The Heisenberg uncertainty relation in quantum mechanics limits the precision of predicting the outcome of measurements of any non-commuting observables. However, this restriction does not apply to retrodictive guessing of the outcomes of past measurements. Here, we experimentally demonstrate this using a spin oscillator consisting of $ 5.17 \times 10^{10}$ rubidium atoms. Through weak continuous measurements, we monitor canonical spin observables
x^A and
p^A with
[x^A,p^A]=iℏ. By combining information obtained before and after time
t, we retrodict the outcomes of measurements of
x^A and
p^A at time
t with variances that remain, concurrently over 1.4 hours,
∼ 1.01 dB below the bound set by the Heisenberg uncertainty relation. We also infer and demonstrate the ability to retrodict, with the same precision, the measurement outcomes for arbitrary quadratures of the spin oscillator. This brings interesting prospects for further research on quantum measurements, and for quantum-enhanced sensing that combines trajectory and entanglement strategies.
We study quantum measurement retrodiction using the principle of minimum change. For quantum-to-classical measurement channels, we show that all standard quantum divergences select the same retrodictive update, yielding a unique and divergence-independent quantum Bayesian inverse for any POVM and prior state. Using this update, we construct a symmetric joint distribution for pairs of POVMs and introduce the mutual retrodictability, for which we also derive a general upper bound that depends only on the prior state and holds for all measurements. This structure leads to two retrodictive entropic uncertainty relations, expressed directly in terms of the prior state and the POVMs, but valid independently of the retrodictive framework and fully compatible with the conventional operational interpretation of entropic uncertainty relations. Finally, we benchmark these relations numerically and find that they provide consistently tighter bounds than existing entropic uncertainty relations over broad classes of measurements and states.
If one has access to information about a quantum system both before and after a measurement, the usual remit of Heisenberg uncertainty relation (HUR) does not apply. Here, we theoretically and experimentally demonstrate that, in such a scenario, one can retrodict position and momentum measurements without being limited by HUR. The experiment uses a large ensemble of 10^11 atoms in a macroscopic vapor cell, and the results may be applicable for quantum state estimation and sensing, especially for sensitive magnetometers equally capable of measuring the amplitude and phase of an RF magnetic field both below the standard quantum limit.