Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2106.03747

The Inductive Bias of Quantum Kernels

Jonas M. Kübler, Simon Buchholz, Bernhard Schölkopf

Published Jun 7, 2021• 100 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It has been hypothesized that quantum computers may lend themselves well to applications in machine learning. In the present work, we analyze function classes defined via quantum kernels. Quantum computers offer the possibility to efficiently compute inner products of exponentially large density operators that are classically hard to compute. However, having an exponentially large feature space renders the problem of generalization hard. Furthermore, being able to evaluate inner products in high dimensional spaces efficiently by itself does not guarantee a quantum advantage, as already classically tractable kernels can correspond to high- or infinite-dimensional reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces (RKHS). We analyze the spectral properties of quantum kernels and find that we can expect an advantage if their RKHS is low dimensional and contains functions that are hard to compute classically. If the target function is known to lie in this class, this implies a quantum advantage, as the quantum computer can encode this inductive bias, whereas there is no classically efficient way to constrain the function class in the same way. However, we show that finding suitable quantum kernels is not easy because the kernel evaluation might require exponentially many measurements. In conclusion, our message is a somewhat sobering one: we conjecture that quantum machine learning models can offer speed-ups only if we manage to encode knowledge about the problem at hand into quantum circuits, while encoding the same bias into a classical model would be hard. These situations may plausibly occur when learning on data generated by a quantum process, however, they appear to be harder to come by for classical datasets.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2106.03747

Related papers

Bandwidth Enables Generalization in Quantum Kernel Models

Abdülkadir Canatar, Evan Peters, Cengiz Pehlevan +2 more

Quantum computers are known to provide speedups over classical state-of-the-art machine learning methods in some specialized settings. For example, quantum kernel methods have been shown to provide an exponential speedup on a learning version of the discrete logarithm problem. Understanding the generalization of quantum models is essential to realizing similar speedups on problems of practical interest. Recent results demonstrate that generalization is hindered by the exponential size of the quantum feature space. Although these results suggest that quantum models cannot generalize when the number of qubits is large, in this paper we show that these results rely on overly restrictive assumptions. We consider a wider class of models by varying a hyperparameter that we call quantum kernel bandwidth. We analyze the large-qubit limit and provide explicit formulas for the generalization of a quantum model that can be solved in closed form. Specifically, we show that changing the value of the bandwidth can take a model from provably not being able to generalize to any target function to good generalization for well-aligned targets. Our analysis shows how the bandwidth controls the spectrum of the kernel integral operator and thereby the inductive bias of the model. We demonstrate empirically that our theory correctly predicts how varying the bandwidth affects generalization of quantum models on challenging datasets, including those far outside our theoretical assumptions. We discuss the implications of our results for quantum advantage in machine learning.

arXiv:2206.06686•Jun 14, 2022•61 citations

Numerical evidence against advantage with quantum fidelity kernels on classical data

Lucas Slattery, Ruslan Shaydulin, Shouvanik Chakrabarti +3 more

Quantum machine learning techniques are commonly considered one of the most promising candidates for demonstrating practical quantum advantage. In particular, quantum kernel methods have been demonstrated to be able to learn certain classically intractable functions efficiently if the kernel is well aligned with the target function. In the more general case, quantum kernels are known to suffer from exponential ``flattening'' of the spectrum as the number of qubits grows, preventing generalization and necessitating the control of the inductive bias by hyperparameters. We show that the general-purpose hyperparameter-tuning techniques proposed to improve the generalization of quantum kernels lead to the kernel becoming well approximated by a classical kernel, removing the possibility of quantum advantage. We provide extensive numerical evidence for this phenomenon utilizing multiple previously studied quantum feature maps and both synthetic and real data. Our results show that unless novel techniques are developed to control the inductive bias of quantum kernels, they are unlikely to provide a quantum advantage on classical data that lacks special structure.

arXiv:2211.16551•Physical Review A•Jun 20, 2023•29 citations

Quantum Machine Learning in Feature Hilbert Spaces

Maria Schuld, Nathan Killoran

A basic idea of quantum computing is surprisingly similar to that of kernel methods in machine learning, namely, to efficiently perform computations in an intractably large Hilbert space. In this Letter we explore some theoretical foundations of this link and show how it opens up a new avenue for the design of quantum machine learning algorithms. We interpret the process of encoding inputs in a quantum state as a nonlinear feature map that maps data to quantum Hilbert space. A quantum computer can now analyze the input data in this feature space. Based on this link, we discuss two approaches for building a quantum model for classification. In the first approach, the quantum device estimates inner products of quantum states to compute a classically intractable kernel. The kernel can be fed into any classical kernel method such as a support vector machine. In the second approach, we use a variational quantum circuit as a linear model that classifies data explicitly in Hilbert space. We illustrate these ideas with a feature map based on squeezing in a continuous-variable system, and visualize the working principle with two-dimensional minibenchmark datasets.

arXiv:1803.07128•Physical Review Letters•Feb 1, 2019•2,212 citations

Benign Overfitting with Quantum Kernels

Joachim Tomasi, Sandrine Anthoine, Hachem Kadri

Kernel methods compare inputs through feature maps. Quantum kernels follow the same principle: input data are encoded into quantum states, which define quantum feature representations in Hilbert spaces. Kernel values are then obtained by estimating inner products between these states using suitable quantum circuit measurements. As a result, quantum kernels may be intractable to compute classically while remaining efficiently computable on quantum hardware, potentially leading to a quantum advantage. However, designing effective quantum kernels remains a major challenge. Many quantum kernels, such as the fidelity kernel, suffer from exponential concentration. This results in near-identity kernel matrices that fail to capture meaningful data correlations and lead to overfitting and poor generalization. In this paper, we propose a novel strategy for constructing quantum kernels that achieve good generalization performance, drawing inspiration from benign overfitting in classical machine learning. We introduce the concept of Local-Global quantum kernels, which combine two components: a local quantum kernel based on measurements of small subsystems, and a global quantum kernel derived from full-system measurements. To support the effectiveness of the proposed construction, we show theoretically and empirically that Local-Global quantum kernels exhibit benign overfitting.

arXiv:2503.17020•Mar 21, 2025•6 citations

On the expressivity of embedding quantum kernels

Elies Gil-Fuster, Jens Eisert, Vedran Dunjko

Abstract One of the most natural connections between quantum and classical machine learning has been established in the context of kernel methods. Kernel methods rely on kernels, which are inner products of feature vectors living in large feature spaces. Quantum kernels are typically evaluated by explicitly constructing quantum feature states and then taking their inner product, here called embedding quantum kernels. Since classical kernels are usually evaluated without using the feature vectors explicitly, we wonder how expressive embedding quantum kernels are. In this work, we raise the fundamental question: can all quantum kernels be expressed as the inner product of quantum feature states? Our first result is positive: Invoking computational universality, we find that for any kernel function there always exists a corresponding quantum feature map and an embedding quantum kernel. The more operational reading of the question is concerned with efficient constructions, however. In a second part, we formalize the question of universality of efficient embedding quantum kernels. For shift-invariant kernels, we use the technique of random Fourier features to show that they are universal within the broad class of all kernels which allow a variant of efficient Fourier sampling. We then extend this result to a new class of so-called composition kernels, which we show also contains projected quantum kernels introduced in recent works. After proving the universality of embedding quantum kernels for both shift-invariant and composition kernels, we identify the directions towards new, more exotic, and unexplored quantum kernel families, for which it still remains open whether they correspond to efficient embedding quantum kernels.

arXiv:2309.14419•Machine Learning Science and Technology•Mar 2, 2024•31 citations

양자 기계 학습 모델에 의해 생성되는 함수 집합

신성욱

The advent of quantum computing has dramatically changed the field of human information processing technology. Simultaneously, machine learning algorithms have achieved remarkable success in various applications. In this context, integrating quantum computing with machine learning has gained attention, spurring investigations into its potential advantages over classical methods. To deepen our understanding of quantum machine learning, we analyze function classes generated by quantum machine learning models that utilize classical data. These include variational quantum circuits and quantum kernel models that can be efficiently implemented using quantum devices. We initially examine the dimensionality of the function classes of these quantum models, noting that their dimensions can be exponentially large while requiring only polynomial scaling of quantum resources. Using a tensor network framework, we identify that all variational quantum machine learning models are essentially linear models within a potentially exponentially large-dimensional feature space, where the feature map is derived from a tensor product. The coefficients of quantum models, determined by the data-independent part of the circuits, exhibit high entanglement with a small number of parameters. We apply a similar approach to reveal the function space of quantum kernel models, offering a novel perspective for their analysis. On the other hand, we introduce and explore the dequantizability of quantum machine learning models, which serves as a necessary condition for their replacement with efficient classical models. We determine the conditions for (non)dequantizable models and highlight the importance of analyzing the coefficient part of these models. This approach provides us insight into the potential limitations and strengths of quantum computing in the realm of machine learning.

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations
It has been hypothesized that quantum computers may lend themselves well to applications in machine learning. In the present work, we analyze function classes defined via quantum kernels. Quantum computers offer the possibility to efficiently compute inner products of exponentially large density operators that are classically hard to compute. However, having an exponentially large feature space renders the problem of generalization hard. Furthermore, being able to evaluate inner products in high dimensional spaces efficiently by itself does not guarantee a quantum advantage, as already classically tractable kernels can correspond to high- or infinite-dimensional reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces (RKHS). We analyze the spectral properties of quantum kernels and find that we can expect an advantage if their RKHS is low dimensional and contains functions that are hard to compute classically. If the target function is known to lie in this class, this implies a quantum advantage, as the quantum computer can encode this inductive bias, whereas there is no classically efficient way to constrain the function class in the same way. However, we show that finding suitable quantum kernels is not easy because the kernel evaluation might require exponentially many measurements. In conclusion, our message is a somewhat sobering one: we conjecture that quantum machine learning models can offer speed-ups only if we manage to encode knowledge about the problem at hand into quantum circuits, while encoding the same bias into a classical model would be hard. These situations may plausibly occur when learning on data generated by a quantum process, however, they appear to be harder to come by for classical datasets.
Quantum computers are known to provide speedups over classical state-of-the-art machine learning methods in some specialized settings. For example, quantum kernel methods have been shown to provide an exponential speedup on a learning version of the discrete logarithm problem. Understanding the generalization of quantum models is essential to realizing similar speedups on problems of practical interest. Recent results demonstrate that generalization is hindered by the exponential size of the quantum feature space. Although these results suggest that quantum models cannot generalize when the number of qubits is large, in this paper we show that these results rely on overly restrictive assumptions. We consider a wider class of models by varying a hyperparameter that we call quantum kernel bandwidth. We analyze the large-qubit limit and provide explicit formulas for the generalization of a quantum model that can be solved in closed form. Specifically, we show that changing the value of the bandwidth can take a model from provably not being able to generalize to any target function to good generalization for well-aligned targets. Our analysis shows how the bandwidth controls the spectrum of the kernel integral operator and thereby the inductive bias of the model. We demonstrate empirically that our theory correctly predicts how varying the bandwidth affects generalization of quantum models on challenging datasets, including those far outside our theoretical assumptions. We discuss the implications of our results for quantum advantage in machine learning.
Quantum machine learning techniques are commonly considered one of the most promising candidates for demonstrating practical quantum advantage. In particular, quantum kernel methods have been demonstrated to be able to learn certain classically intractable functions efficiently if the kernel is well aligned with the target function. In the more general case, quantum kernels are known to suffer from exponential ``flattening'' of the spectrum as the number of qubits grows, preventing generalization and necessitating the control of the inductive bias by hyperparameters. We show that the general-purpose hyperparameter-tuning techniques proposed to improve the generalization of quantum kernels lead to the kernel becoming well approximated by a classical kernel, removing the possibility of quantum advantage. We provide extensive numerical evidence for this phenomenon utilizing multiple previously studied quantum feature maps and both synthetic and real data. Our results show that unless novel techniques are developed to control the inductive bias of quantum kernels, they are unlikely to provide a quantum advantage on classical data that lacks special structure.
A basic idea of quantum computing is surprisingly similar to that of kernel methods in machine learning, namely, to efficiently perform computations in an intractably large Hilbert space. In this Letter we explore some theoretical foundations of this link and show how it opens up a new avenue for the design of quantum machine learning algorithms. We interpret the process of encoding inputs in a quantum state as a nonlinear feature map that maps data to quantum Hilbert space. A quantum computer can now analyze the input data in this feature space. Based on this link, we discuss two approaches for building a quantum model for classification. In the first approach, the quantum device estimates inner products of quantum states to compute a classically intractable kernel. The kernel can be fed into any classical kernel method such as a support vector machine. In the second approach, we use a variational quantum circuit as a linear model that classifies data explicitly in Hilbert space. We illustrate these ideas with a feature map based on squeezing in a continuous-variable system, and visualize the working principle with two-dimensional minibenchmark datasets.
Kernel methods compare inputs through feature maps. Quantum kernels follow the same principle: input data are encoded into quantum states, which define quantum feature representations in Hilbert spaces. Kernel values are then obtained by estimating inner products between these states using suitable quantum circuit measurements. As a result, quantum kernels may be intractable to compute classically while remaining efficiently computable on quantum hardware, potentially leading to a quantum advantage. However, designing effective quantum kernels remains a major challenge. Many quantum kernels, such as the fidelity kernel, suffer from exponential concentration. This results in near-identity kernel matrices that fail to capture meaningful data correlations and lead to overfitting and poor generalization. In this paper, we propose a novel strategy for constructing quantum kernels that achieve good generalization performance, drawing inspiration from benign overfitting in classical machine learning. We introduce the concept of Local-Global quantum kernels, which combine two components: a local quantum kernel based on measurements of small subsystems, and a global quantum kernel derived from full-system measurements. To support the effectiveness of the proposed construction, we show theoretically and empirically that Local-Global quantum kernels exhibit benign overfitting.
Abstract One of the most natural connections between quantum and classical machine learning has been established in the context of kernel methods. Kernel methods rely on kernels, which are inner products of feature vectors living in large feature spaces. Quantum kernels are typically evaluated by explicitly constructing quantum feature states and then taking their inner product, here called embedding quantum kernels. Since classical kernels are usually evaluated without using the feature vectors explicitly, we wonder how expressive embedding quantum kernels are. In this work, we raise the fundamental question: can all quantum kernels be expressed as the inner product of quantum feature states? Our first result is positive: Invoking computational universality, we find that for any kernel function there always exists a corresponding quantum feature map and an embedding quantum kernel. The more operational reading of the question is concerned with efficient constructions, however. In a second part, we formalize the question of universality of efficient embedding quantum kernels. For shift-invariant kernels, we use the technique of random Fourier features to show that they are universal within the broad class of all kernels which allow a variant of efficient Fourier sampling. We then extend this result to a new class of so-called composition kernels, which we show also contains projected quantum kernels introduced in recent works. After proving the universality of embedding quantum kernels for both shift-invariant and composition kernels, we identify the directions towards new, more exotic, and unexplored quantum kernel families, for which it still remains open whether they correspond to efficient embedding quantum kernels.
The advent of quantum computing has dramatically changed the field of human information processing technology. Simultaneously, machine learning algorithms have achieved remarkable success in various applications. In this context, integrating quantum computing with machine learning has gained attention, spurring investigations into its potential advantages over classical methods. To deepen our understanding of quantum machine learning, we analyze function classes generated by quantum machine learning models that utilize classical data. These include variational quantum circuits and quantum kernel models that can be efficiently implemented using quantum devices. We initially examine the dimensionality of the function classes of these quantum models, noting that their dimensions can be exponentially large while requiring only polynomial scaling of quantum resources. Using a tensor network framework, we identify that all variational quantum machine learning models are essentially linear models within a potentially exponentially large-dimensional feature space, where the feature map is derived from a tensor product. The coefficients of quantum models, determined by the data-independent part of the circuits, exhibit high entanglement with a small number of parameters. We apply a similar approach to reveal the function space of quantum kernel models, offering a novel perspective for their analysis. On the other hand, we introduce and explore the dequantizability of quantum machine learning models, which serves as a necessary condition for their replacement with efficient classical models. We determine the conditions for (non)dequantizable models and highlight the importance of analyzing the coefficient part of these models. This approach provides us insight into the potential limitations and strengths of quantum computing in the realm of machine learning.