional inflationary cosmology. We identify observables that should persist in this case and discuss opportunities to detect them in cosmic ray experiments, tests of strong field general relativity and current probes of the equation of state of the universe. Nonlinear quantum mechanics also enables novel gravitational phenomena and may open new directions to solve the black hole information problem and to uncover the theory underlying quantum field theory and gravitation.
Quantum mechanics requires the time evolution of the wave function to be linear. While this feature has been associated with the preservation of causality, a consistent causal nonlinear theory was recently developed. Interestingly, this theory is unavoidably sensitive to the full physical spread of the wave function, rendering existing experimental tests for nonlinearities inapplicable. Here, using well-controlled motional superpositions of a trapped ion, we set a stringent limit of 5.4×10^{-12} on the magnitude of the unitless scaling factor ε[over ˜]_{γ} for the predicted causal nonlinear perturbation.
If quantum mechanics had a state-dependent, nonlinear term of the kind proposed by Kaplan and Rajendran (Phys. Rev. D 105, 055002), the two outcomes of a measurement would not be closed to each other: what is done in one outcome would appear in the other as a weak background field, a possibility first noted by Polchinski for Weinberg's nonlinear theory (the "Everett phone"). In linear quantum mechanics, in any interpretation, the effect is exactly zero. Laboratory experiments have bounded the electromagnetic parameter at the level of 10^-11 to 10^-12. This deposit holds a test of the same effect in which the measurement, the sender and the receiver are two qubits and the control electronics of one publicly accessible processor. On the IBM Heron processor ibm_fez a switch qubit is measured inside the circuit. If it reads 1, the controller fires N signed pi pulses (N = 200 to 1600) on a sensor qubit 25 edges away; if it reads 0, the sensor rests for exactly the same time on the y axis of its Bloch sphere, where a small rotation about x appears linearly in <Z>. A leak would rotate the resting sensor by epsilon p N pi with the sign of the drive, p being the Born weight of the outcome in which the drive was fired (1/2 and 2/3). The session has four arms: the measurement arm; a classical twin in which the switch is prepared instead of being in superposition (the same pulses and feed-forward, no other outcome); a sender check; and the response of the sensor to a real rotation injected over the window, measured in the same session. The sensor and the switch were chosen at submission by a registered rule from a scan job. Which of the two sign labels is the + sign was sealed before the first job and opened after the lines were formed. Lines, thresholds, the layout rule and the analysis were fixed and hashed before the first job (registration SHA-256 fbdec5d40b76af84b1fc0d98f71ee0d534f454a1ea96052ba5059077ce16d134; a first version was replaced before any job ran under it and is part of the deposit). Results, as they fell: 1060 circuits, 844,000 shots, 11 jobs run back to back in five minutes. The slope is epsilon = (+0.8 +- 4.5) x 10^-6, 0.18 standard errors from zero; |epsilon| < 8.2 x 10^-6 (90 %). The silent sender, the classical twin and the split by the preceding shot are flat at all eight settings (at most 1.9, 1.7 and 1.3 standard errors against a registered limit of 4), the sender check separates the two signs (0.82 and 0.65 against a floor of 0.5), and the response of the sensor was 0.90, 0.86, 0.79, 0.62 for the four windows. All nine binding lines and the four attestation lines held. The bound is five to six orders of magnitude weaker than the laboratory bounds on the same parameter and competes with none of them. What the experiment adds is the place: the test runs on a public device, the sensor listens within microseconds of the measurement, and anyone with access to such a processor can run it again. Nothing here is a statement about the existence of other worlds. The deposit holds the registration and its superseded first version, the shared module with the circuits, the design and the estimators, the model and registration script, the runner, the verdict script, the logs of two preliminary looks on the device, the rehearsal of the whole session on the noiseless simulator under the hashed registration, the session log with the bits of every shot of every circuit in the order of execution, the seal file, the verdict (formed once), the ledger, the write-up (nuntius_paper_v1.pdf) and the scripts and figures that build it. Licence: CC BY 4.0.
Abstract Quantum random numbers are fundamental resources ( Rev. Mod. Phys. 89 015004) for the fields of communications and information security. Usually, projective measurements can be applied on a two-qubit entangled state to generate quantum random numbers. However, it cannot certify more than one bit of randomness for one set of measurements. On contrast, non-projective measurements in-principle may be able to generate more random bits, and therefore show some merits among present methods. Here, we report the implementation of a quantum random number generator based on a symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measure. In our experiment, we prepare a maximally entangled state of two-qubits through spontaneous parametric down-conversion processes, and observe the violation of Gisin’s elegant Bell inequality with the value of 6.8138 ± 0.0822, exceeding the classical bound of 6. Through randomness extractors, including a Toeplitz extractor and a parallel linear feedback shift register based extractor, we finally extract a random string with an autocorrelation coefficient below 10 −3 and the string can pass all randomness tests of the National Institute of Science and Technology (NIST).
Quantum information theory explores the fundamental principles governing the manipulation and utilization of quantum states. A crucial aspect of this field is the concept of non-linear collapse, a process that fundamentally alters the quantum state upon measurement. This paper investigates the impact of non-linear collapse on quantum state evolution and measurement results, specifically focusing on its implications for quantum algorithm design. We propose a novel quantum algorithm leveraging the principles of non-linear collapse to achieve enhanced quantum information processing efficiency. This work will detail the development of a quantum state evolution model incorporating non-linear collapse, highlighting its potential to accelerate quantum computation and offer a new approach to quantum information handling. This research represents a significant step towards refining quantum algorithms and pushing the boundaries of quantum information processing.