Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2205.00555 · Physical review. D/Physical review. D.

Thermalization by off-shell processes: The virtues of small virtuality

D. Boyanovsky

Published Aug 19, 2022• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the thermalization of a scalar field $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ coupled to two other scalar fields ${\ensuremath{\chi}}_{1,2}$ that constitute a bath in thermal equilibrium. For a range of masses the $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ propagator features threshold and infrared divergences, a vanishing residue at the (quasi)particle pole, and vanishing on-shell decay rates thereby preventing the equilibration of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ with the bath via on-shell processes. Inspired by the theory of quantum open systems we obtain a quantum master equation for the reduced density matrix of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$ that includes the time dependence of bath correlations, yielding time dependent rates in the dynamics of relaxation and allowing virtual processes with an energy ${q}_{0}$ whose difference from the on-shell energy is of $\mathcal{O}(1/t)$ at long time $t$. These off-shell processes lead to thermalization despite vanishing $S$-matrix rates. In the case of threshold divergences we find that a thermal fixed point is approached as ${e}^{\ensuremath{-}\sqrt{t/{t}^{*}}}$ with the relaxation time ${t}^{*}$ becoming shorter at high temperature as a consequence of stimulated emission and absorption. In the infrared case, the thermal fixed point is approached as ${e}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\gamma}(t)}$, where $\ensuremath{\gamma}(t)$ features a crossover between $\mathrm{ln}(t)$ and $t$ behavior for $t\ensuremath{\gg}1/T$. The vanishing of the residue and the crossover in relaxational dynamics in this case is strikingly reminiscent of the orthogonality catastrophe in heavy impurity systems. The results yield more general lessons on thermalization via virtual processes.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.106.045019

Related papers

Quantum kinetics and thermalization in an exactly solvable model

S. M. Alamoudi, D. Boyanovsky, Hector J. de Vega +1 more

We study the dynamics of relaxation and thermalization in an exactly solvable model of a quantum particle interacting with a thermal bath of oscillators with the goal of understanding the effects of off-shell processes. The focus is to compare the exact evolution of the distribution function with different approximations to the relaxational dynamics: Boltzmann, non-Markovian and Markovian quantum kinetics. The time evolution of the distribution function is evaluated exactly using different approaches where each method provides different insights. There are two different cases that are studied in detail: (i) no stable particle states below threshold of the bath and a quasiparticle resonance above it and (ii) a stable discrete exact ``particle'' state below threshold. The exact solution for the evolution allows us to investigate the concept of the formation time of a quasiparticle and to study the difference between the relaxation of the distribution of particles and quasiparticles. For the case of quasiparticles in the continuum (resonances) the exact quasiparticle distribution asymptotically tends to a statistical equilibrium distribution that differs from a simple Bose-Einstein form as a result of off-shell processes such as the strength of the quasiparticle poles, the width of the unstable particle and proximity to thresholds. In case (ii), the distribution of particles does not thermalize with the bath. We study the kinetics of thermalization and relaxation by deriving a non-Markovian quantum kinetic equation which resums the perturbative series and includes off-shell effects. A Markovian approximation that includes off-shell contributions and the usual Boltzmann equation are obtained from the quantum kinetic equation in the limit of a wide separation of time scales upon different coarse-graining assumptions. The relaxational dynamics predicted by the non-Markovian, Markovian and Boltzmann approximations are compared to the exact result of the model. The Boltzmann approach is seen to fail in the case of wide resonances and when threshold and renormalization effects are important. Implications for thermalization in field theory models are discussed.

arXiv:hep-ph/9806235•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Dec 7, 1998•18 citations

Quantum kinetics and thermalization in a particle bath model

S. M. Alamoudi, D. Boyanovsky, Hector J. de Vega

We study the dynamics of relaxation and thermalization in an exactly solvable model of a particle interacting with a harmonic oscillator bath. Our goal is to understand the effects of non-Markovian processes on the relaxational dynamics and to compare the exact evolution of the distribution function with approximate Markovian and non-Markovian quantum kinetics. There are two different cases that are studied in detail: (i) a quasiparticle (resonance) when the renormalized frequency of the particle is above the frequency threshold of the bath and (ii) a stable renormalized "particle" state below this threshold. The time evolution of the occupation number for the particle is evaluated exactly using different approaches that yield to complementary insights. The exact solution allows us to investigate the concept of the formation time of a quasiparticle and to study the difference between the relaxation of the distribution of bare particles and that of quasiparticles. For the case of quasiparticles, the exact occupation number asymptotically tends to a statistical equilibrium distribution that differs from a simple Bose-Einstein form as a result of off-shell processes whereas in the stable particle case, the distribution of particles does not thermalize with the bath. We derive a non-Markovian quantum kinetic equation which resums the perturbative series and includes off-shell effects. A Markovian approximation that includes off-shell contributions and the usual Boltzmann equation (energy conserving) are obtained from the quantum kinetic equation in the limit of wide separation of time scales upon different coarse-graining assumptions. The relaxational dynamics predicted by the non-Markovian, Markovian, and Boltzmann approximations are compared to the exact result. The Boltzmann approach is seen to fail in the case of wide resonances and when threshold and renormalization effects are important.

arXiv:cond-mat/9812029•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Jul 1, 1999•17 citations

Quantum dynamics and thermalization for out-of-equilibrium φ4 theory

S. Juchem, W. Cassing, Carsten Greiner

The quantum time evolution of ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{4}$-field theory for a spatially homogeneous system in 2+1 space-time dimensions is investigated numerically for out-of-equilibrium initial conditions on the basis of the Kadanoff-Baym equations including the tadpole and sunset self-energies. Whereas the tadpole self-energy yields a dynamical mass, the sunset self-energy is responsible for dissipation and an equilibration of the system. In particular we address the dynamics of the spectral (``off-shell'') distributions of the excited quantum modes and the different phases in the approach to equilibrium described by Kubo-Martin-Schwinger relations for thermal equilibrium states. The investigation explicitly demonstrates that the only translation invariant solutions representing the stationary fixed points of the coupled equation of motions are those of full thermal equilibrium. They agree with those extracted from the time integration of the Kadanoff-Baym equations for $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{t}\ensuremath{\infty}.$ Furthermore, a detailed comparison of the full quantum dynamics to more approximate and simple schemes such as that of a standard kinetic (on-shell) Boltzmann equation is performed. Our analysis shows that the consistent inclusion of the dynamical spectral function has a significant impact on relaxation phenomena. The different time scales that are involved in the dynamical quantum evolution towards a complete thermalized state are discussed in detail. We find that far off-shell $1\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}3$ processes are responsible for chemical equilibration, which is missed in the Boltzmann limit. Finally, we briefly address the case of (bare) massless fields. For sufficiently large couplings $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ we observe the onset of Bose condensation, where our scheme within symmetric ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{4}$ theory breaks down.

arXiv:hep-ph/0307353•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jan 30, 2004•143 citations

Quantum Open Effective Field Theory: anomalous decoherence

Gabriela Barenboim, D. Boyanovsky

We study decoherence of a scalar field coupled to ``anomalous'' environments with critical behavior with the Schwinger-Keldysh including the influence functional, and the quantum master equation (QME) up to second order in the coupling. The Schwinger-Keldysh formulation yields a Langevin equation and the Lindblad (QME) includes \emph{time dependent rates} allowing to study transient dynamics. We focus on three examples featuring non-Markov dynamics that cannot be described with S-matrix/Fermi's golden rule rates \textbf{i) Unparticle physics:} a conformal sector beyond the Standard Model at an infrared fixed point featuring correlation functions with anomalous scaling dimensions, \textbf{ii) Threshold and infrared enhancement:} when the mass shell of the field coincides with or is near to a kinematic threshold of the spectral density of the bath, \textbf{iii) Critical environments:} the bath is at a critical point, correlation functions scale with anomalous dimensions and long-wavelength fluctuations feature critical slowing down. In all cases the reduced density matrix undergoes decoherence in the energy basis of the probe, and off-diagonal matrix elements decay as $e^{-Φ(t)}$ with $Φ(t)>0 $ the \emph{decoherence function} and $Γ(t) = \dotΦ(t)$ the decoherence rate. In all cases we find that either transient or asymptotically $Φ(t) \propto t^{-μ}~;~ μ>0$ with $μ$, determined by the behavior of the spectral density at threshold and the anomalous scaling dimensions of the correlation functions, or $Φ(t) \propto \ln(t)$ for the infrared case. For a critical environment there is a new dynamical scaling exponent. A probe of frequency $ω_q$ is resonant with a \emph{critically slow} quasiparticle for $q_*\propto ω^{1/z}_q$ at which decoherence is strongly \emph{enhanced}.

arXiv:2611.10287•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

Relaxation and kinetics in scalar field theories

D. Boyanovsky, Ian D. Lawrie, D. S. Lee

A new approach to the dynamics of relaxation and kinetics of thermalization in a scalar field theory is presented that incorporates the relevant time scales through the resummation of hard thermal loops. An alternative derivation of the kinetic equations for the "quasiparticle" distribution functions is obtained that allows a clear understanding of the different "coarse-graining" approximations usually involved in a kinetic description. This method leads to a systematic perturbative expansion to obtain the kinetic equations including hard thermal loop resummation and to an improvement including renormalization, off-shell effects, and contributions that change chemical equilibrium on short time scales. As a by-product of these methods we establish the equivalence between the relaxation time scale in the linearized equation of motion of the quasiparticles and the thermalization time scale of the quasiparticle distribution function in the "relaxation time approximation" including hard thermal loop effects. Hard thermal loop resummation dramatically modifies the scattering rate for long wavelength modes as compared to the usual (semi)classical estimate. Relaxation and kinetics are studied both in the unbroken and broken symmetry phases of the theory. The broken symmetry phase also provides the setting to obtain the contribution to the kinetic equations from processes that involve decay of a heavy scalar into light scalar particles in the medium.

arXiv:hep-ph/9603217•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Sep 15, 1996•58 citations

What does "instant thermalization" in large-$q$ SYK models mean?

Alexander Osterkorn, Jan C. Louw

Motivated by the Planckian thermalization rate $Γ\sim T$ observed in the two-body interacting SYK model, we study thermalization in the $q/2$-body case. Previous studies of such systems have established the notion of instantaneous thermalization to leading order in $1/q$. It was conjectured that the thermalization may still be Planckian but with a divergent rate $Γ\sim T q$, explaining the ``instantaneous'' part. For an analytically and numerically tractable system, we calculate the effective temperatures after a quench at time $t = 0$ and indeed find a Planckian rate, albeit with the unexpected decaying behavior $Γ\sim T q^{-1} $. This is contrasted with the behavior of the causal Green's function $\mathcal{G}(t_1, t_2)$, which instantly acquires a thermal form in the two-time plane block $t_1, t_2 > 0$. The resulting picture is that instant thermalization is a meaningful concept only for this block, while the off-diagonal blocks $t_1 \cdot t_2 < 0$ are inherently non-thermal at any $q$. Since the effective temperature is obtained from correlations spanning all blocks, it inherits a finite rate set by the off-diagonal. We illustrate this directly by studying the non-thermal correlations' time dependence.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2609.17794•Sep 17, 2026•1 citation
We study the thermalization of a scalar field \ensuremathΦ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}\ensuremathΦ coupled to two other scalar fields \ensuremathχ1,2{\ensuremath{\chi}}_{1,2}\ensuremathχ1,2​ that constitute a bath in thermal equilibrium. For a range of masses the \ensuremathΦ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}\ensuremathΦ propagator features threshold and infrared divergences, a vanishing residue at the (quasi)particle pole, and vanishing on-shell decay rates thereby preventing the equilibration of \ensuremathΦ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}\ensuremathΦ with the bath via on-shell processes. Inspired by the theory of quantum open systems we obtain a quantum master equation for the reduced density matrix of \ensuremathΦ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}\ensuremathΦ that includes the time dependence of bath correlations, yielding time dependent rates in the dynamics of relaxation and allowing virtual processes with an energy q0{q}_{0}q0​ whose difference from the on-shell energy is of O(1/t)\mathcal{O}(1/t)O(1/t) at long time ttt. These off-shell processes lead to thermalization despite vanishing SSS-matrix rates. In the case of threshold divergences we find that a thermal fixed point is approached as e\ensuremath−t/t∗{e}^{\ensuremath{-}\sqrt{t/{t}^{*}}}e\ensuremath−t/t∗​ with the relaxation time t∗{t}^{*}t∗ becoming shorter at high temperature as a consequence of stimulated emission and absorption. In the infrared case, the thermal fixed point is approached as e\ensuremath−\ensuremathγ(t){e}^{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\gamma}(t)}e\ensuremath−\ensuremathγ(t), where \ensuremathγ(t)\ensuremath{\gamma}(t)\ensuremathγ(t) features a crossover between ln(t)\mathrm{ln}(t)ln(t) and ttt behavior for t\ensuremath≫1/Tt\ensuremath{\gg}1/Tt\ensuremath≫1/T. The vanishing of the residue and the crossover in relaxational dynamics in this case is strikingly reminiscent of the orthogonality catastrophe in heavy impurity systems. The results yield more general lessons on thermalization via virtual processes.
We study the dynamics of relaxation and thermalization in an exactly solvable model of a quantum particle interacting with a thermal bath of oscillators with the goal of understanding the effects of off-shell processes. The focus is to compare the exact evolution of the distribution function with different approximations to the relaxational dynamics: Boltzmann, non-Markovian and Markovian quantum kinetics. The time evolution of the distribution function is evaluated exactly using different approaches where each method provides different insights. There are two different cases that are studied in detail: (i) no stable particle states below threshold of the bath and a quasiparticle resonance above it and (ii) a stable discrete exact ``particle'' state below threshold. The exact solution for the evolution allows us to investigate the concept of the formation time of a quasiparticle and to study the difference between the relaxation of the distribution of particles and quasiparticles. For the case of quasiparticles in the continuum (resonances) the exact quasiparticle distribution asymptotically tends to a statistical equilibrium distribution that differs from a simple Bose-Einstein form as a result of off-shell processes such as the strength of the quasiparticle poles, the width of the unstable particle and proximity to thresholds. In case (ii), the distribution of particles does not thermalize with the bath. We study the kinetics of thermalization and relaxation by deriving a non-Markovian quantum kinetic equation which resums the perturbative series and includes off-shell effects. A Markovian approximation that includes off-shell contributions and the usual Boltzmann equation are obtained from the quantum kinetic equation in the limit of a wide separation of time scales upon different coarse-graining assumptions. The relaxational dynamics predicted by the non-Markovian, Markovian and Boltzmann approximations are compared to the exact result of the model. The Boltzmann approach is seen to fail in the case of wide resonances and when threshold and renormalization effects are important. Implications for thermalization in field theory models are discussed.
We study the dynamics of relaxation and thermalization in an exactly solvable model of a particle interacting with a harmonic oscillator bath. Our goal is to understand the effects of non-Markovian processes on the relaxational dynamics and to compare the exact evolution of the distribution function with approximate Markovian and non-Markovian quantum kinetics. There are two different cases that are studied in detail: (i) a quasiparticle (resonance) when the renormalized frequency of the particle is above the frequency threshold of the bath and (ii) a stable renormalized "particle" state below this threshold. The time evolution of the occupation number for the particle is evaluated exactly using different approaches that yield to complementary insights. The exact solution allows us to investigate the concept of the formation time of a quasiparticle and to study the difference between the relaxation of the distribution of bare particles and that of quasiparticles. For the case of quasiparticles, the exact occupation number asymptotically tends to a statistical equilibrium distribution that differs from a simple Bose-Einstein form as a result of off-shell processes whereas in the stable particle case, the distribution of particles does not thermalize with the bath. We derive a non-Markovian quantum kinetic equation which resums the perturbative series and includes off-shell effects. A Markovian approximation that includes off-shell contributions and the usual Boltzmann equation (energy conserving) are obtained from the quantum kinetic equation in the limit of wide separation of time scales upon different coarse-graining assumptions. The relaxational dynamics predicted by the non-Markovian, Markovian, and Boltzmann approximations are compared to the exact result. The Boltzmann approach is seen to fail in the case of wide resonances and when threshold and renormalization effects are important.
The quantum time evolution of ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{4}$-field theory for a spatially homogeneous system in 2+1 space-time dimensions is investigated numerically for out-of-equilibrium initial conditions on the basis of the Kadanoff-Baym equations including the tadpole and sunset self-energies. Whereas the tadpole self-energy yields a dynamical mass, the sunset self-energy is responsible for dissipation and an equilibration of the system. In particular we address the dynamics of the spectral (``off-shell'') distributions of the excited quantum modes and the different phases in the approach to equilibrium described by Kubo-Martin-Schwinger relations for thermal equilibrium states. The investigation explicitly demonstrates that the only translation invariant solutions representing the stationary fixed points of the coupled equation of motions are those of full thermal equilibrium. They agree with those extracted from the time integration of the Kadanoff-Baym equations for $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{t}\ensuremath{\infty}.$ Furthermore, a detailed comparison of the full quantum dynamics to more approximate and simple schemes such as that of a standard kinetic (on-shell) Boltzmann equation is performed. Our analysis shows that the consistent inclusion of the dynamical spectral function has a significant impact on relaxation phenomena. The different time scales that are involved in the dynamical quantum evolution towards a complete thermalized state are discussed in detail. We find that far off-shell $1\ensuremath{\leftrightarrow}3$ processes are responsible for chemical equilibration, which is missed in the Boltzmann limit. Finally, we briefly address the case of (bare) massless fields. For sufficiently large couplings $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ we observe the onset of Bose condensation, where our scheme within symmetric ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{4}$ theory breaks down.
We study decoherence of a scalar field coupled to ``anomalous'' environments with critical behavior with the Schwinger-Keldysh including the influence functional, and the quantum master equation (QME) up to second order in the coupling. The Schwinger-Keldysh formulation yields a Langevin equation and the Lindblad (QME) includes \emph{time dependent rates} allowing to study transient dynamics. We focus on three examples featuring non-Markov dynamics that cannot be described with S-matrix/Fermi's golden rule rates \textbf{i) Unparticle physics:} a conformal sector beyond the Standard Model at an infrared fixed point featuring correlation functions with anomalous scaling dimensions, \textbf{ii) Threshold and infrared enhancement:} when the mass shell of the field coincides with or is near to a kinematic threshold of the spectral density of the bath, \textbf{iii) Critical environments:} the bath is at a critical point, correlation functions scale with anomalous dimensions and long-wavelength fluctuations feature critical slowing down. In all cases the reduced density matrix undergoes decoherence in the energy basis of the probe, and off-diagonal matrix elements decay as e−Φ(t)e^{-Φ(t)}e−Φ(t) with $Φ(t)>0 $ the \emph{decoherence function} and Γ(t)=Φ˙(t)Γ(t) = \dotΦ(t)Γ(t)=Φ˙(t) the decoherence rate. In all cases we find that either transient or asymptotically Φ(t)∝t−μ ; μ>0Φ(t) \propto t^{-μ}~;~ μ>0Φ(t)∝t−μ ; μ>0 with μμμ, determined by the behavior of the spectral density at threshold and the anomalous scaling dimensions of the correlation functions, or Φ(t)∝ln⁡(t)Φ(t) \propto \ln(t)Φ(t)∝ln(t) for the infrared case. For a critical environment there is a new dynamical scaling exponent. A probe of frequency ωqω_qωq​ is resonant with a \emph{critically slow} quasiparticle for q∗∝ωq1/zq_*\propto ω^{1/z}_qq∗​∝ωq1/z​ at which decoherence is strongly \emph{enhanced}.
A new approach to the dynamics of relaxation and kinetics of thermalization in a scalar field theory is presented that incorporates the relevant time scales through the resummation of hard thermal loops. An alternative derivation of the kinetic equations for the "quasiparticle" distribution functions is obtained that allows a clear understanding of the different "coarse-graining" approximations usually involved in a kinetic description. This method leads to a systematic perturbative expansion to obtain the kinetic equations including hard thermal loop resummation and to an improvement including renormalization, off-shell effects, and contributions that change chemical equilibrium on short time scales. As a by-product of these methods we establish the equivalence between the relaxation time scale in the linearized equation of motion of the quasiparticles and the thermalization time scale of the quasiparticle distribution function in the "relaxation time approximation" including hard thermal loop effects. Hard thermal loop resummation dramatically modifies the scattering rate for long wavelength modes as compared to the usual (semi)classical estimate. Relaxation and kinetics are studied both in the unbroken and broken symmetry phases of the theory. The broken symmetry phase also provides the setting to obtain the contribution to the kinetic equations from processes that involve decay of a heavy scalar into light scalar particles in the medium.
What does "instant thermalization" in large-qqq SYK models mean?
Motivated by the Planckian thermalization rate Γ∼TΓ\sim TΓ∼T observed in the two-body interacting SYK model, we study thermalization in the q/2q/2q/2-body case. Previous studies of such systems have established the notion of instantaneous thermalization to leading order in 1/q1/q1/q. It was conjectured that the thermalization may still be Planckian but with a divergent rate Γ∼TqΓ\sim T qΓ∼Tq, explaining the ``instantaneous'' part. For an analytically and numerically tractable system, we calculate the effective temperatures after a quench at time t=0t = 0t=0 and indeed find a Planckian rate, albeit with the unexpected decaying behavior $Γ\sim T q^{-1} $. This is contrasted with the behavior of the causal Green's function G(t1,t2)\mathcal{G}(t_1, t_2)G(t1​,t2​), which instantly acquires a thermal form in the two-time plane block t1,t2>0t_1, t_2 > 0t1​,t2​>0. The resulting picture is that instant thermalization is a meaningful concept only for this block, while the off-diagonal blocks t1⋅t2<0t_1 \cdot t_2 < 0t1​⋅t2​<0 are inherently non-thermal at any qqq. Since the effective temperature is obtained from correlations spanning all blocks, it inherits a finite rate set by the off-diagonal. We illustrate this directly by studying the non-thermal correlations' time dependence.