Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2107.07802 · Reviews of Modern Physics

Colloquium : Planckian dissipation in metals

Sean A. Hartnoll, Andrew Peter Mackenzie

Published Nov 30, 2022• 215 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Relaxational processes for conduction electrons in metals come with characteristic temperature dependences; classic examples at low temperatures are the $1/{T}^{2}$ law for the relaxation time in a Fermi liquid, and the Bloch $1/{T}^{5}$ law for electron-phonon scattering. The strange metal phase of cuprate superconductors is governed instead by the Planckian time, which is given in terms of fundamental constants only. This Colloquium discusses the concept of such a fundamental timescale and the degree to which it provides a lower bound for relaxation times, and illustrates these ideas with examples from conventional and unconventional metals.

DOI
10.1103/revmodphys.94.041002

Related papers

Phonon Induced Energy Relaxation in Quantum Critical Metals

Haoyu Guo, Debanjan Chowdhury

Metals at the brink of electronic quantum phase transitions display high-temperature superconductivity, competing orders, and unconventional charge transport, revealing strong departures from conventional Fermi liquid behavior. Investigation of these fascinating intertwined phenomena has been at the center of research across a variety of correlated materials over the past many decades. A ubiquitous experimental observation is the emergence of a universal timescale that governs electrical transport and momentum relaxation. In this Letter, we analyze an equally important theoretical question of how the energy contained in the electronic degrees of freedom near a quantum phase transition relaxes to the environment via their coupling to acoustic phonons. Assuming that the bottleneck for energy dissipation is controlled by the coupling between electronic degrees of freedom and acoustic phonons, we present a universal theory of the temperature dependence of the energy relaxation rate in a marginal Fermi liquid. We find that the energy relaxation rate exhibits a complex set of temperature-dependent crossovers controlled by emergent energy scales in the problem. We place these results in the context of recent measurements of the energy relaxation rate via nonlinear optical spectroscopy in the normal state of hole-doped cuprates.

arXiv:2505.00067•Physical Review Letters•Mar 10, 2026•2 citations

Linear resistivity and Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) spin liquid behavior in a quantum critical metal with spin-1/2 fermions

Peter Cha, Nils Wentzell, Olivier Parcollet +2 more

Significance In “Planckian metals,” electrons dissipate energy at the fastest possible rate allowed by the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics, resulting in a linear temperature dependence of their electrical resistivity. Although observed for a number of quantum materials, this phenomenon lacks a general theoretical understanding and is often considered as one of the prominent fundamental questions in condensed matter physics. Here, we show that Planckian dissipation and a behavior consistent with the “marginal Fermi liquid” phenomenology emerge in the quantum critical regime separating a Mott insulating spin glass and a Fermi liquid. By establishing this behavior in an explicit model solvable by state-of-the-art computational methods, our theory paves the way toward a deeper understanding of Planckian or “strange” metals.

arXiv:2002.07181•Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Jul 22, 2020•71 citations

Emergent mesoscopic quantum vortex and Planckian dissipation in the strange metal phase

Rong Li, Zhen-Su She

Abstract A major puzzle of condensed-matter physics is the physics behind the linear-in-temperature law of resistivity in many exotic metallic systems, including cuprates, pnictides, and heavy fermions. In this work, we propose, based on a symmetry-breaking analysis, that the strange metal phase is a novel emergent mesoscopic quantum state, beyond Landau’s quasiparticle excitation, which is composed of fluctuating vortices. The model predicts, in a straightforward way, the local magnetic field with a correlation time determined by the Coulomb potential, validated by observations of dynamic muon spin relaxation rates in both 3d cuprates and 5d iridate without fitting parameter. Furthermore, the model resolves the underlying quantum mechanism of the Planckian dissipation in terms of carrier scattering by fluctuating vortex, which predicts a scattering rate proportional to the vortex density, thus deriving both linear-in temperature and linear-in field laws, with a universal scattering coefficient validated by data of several dozens of samples for cuprates and iron pnictides. These findings offer a new phenomenology for non-Fermi liquid in strongly correlated materials.

New Journal of Physics•Mar 15, 2021•6 citations

Planckian dissipation, minimal viscosity and the transport in cuprate strange metals

Jan Zaanen

Could it be that the matter formed from the electrons in high Tc superconductors is of a radically new kind that may be called "many body entangled compressible quantum matter"? Much of this text is intended as an easy to read tutorial, explaining recent theoretical advances that have been unfolding at the cross roads of condensed matter- and string theory, black hole physics as well as quantum information theory. These developments suggest that the physics of such matter may be governed by surprisingly simple principles. My real objective is to present an experimental strategy to test critically whether these principles are actually at work, revolving around the famous linear resistivity characterizing the strange metal phase. The theory suggests a very simple explanation of this "unreasonably simple" behavior that is actually directly linked to remarkable results from the study of the quark gluon plasma formed at the heavy ion colliders: the "fast hydrodynamization" and the "minimal viscosity". This leads to high quality predictions for experiment: the momentum relaxation rate governing the resistivity relates directly to the electronic entropy, while at low temperatures the electron fluid should become unviscous to a degree that turbulent flows can develop even on the nanometre scale.

arXiv:1807.10951•SciPost Physics•May 20, 2019•203 citations

Quantum Acoustics Demystifies the Strange Metals

Eric J. Heller, Alhun Aydin, Anton M. Graf +11 more

Phonons have long been thought to be incapable of explaining key phenomena in strange metals, including linear-in-\textit{T} Planckian resistivity from high to very low temperatures. We argue that these conclusions were based on static, perturbative approaches that overlooked essential time-dependent and nonperturbative electron-lattice physics. In fact ``phonons'' are not the best target for discussion, just like ``photons'' are not the best way to think about Maxwell's equations. Quantum optics connects photons and electromagnetism, as developed 60 years ago by Glauber and others. We have been developing the parallel world of quantum acoustics. Far from being only of academic interest, the new tools are rapidly exposing the secrets of the strange metals, revealing strong vibronic (vibration-electronic) interactions playing a crucial role forming polarons and charge density waves, linear-in-$T$ resistivity at the Planckian rate over thousands of degrees, resolution of the Drude peak infrared anomaly, and the absence of a $T^4$ low-temperature resistivity rise in 2D systems, and of a Mott-Ioffe-Regel resistivity saturation. We derive Planckian transport, polarons, CDWs, and pseudogaps from the Fröhlich model. The ``new physics'' has been hiding in this model all along, in the right parameter regime, if it is treated nonperturbatively. In the course of this work we have uncovered the generalization of Anderson localization to dynamic media: a universal Planckian diffusion emerges, a ``ghost'' of Anderson localization. Planckian diffusion is clearly defined and is more fundamental than the popular but elusive, model dependent concept of ``Planckian speed limit''.

arXiv:2511.01853•Nov 3, 2025•4 citations

Counterexample to the conjectured Planckian bound on transport

Nicholas R. Poniatowski, Tarapada Sarkar, R. P. S. M. Lobo +2 more

It has recently been conjectured that the transport relaxation rate in metals is bounded above by the temperature of the system. In this paper, we discuss the transport phenomenology of overdoped electron-doped cuprates, which we show constitute an unambiguous counterexample to this putative ``Planckian'' bound, raising serious questions about the efficacy of the bound.

arXiv:2109.00513•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 20, 2021•20 citations
Relaxational processes for conduction electrons in metals come with characteristic temperature dependences; classic examples at low temperatures are the 1/T21/{T}^{2}1/T2 law for the relaxation time in a Fermi liquid, and the Bloch 1/T51/{T}^{5}1/T5 law for electron-phonon scattering. The strange metal phase of cuprate superconductors is governed instead by the Planckian time, which is given in terms of fundamental constants only. This Colloquium discusses the concept of such a fundamental timescale and the degree to which it provides a lower bound for relaxation times, and illustrates these ideas with examples from conventional and unconventional metals.
Metals at the brink of electronic quantum phase transitions display high-temperature superconductivity, competing orders, and unconventional charge transport, revealing strong departures from conventional Fermi liquid behavior. Investigation of these fascinating intertwined phenomena has been at the center of research across a variety of correlated materials over the past many decades. A ubiquitous experimental observation is the emergence of a universal timescale that governs electrical transport and momentum relaxation. In this Letter, we analyze an equally important theoretical question of how the energy contained in the electronic degrees of freedom near a quantum phase transition relaxes to the environment via their coupling to acoustic phonons. Assuming that the bottleneck for energy dissipation is controlled by the coupling between electronic degrees of freedom and acoustic phonons, we present a universal theory of the temperature dependence of the energy relaxation rate in a marginal Fermi liquid. We find that the energy relaxation rate exhibits a complex set of temperature-dependent crossovers controlled by emergent energy scales in the problem. We place these results in the context of recent measurements of the energy relaxation rate via nonlinear optical spectroscopy in the normal state of hole-doped cuprates.
Significance In “Planckian metals,” electrons dissipate energy at the fastest possible rate allowed by the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics, resulting in a linear temperature dependence of their electrical resistivity. Although observed for a number of quantum materials, this phenomenon lacks a general theoretical understanding and is often considered as one of the prominent fundamental questions in condensed matter physics. Here, we show that Planckian dissipation and a behavior consistent with the “marginal Fermi liquid” phenomenology emerge in the quantum critical regime separating a Mott insulating spin glass and a Fermi liquid. By establishing this behavior in an explicit model solvable by state-of-the-art computational methods, our theory paves the way toward a deeper understanding of Planckian or “strange” metals.
Abstract A major puzzle of condensed-matter physics is the physics behind the linear-in-temperature law of resistivity in many exotic metallic systems, including cuprates, pnictides, and heavy fermions. In this work, we propose, based on a symmetry-breaking analysis, that the strange metal phase is a novel emergent mesoscopic quantum state, beyond Landau’s quasiparticle excitation, which is composed of fluctuating vortices. The model predicts, in a straightforward way, the local magnetic field with a correlation time determined by the Coulomb potential, validated by observations of dynamic muon spin relaxation rates in both 3d cuprates and 5d iridate without fitting parameter. Furthermore, the model resolves the underlying quantum mechanism of the Planckian dissipation in terms of carrier scattering by fluctuating vortex, which predicts a scattering rate proportional to the vortex density, thus deriving both linear-in temperature and linear-in field laws, with a universal scattering coefficient validated by data of several dozens of samples for cuprates and iron pnictides. These findings offer a new phenomenology for non-Fermi liquid in strongly correlated materials.
Could it be that the matter formed from the electrons in high Tc superconductors is of a radically new kind that may be called "many body entangled compressible quantum matter"? Much of this text is intended as an easy to read tutorial, explaining recent theoretical advances that have been unfolding at the cross roads of condensed matter- and string theory, black hole physics as well as quantum information theory. These developments suggest that the physics of such matter may be governed by surprisingly simple principles. My real objective is to present an experimental strategy to test critically whether these principles are actually at work, revolving around the famous linear resistivity characterizing the strange metal phase. The theory suggests a very simple explanation of this "unreasonably simple" behavior that is actually directly linked to remarkable results from the study of the quark gluon plasma formed at the heavy ion colliders: the "fast hydrodynamization" and the "minimal viscosity". This leads to high quality predictions for experiment: the momentum relaxation rate governing the resistivity relates directly to the electronic entropy, while at low temperatures the electron fluid should become unviscous to a degree that turbulent flows can develop even on the nanometre scale.
Phonons have long been thought to be incapable of explaining key phenomena in strange metals, including linear-in-\textit{T} Planckian resistivity from high to very low temperatures. We argue that these conclusions were based on static, perturbative approaches that overlooked essential time-dependent and nonperturbative electron-lattice physics. In fact ``phonons'' are not the best target for discussion, just like ``photons'' are not the best way to think about Maxwell's equations. Quantum optics connects photons and electromagnetism, as developed 60 years ago by Glauber and others. We have been developing the parallel world of quantum acoustics. Far from being only of academic interest, the new tools are rapidly exposing the secrets of the strange metals, revealing strong vibronic (vibration-electronic) interactions playing a crucial role forming polarons and charge density waves, linear-in-TTT resistivity at the Planckian rate over thousands of degrees, resolution of the Drude peak infrared anomaly, and the absence of a T4T^4T4 low-temperature resistivity rise in 2D systems, and of a Mott-Ioffe-Regel resistivity saturation. We derive Planckian transport, polarons, CDWs, and pseudogaps from the Fröhlich model. The ``new physics'' has been hiding in this model all along, in the right parameter regime, if it is treated nonperturbatively. In the course of this work we have uncovered the generalization of Anderson localization to dynamic media: a universal Planckian diffusion emerges, a ``ghost'' of Anderson localization. Planckian diffusion is clearly defined and is more fundamental than the popular but elusive, model dependent concept of ``Planckian speed limit''.