Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2103.17233 · Machine Learning Science and Technology

Symmetric and antisymmetric kernels for machine learning problems in quantum physics and chemistry

Stefan Klus, Patrick Gelß, Feliks Nüske, Frank Noé

Published Jul 14, 2021• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract We derive symmetric and antisymmetric kernels by symmetrizing and antisymmetrizing conventional kernels and analyze their properties. In particular, we compute the feature space dimensions of the resulting polynomial kernels, prove that the reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces induced by symmetric and antisymmetric Gaussian kernels are dense in the space of symmetric and antisymmetric functions, and propose a Slater determinant representation of the antisymmetric Gaussian kernel, which allows for an efficient evaluation even if the state space is high-dimensional. Furthermore, we show that by exploiting symmetries or antisymmetries the size of the training data set can be significantly reduced. The results are illustrated with guiding examples and simple quantum physics and chemistry applications.

DOI
10.1088/2632-2153/ac14ad

Related papers

The Inductive Bias of Quantum Kernels

Jonas M. Kübler, Simon Buchholz, Bernhard Schölkopf

It has been hypothesized that quantum computers may lend themselves well to applications in machine learning. In the present work, we analyze function classes defined via quantum kernels. Quantum computers offer the possibility to efficiently compute inner products of exponentially large density operators that are classically hard to compute. However, having an exponentially large feature space renders the problem of generalization hard. Furthermore, being able to evaluate inner products in high dimensional spaces efficiently by itself does not guarantee a quantum advantage, as already classically tractable kernels can correspond to high- or infinite-dimensional reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces (RKHS). We analyze the spectral properties of quantum kernels and find that we can expect an advantage if their RKHS is low dimensional and contains functions that are hard to compute classically. If the target function is known to lie in this class, this implies a quantum advantage, as the quantum computer can encode this inductive bias, whereas there is no classically efficient way to constrain the function class in the same way. However, we show that finding suitable quantum kernels is not easy because the kernel evaluation might require exponentially many measurements. In conclusion, our message is a somewhat sobering one: we conjecture that quantum machine learning models can offer speed-ups only if we manage to encode knowledge about the problem at hand into quantum circuits, while encoding the same bias into a classical model would be hard. These situations may plausibly occur when learning on data generated by a quantum process, however, they appear to be harder to come by for classical datasets.

arXiv:2106.03747•Jun 7, 2021•100 citations

Quantum Machine Learning in Feature Hilbert Spaces

Maria Schuld, Nathan Killoran

A basic idea of quantum computing is surprisingly similar to that of kernel methods in machine learning, namely, to efficiently perform computations in an intractably large Hilbert space. In this Letter we explore some theoretical foundations of this link and show how it opens up a new avenue for the design of quantum machine learning algorithms. We interpret the process of encoding inputs in a quantum state as a nonlinear feature map that maps data to quantum Hilbert space. A quantum computer can now analyze the input data in this feature space. Based on this link, we discuss two approaches for building a quantum model for classification. In the first approach, the quantum device estimates inner products of quantum states to compute a classically intractable kernel. The kernel can be fed into any classical kernel method such as a support vector machine. In the second approach, we use a variational quantum circuit as a linear model that classifies data explicitly in Hilbert space. We illustrate these ideas with a feature map based on squeezing in a continuous-variable system, and visualize the working principle with two-dimensional minibenchmark datasets.

arXiv:1803.07128•Physical Review Letters•Feb 1, 2019•2,212 citations

Antisymmetric Functions and Slater Determinants

Leslie L. Foldy

Given a function w completely antisymmetric in n variables, there may exist a set of n functions of one variable such that the given function is a Slater determinant in the latter. The first problem considered is that of obtaining a criterion for this to be the case for a given function. This problem is solved by considering the function w as a mapping of the space of functions in n − 1 variables onto the space of functions of one variable. A necessary and sufficient condition for the initial function to be a Slater determinant is then shown to be that the image space be n dimensional. This criterion is converted into practical algorithms which can be employed for the determination. The application of one of these yields the theorem that an arbitrary linear combination of the n + 1 Slater determinants in n variables formed from n + 1 one-variable functions can always be written as a single Slater determinant. It is further proved that if the image space of the mapping is m(>n) dimensional, the original function can be expressed as a linear combination of m!/(m − n)!n! Slater determinants in n variables formed from m one-variable functions. Playing an important role in the analysis is the product of the mapping described above by its adjoint (the product is simply related to Dirac's density matrix for a quantum mechanical system of identical particles) as well as the eigenvectors and eigenvalues of this Hermitian positive semidefinite mapping. The latter form a basis for a systematic approximation procedure for representing a given function by a single Slater determinant or by sums of Slater determinants formed from a particular number of one-variable functions, which yields results obtained previously by Löwdin. Problems of simultaneous approximation of sets of antisymmetric functions and possible physical applications to many-fermion systems are briefly discussed.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1962•15 citations

Stochastic representation of many-body quantum states

Hristiana Atanasova, Liam Bernheimer, Guy Cohen

The quantum many-body problem is ultimately a curse of dimensionality: the state of a system with many particles is determined by a function with many dimensions, which rapidly becomes difficult to efficiently store, evaluate and manipulate numerically. On the other hand, modern machine learning models like deep neural networks can express highly correlated functions in extremely large-dimensional spaces, including those describing quantum mechanical problems. We show that if one represents wavefunctions as a stochastically generated set of sample points, the problem of finding ground states can be reduced to one where the most technically challenging step is that of performing regression-a standard supervised learning task. In the stochastic representation the (anti)symmetric property of fermionic/bosonic wavefunction can be used for data augmentation and learned rather than explicitly enforced. We further demonstrate that propagation of an ansatz towards the ground state can then be performed in a more robust and computationally scalable fashion than traditional variational approaches allow.

Nature Communications•Jun 16, 2023•13 citations

Predicting Molecular Properties With Quantum Kernels: a Study on the Qm9 Dataset

Sonam Khattar, Harshit Kumawat, Aryan

Predicting molecular properties is a cornerstone of drug discovery, materials science, and quantum chemistry, where accuracy and speed are critical. Classical machine learning mod- els offer rapid predictions but often fail to capture the intricate quantum interactions governing molecular behavior. Our team investigated quantum kernel methods to predict properties of the QM9 dataset, a widely recognized benchmark containing$\mathbf{1 3 4, 0 0 0}$organic molecules with diverse chemical structures. By encoding molecular features into quantum circuits, we mapped classical data into highdimensional Hilbert spaces to enhance prediction accuracy. Our pipeline encompasses data preprocessing, quantum circuit design, model training with support vector regression, and evaluation of ten key molecular properties. The quantum kernel approach delivered promising results, achieving mean absolute errors of 0.13 Debye for dipole moment and 0.08 eV for HOMOLUMO gap, even when executed on noisy quantum devices. This work provides a comprehensive, reproducible pipeline, benchmarks quantum and classical models, and discusses practical challenges, contributing significantly to the field of quantumenhanced computational chemistry.

IEEE International Conference for Women in Innovation, Technology & Entrepreneurship (ICWITE)•Sep 26, 2025•0 citations

Entangling Solid Solutions: Machine Learning of Tensor Networks for Materials Property Prediction

David E. Sommer, Scott T. Dunham

Progress in the application of machine learning techniques to the prediction of solid-state and molecular materials properties has been greatly facilitated by the development state-of-the-art feature representations and novel deep learning architectures. A large class of atomic structure representations based on expansions of smoothed atomic densities have been shown to correspond to specific choices of basis sets in an abstract many-body Hilbert space. Concurrently, tensor network structures, conventionally the purview of quantum many-body physics and quantum information, have been successfully applied in supervised and unsupervised learning tasks in computer vision and natural language processing. In this work, we argue that architectures based on tensor networks are well-suited to machine learning on Hilbert-space representations of atomic structures. This is demonstrated on supervised learning tasks involving widely available datasets of density functional theory calculations of metal and semiconductor alloys. In particular, we show that certain standard tensor network topologies exhibit strong generalizability even on small training datasets while being parametrically efficient. We further relate this generalizability to the presence of complex entanglement in the trained tensor networks. We also discuss connections to learning with generalized structural kernels and related strategies for compressing large input feature spaces.

arXiv:2203.09613•Mar 17, 2022•4 citations
Abstract We derive symmetric and antisymmetric kernels by symmetrizing and antisymmetrizing conventional kernels and analyze their properties. In particular, we compute the feature space dimensions of the resulting polynomial kernels, prove that the reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces induced by symmetric and antisymmetric Gaussian kernels are dense in the space of symmetric and antisymmetric functions, and propose a Slater determinant representation of the antisymmetric Gaussian kernel, which allows for an efficient evaluation even if the state space is high-dimensional. Furthermore, we show that by exploiting symmetries or antisymmetries the size of the training data set can be significantly reduced. The results are illustrated with guiding examples and simple quantum physics and chemistry applications.
It has been hypothesized that quantum computers may lend themselves well to applications in machine learning. In the present work, we analyze function classes defined via quantum kernels. Quantum computers offer the possibility to efficiently compute inner products of exponentially large density operators that are classically hard to compute. However, having an exponentially large feature space renders the problem of generalization hard. Furthermore, being able to evaluate inner products in high dimensional spaces efficiently by itself does not guarantee a quantum advantage, as already classically tractable kernels can correspond to high- or infinite-dimensional reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces (RKHS). We analyze the spectral properties of quantum kernels and find that we can expect an advantage if their RKHS is low dimensional and contains functions that are hard to compute classically. If the target function is known to lie in this class, this implies a quantum advantage, as the quantum computer can encode this inductive bias, whereas there is no classically efficient way to constrain the function class in the same way. However, we show that finding suitable quantum kernels is not easy because the kernel evaluation might require exponentially many measurements. In conclusion, our message is a somewhat sobering one: we conjecture that quantum machine learning models can offer speed-ups only if we manage to encode knowledge about the problem at hand into quantum circuits, while encoding the same bias into a classical model would be hard. These situations may plausibly occur when learning on data generated by a quantum process, however, they appear to be harder to come by for classical datasets.
A basic idea of quantum computing is surprisingly similar to that of kernel methods in machine learning, namely, to efficiently perform computations in an intractably large Hilbert space. In this Letter we explore some theoretical foundations of this link and show how it opens up a new avenue for the design of quantum machine learning algorithms. We interpret the process of encoding inputs in a quantum state as a nonlinear feature map that maps data to quantum Hilbert space. A quantum computer can now analyze the input data in this feature space. Based on this link, we discuss two approaches for building a quantum model for classification. In the first approach, the quantum device estimates inner products of quantum states to compute a classically intractable kernel. The kernel can be fed into any classical kernel method such as a support vector machine. In the second approach, we use a variational quantum circuit as a linear model that classifies data explicitly in Hilbert space. We illustrate these ideas with a feature map based on squeezing in a continuous-variable system, and visualize the working principle with two-dimensional minibenchmark datasets.
Given a function w completely antisymmetric in n variables, there may exist a set of n functions of one variable such that the given function is a Slater determinant in the latter. The first problem considered is that of obtaining a criterion for this to be the case for a given function. This problem is solved by considering the function w as a mapping of the space of functions in n − 1 variables onto the space of functions of one variable. A necessary and sufficient condition for the initial function to be a Slater determinant is then shown to be that the image space be n dimensional. This criterion is converted into practical algorithms which can be employed for the determination. The application of one of these yields the theorem that an arbitrary linear combination of the n + 1 Slater determinants in n variables formed from n + 1 one-variable functions can always be written as a single Slater determinant. It is further proved that if the image space of the mapping is m(>n) dimensional, the original function can be expressed as a linear combination of m!/(m − n)!n! Slater determinants in n variables formed from m one-variable functions. Playing an important role in the analysis is the product of the mapping described above by its adjoint (the product is simply related to Dirac's density matrix for a quantum mechanical system of identical particles) as well as the eigenvectors and eigenvalues of this Hermitian positive semidefinite mapping. The latter form a basis for a systematic approximation procedure for representing a given function by a single Slater determinant or by sums of Slater determinants formed from a particular number of one-variable functions, which yields results obtained previously by Löwdin. Problems of simultaneous approximation of sets of antisymmetric functions and possible physical applications to many-fermion systems are briefly discussed.
The quantum many-body problem is ultimately a curse of dimensionality: the state of a system with many particles is determined by a function with many dimensions, which rapidly becomes difficult to efficiently store, evaluate and manipulate numerically. On the other hand, modern machine learning models like deep neural networks can express highly correlated functions in extremely large-dimensional spaces, including those describing quantum mechanical problems. We show that if one represents wavefunctions as a stochastically generated set of sample points, the problem of finding ground states can be reduced to one where the most technically challenging step is that of performing regression-a standard supervised learning task. In the stochastic representation the (anti)symmetric property of fermionic/bosonic wavefunction can be used for data augmentation and learned rather than explicitly enforced. We further demonstrate that propagation of an ansatz towards the ground state can then be performed in a more robust and computationally scalable fashion than traditional variational approaches allow.
Predicting molecular properties is a cornerstone of drug discovery, materials science, and quantum chemistry, where accuracy and speed are critical. Classical machine learning mod- els offer rapid predictions but often fail to capture the intricate quantum interactions governing molecular behavior. Our team investigated quantum kernel methods to predict properties of the QM9 dataset, a widely recognized benchmark containing134,000\mathbf{1 3 4, 0 0 0}134,000organic molecules with diverse chemical structures. By encoding molecular features into quantum circuits, we mapped classical data into highdimensional Hilbert spaces to enhance prediction accuracy. Our pipeline encompasses data preprocessing, quantum circuit design, model training with support vector regression, and evaluation of ten key molecular properties. The quantum kernel approach delivered promising results, achieving mean absolute errors of 0.13 Debye for dipole moment and 0.08 eV for HOMOLUMO gap, even when executed on noisy quantum devices. This work provides a comprehensive, reproducible pipeline, benchmarks quantum and classical models, and discusses practical challenges, contributing significantly to the field of quantumenhanced computational chemistry.
Progress in the application of machine learning techniques to the prediction of solid-state and molecular materials properties has been greatly facilitated by the development state-of-the-art feature representations and novel deep learning architectures. A large class of atomic structure representations based on expansions of smoothed atomic densities have been shown to correspond to specific choices of basis sets in an abstract many-body Hilbert space. Concurrently, tensor network structures, conventionally the purview of quantum many-body physics and quantum information, have been successfully applied in supervised and unsupervised learning tasks in computer vision and natural language processing. In this work, we argue that architectures based on tensor networks are well-suited to machine learning on Hilbert-space representations of atomic structures. This is demonstrated on supervised learning tasks involving widely available datasets of density functional theory calculations of metal and semiconductor alloys. In particular, we show that certain standard tensor network topologies exhibit strong generalizability even on small training datasets while being parametrically efficient. We further relate this generalizability to the presence of complex entanglement in the trained tensor networks. We also discuss connections to learning with generalized structural kernels and related strategies for compressing large input feature spaces.