Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2109.00513 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Counterexample to the conjectured Planckian bound on transport

Nicholas R. Poniatowski, Tarapada Sarkar, R. P. S. M. Lobo, S. Das Sarma, R. L. Greene

Published Dec 20, 2021• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It has recently been conjectured that the transport relaxation rate in metals is bounded above by the temperature of the system. In this paper, we discuss the transport phenomenology of overdoped electron-doped cuprates, which we show constitute an unambiguous counterexample to this putative ``Planckian'' bound, raising serious questions about the efficacy of the bound.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.104.235138

Related papers

Colloquium : Planckian dissipation in metals

Sean A. Hartnoll, Andrew Peter Mackenzie

Relaxational processes for conduction electrons in metals come with characteristic temperature dependences; classic examples at low temperatures are the $1/{T}^{2}$ law for the relaxation time in a Fermi liquid, and the Bloch $1/{T}^{5}$ law for electron-phonon scattering. The strange metal phase of cuprate superconductors is governed instead by the Planckian time, which is given in terms of fundamental constants only. This Colloquium discusses the concept of such a fundamental timescale and the degree to which it provides a lower bound for relaxation times, and illustrates these ideas with examples from conventional and unconventional metals.

arXiv:2107.07802•Reviews of Modern Physics•Nov 30, 2022•215 citations

A stability bound on the T-linear resistivity of conventional metals

Chaitanya Murthy, Akshat Pandey, Ilya Esterlis +1 more

Perturbative considerations account for the properties of conventional metals, including the range of temperatures where the transport scattering rate is 1/ τ tr = 2 π λ T , where λ is a dimensionless strength of the electron–phonon coupling. The fact that measured values satisfy λ ≲ 1 has been noted in the context of a possible “Planckian” bound on transport. However, since the electron–phonon scattering is quasielastic in this regime, no such Planckian considerations can be relevant. We present and analyze Monte Carlo results on the Holstein model which show that a different sort of bound is at play: a “stability” bound on λ consistent with metallic transport. We conjecture that a qualitatively similar bound on the strength of residual interactions, which is often stronger than Planckian, may apply to metals more generally.

arXiv:2112.06966•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Jan 12, 2023•22 citations

Non-Fermi liquid phase and linear-in-temperature scattering rate in overdoped two-dimensional Hubbard model

Wéi Wú, Xiang Wang, A.–M. S. Tremblay

Significance Most metals display an electron-scattering rate 1 / τ that follows 1 / τ ∼ T 2 at low temperatures, as prescribed by Fermi liquid theory. But there are important exceptions. One of the most prominent examples is the “strange” metal regime in overdoped cuprate supercondcutors, which exhibits a linear T dependence of the scattering rate 1 / τ ∼ T that reaches a putative Planckian limit. Here, using cutting-edge computational approaches, we show that T -linear scattering rate can emerge from the overdoped Hubbard model at low temperatures. Our results agree with cuprate experiments in various aspects but challenge the Planckian limit. Finally, by identifying antiferromagnetic fluctuations as the physical origin of the T -linear scattering rate, we discover the microscopic mechanism of strange metallicity in cuprates.

arXiv:2109.02635•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Mar 23, 2022•46 citations

Homes' Law and Universal Planckian Relaxation

Arkady Shekhter, McDonald, M. K. Chan R. D., N. M. Harrison

According to Zaanen's interpretation of Homes' empirical law~[Zaanen, {\it Nature} {\bf 430}, 512 (2004)], the superconducting transition temperatures in the cuprates are high because their metallic states are as viscous as quantum mechanics permits. Here, we show that Homes' law in fact implies three key points: (i) the resistivity is linear in temperature in the normal state near the transition temperature; (ii) the dimensionless coefficient of proportionality of the relaxation rate with temperature is of order unity -- the so-called universal Planckian relaxation rate; and (iii) the logarithmically broad applicability of this law arises from an unusually wide range of effective masses throughout the cuprate phase diagram. In fact, a universal Planckian relaxation rate implies Homes' law only if the mechanism of mass renormalization is independent of the Planckian relaxation.

arXiv:2504.02179•Apr 2, 2025•4 citations

Planckian Bounds via Spectral Moments of Optical Conductivity

Debanjan Chowdhury

The observation of Planckian scattering, often inferred from Drude fits in strongly correlated metals, raises the question of how to extract an intrinsic timescale from measurable quantities in a model-independent way. We address this by focusing on a ratio (${\cal{B}}$) of spectral moments of the dissipative part of the optical conductivity and prove a rigorous upper bound on ${\cal{B}}$ in terms of the Planckian rate. The bound emerges from the analytic structure of thermally weighted response functions of the current operator. Crucially, the bounded quantity is directly accessible via optical spectroscopy and computable from imaginary-time correlators in quantum Monte Carlo simulations, without any need for analytic continuation. We evaluate ${\cal{B}}$ for simplified examples of both Drude and non-Drude forms of the optical conductivity with a single scattering rate in various asymptotic regimes, and find that ${\cal{B}}$ lies far below the saturation value. These findings demonstrate that Planckian bounds can arise from fundamental constraints on equilibrium dynamics, pointing toward a possibly universal structure governing transport in correlated quantum matter.

arXiv:2512.09979•Dec 10, 2025•2 citations

Thermal diffusivity above the Mott-Ioffe-Regel limit

Jiecheng Zhang, Erik D. Kountz, Eli M. Levenson-Falk +3 more

Understanding transport of charge excitations in strongly correlated electron systems exhibiting the ``strange metal'' state without long-lived quasiparticle excitations has been a long-standing challenge in condensed matter physics. Here, the authors demonstrate that thermal diffusivity, which tracks energy-thermalization processes, exhibits a limiting Planckian relaxation time and a unique thermal diffusion velocity. These reflect both the contribution of phonons and electrons. This result is bound by the thermal diffusivity of the electrons at the Mott-Ioffe-Regel limit, where the mean-free-path reaches atomic distances.

arXiv:1808.07564•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 24, 2019•41 citations
It has recently been conjectured that the transport relaxation rate in metals is bounded above by the temperature of the system. In this paper, we discuss the transport phenomenology of overdoped electron-doped cuprates, which we show constitute an unambiguous counterexample to this putative ``Planckian'' bound, raising serious questions about the efficacy of the bound.
Relaxational processes for conduction electrons in metals come with characteristic temperature dependences; classic examples at low temperatures are the 1/T21/{T}^{2}1/T2 law for the relaxation time in a Fermi liquid, and the Bloch 1/T51/{T}^{5}1/T5 law for electron-phonon scattering. The strange metal phase of cuprate superconductors is governed instead by the Planckian time, which is given in terms of fundamental constants only. This Colloquium discusses the concept of such a fundamental timescale and the degree to which it provides a lower bound for relaxation times, and illustrates these ideas with examples from conventional and unconventional metals.
Perturbative considerations account for the properties of conventional metals, including the range of temperatures where the transport scattering rate is 1/ τ tr = 2 π λ T , where λ is a dimensionless strength of the electron–phonon coupling. The fact that measured values satisfy λ ≲ 1 has been noted in the context of a possible “Planckian” bound on transport. However, since the electron–phonon scattering is quasielastic in this regime, no such Planckian considerations can be relevant. We present and analyze Monte Carlo results on the Holstein model which show that a different sort of bound is at play: a “stability” bound on λ consistent with metallic transport. We conjecture that a qualitatively similar bound on the strength of residual interactions, which is often stronger than Planckian, may apply to metals more generally.
Significance Most metals display an electron-scattering rate 1 / τ that follows 1 / τ ∼ T 2 at low temperatures, as prescribed by Fermi liquid theory. But there are important exceptions. One of the most prominent examples is the “strange” metal regime in overdoped cuprate supercondcutors, which exhibits a linear T dependence of the scattering rate 1 / τ ∼ T that reaches a putative Planckian limit. Here, using cutting-edge computational approaches, we show that T -linear scattering rate can emerge from the overdoped Hubbard model at low temperatures. Our results agree with cuprate experiments in various aspects but challenge the Planckian limit. Finally, by identifying antiferromagnetic fluctuations as the physical origin of the T -linear scattering rate, we discover the microscopic mechanism of strange metallicity in cuprates.
According to Zaanen's interpretation of Homes' empirical law~[Zaanen, {\it Nature} {\bf 430}, 512 (2004)], the superconducting transition temperatures in the cuprates are high because their metallic states are as viscous as quantum mechanics permits. Here, we show that Homes' law in fact implies three key points: (i) the resistivity is linear in temperature in the normal state near the transition temperature; (ii) the dimensionless coefficient of proportionality of the relaxation rate with temperature is of order unity -- the so-called universal Planckian relaxation rate; and (iii) the logarithmically broad applicability of this law arises from an unusually wide range of effective masses throughout the cuprate phase diagram. In fact, a universal Planckian relaxation rate implies Homes' law only if the mechanism of mass renormalization is independent of the Planckian relaxation.
The observation of Planckian scattering, often inferred from Drude fits in strongly correlated metals, raises the question of how to extract an intrinsic timescale from measurable quantities in a model-independent way. We address this by focusing on a ratio (B{\cal{B}}B) of spectral moments of the dissipative part of the optical conductivity and prove a rigorous upper bound on B{\cal{B}}B in terms of the Planckian rate. The bound emerges from the analytic structure of thermally weighted response functions of the current operator. Crucially, the bounded quantity is directly accessible via optical spectroscopy and computable from imaginary-time correlators in quantum Monte Carlo simulations, without any need for analytic continuation. We evaluate B{\cal{B}}B for simplified examples of both Drude and non-Drude forms of the optical conductivity with a single scattering rate in various asymptotic regimes, and find that B{\cal{B}}B lies far below the saturation value. These findings demonstrate that Planckian bounds can arise from fundamental constraints on equilibrium dynamics, pointing toward a possibly universal structure governing transport in correlated quantum matter.
Understanding transport of charge excitations in strongly correlated electron systems exhibiting the ``strange metal'' state without long-lived quasiparticle excitations has been a long-standing challenge in condensed matter physics. Here, the authors demonstrate that thermal diffusivity, which tracks energy-thermalization processes, exhibits a limiting Planckian relaxation time and a unique thermal diffusion velocity. These reflect both the contribution of phonons and electrons. This result is bound by the thermal diffusivity of the electrons at the Mott-Ioffe-Regel limit, where the mean-free-path reaches atomic distances.