Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2109.00581 · The European Physical Journal Plus

Effects of the free evolution in the Arthurs–Kelly model of simultaneous measurement and in the retrodictive predictions of the Heisenberg uncertainty relations

J. A. Mendoza-Fierro, L. M. Arévalo Aguilar, Víctor Manuel Velázquez Aguilar

Published Sep 1, 2021• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1140/epjp/s13360-021-01943-6

Related papers

Quantum Uncertainties in Sequential Measurements Under Prediction and Retrodiction

Le Bin Ho

•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Maximal accuracy and minimal disturbance in the Arthurs-Kelly simultaneous measurement process

D. M. Appleby

The accuracy of the Arthurs-Kelly model of a simultaneous measurement of position and momentum is analysed using concepts developed by Braginsky and Khalili in the context of measurements of a single quantum observable. A distinction is made between the errors of retrodiction and prediction. It is shown that the distribution of measured values coincides with the initial-state Husimi function when the retrodictive accuracy is maximized (this being the result first obtained by Busch, using somewhat different methods). It is further shown that the distribution of measured values is related to the final-state anti-Husimi function (the P representation of quantum optics) when the predictive accuracy is maximized. The disturbance of the system by the measurement is also discussed. A class of minimally disturbing measurements is characterized. It is shown that the distribution of measured values then coincides with one of the smoothed Wigner functions described by Cartwright.

arXiv:quant-ph/9803047•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jul 31, 1998•26 citations

Uncertainty relation and simultaneous measurements in quantum theory

Paul Busch

•May 15, 1982•0 citations

Aspects of universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation

Kazuo Fujikawa, Koichiro Umetsu

A numerical illustration of a universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation, which was proposed recently, is presented by using the experimental data on spin-measurements by J. Erhart et al. [Nat. Phys. 8, 185 (2012)]. This uncertainty relation is closely related to a modified form of the Arthurs–Kelly uncertainty relation, which is also tested by the spin-measurements. The universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation always holds, but both the modified Arthurs–Kelly uncertainty relation and the Heisenberg error–disturbance relation proposed by Ozawa, which was analyzed in the original experiment, fail in the present context of spin-measurements, and the cause of their failure is identified with the assumptions of unbiased measurement and disturbance. It is also shown that all the universally valid uncertainty relations are derived from Robertson's relation and thus the essence of the uncertainty relation is exhausted by Robertson's relation, as is widely accepted.

arXiv:1211.1828•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Jan 1, 2013•9 citations

Conditionally valid uncertainty relations

Kazuo Fujikawa

It is shown that the well-defined unbiased measurement or disturbance of a dynamical variable is not maintained for the precise measurement of the conjugate variable, independently of uncertainty relations. The conditionally valid uncertainty relations on the basis of those additional assumptions, which include most of the familiar Heisenberg-type relations, thus become singular for the precise measurement. We clarify some contradicting conclusions in the literature concerning those conditionally valid uncertainty relations: The failure of a naive Heisenberg-type error-disturbance relation and the modified Arthurs-Kelly relation in the recent spin measurement is attributed to this singular behavior. The naive Heisenberg-type error-disturbance relation is formally preserved in quantum estimation theory, which is shown to be based on the strict unbiased measurement and disturbance, but it leads to unbounded disturbance for bounded operators such as spin variables. In contrast, the Heisenberg-type error-error uncertainty relation and the Arthurs-Kelly relation, as conditionally valid uncertainty relations, are consistently maintained.

arXiv:1305.6375•Physical Review A•Jul 26, 2013•6 citations

Indeterminacy relations and simultaneous measurements in quantum theory

Paul Busch

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 1985•121 citations
The accuracy of the Arthurs-Kelly model of a simultaneous measurement of position and momentum is analysed using concepts developed by Braginsky and Khalili in the context of measurements of a single quantum observable. A distinction is made between the errors of retrodiction and prediction. It is shown that the distribution of measured values coincides with the initial-state Husimi function when the retrodictive accuracy is maximized (this being the result first obtained by Busch, using somewhat different methods). It is further shown that the distribution of measured values is related to the final-state anti-Husimi function (the P representation of quantum optics) when the predictive accuracy is maximized. The disturbance of the system by the measurement is also discussed. A class of minimally disturbing measurements is characterized. It is shown that the distribution of measured values then coincides with one of the smoothed Wigner functions described by Cartwright.
A numerical illustration of a universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation, which was proposed recently, is presented by using the experimental data on spin-measurements by J. Erhart et al. [Nat. Phys. 8, 185 (2012)]. This uncertainty relation is closely related to a modified form of the Arthurs–Kelly uncertainty relation, which is also tested by the spin-measurements. The universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation always holds, but both the modified Arthurs–Kelly uncertainty relation and the Heisenberg error–disturbance relation proposed by Ozawa, which was analyzed in the original experiment, fail in the present context of spin-measurements, and the cause of their failure is identified with the assumptions of unbiased measurement and disturbance. It is also shown that all the universally valid uncertainty relations are derived from Robertson's relation and thus the essence of the uncertainty relation is exhausted by Robertson's relation, as is widely accepted.
It is shown that the well-defined unbiased measurement or disturbance of a dynamical variable is not maintained for the precise measurement of the conjugate variable, independently of uncertainty relations. The conditionally valid uncertainty relations on the basis of those additional assumptions, which include most of the familiar Heisenberg-type relations, thus become singular for the precise measurement. We clarify some contradicting conclusions in the literature concerning those conditionally valid uncertainty relations: The failure of a naive Heisenberg-type error-disturbance relation and the modified Arthurs-Kelly relation in the recent spin measurement is attributed to this singular behavior. The naive Heisenberg-type error-disturbance relation is formally preserved in quantum estimation theory, which is shown to be based on the strict unbiased measurement and disturbance, but it leads to unbounded disturbance for bounded operators such as spin variables. In contrast, the Heisenberg-type error-error uncertainty relation and the Arthurs-Kelly relation, as conditionally valid uncertainty relations, are consistently maintained.