Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2205.07112

FROG: Forward-Secure Post-Quantum Signature

Attila A. Yavuz, Rouzbeh Behnia

Published May 14, 2022• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Forward-secure signatures guarantee that the signatures generated before the compromise of private key remain secure, and therefore offer an enhanced compromise-resiliency for real-life applications such as digital forensics, audit logs, and financial systems. However, the vast majority of state-of-the-art forward-secure signatures rely on conventional intractability assumptions and therefore are not secure against quantum computers. Hash-based signatures (HBS) (e.g., XMSS) can offer forward-secure post-quantum security. However, they are efficient only for a pre-defined number of messages to be signed and incur high key generation overhead, highly expensive signing, and large signature sizes for an increasing number of messages. It is an open problem to develop quantum-safe forward-secure signatures that are efficient and practical with a signing capability scalable to their security parameters. In this work, we propose a new series of post-quantum signatures that we call FROG (Forward-secuRe pOst-quantum siGnature). Unlike HBS alternatives, FROG can achieve highly computational efficient signatures with sub-linear key/signature sizes and (practically) unbounded signing capability. This is achieved by transforming suitable post-quantum signatures into forward-secure settings via MMM constructions. We investigated the transformation of prominent post-quantum secure signatures such as Dilithium, WOTS, and BLISS with MMM. Our experiments indicate that FROG outperforms XMSS for the vast majority (if not all for a large number of messages) of performance metrics. We also discuss one-time variants of these base signature schemes that can push the performance of FROG to the edge. Overall, FROG shows a better performance than the existing alternatives with forward-security and therefore is an ideal alternative for the standardization efforts for forward-secure post-quantum signatures.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2205.07112

Related papers

Post-quantum algorithms for digital signing in Public Key Infrastructures

Mikael Sjöberg

One emerging threat to Public Key Infrastructures is the possible development of large-scale quantum computers, which would be able to break the public-key cryptosystems used today. Several possibly post-quantum secure cryptographic algorithms have been proposed but so far they have not been used in many practical settings. The purpose of this thesis was to find post-quantum digital signature algorithms that might be suitable for use in Public Key Infrastructures today. To answer the research question, an extensive literature study was conducted where relevant algorithms were surveyed. Algorithms with high-grade implementations in different cryptographic libraries were benchmarked for performance. Hash-based XMSS and SPHINCS, multivariate-based Rainbow and lattice-based BLISS-B were benchmarked and the results showed that BLISS-B offered the best performance, on par with RSA and ECDSA. All the algorithms did however have relatively large signature sizes and/or key sizes. Support for post-quantum digital signature algorithms in Public Key Infrastructure products could easily be achieved since many algorithms are implemented in cryptographic libraries. The algorithms that could be recommended for use today were SPHINCS for high-security applications and possibly BLISS-B for lower security applications requiring higher efficiency. The biggest obstacles to widespread deployment of post-quantum algorithms was deemed to be lack of standardisation and either inefficient operations compared to classical algorithms, uncertain security levels, or both.

•Jan 1, 2017•7 citations

LPQ-HBSS: A Lightweight Post-Quantum Hash-Based Signature Scheme for Fog-Enabled Internet of Things Systems

Efat Fathalla, Raveendra Babu Ponnuru, Mohamed Azab

The emergence of quantum computing threatens the security assumptions underlying widely deployed public-key cryptographic systems across modern digital infrastructures. This challenge has accelerated the development of post-quantum cryptographic primitives capable of resisting quantum-capable adversaries. Among these, hash-based signature schemes are widely recognized as strong post-quantum candidates because their security relies solely on cryptographic hash functions. However, existing multi-time hash-based signature schemes, such as XMSS, rely on Merkle-tree structures to manage one-time signature keys, resulting in additional computational, communication, and verification overhead due to authentication-path construction and traversal.

IEEE Internet of Things Journal•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Design and Implementation of a Hash-based Post-Quantum Digital Signature Scheme for Lightweight Applications

Tara Nawzad Ahmad Al Attar, Mohammed Anwar Mohammed, Rebaz Nawzad Mohammed

The rapid advancement of quantum computing poses a serious threat to classical digital signature algorithms such as RSA and ECDSA, which rely on mathematical problems vulnerable to quantum attacks. Hash-based digital signatures offer a strong post-quantum alternative due to their reliance on cryptographic hash functions and their resistance to both classical and quantum adversaries. This study evaluates the feasibility of hash-based signatures in lightweight and resource-constrained environments by implementing three representative schemes: Lamport One-Time Signatures (OTS), Winternitz One-Time Signatures (WOTS), and Merkle-WOTS. The analysis focuses on key performance factors relevant to constrained devices, including key size, signature size, signing time, and verification speed. Experimental results show that while Lamport OTS provides conceptual simplicity and WOTS offers improved efficiency, the Merkle-WOTS scheme delivers the most practical balance. It supports multiple signatures under a compact public key while maintaining moderate signature sizes and competitive performance. These findings indicate that Merkle-WOTS is a strong candidate for post-quantum authentication in IoT and other lightweight embedded systems.

UHD Journal of Science and Technology•Jan 27, 2026•0 citations

K2SN-MSS: An Efficient Post-Quantum Signature

Sabyasachi Karati, Reihaneh Safavi–Naini

With the rapid development of quantum technologies, quantum-safe cryptography has found significant attention. Hash-based signature schemes have been in particular of interest because of (i) the importance of digital signature as the main source of trust on the Internet, (ii) the fact that the security of these signatures relies on existence of one-way functions, which is the minimal assumption for signature schemes, and (iii) they can be efficiently implemented. Basic hash-based signatures are for a single message, but have been extended for signing multiple messages. In this paper we design a Multi-message Signature Scheme (MSS) based on an existing One-Time Signature (OTS) that we refer to as KSN-OTS. KSN uses SWIFFT, an additive homomorphic lattice-based hash function family with provable one-wayness property, as the one-way-function and achieves a short signature. We prove security of our proposed signature scheme in a new strengthened security model (multi-target multi-function) of MSS, determine the system parameters for 512 bit classical (256 bit quantum) security, and compare parameter sizes of our scheme against XMSS, a widely studied hash based MSS that has been a candidate for NIST standardization of post-quantum signature scheme. We give an efficient implementation of our scheme using Intel SIMD (Single Instruction Multiple Data) instruction set. For this, we first implement SWIFFT computation using a SIMD parallelization of Number Theoretic Transform (NTT) of elements of the ring Zp[X]/(Xn+1), that can support different levels of parallelization. We compare efficiency of this implementation with a comparable (security level) implementation of XMSS and show its superior performance on a number of efficiency parameters.

ACM Asia Conference on Computer and Communications Security (ASIA CCS)•Jul 2, 2019•6 citations

An Analysis of Existing Hash-Based Post-Quantum Signature Schemes

Cristina Maria Păcurar, Răzvan Bocu, Maksim Iavich

The rapid development of quantum computing poses challenges to the foundations of traditional cryptography. The threats are significant in terms of both asymmetric cryptography (which exposes schemes like RSA and ECC to efficient attacks) and symmetric cryptography, where key sizes must be increased to mitigate these threats. In this paper, we review the evolution of hash-based digital signatures, from early one-time signatures to modern stateless schemes, with an emphasis on their security properties, efficiency, and practical constraints. Moreover, we propose a simple comparative metric that reflects structural symmetry across key parameters such as key size, signature size, and computational cost, enabling a visual clustering of the schemes. We give particular attention to recent developments such as Verkle trees, which preserve symmetric design principles while improving scalability and proof compactness. The study highlights ongoing tradeoffs between stateful and stateless designs and argues for the continued relevance of symmetric cryptographic constructions in building secure, efficient post-quantum systems.

Symmetry•Jun 10, 2025•6 citations

Improvement of Post-Quantum Signatures

Ming-Yi Syu, Wen‐Chung Kuo, Ming-Chun Wei +1 more

Recently, NIST released the quantum cryptography standard, which includes three new encryption algorithms capable of effectively resisting attacks from quantum computers. Experts predict that quantum computers with the ability to break current encryption methods may emerge within the next decade. In particular, the advent of Shor’s algorithm [1] has rendered public-key encryption systems based on factoring and discrete logarithm problems vulnerable. Therefore, the release of the PQC (Post-Quantum Cryptography) standard is especially timely and significant. NIST encourages system administrators to begin integrating these standards into their systems immediately to ensure future security.Among these three new encryption algorithms, SLH-DSA (derived from SPHINCS+ [2]) is a stateless hash-based digital signature scheme. This innovative scheme is designed to provide robust security while maintaining efficiency. In the SLH-DSA signature scheme, the One-Time Signature (OTS) serves as its fundamental building block. This means that improving the OTS directly enhances the overall performance of the SLH-DSA scheme.Hash-based signature schemes are generally constructed using OTS schemes. The underlying OTS scheme plays a crucial role in determining the key size and signature size of hash-based signature schemes. We propose a novel signature scheme that allows partial key reuse while maintaining a minimum quantum security level of 128 bits. Compared to the popular Winternitz OTS scheme [3] [4] [5], our proposed signature scheme demonstrates superior performance in terms of key and signature sizes for the same number of signatures, while still preserving post-quantum security.

Advances in transdisciplinary engineering•Oct 13, 2025•0 citations
Forward-secure signatures guarantee that the signatures generated before the compromise of private key remain secure, and therefore offer an enhanced compromise-resiliency for real-life applications such as digital forensics, audit logs, and financial systems. However, the vast majority of state-of-the-art forward-secure signatures rely on conventional intractability assumptions and therefore are not secure against quantum computers. Hash-based signatures (HBS) (e.g., XMSS) can offer forward-secure post-quantum security. However, they are efficient only for a pre-defined number of messages to be signed and incur high key generation overhead, highly expensive signing, and large signature sizes for an increasing number of messages. It is an open problem to develop quantum-safe forward-secure signatures that are efficient and practical with a signing capability scalable to their security parameters. In this work, we propose a new series of post-quantum signatures that we call FROG (Forward-secuRe pOst-quantum siGnature). Unlike HBS alternatives, FROG can achieve highly computational efficient signatures with sub-linear key/signature sizes and (practically) unbounded signing capability. This is achieved by transforming suitable post-quantum signatures into forward-secure settings via MMM constructions. We investigated the transformation of prominent post-quantum secure signatures such as Dilithium, WOTS, and BLISS with MMM. Our experiments indicate that FROG outperforms XMSS for the vast majority (if not all for a large number of messages) of performance metrics. We also discuss one-time variants of these base signature schemes that can push the performance of FROG to the edge. Overall, FROG shows a better performance than the existing alternatives with forward-security and therefore is an ideal alternative for the standardization efforts for forward-secure post-quantum signatures.
One emerging threat to Public Key Infrastructures is the possible development of large-scale quantum computers, which would be able to break the public-key cryptosystems used today. Several possibly post-quantum secure cryptographic algorithms have been proposed but so far they have not been used in many practical settings. The purpose of this thesis was to find post-quantum digital signature algorithms that might be suitable for use in Public Key Infrastructures today. To answer the research question, an extensive literature study was conducted where relevant algorithms were surveyed. Algorithms with high-grade implementations in different cryptographic libraries were benchmarked for performance. Hash-based XMSS and SPHINCS, multivariate-based Rainbow and lattice-based BLISS-B were benchmarked and the results showed that BLISS-B offered the best performance, on par with RSA and ECDSA. All the algorithms did however have relatively large signature sizes and/or key sizes. Support for post-quantum digital signature algorithms in Public Key Infrastructure products could easily be achieved since many algorithms are implemented in cryptographic libraries. The algorithms that could be recommended for use today were SPHINCS for high-security applications and possibly BLISS-B for lower security applications requiring higher efficiency. The biggest obstacles to widespread deployment of post-quantum algorithms was deemed to be lack of standardisation and either inefficient operations compared to classical algorithms, uncertain security levels, or both.
The emergence of quantum computing threatens the security assumptions underlying widely deployed public-key cryptographic systems across modern digital infrastructures. This challenge has accelerated the development of post-quantum cryptographic primitives capable of resisting quantum-capable adversaries. Among these, hash-based signature schemes are widely recognized as strong post-quantum candidates because their security relies solely on cryptographic hash functions. However, existing multi-time hash-based signature schemes, such as XMSS, rely on Merkle-tree structures to manage one-time signature keys, resulting in additional computational, communication, and verification overhead due to authentication-path construction and traversal.
The rapid advancement of quantum computing poses a serious threat to classical digital signature algorithms such as RSA and ECDSA, which rely on mathematical problems vulnerable to quantum attacks. Hash-based digital signatures offer a strong post-quantum alternative due to their reliance on cryptographic hash functions and their resistance to both classical and quantum adversaries. This study evaluates the feasibility of hash-based signatures in lightweight and resource-constrained environments by implementing three representative schemes: Lamport One-Time Signatures (OTS), Winternitz One-Time Signatures (WOTS), and Merkle-WOTS. The analysis focuses on key performance factors relevant to constrained devices, including key size, signature size, signing time, and verification speed. Experimental results show that while Lamport OTS provides conceptual simplicity and WOTS offers improved efficiency, the Merkle-WOTS scheme delivers the most practical balance. It supports multiple signatures under a compact public key while maintaining moderate signature sizes and competitive performance. These findings indicate that Merkle-WOTS is a strong candidate for post-quantum authentication in IoT and other lightweight embedded systems.
With the rapid development of quantum technologies, quantum-safe cryptography has found significant attention. Hash-based signature schemes have been in particular of interest because of (i) the importance of digital signature as the main source of trust on the Internet, (ii) the fact that the security of these signatures relies on existence of one-way functions, which is the minimal assumption for signature schemes, and (iii) they can be efficiently implemented. Basic hash-based signatures are for a single message, but have been extended for signing multiple messages. In this paper we design a Multi-message Signature Scheme (MSS) based on an existing One-Time Signature (OTS) that we refer to as KSN-OTS. KSN uses SWIFFT, an additive homomorphic lattice-based hash function family with provable one-wayness property, as the one-way-function and achieves a short signature. We prove security of our proposed signature scheme in a new strengthened security model (multi-target multi-function) of MSS, determine the system parameters for 512 bit classical (256 bit quantum) security, and compare parameter sizes of our scheme against XMSS, a widely studied hash based MSS that has been a candidate for NIST standardization of post-quantum signature scheme. We give an efficient implementation of our scheme using Intel SIMD (Single Instruction Multiple Data) instruction set. For this, we first implement SWIFFT computation using a SIMD parallelization of Number Theoretic Transform (NTT) of elements of the ring Zp[X]/(Xn+1), that can support different levels of parallelization. We compare efficiency of this implementation with a comparable (security level) implementation of XMSS and show its superior performance on a number of efficiency parameters.
The rapid development of quantum computing poses challenges to the foundations of traditional cryptography. The threats are significant in terms of both asymmetric cryptography (which exposes schemes like RSA and ECC to efficient attacks) and symmetric cryptography, where key sizes must be increased to mitigate these threats. In this paper, we review the evolution of hash-based digital signatures, from early one-time signatures to modern stateless schemes, with an emphasis on their security properties, efficiency, and practical constraints. Moreover, we propose a simple comparative metric that reflects structural symmetry across key parameters such as key size, signature size, and computational cost, enabling a visual clustering of the schemes. We give particular attention to recent developments such as Verkle trees, which preserve symmetric design principles while improving scalability and proof compactness. The study highlights ongoing tradeoffs between stateful and stateless designs and argues for the continued relevance of symmetric cryptographic constructions in building secure, efficient post-quantum systems.
Recently, NIST released the quantum cryptography standard, which includes three new encryption algorithms capable of effectively resisting attacks from quantum computers. Experts predict that quantum computers with the ability to break current encryption methods may emerge within the next decade. In particular, the advent of Shor’s algorithm [1] has rendered public-key encryption systems based on factoring and discrete logarithm problems vulnerable. Therefore, the release of the PQC (Post-Quantum Cryptography) standard is especially timely and significant. NIST encourages system administrators to begin integrating these standards into their systems immediately to ensure future security.Among these three new encryption algorithms, SLH-DSA (derived from SPHINCS+ [2]) is a stateless hash-based digital signature scheme. This innovative scheme is designed to provide robust security while maintaining efficiency. In the SLH-DSA signature scheme, the One-Time Signature (OTS) serves as its fundamental building block. This means that improving the OTS directly enhances the overall performance of the SLH-DSA scheme.Hash-based signature schemes are generally constructed using OTS schemes. The underlying OTS scheme plays a crucial role in determining the key size and signature size of hash-based signature schemes. We propose a novel signature scheme that allows partial key reuse while maintaining a minimum quantum security level of 128 bits. Compared to the popular Winternitz OTS scheme [3] [4] [5], our proposed signature scheme demonstrates superior performance in terms of key and signature sizes for the same number of signatures, while still preserving post-quantum security.