Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2103.12939 · Quantum

Adiabatic critical quantum metrology cannot reach the Heisenberg limit even when shortcuts to adiabaticity are applied

Karol Gietka, Friederike Metz, Tim Keller, Jing Li

Published Jul 1, 2021• 48 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that the quantum Fisher information attained in an adiabatic approach to critical quantum metrology cannot lead to the Heisenberg limit of precision and therefore regular quantum metrology under optimal settings is always superior. Furthermore, we argue that even though shortcuts to adiabaticity can arbitrarily decrease the time of preparing critical ground states, they cannot be used to achieve or overcome the Heisenberg limit for quantum parameter estimation in adiabatic critical quantum metrology. As case studies, we explore the application of counter-diabatic driving to the Landau-Zener model and the quantum Rabi model.

DOI
10.22331/q-2021-07-01-489

Related papers

Squeezing by critical speeding up: Applications in quantum metrology

Karol Gietka

We present an alternative protocol allowing for the preparation of critical states that instead of suffering from the critical slowing down benefits from the critical speeding up. Paradoxically, we prepare these states by going away from the critical point which allows for the speed-up. We apply the protocol to the paradigmatic quantum Rabi model and its classical oscillator limit as well as the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model. Subsequently, we discuss the application of the adiabatic speed-up protocol in quantum metrology and compare its performance with critical quantum metrology. We show that critical quantum metrology with the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model cannot even overcome the standard quantum limit, and we argue that, even though critical metrology protocols can overcome it in some cases, critical metrology is a suboptimal metrological strategy. Finally, we conclude that systems exhibiting a phase transition are indeed interesting from the viewpoint of quantum technologies; however, it may not be the critical point that should attract the most attention.

arXiv:2111.12206•Physical Review A•Apr 28, 2022•35 citations

Mind the Gap: Anti-Critical Quantum Metrology

George Mihailescu, Karol Gietka

Critical quantum metrology exploits the dramatic growth of the quantum Fisher information near quantum phase transitions to enhance the precision of parameter estimation. This enhancement is commonly associated with a closing energy gap, which causes the characteristic timescales for adiabatic preparation or relaxation to diverge with increasing system size. As a consequence, the apparent growth of the quantum Fisher information largely reflects the increasing evolution time induced by critical slowing down rather than a genuine improvement in metrological performance, thereby limiting the practical usefulness of such protocols. Here we show that the relationship between energy gaps, quantum correlations, and achievable precision in interacting quantum systems can be far more subtle. In particular, quantum-enhanced sensitivity can also emerge when the energy gap increases, eliminating critical slowing down and enabling substantially faster relaxation dynamics. Although the corresponding quantum Fisher information may decrease due to the shorter evolution time, the resulting precision can nevertheless remain quantum-enhanced. Building on this insight, we introduce an anti-critical quantum metrology scheme in which quantum-enhanced precision arises while the energy gap grows. We illustrate this mechanism using the quantum Rabi model, thereby identifying a route to metrological advantage that avoids the slow dynamics associated with conventional criticality.

quant-pharXiv:2602.03675•Feb 4, 2026•5 citations

Quantum Critical Metrology

Irénée Frérot, Tommaso Roscilde

Quantum metrology fundamentally relies upon the efficient management of quantum uncertainties. We show that under equilibrium conditions the management of quantum noise becomes extremely flexible around the quantum critical point of a quantum many-body system: this is due to the critical divergence of quantum fluctuations of the order parameter, which, via Heisenberg's inequalities, may lead to the critical suppression of the fluctuations in conjugate observables. Taking the quantum Ising model as the paradigmatic incarnation of quantum phase transitions, we show that it exhibits quantum critical squeezing of one spin component, providing a scaling for the precision of interferometric parameter estimation which, in dimensions d>2, lies in between the standard quantum limit and the Heisenberg limit. Quantum critical squeezing saturates the maximum metrological gain allowed by the quantum Fisher information in d=∞ (or with infinite-range interactions) at all temperatures, and it approaches closely the bound in a broad range of temperatures in d=2 and 3. This demonstrates the immediate metrological potential of equilibrium many-body states close to quantum criticality, which are accessible, e.g., to atomic quantum simulators via elementary adiabatic protocols.

arXiv:1707.08804•Physical Review Letters•Jul 11, 2018•160 citations

Shortcut-to-Adiabaticity-Like Techniques for Parameter Estimation in Quantum Metrology

Marina Cabedo-Olaya, Juan Gonzalo Muga, Sofía Martínez-Garaot

Quantum metrology makes use of quantum mechanics to improve precision measurements and measurement sensitivities. It is usually formulated for time-independent Hamiltonians, but time-dependent Hamiltonians may offer advantages, such as a T4 time dependence of the Fisher information which cannot be reached with a time-independent Hamiltonian. In Optimal adaptive control for quantum metrology with time-dependent Hamiltonians (Nature Communications 8, 2017), Shengshi Pang and Andrew N. Jordan put forward a Shortcut-to-adiabaticity (STA)-like method, specifically an approach formally similar to the “counterdiabatic approach”, adding a control term to the original Hamiltonian to reach the upper bound of the Fisher information. We revisit this work from the point of view of STA to set the relations and differences between STA-like methods in metrology and ordinary STA. This analysis paves the way for the application of other STA-like techniques in parameter estimation. In particular we explore the use of physical unitary transformations to propose alternative time-dependent Hamiltonians which may be easier to implement in the laboratory.

arXiv:2010.05828•Entropy•Nov 3, 2020•9 citations

Reaching the Limits of Ground-State Metrology with Many-Body Probes

Erik L. André, Víctor Izquierdo, Ricard Puig +2 more

We investigate the physical requirements to reach the ultimate limits of ground-state metrology -- i.e., the estimation of an unknown parameter $θ$ of an $N$-body Hamiltonian via measurements on its ground state -- using many-body probes featuring either short-range or long-range interactions. We characterize the conditions to saturate two fundamental limits of the quantum Fisher information $F_θ$: the static ground-state bound $F_θ\lesssim N^2/Δ^2$, where $Δ$ is the spectral gap, and the dynamical Heisenberg limit $F_θ\lesssim N^2 τ^2$, where $τ$ is the total protocol duration. To saturate the static limit, we argue that short-range interacting systems require a spectral gap that closes with $N$. At second-order quantum critical points this leads to a universal condition on the critical exponents, $ν(d+z)=1$, which can be approached arbitrarily closely, as we show for the XXZ chain; cat-like ground states at first-order transitions provide an alternative route to static optimality. In contrast, we find that all-to-all interacting models can achieve optimality even in gapped regimes. Furthermore, reaching the dynamical bound is tightly related to the ground-state preparation time; we demonstrate that its optimal, inverse-gap profile can be obtained via local adiabatic protocols. By analyzing paradigmatic systems -- the transverse-field Ising chain, the XXZ chain, a squeezing Hamiltonian, and the two-mode Bose-Hubbard model -- we identify specific many-body probes capable of approaching both limits. Overall, our results provide a theoretical basis for the design of (local) many-body ground-state sensors operating at the ultimate limits of quantum precision.

quant-pharXiv:2610.03653•Oct 5, 2026•0 citations

Experimental critical quantum metrology with the Heisenberg scaling

Ran Liu, Yu Chen, Min Jiang +6 more

Abstract Critical quantum metrology, which exploits quantum critical systems as probes to estimate a physical parameter, has gained increasing attention recently. However, the critical quantum metrology with a continuous quantum phase transition (QPT) is experimentally challenging since a continuous QPT only occurs at the thermodynamic limit. Here, we propose an adiabatic scheme on a perturbed Ising spin model with a first-order QPT. By introducing a small transverse magnetic field, we can not only encode an unknown parameter in the ground state but also tune the energy gap to control the evolution time of the adiabatic passage. Moreover, we experimentally implement the critical quantum metrology scheme using nuclear magnetic resonance techniques and show that at the critical point the precision achieves the Heisenberg scaling as 1/ T . As a theoretical proposal and experimental implementation of the adiabatic scheme of critical quantum metrology and its advantages of easy implementation, inherent robustness against decays and tunable energy gap, our adiabatic scheme is promising for exploring potential applications of critical quantum metrology on various physical systems.

arXiv:2102.07056•npj Quantum Information•Dec 13, 2021•75 citations
We show that the quantum Fisher information attained in an adiabatic approach to critical quantum metrology cannot lead to the Heisenberg limit of precision and therefore regular quantum metrology under optimal settings is always superior. Furthermore, we argue that even though shortcuts to adiabaticity can arbitrarily decrease the time of preparing critical ground states, they cannot be used to achieve or overcome the Heisenberg limit for quantum parameter estimation in adiabatic critical quantum metrology. As case studies, we explore the application of counter-diabatic driving to the Landau-Zener model and the quantum Rabi model.
We present an alternative protocol allowing for the preparation of critical states that instead of suffering from the critical slowing down benefits from the critical speeding up. Paradoxically, we prepare these states by going away from the critical point which allows for the speed-up. We apply the protocol to the paradigmatic quantum Rabi model and its classical oscillator limit as well as the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model. Subsequently, we discuss the application of the adiabatic speed-up protocol in quantum metrology and compare its performance with critical quantum metrology. We show that critical quantum metrology with the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model cannot even overcome the standard quantum limit, and we argue that, even though critical metrology protocols can overcome it in some cases, critical metrology is a suboptimal metrological strategy. Finally, we conclude that systems exhibiting a phase transition are indeed interesting from the viewpoint of quantum technologies; however, it may not be the critical point that should attract the most attention.
Critical quantum metrology exploits the dramatic growth of the quantum Fisher information near quantum phase transitions to enhance the precision of parameter estimation. This enhancement is commonly associated with a closing energy gap, which causes the characteristic timescales for adiabatic preparation or relaxation to diverge with increasing system size. As a consequence, the apparent growth of the quantum Fisher information largely reflects the increasing evolution time induced by critical slowing down rather than a genuine improvement in metrological performance, thereby limiting the practical usefulness of such protocols. Here we show that the relationship between energy gaps, quantum correlations, and achievable precision in interacting quantum systems can be far more subtle. In particular, quantum-enhanced sensitivity can also emerge when the energy gap increases, eliminating critical slowing down and enabling substantially faster relaxation dynamics. Although the corresponding quantum Fisher information may decrease due to the shorter evolution time, the resulting precision can nevertheless remain quantum-enhanced. Building on this insight, we introduce an anti-critical quantum metrology scheme in which quantum-enhanced precision arises while the energy gap grows. We illustrate this mechanism using the quantum Rabi model, thereby identifying a route to metrological advantage that avoids the slow dynamics associated with conventional criticality.
Quantum metrology fundamentally relies upon the efficient management of quantum uncertainties. We show that under equilibrium conditions the management of quantum noise becomes extremely flexible around the quantum critical point of a quantum many-body system: this is due to the critical divergence of quantum fluctuations of the order parameter, which, via Heisenberg's inequalities, may lead to the critical suppression of the fluctuations in conjugate observables. Taking the quantum Ising model as the paradigmatic incarnation of quantum phase transitions, we show that it exhibits quantum critical squeezing of one spin component, providing a scaling for the precision of interferometric parameter estimation which, in dimensions d>2, lies in between the standard quantum limit and the Heisenberg limit. Quantum critical squeezing saturates the maximum metrological gain allowed by the quantum Fisher information in d=∞ (or with infinite-range interactions) at all temperatures, and it approaches closely the bound in a broad range of temperatures in d=2 and 3. This demonstrates the immediate metrological potential of equilibrium many-body states close to quantum criticality, which are accessible, e.g., to atomic quantum simulators via elementary adiabatic protocols.
Quantum metrology makes use of quantum mechanics to improve precision measurements and measurement sensitivities. It is usually formulated for time-independent Hamiltonians, but time-dependent Hamiltonians may offer advantages, such as a T4 time dependence of the Fisher information which cannot be reached with a time-independent Hamiltonian. In Optimal adaptive control for quantum metrology with time-dependent Hamiltonians (Nature Communications 8, 2017), Shengshi Pang and Andrew N. Jordan put forward a Shortcut-to-adiabaticity (STA)-like method, specifically an approach formally similar to the “counterdiabatic approach”, adding a control term to the original Hamiltonian to reach the upper bound of the Fisher information. We revisit this work from the point of view of STA to set the relations and differences between STA-like methods in metrology and ordinary STA. This analysis paves the way for the application of other STA-like techniques in parameter estimation. In particular we explore the use of physical unitary transformations to propose alternative time-dependent Hamiltonians which may be easier to implement in the laboratory.
We investigate the physical requirements to reach the ultimate limits of ground-state metrology -- i.e., the estimation of an unknown parameter θθθ of an NNN-body Hamiltonian via measurements on its ground state -- using many-body probes featuring either short-range or long-range interactions. We characterize the conditions to saturate two fundamental limits of the quantum Fisher information FθF_θFθ​: the static ground-state bound Fθ≲N2/Δ2F_θ\lesssim N^2/Δ^2Fθ​≲N2/Δ2, where ΔΔΔ is the spectral gap, and the dynamical Heisenberg limit Fθ≲N2τ2F_θ\lesssim N^2 τ^2Fθ​≲N2τ2, where τττ is the total protocol duration. To saturate the static limit, we argue that short-range interacting systems require a spectral gap that closes with NNN. At second-order quantum critical points this leads to a universal condition on the critical exponents, ν(d+z)=1ν(d+z)=1ν(d+z)=1, which can be approached arbitrarily closely, as we show for the XXZ chain; cat-like ground states at first-order transitions provide an alternative route to static optimality. In contrast, we find that all-to-all interacting models can achieve optimality even in gapped regimes. Furthermore, reaching the dynamical bound is tightly related to the ground-state preparation time; we demonstrate that its optimal, inverse-gap profile can be obtained via local adiabatic protocols. By analyzing paradigmatic systems -- the transverse-field Ising chain, the XXZ chain, a squeezing Hamiltonian, and the two-mode Bose-Hubbard model -- we identify specific many-body probes capable of approaching both limits. Overall, our results provide a theoretical basis for the design of (local) many-body ground-state sensors operating at the ultimate limits of quantum precision.
Abstract Critical quantum metrology, which exploits quantum critical systems as probes to estimate a physical parameter, has gained increasing attention recently. However, the critical quantum metrology with a continuous quantum phase transition (QPT) is experimentally challenging since a continuous QPT only occurs at the thermodynamic limit. Here, we propose an adiabatic scheme on a perturbed Ising spin model with a first-order QPT. By introducing a small transverse magnetic field, we can not only encode an unknown parameter in the ground state but also tune the energy gap to control the evolution time of the adiabatic passage. Moreover, we experimentally implement the critical quantum metrology scheme using nuclear magnetic resonance techniques and show that at the critical point the precision achieves the Heisenberg scaling as 1/ T . As a theoretical proposal and experimental implementation of the adiabatic scheme of critical quantum metrology and its advantages of easy implementation, inherent robustness against decays and tunable energy gap, our adiabatic scheme is promising for exploring potential applications of critical quantum metrology on various physical systems.